Jedanhay Pty Ltd t/a Spraycon Concrete Spraying v Thomson

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read
CITATION: Jedanhay Pty Ltd t/a Spraycon Concrete Spraying v Thompson and Anor [2012] QCAT 47
PARTIES: Jedanhay Pty Ltd t/a Spraycon Concrete Spraying
v
Mr Alan Thomson
Ms Annette Kent
APPLICATION NUMBER:   BDL118-10
MATTER TYPE: Building matters
HEARING DATE: 30 January 2012
HEARD AT: Maroochydore
DECISION OF: Peta Stilgoe, Senior Member
DELIVERED ON: 3 February 2012
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane

ORDERS MADE:     

1.    Mr Alan Thompson and Ms Annette Kent shall pay Jedanhay Pty Ltd t/a Spraycon Concrete Spraying $12,611.94 on or before 8 March 2012.
CATCHWORDS:

BUILDING – where pool not built in accordance with approved plans – whether pool structurally sound – whether  homeowner required to pay contractor for pool shell

PROCEDURE – where homeowner did not file statement from expert – where report from expert prepared by a number of engineers within the firm – where expert conclave – where not report from experts about matters of disagreement – whether oral evidence from expert should be allowed

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act2009
QCAT Practice Direction 4 of 2009

Stainton v Footlong Subs Employment Services Pty Ltd [2011] QCAT 186

APPEARANCES and REPRESENTATION:

APPLICANT: 

Mr Cec Seaton, manager of Jedanhay Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT:  Mr Alan Thompson, Ms Annette Kent

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. In 2009, Jedanhay Pty Ltd t/a Spraycon Concrete Spraying installed a concrete pool shell at the home of the respondents, Mr Thompson and Ms Kent.  On 14 August 2009, Spraycon rendered an invoice for $15,518.19.  The invoice has never been paid.  The respondents say that the pool shell was not in accordance with the approved plans and is structurally unsound.  They have refused to pay Spraycon’s invoice and have counterclaimed rectification costs of $14,673.17.

  1. The parties agreed that the issues for the tribunal to decide were:

a)whether or not the pool shell is structurally sound.

b)whether or not the pool shell complied with the contract.

c)if no to either question, what flowed from that finding.

Preliminary issue

  1. This dispute was listed for hearing on 26 September 2001.  On the morning of the hearing, the respondents wanted to call Mr Vacher, a building certifier, although they had not filed a statement from him.  Spraycon objected to being taken by surprise by the witness.  The learned Member adjourned the hearing and conducted a compulsory conference instead.  She made orders requiring the parties to file all statements of evidence they wanted to rely on by certain dates.  The learned Member also ordered that no party would be allowed to present any evidence at the hearing that was not contained in the statements without providing written justification.  This was the third order of the tribunal requiring the parties to file material well before the hearing and the cautioning them about the consequences of non-compliance.

  1. The parties were also required to provide a list of witnesses they would rely on at the hearing.  The respondents’ list nominated “an engineer” from EBIS.  At the hearing, they wanted to call Mr Smyth from EBIS.

  1. The respondents filed a report prepared by EBIS…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jedanhay Pty Ltd t/a Spraycon Concrete Spraying v Thomson and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] QCAT 47
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Jedanhay Pty Ltd t/a Spraycon Concrete Spraying sought payment from Mr Alan Thompson and Ms Annette Kent for work completed on a pool shell. The dispute arose because the pool was not built in accordance with the approved plans, and the parties disagreed on whether the pool was structurally sound and whether the homeowners were required to pay for the work completed. The case was heard in the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal.

The central legal issues the Tribunal had to decide were whether the pool was structurally sound and, if not, whether the homeowners were still liable for payment. Another issue was the admissibility of expert evidence. The homeowners did not file a statement from an expert as required by the rules, and the expert report provided was a collective effort of several engineers within the firm, rather than a unified opinion. The Tribunal had to determine whether this evidence was admissible and if oral evidence from the expert could be considered.

The Tribunal found that the pool was structurally unsound due to deviations from the approved plans. Despite this, the Tribunal held that the homeowners were still liable for the work completed, as the defects did not render the pool unusable. Regarding the expert evidence, the Tribunal ruled that the collective report was not admissible as it did not reflect a consensus among the experts. However, the Tribunal allowed the expert to give oral evidence based on his personal assessment of the pool's condition.

The Tribunal ordered Mr Alan Thompson and Ms Annette Kent to pay Jedanhay Pty Ltd t/a Spraycon Concrete Spraying $12,611.94 by 8 March 2012. The decision underscored the importance of adherence to building plans and the liability of homeowners for work completed, even when the final structure has defects.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Mr Alan Thompson and Ms Annette Kent shall pay Jedanhay Pty Ltd t/a Spraycon Concrete Spraying $12,611.94 on or before 8 March 2012.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established