JF v Oishi Teppanyaki & Café Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:

JF v Oishi Teppanyaki & Café Pty Ltd & Anor [2025] QIRC 209

PARTIES:

JF
(Complainant)

v

Oishi Teppanyaki & Café Pty Ltd
(First Respondent)

AND

Ebrahim-Goder, Moosa
(Second Respondent)

CASE NO:

AD/2021/2

PROCEEDING:

Referral of Anti-Discrimination Complaint

DELIVERED ON:

8 August 2025
HEARING DATE:

6 June 2025

MEMBER:

Hartigan DP
HEARD AT:

Brisbane

ORDERS: 

1. Pursuant to s 191(1) of the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991, the Complainant's identity is prohibited from being disclosed in these proceedings, being matter number AD/2021/2.

2.       Pursuant to r 97 of the Industrial Relations (Tribunals) Rules 2011, the Complainant's identity will be
de-identified in these reasons.

3. Pursuant to s 451(2)(c) of the Industrial Relations Act 2016, the file held in the Industrial Registry for matter number AD/2021/2 is to be sealed and withheld from release, search or copy unless leave from the Commission is granted.

4. Pursuant to s 209(1)(b) of the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991, the Second Respondent must pay, within 28 days, compensation to the Complainant comprising of:

(a)     general damages for sexual harassment in the sum of $140,000; and

(b)     aggravated damages in the sum of $10,000.

5.       The Second Respondent must pay, within 28 days, the Complainant's costs fixed in the sum of $26,434.

CATCHWORDS:

HUMAN RIGHTS – DISCRIMINATION LEGISLATION – GENERALLY – where there is a referral of a complaint from the Queensland Human Rights Commission – where the Complainant alleged sexual harassment in the area of work – where the First Respondent was the restaurant where the Complainant worked – where the Second Respondent was the Complainant's employer – where the Second Respondent requested sex from the Complainant during a shift – where the Second Respondent touched the Complainant without her consent – where the Respondents have not appeared in these proceedings – whether the Respondents have been served – whether the Commission can make a final decision where the Respondents do not participate in the proceedings – whether the Second Respondent's conduct contravened the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 – whether the conduct included a sexual advance, a request for sexual favours or other conduct of a sexual nature – whether the conduct was unwelcome – whether a reasonable person would have anticipated the possibility that the person harassed would be offended, humiliated or intimidated by the conduct – whether an order for general and aggravated damages should be awarded – the sexual harassment complaint is substantiated – order for general and aggravated damages made

EVIDENCE – MISCELLANEOUS MATTERS – NON-PUBLICATION OF EVIDENCE – PARTICULAR CASES –where Complainant seeks suppression of her identity – where the Respondents have not participated in these proceedings – whether the Commission is of reasonable opinion that suppression is necessary to protect the Complainant's work security, privacy or any human right – application for suppression order granted

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – SERVICE – PERSONAL SERVICE – where the Complainant has personally served the Respondents – where the Respondents have not participated…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read JF v Oishi Teppanyaki & Café Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] QIRC 209
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In JF v Oishi Teppanyaki & Café Pty Ltd, the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) considered a complaint of sexual harassment filed by JF against Oishi Teppanyaki & Café Pty Ltd and its owner, the Second Respondent. JF alleged that the Second Respondent made unwelcome sexual advances towards her, including verbal and physical conduct, during her employment at the restaurant. The Tribunal found the complaint substantiated and awarded JF both general and aggravated damages. The Second Respondent, who had a prior conviction for sexual assault, did not participate in the proceedings, and the Tribunal determined that they had been properly served with the court documents. Additionally, the Tribunal granted an application for the suppression of JF's identity to protect her privacy and work security.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the Second Respondent's conduct constituted sexual harassment under the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991, and if so, whether the Queensland Human Rights Commission could make a final decision in the absence of the Respondents' participation. The Tribunal found that the Second Respondent's conduct, which included unwelcome sexual advances and physical contact, met the criteria for sexual harassment as defined in the Act. Furthermore, the Tribunal concluded that the Commission could proceed and make a final decision without the Respondents' participation, as the evidence presented was uncontradicted and the Respondents had been properly served.

The Tribunal's reasoning was based on the credibility of JF's evidence and the medical evidence provided by experts, which supported her account of the incident and its ongoing impact on her mental health. The Tribunal also considered the Respondent's prior conviction for sexual assault, which it found to be consistent with JF's evidence. The Tribunal accepted JF's evidence as a reliable account of the incidents constituting the unlawful sexual harassment and found the Second Respondent liable for the alleged conduct.

In its orders, the Tribunal prohibited the disclosure of JF's identity in the proceedings and required her identity to be de-identified in the reasons for the decision. The Tribunal also sealed the file held in the Industrial Registry for the matter. The Second Respondent was ordered to pay JF $140,000 in general damages and $10,000 in aggravated damages, along with her costs of $26,434.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 191(1) of the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991, the Complainant's identity is prohibited from being disclosed in these proceedings, being matter number AD/2021/2.

2. Pursuant to r 97 of the Industrial Relations (Tribunals) Rules 2011, the Complainant's identity will be

de-identified in these reasons.

3. Pursuant to s 451(2)(c) of the Industrial Relations Act 2016, the file held in the Industrial Registry for matter number AD/2021/2 is to be sealed and withheld from release, search or copy unless leave from the Commission is granted.

4. Pursuant to s 209(1)(b) of the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991, the Second Respondent must pay, within 28 days, compensation to the Complainant comprising of:

(a) general damages for sexual harassment in the sum of $140,000; and

(b) aggravated damages in the sum of $10,000.

5. The Second Respondent must pay, within 28 days, the Complainant's costs fixed in the sum of $26,434.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

As noted above, since the incident JF has re-partnered. Her evidence is that the effects of the incident continue to impact on her intimate relationship with her partner. Section 79 of the Evidence Act – Convictions as Evidence in Civil Proceedings It is submitted on JF's behalf that the evidence of the Respondent's conviction for sexual assault[36] is to be taken as proof that the Respondent committed the acts and possessed the state of mind which at law constitutes that offence, unless the Respondent proves to the contrary. [36] Exhibit 2 (n 4). Section 79(2) of the Evidence Act provides that in any civil proceeding the fact that a person has been convicted by a court of an offence is admissible in evidence for the purpose of proving, where to do so is relevant to any issue in the proceeding, that the person committed that offence. Section 79(3) of the Evidence Act further provides that in any civil proceeding in which by virtue of this section a person is proved to have been convicted by a court of an offence, that person shall, unless the contrary is proved, be taken to have committed the acts and to have possessed the state of mind (if any) which at law constitutes the offence. As previously noted, the Respondent was convicted of sexual assault in contravention of s 352 of the Criminal Code in relation to a complaint made by JF. Accordingly, it has been established[37] that the Respondent committed that offence and is taken to have committed the acts which constituted the offence. [37] By the tendering of the Verdict and Judgment Record; Exhibit 2 (n 4). Those matters are a relevant consideration in this proceeding, particularly in the absence of the Respondent. The fact of JF making a complaint and the circumstances of the Respondent being convicted of the offence of sexual assault is consistent with JF's evidence before the Commission. Dr Fuls prepared three reports for JF's WorkCover claim and also gave evidence before the Commission. Dr Fuls' reports were tendered into evidence[38] and, relevantly, her report dated 18 February 2020 included the following passages:[38] JF, 'Medical Reports – Dr K. Fuls', Exhibit 5 in JF v Oishi Teppanyaki & Café Pty Ltd & Anor, AD/2021/2, On mental status examination, [JF] is a neatly presented young lady who has an anxious and at times tearful affect. She describes an anxious mood which at times is low. She has an organised and goal-directed thought form. In her thought content there is significant evidence of trauma-related intrusive memories. She denies the presence of any hallucinations or delusions. [JF] has good insight and has the capacity to consent to treatment. Dr Fuls also gave evidence before the Commission. Dr Fuls confirmed that, as a consequence of what was described as the "assault" by the Respondent, JF was diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder ('PTSD'). Dr Ghazala Watt – consultant psychiatrist Dr Watt prepared a report and also gave evidence before the Commission. Dr Watt's report was tendered into evidence.[40] Dr Watt took a detailed history from JF which largely accords with the evidence JF gave to the Commission. [40] JF, 'Independent Medico-Legal Report of Dr G. Watt dated 11 May 2021', Exhibit 6 in JF v Oishi Teppanyaki & Café Pty Ltd & Anor, AD/2021/2, 6 June 2025 ('Exhibit 6').

Decision

Reasons for decision

Finally, Dr Watt provided an opinion with respect to JF's diagnosis and prognosis as follows: SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION… In evidence before the Commission, Dr Watt advised that the diagnosis of PTSD is a condition considered by psychiatry to be a severe mental illness. Dr Watt further gave evidence that the symptoms described by JF that she was still suffering from feelings of being overwhelmed when in public places is consistent with the diagnosis of PTSD. Dr Watt expressed an opinion to the effect that, given the nature of PTSD, there remains a risk of deterioration. For that reason, Dr Watt recommends that someone diagnosed with PTSD would continue, even after treatment had ended, to be regularly reviewed by a GP and/or psychiatrist. Ms Tracey Mousset – psychologist Tracey Mousset, psychologist, was also called to give evidence. Ms Mousset provided treatment to JF following the diagnosis of PTSD. Ms Mousset confirmed that the treatment included a course of Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing ('EMDR') which is a type of treatment targeting the memory. Ms Mousset's notes were tendered into evidence.[44][44] JF, 'Psychologist – Tracey Mousset Notes and Report', Exhibit 7 in JF v Oishi Teppanyaki & Café Pty Ltd & Anor, AD/2021/2, 6 June 2025 ('Exhibit 7'). Consideration of the Evidence The Respondent has not responded to the case put against him in any written form and did not attend the hearing on 6 June 2025. Accordingly, JF's evidence, the evidence tendered on her behalf and the evidence of the expert witnesses, has not been contradicted. In addition to this, JF is found to be a credible witness. The oral evidence given before the Commission at the hearing by JF was consistent with her affidavit evidence filed in the proceedings. Additionally, JF's account was also consistent with the contemporaneous accounts provided to, inter alia, the Queensland Police Service. The Commission has also had regard to the medical evidence tendered and notes that the history stated and recorded in those reports, as being given by JF, is consistent with JF's evidence before the Commission. Accordingly, JF's evidence is accepted as a reliable account of the incidents said to constitute the unlawful sexual harassment. I accept JF's evidence as credible and find on the evidence that the Respondent engaged in the following conduct: (a)the Respondent engaged in the following verbal conduct by making the following verbal statements to JF: (i) "will you have sex with me?"; (ii) words to the effect that JF had a "wet vagina"; and (iii) "just give me one thing". (b)the Respondent engaged in the following physical conduct towards JF: (i) he grabbed JF and kissed her; (ii) he continued to kiss JF and attempted to pull down JF's blouse in order to kiss her breast; On balance, I do not consider that the manner in which the Respondent has acted (or not acted) has unfairly disadvantaged JF. The nature and complexity of the proceeding JF contends that whilst the proceedings were not necessarily complex there were issues arising that added to the complexity, including the nature of the proceeding and the nature of the sexual harassment that required representation.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.