JH7 Holdings Pty Ltd (ACN 601664617) v Chung

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

JH7 Holdings Pty Ltd (ACN 601664617) v Chung & Ors [2024] QSC 55

PARTIES:

JH7 HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 601663617)

(plaintiff)

v
KUO-JEN CHUNG (in his personal capacity and as trustee for the Chung Family Trust)

(first defendant)

JH3 HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 619035755)        (second defendant)

ZHUO LI  (first defendant added by counterclaim)

LIMING HU  (second defendant added by counterclaim)

FILE NO/S:

BS 8669/20

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland

DELIVERED ON:

6 March 2024

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

23 February 2024

JUDGE:

Callaghan J

ORDER:

1. The oral application by the plaintiff and first and second defendants by counterclaim made on 27 February 2024 is dismissed.

2.  By 4:00 pm on 30 November 2023, the plaintiff and first and second defendants by counterclaim did not comply with paragraphs 2 and 3 of the orders made by Freeburn J on 11 August 2023, as extended by paragraphs 2 and 3 of the orders made by Freeburn J on 20 November 2023.

3.  On 5 December 2023 upon the filing of the affidavit of Alexander William Thompson, sworn 5 December 2023, judgment was entered for the first defendant against the plaintiff on the claim and an order that the plaintiff pay the first defendant’s costs of the claim on the standard basis, pursuant to paragraph 4 of the 20 November 2023 orders.

4. The plaintiff and first and second defendants by counterclaim pay the first defendant’s costs of the application filed 7 December 2023, and the oral application.

CATCHWORDS:

COURT PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – QUEENSLAND CIVIL PRACTICE – UNIFORM CIVIL PROCEDURE RULES 1999- FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH RULES OR ORDER – Where a guillotine order has been issued– Where the applicant seeks the exercise of a discretion to declare compliance – where the applicant in the alternative seeks to be relieved of the consequences of failing to comply with the guillotine order – circumstances in which the order was made - whether the non-compliance was inadvertent – prejudice to the plaintiff – prejudice to the defendant – injustice – application refused

COSTS – Applicant for indemnity costs – indemnity costs refused

COUNSEL:

M Goldsworthy for the applicant

B Cohen for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

HWL Ebsworth for the applicant
Cohen Law for the respondent

  1. My reasons for judgment are as follows.  This unfortunate piece of litigation now involves a counterclaim as well as this application, but I shall continue to refer to JH7 Holdings and the parties associated with it simply as the plaintiff, and Mr Chung as the defendant.

    Background

  2. As described by the plaintiff itself, the cause is “not complex.”[1] It is averred that some $842,873.46 was advanced to the defendant for the purposes of a joint venture property agreement.[2]  The arrangement is said to be the subject of a written loan agreement.  Of course, the materials before me contain a lot more detail.  Different forms of relief are sought by the plaintiff and, as noted, a counterclaim has…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read JH7 Holdings Pty Ltd (ACN 601664617) v Chung and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QSC 55
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of JH7 Holdings Pty Ltd (ACN 601664617) v Chung, the parties were involved in a legal dispute concerning a property investment agreement. The plaintiff alleged that it had advanced funds to the defendant for a joint venture property agreement, but had received nothing in return. The case had a complicated procedural history, including delays and non-compliance with court orders. The defendant sought to enforce a guillotine order that required the plaintiff to file affidavits and documents by a specified date. The plaintiff subsequently applied for a declaration of compliance or, in the alternative, to be relieved of the consequences of non-compliance. The court had to determine whether the non-compliance was inadvertent and whether it caused prejudice to either party.

The central legal issues the court needed to address were whether the plaintiff's non-compliance with the guillotine order was inadvertent and if so, whether it should be excused. The court also considered whether granting the relief requested by the plaintiff would result in an injustice to the defendant. Furthermore, the court examined whether the plaintiff was entitled to indemnity costs due to the defendant's persistent litigation. The court's reasoning involved a detailed assessment of the procedural history, the nature of the non-compliance, and the potential prejudice to the parties. The court held that the plaintiff's non-compliance was not inadvertent, and that the defendant had suffered prejudice. The court also found that the plaintiff's application was not one where the exercise of discretion was warranted, and therefore, the application was dismissed. Additionally, the court determined that the plaintiff was not entitled to indemnity costs.

The court's decision was that the plaintiff's application was dismissed, and the non-compliance with the guillotine order was confirmed. Judgment was entered for the defendant, and the plaintiff was ordered to pay the defendant's costs. The court also ruled that the plaintiff was not entitled to indemnity costs. The final orders included dismissing the plaintiff's application, confirming the non-compliance with the guillotine order, entering judgment for the defendant, and ordering the plaintiff to pay the defendant's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The oral application by the plaintiff and first and second defendants by counterclaim made on 27 February 2024 is dismissed.

2. By 4:00 pm on 30 November 2023, the plaintiff and first and second defendants by counterclaim did not comply with paragraphs 2 and 3 of the orders made by Freeburn J on 11 August 2023, as extended by paragraphs 2 and 3 of the orders made by Freeburn J on 20 November 2023.

3. On 5 December 2023 upon the filing of the affidavit of Alexander William Thompson, sworn 5 December 2023, judgment was entered for the first defendant against the plaintiff on the claim and an order that the plaintiff pay the first defendant’s costs of the claim on the standard basis, pursuant to paragraph 4 of the 20 November 2023 orders.

4. The plaintiff and first and second defendants by counterclaim pay the first defendant’s costs of the application filed 7 December 2023, and the oral application.

Background

Background to the litigation

My reasons for judgment are as follows. This unfortunate piece of litigation now involves a counterclaim as well as this application, but I shall continue to refer to JH7 Holdings and the parties associated with it simply as the plaintiff, and Mr Chung as the defendant.Background As described by the plaintiff itself, the cause is “not complex.”[1] It is averred that some $842,873.46 was advanced to the defendant for the purposes of a joint venture property agreement.[2] The arrangement is said to be the subject of a written loan agreement. Of course, the materials before me contain a lot more detail. Different forms of relief are sought by the plaintiff and, as noted, a counterclaim has been made by the defendant. But for current purposes it all does really reduce to the proposition that one party claims to have given money to another party and to have nothing to show for it.[1]Submissions of plaintiff, dated 20 February 2024, [1].[2]Plaintiff’s amended statement of claim, CFI 78 [12A]. Proceedings were instituted originally in New South Wales but have been before this court since July 2020. It may be, as put by counsel for the plaintiff, that between then and August 2023 there had been “delay on both sides”. However, there was little more to be said about that after orders were made by Freeburn J on 11 August 2023. These were made in the absence of an appearance by the plaintiff, and included the following:Order 2: by 4 pm on 15 September 2023 the plaintiff and first and second defendants by counter‑claim file any amended reply and answer to the further amended counter‑claim; ...Order 4: Except as otherwise ordered by the Court, the evidence‑in‑chief of lay witnesses at the trial be given by affidavit; andOrder 5: By 4 pm on 3 November 2023 the plaintiff and first and second defendants by counter‑claim:(a) file and serve affidavits of evidence of each lay witness that they intend to call at trial; and(b) serve a list of additional documents they intend to rely on at trial. Implicitly, the affidavits were required to contain the evidence with which the plaintiff was going to prove its case. On 20 November 2023, his Honour extended time for compliance with paras 2 and 5 until 4:00pm on 30 November 2023. He also made a further order which added a new dimension to proceedings. It included this paragraph:If the plaintiff and first and second defendants by counter‑claim do not comply with paragraphs 2 and 5 of the order made by Freeburn J on 11 August 2023 (as extended ...) by 4 pm on 30 November 2023, then, upon the solicitors for the first defendant filing an affidavit deposing to such noncompliance, there shall be judgment for the first defendant against the plaintiff on the claim and an order that the plaintiff pay the first defendant’s costs of the claim on the standard basis. The orders made on 20 November 2023 also included an award of costs for that hearing and for a review on 6 November 2023 at which it may also be noted there was no appearance for the plaintiff. These were not the first costs orders made against the plaintiff.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

However, when all relevant considerations are synthesised and the wider context of the litigation is assessed, it cannot be concluded that the success of this application would be the root cause of any injustice. Rather, the source of injustice, if there is one, is to be found in the plaintiff’s own omissions. To the extent that these trace to the failures of the solicitor who previously acted, the situation is susceptible to other remedies.Conclusions There is insufficient reason to refrain from application of the principles that parties generally are responsible for the actions of their lawyers and that the orders of the court should be enforced. In the result, and notwithstanding the able arguments of Mr Goldsworthy, the order the court will be that the court declares:1.The oral application by the plaintiff and first and second defendants by counterclaim made on 27 February 2024 is dismissed. 2.By 4:00pm on 30 November 2023, the plaintiff and first and second defendants by counterclaim did not comply with paras 2 and 3 of the orders made by Freeburn J on 11 August 2023, as extended by paras 2 and 3 of the orders made by Freeburn J on 20 November 2023.3.On 5 December 2023 upon the filing of the affidavit of Alexander William Thompson, sworn 5 December 2023, judgment was entered for the first defendant against the plaintiff on the claim and an order that the plaintiff pay the first defendant’s costs of the claim on the standard basis, pursuant to para 4 of the 20 November 2023 orders.Costs The defendant has made an application for indemnity costs. It is submitted that the case is one which has been maintained and persisted in when, had the plaintiff been properly advised, it ought not to have been advanced or maintained. Ultimately, the case has been decided by way of the exercise of a discretion. The plaintiff was wrong about the reasons why I had the discretion and only belatedly did what was necessary to invest me with it. Nevertheless, along the way I was directed to the law that was applicable to its exercise, and I was at least provided with some functional argument as to why it should be exercised in the plaintiff’s favour. I remain disturbed about the lack of materials, which might have been capable of establishing reasons for noncompliance and prejudice to the defendant, but given that the exercise of the discretion is an exercise to be formed after synthesising all of the relevant factors, I cannot conclude that the failures of the plaintiff were so wholesale as to fall into the category in which it is said they lie. The case might be a marginal one, but in the result, I have concluded that it is not one in which an order of indemnity costs is appropriate. And so the order of the court will be:4.The plaintiff and first and second defendants by counter-claim pay the first defendant’s costs of the application filed 7 December 2023, and the oral application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established