Jemena Gas Networks (NSW) Ltd v Mine Subsidence Board

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FRENCH CJ,
GUMMOW, HAYNE, HEYDON, CRENNAN, KIEFEL AND BELL JJ

JEMENA GAS NETWORKS (NSW) LIMITED  APPELLANT

AND

MINE SUBSIDENCE BOARD  RESPONDENT

Jemena Gas Networks (NSW) Limited v Mine Subsidence Board
[2011] HCA 19
1 June 2011
S312/2010

ORDER

1.        Appeal allowed.

2.Set aside the orders of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales made on 28 June 2010 and in their place order:

(a)      That the appeal to that Court be allowed.

(b)Set aside the orders of the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales made on 17 July 2009 and in their place order that the preliminary question of law identified by Sheahan J of the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales, namely:

Whether the Applicant is entitled to an amount under section 12A(1)(b) of the Mine Subsidence Compensation Act 1961 (NSW) in respect of expenses that it incurred in performing work on the Sydney to Moomba Gas Pipeline in circumstances where subsidence occurred at or near Mallaty Creek near Campbelltown in or about October 2005, on the assumption that the Applicant can establish that, for the purposes of that section, the expenses incurred by it were "proper and necessary",

be answered:

It being agreed that the applicant reasonably anticipated, based on expert advice, that cumulative subsidence at Mallaty

Creek from approved longwall mining of Longwalls 30-32 was likely to cause damage to its pipeline, the applicant was entitled under s 12A(1)(b) of the Mine Subsidence Compensation Act 1961 (NSW) to an amount from the Mine Subsidence Compensation Fund to meet the proper and necessary expense of preventing or mitigating that damage.

(c)The Board to pay the appellant's costs of the hearing of the preliminary question before the Land and Environment Court and of the appeal to the Court of Appeal.

3.The Board to pay the costs of the appellant of the appeal to this Court.

On appeal from the Supreme Court of New South Wales

Representation

R J Ellicott QC with J R Williams for the appellant (instructed by Freehills)

S B Lloyd SC with S J Free for the respondent (instructed by Crown Solicitor (NSW))

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. FRENCH CJ, GUMMOW, HAYNE, HEYDON, CRENNAN AND KIEFEL JJ.   This appeal relates to the Mine Subsidence Compensation Act 1961 (NSW) ("the Act"). Section 10 of the Act provides for the creation of a Mine Subsidence Compensation Fund ("the Fund"). The Fund is administered by the respondent, the Mine Subsidence Board ("the Board"). By s 8 of the Act, the Board has the wide powers of a commission under the Royal Commissions Act 1923 (NSW), Pt 2 Div 1. Colliery proprietors make compulsory contributions to the Fund (s 11). Claims may be made by the owners of improvements for payment from the Fund of expenditures in relation to subsidence-caused damage to those improvements (ss 12 and 12A).

  2. The appeal…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jemena Gas Networks (NSW) Ltd v Mine Subsidence Board and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] HCA 19
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia heard an appeal from Jemena Gas Networks (NSW) Ltd (the appellant) against the Mine Subsidence Board (the Board). The dispute concerned the appellant's entitlement to compensation from the Mine Subsidence Compensation Fund for expenses incurred in performing preventative and mitigatory works on a gas pipeline. These works were undertaken after the appellant received expert advice predicting that longwall mining would cause subsidence and damage to the pipeline.

The central legal issue before the High Court was the proper construction of section 12A(1)(b) of the *Mine Subsidence Compensation Act 1961* (NSW). Specifically, the Court had to determine whether the phrase "from a subsidence that has taken place" required that the subsidence must have actually occurred *before* the owner incurred expenses to prevent or mitigate damage, or if it encompassed a hypothetical or anticipated future subsidence. The Court also considered whether the appellant's claim for expenses incurred in preventing or mitigating damage was valid under the provision.

The High Court reasoned that the language of section 12A(1)(b) did not mandate that subsidence must have already occurred for an owner to be entitled to compensation for preventative or mitigatory expenses. The Court held that the provision allowed for claims where an owner could reasonably anticipate that damage "would otherwise have arisen, or could reasonably anticipate would otherwise arise, from a subsidence that has taken place." This wording indicated that the provision was intended to cover both actual past subsidence and reasonably anticipated future subsidence. Therefore, the appellant was entitled to compensation for the proper and necessary expenses incurred in preventing or mitigating damage to its pipeline, even though the full extent of the subsidence had not yet manifested at the time the works were undertaken, provided the damage was reasonably anticipated.

The High Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the orders of the Court of Appeal and the Land and Environment Court. The Court ordered that the preliminary question of law be answered in favour of the appellant, confirming its entitlement to compensation from the Mine Subsidence Compensation Fund for the proper and necessary expenses of preventing or mitigating damage to its pipeline, based on reasonable anticipation of subsidence from approved longwall mining. The Board was ordered to pay the appellant's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed.

2. Set aside the orders of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales made on 28 June 2010 and in their place order:

(a) That the appeal to that Court be allowed.

(b) Set aside the orders of the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales made on 17 July 2009 and in their place order that the preliminary question of law identified by Sheahan J of the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales, namely:

Whether the Applicant is entitled to an amount under section 12A(1)(b) of the Mine Subsidence Compensation Act 1961 (NSW) in respect of expenses that it incurred in performing work on the Sydney to Moomba Gas Pipeline in circumstances where subsidence occurred at or near Mallaty Creek near Campbelltown in or about October 2005, on the assumption that the Applicant can establish that, for the purposes of that section, the expenses incurred by it were "proper and necessary",

be answered:

It being agreed that the applicant reasonably anticipated, based on expert advice, that cumulative subsidence at Mallaty

Creek from approved longwall mining of Longwalls 30-32 was likely to cause damage to its pipeline, the applicant was entitled under s 12A(1)(b) of the Mine Subsidence Compensation Act 1961 (NSW) to an amount from the Mine Subsidence Compensation Fund to meet the proper and necessary expense of preventing or mitigating that damage.

(c) The Board to pay the appellant's costs of the hearing of the preliminary question before the Land and Environment Court and of the appeal to the Court of Appeal.

3. The Board to pay the costs of the appellant of the appeal to this Court.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appeal concerns the construction of s 12A(1)(b) of the Act. Section 12A(1)(b) provides for compensation to be paid out of the Fund by the Board to the owners of improvements on land for expense incurred in preventing or mitigating damage from subsidence caused by mining[1]. It is a difficult provision, which has occasioned considerable controversy in the courts of New South Wales. [1]See below at [6].The factual background The appellant owns and operates a gas pipeline which runs from Moomba to Sydney. It is licensed to do so under Pt 3 of the Pipelines Act 1967 (NSW), and hence it is a "licensee" for the purposes of that Act. The gas pipeline is the main source of natural gas for the large populations who live in the Sydney and Newcastle metropolitan areas. For the most part the gas pipeline runs underground, and it does so at a point where it crosses Mallaty Creek. The pipeline traverses an area of land which is subject to a mining lease relating to the West Cliff Colliery. That mining lease is held by a subsidiary of BHP Billiton Limited. The pipeline runs above a series of parallel panels numbered 29-36. Those panels have been proposed for longwall mining. Longwall mining has been taking place in them for some years. On 14 April 2003, longwall mining in Longwall 29 began. In December 2003, expert consultants predicted that there would be subsidence at the point where the pipeline crosses Mallaty Creek when Longwall 30 was mined. They also predicted that the subsidence would increase as subsequent longwall panels were mined. In February 2004, other expert consultants advised that no works were needed to mitigate the cumulative effects of subsidence arising from extraction from Longwall 30 and Longwall 31. But they advised that mitigation works would be needed as a result of extraction from Longwall 30, Longwall 31 and Longwall 32. The mining of Longwall 30 was completed on 4 June 2005, and of Longwall 31 on 11 December 2006. Between December 2005 and January 2007, work was done to excavate the pipeline and the three other pipelines which pass along the same easement, to decouple the four pipelines from the soil, and to carry out associated filling. On 20 December 2006, the cumulative subsidence was 42.3mm. In February 2007, the mining of Longwall 32 commenced. By 30 April 2007, the cumulative subsidence had risen to 140.4mm. By 28 August 2007, the cumulative subsidence had risen to 274.7mm. This broadly corresponded with the predictions of the expert consultants. Meanwhile, on 17 July 2007 the appellant made a claim for $2,770,664 against the Board under the Act for the costs of preventative and mitigatory works performed on the pipeline on the northern side of Mallaty Creek. Section 12A(1)(b) provides:"(1)Subject to this section, claims may be made under this Act for payment from the Fund of: … (b) an amount to meet the proper and necessary expense incurred or proposed by or on behalf of the owner of improvements or household or other effects in preventing or mitigating damage to those improvements or household or other effects that, in the opinion of the Board, the owner could reasonably have anticipated would otherwise have arisen, or could reasonably anticipate would otherwise arise, from a subsidence that has taken place, other than a subsidence due to operations carried on by the owner."[2][2]Section 12A(1)(b), introduced in 1969, may be compared with s 12(1)(a) and (b), which provide:"(1)Claims may be made under this Act for payment from the Fund of:(a)compensation for any damage to improvements that arises from subsidence, except where the subsidence is due to operations carried on by the owner of the improvements,(b)an amount to meet the proper and necessary expense incurred or to be incurred as a result of such damage in [listed respects]".Section 13 provides that in lieu of making payments in respect of claims under s 12, the Board has power to purchase the damaged land or restore it.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH CJ, GUMMOW, HAYNE, HEYDON, CRENNAN AND KIEFEL JJ BELL J (dissent)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH CJ, GUMMOW, HAYNE, HEYDON, CRENNAN AND KIEFEL JJ,