Jeffrey v Form Fitness Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Jeffrey v Form Fitness Pty Ltd [2022] FedCFamC2G 600

File number(s): SYG 2487 of 2020
Judgment of: JUDGE DRIVER
Date of judgment: 12 August 2022
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – FAIR WORK – alleged underpayments – whether the applicant was employed  as a casual considered – disagreement over employment records – conflicting evidence of times worked – underpayments unproven – application dismissed
Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 44, 45, 293, 545

Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth)

Superannuation Guarantee (Administration) Act 1992 (Cth) s 49

Cases cited:

Amcor Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union & Ors (2005) 222 CLR 241

Australasian Meat Industry Employees Union (WA Branch) v Woolworths Ltd (2007) 244 ALR 658

City of Wanneroo v Australian Municipal, Administrative, Clerical and Services Union (2006) 153 IR 426

Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v CSBP Limited (2012) 212 IR 206, 64 AILR 101-578

Co-operative Bulk Handling Ltd v Waterside Workers’ Federation of Australia & Anor (1980) 32 ALR 541

Devonald v Rosser & Sons (1906) 2 KB 728

Fair Work Ombudsman v Broome Helicopter Services Pty Ltd & Anor [2017] FCCA 2364

Fair Work Ombudsman v D’Adamo Nominees Pty Ltd (No 4) [2015] FCCA 1178

Federated Clerks’ Union of Australia Industrial Union of Workers (WA Branch) v Cary (1977) 57 WAIG 585

Fightvision Pty Ltd v Onisforou (1999) 47 NSWLR 473

FWO v Quest South Perth Holdings Pty Ltd [2015] HCA 45

Gapes v Commercial Bank of Australia Ltd [1980] FCA 21
Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298

George A Bond & Co Ltd (In liq) v McKenzie [1929] AR (NSW) 498 at 503-504

Keen v Health Corporation Ltd [2008] FMCA 1622

Kucks v CSR Ltd (1996) 66 IR 182

O’Donnell v Reichard [1975] VR 916

Re Porter (1989) 34 IR 179

Sim v LUO Enterprise Pty Ltd (No 2) [2009] FMCA 1060

Stevens v Brodribb Sawmilling Co Pty Ltd [1986] HCA 1

The Director of the Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate v Linkhill Pty Ltd (No 7) [2013] FCCA 1097

The Federated Engine Drivers & Firemen’s Union (WA) v Mt Newman Mining Co Pty Ltd

Transport Workers' Union of Australia v Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Ltd (2014) 284 FLR 238

Vickery v Woods (1952) 85 CLR 336

Ware v O’Donnell Griffin (Television Services) Pty Ltd [1971] AR (NSW) 18

Workpac Pty Ltd v Rossato & Anor [2021] HCA 23

ZG Operations Australia Pty Ltd v Jamsek [2022] HCA 2

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 148
Dates of hearing: 9, 22, 24, 29 September, 1 November 2021, 3, 4, 9 March, 11 May, 1 June 2022
Place: Sydney
Solicitor for the Applicant: Mr K Kutasi of Solve Legal
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr M Fantin
Solicitor for the Respondents: Rickard Lawyers

ORDERS

SYG 2487 of 2020

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

MANNING JEFFREY

Applicant

AND:

FORM FITNESS PTY LTD

First Respondent

RICKY GUILBERT

Second Respondent

DAMIAN SOLDADO

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jeffrey v Form Fitness Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FedCFamC2G 600
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Jeffrey v Form Fitness Pty Ltd involved a dispute between the plaintiff, Mr Jeffrey, and the defendants, Form Fitness Pty Ltd and others. Mr Jeffrey alleged that he had been underpaid during his employment as a personal trainer by the defendants, who operated a gym in Pymble, NSW. The case was contentious, with the trial conducted over multiple days and the parties relying on extensive affidavit evidence and exhibits. The primary issues in dispute were the identity of Mr Jeffrey’s employer, the start date of his employment, the classification of his employment under the Fitness Industry Award 2010, the nature of his employment (full-time or casual), the hours he worked, and the amount he was entitled to be paid during his employment period.

The court had to determine the credibility of the evidence provided by Mr Jeffrey, Mr Guilbert, and Mr Soldado, particularly given the conflicting accounts of the employment terms and conditions. The court found that Mr Jeffrey’s claims were not substantiated. It was determined that Mr Jeffrey was initially employed by Messrs Guilbert and Soldado and subsequently employed by Form Fitness Pty Ltd. Despite Mr Jeffrey's assertions that he was employed by Messrs Guilbert and Soldado, it was clear that his employment transitioned to Form Fitness Pty Ltd after the incorporation of the company on 19 August 2019. The court also found that Mr Jeffrey had exaggerated his working hours to claim additional money and concluded that he was not underpaid any entitlements based on the records of employment.

The court dismissed Mr Jeffrey’s application, holding that he had not proven his claims of underpayment. The decision hinged on the credibility of the evidence and the interpretation of the employment agreement signed by Mr Jeffrey. The court found that the records indicated Mr Jeffrey was overpaid by $17,690, contrary to his claims of underpayment. The court’s decision was based on the clear evidence presented and the inconsistencies in Mr Jeffrey’s account of his employment and entitlements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

These proceedings were hotly contested and the trial was conducted over an extended period on 9, 22, 24 and 29 September 2021, 1 November 2021, 3, 4, and 9 March 2022 and 11 May 2022. The trial concluded with oral submissions on 1 June 2022. The evidence The parties rely on the following affidavit evidence:(a)affidavit of Mr Jeffrey, dated 16 June 2021 (MJ1);(b)affidavit of Mr Jeffrey, dated 3 September 2021 (MJ2);(c)affidavit of Mr Jeffrey, dated 8 September 2021 (MJ3);(d)affidavit of Mr Jeffrey, dated 24 September 2021 (MJ4);(e)affidavit of Dr Rosalind Deaker, dated 24 September 2021 (RD);(f)affidavit of Victor Lau, dated 7 September 2021 (VL);(g)affidavit of Meg Dwyer, dated 7 September 2021 (MD);(h)affidavit of Mr Guilbert, dated 5 or 6 August 2021 (RG1);(i)affidavit of Mr Guilbert, dated 22 September 2021 (RG2);(j)affidavit of Mr Guilbert, dated 24 September 2021 (RG3);(k)affidavit of Mr Soldado, dated 5 August 2021 (DS1);(l)affidavit of Mr Soldado, dated 22 September 2021 (DS2);(m)affidavit of Mr Soldado, dated 24 September 2021 (DS3);(n)affidavit of Cheryl Sloggett, dated 22 September 2021 (CS);(o)affidavit of Peter O’Brien, dated 24 September 2021 (PO);(p)affidavit of Kyle Kutasi, dated 24 September 2021 (KK). I also received the following exhibits:·A1: applicant’s objections to evidence;·A2: “Form Fitness Lawyer File”;·A3: Copy of Fitness Industry Award;·A4: text messages (earlier marked MFI A1);·R1: outline of submissions for respondents;·R2: BSBSMB401, assessment requirements;·R3: BSBSB401, Legal and Risk Management Requirements of Small Businesses;·R4: MA0000094 Fitness Industry Pay Award Guide;·R5: clearer copy of Manning Jeffrey PT Minder calendar 24 June 2019;·R6: PDF document, comparison of casual and full-time employees; ·R7: Air-Tite employment details;·R8: Air-Tite payslips from 27 April 2020 to 14 June 2020;·R9: Air-Tite induction document;·R10: Air-Tite tax declaration;·R11: the Excel spreadsheet which was subpoenaed;·R12: Bar certificate showing Manning Jeffrey’s Certificate 4 in Fitness;·MFI R13: Jeffrey Manning Calendar, Level 3 and 4A;·MFI R14: Jeffrey Manning Calendar, level 4 and 4A. The evidence of Mr Jeffrey, Mr Guilbert and Mr Soldado was tested at length under cross-examination. Issues of credibility arise from that cross-examination.CONSIDERATIONAgreed facts The following matters are common ground between the parties:(a)Mr Jeffrey was originally engaged by Mr Guilbert and Mr Soldado as a contractor on 5 January 2019;(b)Mr Jeffrey was employed by at least one of the respondents between at least 24 June 2019 and 6 June 2020 (“the Employment Period”);(c)Mr Jeffrey was employed as a personal trainer by the respondents;(d)the respondents’ business was at all relevant times a gymnasium located in Pymble, NSW;(e)Mr Jeffrey’s employment was subject to the coverage and operation of the Fitness Industry Award 2010 (“the Award”) at all relevant times;(f)Mr Jeffrey executed a document entitled “Form Fitness – Casual Employment Agreement” on 17 July 2019 (“the Casual Agreement”).[1][1] MJ1 [4], and annexure starting on page 6Issues in dispute

Decision

Reasons for decision

I reject that contention. Mr Jeffrey claims over $70,000 but the basis of that claim, by reference to the Award, is not clear. On the contrary, it appears that Mr Jeffrey was in fact over paid. I received as an aide memoire[62] a spreadsheet prepared by counsel for the respondents which was prepared based upon the Award entitlements for a casual level 3 and level 4A employee. That shows that Mr Jeffrey was over paid $17,690.[62] MFI R13CONCLUSION I make the following findings:(a)Mr Jeffrey was initially employed by Mr Guilbert and Mr Soldado who were, at the time, partners in their gymnasium business;(b)Mr Jeffrey was subsequently by a common understanding employed by Form Fitness under the employment contract that he signed;(c)Mr Jeffrey’s employment commenced on or about 24 June 2019;(d)Mr Jeffrey was employed as a casual trainer under the Award from 24 June 2019 to 9 February 2020 and was employed as a Level 3 employee initially until 9 February 2020 and as a Level 4A thereafter until his employment terminated;(e)Mr Jeffrey worked the hours that are indicated in the PT Minder timesheets put into evidence by the parties, although the arrangement of those hours is in dispute and cannot be definitively determined because of the conflicting records;(f)Mr Jeffrey has exaggerated the working times of his employment between recorded employment periods in an attempt to claim additional money; and(g)on the basis of the records of employment relating to hours worked, irrespective of the dispute as to the arrangement of those hours at particular times and days, Mr Jeffrey has not been underpaid any of his entitlements. I conclude that the claims made by Mr Jeffrey have not been substantiated. The application will be dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The evidence of Mr Jeffrey, Mr Guilbert and Mr Soldado was tested at length under cross-examination. Issues of credibility arise from that cross-examination.CONSIDERATIONAgreed facts The following matters are common ground between the parties:(a)Mr Jeffrey was originally engaged by Mr Guilbert and Mr Soldado as a contractor on 5 January 2019;(b)Mr Jeffrey was employed by at least one of the respondents between at least 24 June 2019 and 6 June 2020 (“the Employment Period”);(c)Mr Jeffrey was employed as a personal trainer by the respondents;(d)the respondents’ business was at all relevant times a gymnasium located in Pymble, NSW;(e)Mr Jeffrey’s employment was subject to the coverage and operation of the Fitness Industry Award 2010 (“the Award”) at all relevant times;(f)Mr Jeffrey executed a document entitled “Form Fitness – Casual Employment Agreement” on 17 July 2019 (“the Casual Agreement”).[1][1] MJ1 [4], and annexure starting on page 6Issues in dispute There are a significant number of issues in dispute in these proceedings:(a)who was the employer of Mr Jeffrey?(b)when did the employment start?(c)what was the relevant classification(s) for the employment under the Award?(d)was the employment full-time or casual?(e)what were the hours worked by Mr Jeffrey during the Employment Period?(f)how much was Mr Jeffrey entitled to be paid under the Award during the Employment Period?Who was the employer? Mr Jeffrey submits that Messrs Guilbert and Soldado (and not the Form Fitness) were the employers of Mr Jeffrey at all relevant times. Mr Jeffrey contends that he was first employed by Messrs Guilbert and Soldado jointly when they were in partnership, trading as “North Shore Personal Coaching” (NSPC). It is uncontroversial that Mr Jeffrey worked as a subcontractor to Messrs Guilbert and Soldado from 5 January 2019 until his employment with them commenced on 6 May 2019. Mr Jeffrey alleges he began receiving payslips from the respondents from the week beginning 6 May 2019. Mr Jeffrey signed a contract of employment with “Form Fitness” on 17 July 2019. Form Fitness Pty Ltd was not registered with ASIC until 19 August 2019. Mr Jeffrey received payslips from NSPC until 4 August 2019, after which his payslips were issued by Form Fitness. Mr Jeffrey denies that he entered into a contract of employment with Form Fitness, whether in writing or otherwise. It is central to Mr Jeffrey’s argument that one cannot make a contract with a person who does not exist. Form Fitness Pty Ltd was not incorporated on 17 July 2019 when the Casual Agreement was executed. In any event, the Casual Agreement does not stipulate that Form Fitness is a party. The name “Form Fitness Pty Ltd”, nor its ACN, appear nowhere on the document. What can be drawn from the Casual Agreement is that “Form Fitness” was at the time a trading name of Messrs Guilbert and Soldado. Mr Jeffrey contends that this was an attempt to formalise the employment relationship that began on 6 May 2019 between the same parties.