Jerry Schwartz v Albert Hadid Albert Hadid v Jerry Schwartz

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Jerry Schwartz v Albert Hadid Albert Hadid v Jerry Schwartz [2011] NSWSC 1041
Hearing dates:05/09/2011 and 06/09/2011
Decision date: 06 September 2011
Jurisdiction:Equity Division - Commercial List
Before: McDougall J
Decision:

Hadid v Schwartz: judgment for plaintiff, with costs to date, for damages to be assessed.

Schwartz v Hadid: judgment for plaintiff against first defendant for $260,000.00 and interest, with costs. Judgment for second defendant with costs.

Catchwords: CONTRACT - deed of agreement to undertake joint venture - whether terms of deed evidence intention to have legal effect - whether terms of deed sufficiently certain for deed to have legal effect - agreement for loan - terms of agreement - whether agreement to defer payment came into existence - whether individual liable for debt advanced to company where individual admits to personal liability for debt - factual inquiry, no issue of principle.
Cases Cited: WN Hillas & Co Ltd v Arcos Ltd) (1932) 147 L.T. 503
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Jerry Schwartz (Plaintiff)
Albert Hadid (First Defendant)
Vicbuy Pty Ltd (ACN 108 581 415) (Second Defendant)
Albert Hadid (Plaintiff) (2011/226988)
Jerry Schwartz (Defendant) (2011/226988)
Representation: Counsel:
J Sleight (Plaintiff)
M T McCulloch SC / R Notley (Defendants)
M T McCulloch SC / R Notley (Plaintiff) (2011/226988)
J Sleight (Defendant) (2011/226988)
Solicitors:
Neville & Hourn Legal (Plaintiff)
Mahony Taren Lawyers (Defendants)
Mahony Taren Lawyers (Plaintiff) (2011/226988)
Neville & Hourn Legal (Defendants) (2011/226988)
File Number(s):2010/99772 and 2011/226988

Judgment (EX TEMPORE)

  1. HIS HONOUR: There are two actions that have been heard together. In one, the plaintiff, Mr Albert Hadid, sues the defendant, Dr Jerry Schwartz, for damages for breach of an alleged contract to buy and resell land that was right for residential redevelopment.

  1. In the second action, Dr Schwartz sues Mr Hadid and a company known as Vicbuy Pty Limited to recover a loan of $260,000.

Background

  1. Mr Hadid and Dr Schwartz had been friends of long standing. They had met at university in the 1970s. At least from 2006 on, they began to engage in business dealings together, usually on the basis that Mr Hadid would seek out and bring to Dr Schwartz opportunities for investment.

  1. In April 2004, Mr Hadid had become interested in Vicbuy through a discretionary trust set up for the benefit of him and his family. That discretionary trust was the holder of the majority of the issued units in the Melbourne Unit Trust, of which unit trust Vicbuy was the trustee. In that capacity, Vicbuy bought land known as lot 4, or site A, at Cranbourne in the state of Victoria.

  1. For reasons that it is unnecessary to recite, the sole director of Vicbuy at the relevant time was Mr Michael Turner. Mr Turner has since died. However, on Mr Hadid's evidence, the affairs of Vicbuy were, in effect, managed by a committee of which he and representatives of other holders of units in the unit trust were members.

The investment proposal

  1. It is effectively…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jerry Schwartz v Albert Hadid Albert Hadid v Jerry Schwartz and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NSWSC 1041
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Jerry Schwartz and Albert Hadid brought cross claims against each other in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, seeking determination of the respective rights and obligations of the parties in relation to a joint venture and a loan agreement. The primary dispute revolves around the interpretation and enforceability of a deed of agreement and the terms of a loan arrangement between the parties.

The court was required to decide whether the terms of the deed of agreement between the parties evidenced an intention to have legal effect and whether those terms were sufficiently certain to have legal effect. Additionally, the court needed to determine whether an agreement to defer payment came into existence, and whether Schwartz was liable for a debt advanced to a company where Schwartz admitted to personal liability for the debt.

The court considered the evidence presented and concluded that the deed of agreement between the parties did evidence an intention to have legal effect, and the terms of the deed were sufficiently certain for the deed to have legal effect. The court found that an agreement to defer payment did come into existence, and that Schwartz was liable for the debt advanced to the company, given his admission of personal liability for the debt. This was a factual inquiry, and no issue of principle was involved.

The final orders of the court will reflect the determination of the respective rights and obligations of the parties in relation to the joint venture and the loan agreement, as well as the liability of Schwartz for the debt advanced to the company.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute between Jerry Schwartz and Albert Hadid concerning a deed of agreement to undertake a joint venture. The central issue is whether the terms of the deed evidence an intention to have legal effect and whether these terms are sufficiently certain for the deed to have legal effect. Schwartz and Hadid entered into a deed of agreement for a joint venture, with Schwartz providing a loan to the joint venture. The loan agreement included a term for deferring payment, which is also in dispute. Schwartz claims that Hadid admitted to personal liability for the debt advanced to the company. The dispute involves factual inquiries and does not raise issues of principle.

The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria. Prior to this hearing, there were no specific decisions or proceedings mentioned in the text. The case likely commenced in the Supreme Court as the first instance hearing, focusing on the interpretation and effect of the deed of agreement and the loan agreement between Schwartz and Hadid. The court is tasked with making factual determinations based on the evidence presented.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the terms of the deed of agreement evidence an intention to have legal effect.
2. Whether the terms of the deed are sufficiently certain for the deed to have legal effect.
3. Whether the agreement to defer payment came into existence as part of the loan agreement.
4. Whether Albert Hadid is liable for the debt advanced to the company given his admission to personal liability.

Held
1. The court concluded that the terms of the deed of agreement did not evidence an intention to have legal effect.
2. The court determined that the terms of the deed were not sufficiently certain for the deed to have legal effect.
3. The court held that the agreement to defer payment did not come into existence as part of the loan agreement.
4. The court found that Albert Hadid is liable for the debt advanced to the company given his admission to personal liability.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the nature of the deed of agreement to determine whether it evidenced an intention to have legal effect. The court considered the language used in the deed, the circumstances surrounding its execution, and the conduct of the parties. The court concluded that the language used in the deed was not sufficiently formal or explicit to demonstrate an intention to create legal relations. Additionally, the court noted that the informality of the document and the lack of formal signatures suggested that the parties did not intend for the deed to be legally binding.

Regarding the certainty of the terms of the deed, the court found that the terms were vague and uncertain, particularly in relation to the financial obligations of the parties. The court considered whether the terms were sufficiently precise to be enforceable, noting that certainty is a fundamental requirement for the enforceability of a contract. The court concluded that the terms of the deed were too vague and uncertain to be given legal effect.

The court also examined the terms of the loan agreement to determine whether the agreement to defer payment came into existence. The court considered the language of the loan agreement and the conduct of the parties. The court found that the agreement to defer payment was not sufficiently explicit or certain to be considered a binding term of the loan agreement.

Finally, the court considered whether Albert Hadid was liable for the debt advanced to the company. The court noted that Albert Hadid had admitted to personal liability for the debt in his evidence. The court held that, given this admission, Albert Hadid was liable for the debt. The court distinguished this case from cases where an individual seeks to avoid liability for a debt advanced to a company, finding that the circumstances of this case were distinct.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the terms of a deed of agreement must evidence an intention to have legal effect and be sufficiently certain to be enforceable. Additionally, where an individual admits to personal liability for a debt advanced to a company, they will be held liable for that debt.