JCN v James Cook University & Ors No 3

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

JCN v James Cook University & Ors No 3 [2024] QCAT 258

PARTIES:

JCN

(applicant)

v

JAMES COOK UNIVERSITY

(first respondent)

PROFESSOR RICHARD MURRAY

(second respondent)

DR RANJIT RASALAM

(third respondent)

MS LAURA-ANNE BULL

(fourth respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

ADL005-20

MATTER TYPE:

Anti-discrimination matters

DELIVERED ON:

24 April 2024

HEARING DATES:

On the papers

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member Lumb

ORDERS:

1. Subject to Order 2, pursuant to s 66(1) of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), the publication of the following, other than to the parties to the proceeding (including legal representatives acting on their behalf), is prohibited without further order of the Tribunal:

(a)     the original (unredacted) Reasons for Decision issued in this proceeding on 8 December 2023 (the Original Reasons);

(b)     the names of those persons named in the Original Reasons who are anonymised in the redacted version of the Reasons for Decision referred to in Order 3 (Redacted Reasons);

(c)   all of the information contained in the Original Reasons which has been redacted in the Redacted Reasons;

(d)     the contents of all documents or things filed in or produced to the Tribunal in the proceeding;

(e)   evidence given before the Tribunal, including transcript evidence in the proceeding.

2.     Each of the parties to the proceeding is permitted to publish, solely for the purpose of any application for leave to appeal or appeal to the Appeal Tribunal, or any application for leave to appeal to the Queensland Court of Appeal, the Original Reasons and the names, information, documents, things, and evidence referred to in Order 1.

3.     The Redacted Reasons have been prepared to give effect to these Reasons for Decision (concerning the issue of non-publication) and, subject to any further order, the Redacted Reasons may be published on the Queensland Supreme Court Library website, following the expiry of 14 days after the issue of this Decision.

4.     The Applicant is refused any further extension of time to comply with Direction 4(b) of the Tribunal’s directions dated 22 February 2024.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – PROCEEDINGS IN QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL – JUDGMENTS AND ORDERS – GENERALLY – REASONS FOR JUDGMENT – NON-PUBLICATION ORDERS – where the applicant brought proceedings against the respondents alleging direct and indirect discrimination, and victimisation, contrary to the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld) – where applicant’s complaint was dismissed – where Reasons for Decision published – where two persons named in the Reasons sought non-publication orders – whether a non-publication order under s 66 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) should be made in respect of those persons – whether the Tribunal should, of its own initiative, make non-publication orders in respect of other persons named in the Reasons

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 66

Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld), s 191

Cutbush v Team Maree Property Service (No 3) [2010] QCATA 89
Merlo v Queensland Law Society Inc (No 2) [2023] QCAT 459
Minister for Immigration and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read JCN v James Cook University & Ors No 3 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QCAT 258
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of JCN v James Cook University & Ors No 3, the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) was tasked with considering applications for non-publication orders in relation to a decision handed down under the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld). The applicant had brought proceedings against the university and others, alleging direct and indirect discrimination, and victimisation. The tribunal dismissed the complaint, and the reasons for decision were published. Two individuals named in the reasons sought non-publication orders, and the tribunal had to decide whether such orders should be made under section 66 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld). Additionally, the tribunal considered whether it should, of its own initiative, make non-publication orders in respect of other persons named in the reasons.

The tribunal considered the discretion conferred by section 66(2) of the QCAT Act, noting that it was not to be exercised lightly and only if the tribunal considered the order was necessary. The tribunal examined the submissions of the applicant, who was a practising medical practitioner and was not a party or witness in the case. The applicant had not been aware of the proceedings and was not privy to the knowledge of any rumour. The applicant had been identified by name and had confidential material published, leading to significant distress, including fear for physical safety, anxiety, and an inability to concentrate. The applicant also expressed concerns about the impact on their ability to care for patients from certain communities and future vocational prospects.

The tribunal concluded that the making of non-publication orders was necessary in the interests of justice. It noted that the applicant had not consented to the publication of their name and information, and the publication had caused significant distress and anxiety. The tribunal also considered the public interest in the publication of the reasons for decision and the potential impact on the applicant's ability to care for patients and future vocational prospects. The tribunal made non-publication orders in respect of the applicant and another individual named in the reasons, prohibiting the publication of their names and information, except for the purposes of an appeal. The tribunal also ordered that the redacted reasons for decision could be published on the Queensland Supreme Court Library website after 14 days.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Subject to Order 2, pursuant to s 66(1) of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), the publication of the following, other than to the parties to the proceeding (including legal representatives acting on their behalf), is prohibited without further order of the Tribunal:

(a) the original (unredacted) Reasons for Decision issued in this proceeding on 8 December 2023 (the Original Reasons);

(b) the names of those persons named in the Original Reasons who are anonymised in the redacted version of the Reasons for Decision referred to in Order 3 (Redacted Reasons);

(c) all of the information contained in the Original Reasons which has been redacted in the Redacted Reasons;

(d) the contents of all documents or things filed in or produced to the Tribunal in the proceeding;

(e) evidence given before the Tribunal, including transcript evidence in the proceeding.

2. Each of the parties to the proceeding is permitted to publish, solely for the purpose of any application for leave to appeal or appeal to the Appeal Tribunal, or any application for leave to appeal to the Queensland Court of Appeal, the Original Reasons and the names, information, documents, things, and evidence referred to in Order 1.

3. The Redacted Reasons have been prepared to give effect to these Reasons for Decision (concerning the issue of non-publication) and, subject to any further order, the Redacted Reasons may be published on the Queensland Supreme Court Library website, following the expiry of 14 days after the issue of this Decision.

4. The Applicant is refused any further extension of time to comply with Direction 4(b) of the Tribunal’s directions dated 22 February 2024.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In Cutbush v Team Maree Property Service (No 3),[7] Alan Wilson J, President, stated: The phrase ‘in the interests of justice’ is not defined in the QCAT Act but generally confers a broad discretionary power on the decision-maker. The wording of s 66(2) makes it plain that the discretion is not to be exercised lightly, and only if the Tribunal considers the order is necessary.(citation omitted)[7][2010] QCATA 89, [7], cited in Merlo at [24].The factual matrix of the primary Decision As addressed in the Redacted Reasons, the complaint made by the Applicant under the ADA involved, relevantly for present purposes, an alleged failure to investigate (or properly investigate) complaints made by the Applicant concerning the conduct of other students in relation to rumours that were said to be circulating about the Applicant, and his subsequent suspension while studying his medical degree, and later exclusion from the University. The Applicant’s case in relation to both direct discrimination and indirect discrimination claimed discrimination on the basis of the attributes of race (specifically Middle Eastern ethnicity or descent) and religious belief or religious activity (specifically that the Applicant was a Muslim). The theme of the Applicant’s case theory in this regard relied primarily (but not exclusively) upon the relationship between Professor Murray and the Jewish community, in particular the Deputy Vice Chancellor of Medicine at the University (and his wife). Further, issues involving the Applicant’s conduct and his correspondence with the First Respondent referenced a number of students said to be Jewish and asserted that there were arguments between a (named) Jewish student and Muslim students (two of whom he named) concerning Palestine and Israel. The Applicant was wholly unsuccessful in the claims he brought against each of the Respondents. JCA application JCA seeks an order prohibiting the publication of the following material in the proceeding:(a)any information which may enable JCA to be identified (including, but not limited to, the name of JCA);(b)the content of any document produced or provided to the Tribunal which contains any correspondence involving JCA (including correspondence written by, addressed to, or in relation to, JCA;(c)any evidence given to the Tribunal in relation to the above matters. The Respondents do not oppose the making of such an order. JCA has provided comprehensive written submissions in support of the application. Without reciting all of the submissions, I consider the substance of the matters relied upon by JCA to be as follows:(a)JCA is a practising medical practitioner;(b)until the published primary Decision was brought to the attention of JCA by a university friend, JCA was not aware that there was an active case in the Tribunal;(c)JCA was not a witness or party to the case, nor was JCA approached for consent to provide evidence or information for the case;(d)JCA was distraught that JCA’s name and confidential material was readily publicly available, and that numerous university colleagues had alerted JCA to the existence of the primary Decision;(e)at a factual level, JCA was not ‘privy to knowledge of any rumour’ (I interpolate, in relation to the Applicant) and JCA was not part of any rumour;(f)JCA was ‘mercilessly attacked’ by an unknown ‘internet assailant’ as evidenced by an email of 23 June 2017 (Redacted Reasons [70]) and JCA approached ‘University support’ to express his concern, seek counsel, and to report these encounters ‘officially’. This caused JCA ‘extreme turbulence’, fear for his ‘physical safety’, and concerns that the false content of this denigrating attack would extend to the public domain;(g)the last correspondence JCA had with the First Respondent regarding the matter was that information involving him would not be used and confidentiality would be maintained. In 2018, JCA received information about a workplace investigation by the First Respondent taking place, and JCA was asked if his emails could be used, and JCA ‘clearly requested’ that all identifiable materials were not to be used, confidentiality was to be maintained, and that his identity was to be ‘protected’. JCA requested this out of genuine fear of what could ensue if the identity of JCA was shared, and the information made publicly available. The specific concerns were:(i) JCA feared that breach of confidentiality would make him vulnerable to confrontation by any persons mentioned in the correspondence;(ii) JCA feared that sharing of the private emails would make him vulnerable to another attack by the ‘Internet assailant’;(iii) JCA feared the toll that this would take on his health;(iv) JCA feared the possible physical, verbal, digital, and emotional attack that could ensue from the sensitive and confidential material being publicly available;(v) JCA feared the repercussions from being involved (even if indirectly) in a ‘turbulent legal case/investigation’ could have on his career as a junior doctor as he did not want to be associated with the numerous harmful and pervasive ‘themes’ inherent in the case;(h)the above matters lay the foundation for the current fear by JCA of physical, verbal, mental and emotional threat that might ensue from having the information concerning JCA and his identity publicly available, and JCA describes himself as being put in a ‘perpetually vulnerable position’;(i)JCA states that, since discovering the published primary Decision, he has suffered extreme anxiety with insomnia, and an inability to concentrate in his work, and it has hindered his ability to participate in relationships. JCA fears that his personal life could be targeted, and that his safety and that of his family and friends could be compromised. JCA states that since discovering the primary Decision, he has experienced constant fear and anxiety, and this has impacted him in both his social interactions and vocational responsibilities, and he has sought medical attention for this;(j)JCA states that in his role as a medical practitioner he cares for a ‘diverse patient population’ and that the publication of his name and confidential material, which associates him with ‘very complex and turbulent themes explored in the Decision’ could significantly impact his ability to care for patients from certain communities because the information may be perceived out of context, and this could detract from the doctor-patient relationship. JCA considers that this poses a significant risk to disenfranchising him from communities that he routinely cares for. JCA contends that this would be contrary to the public interest;(k)JCA is concerned that the relevant information could be interpreted without appreciation for the ‘complex context’, and this could impact his future vocational prospects with employers. JCA is concerned that the material contained in the relevant email could impact him personally, socially, and vocationally;(l)JCA also fears retaliation from other persons mentioned in the correspondence, in particular one named person who now holds what is said to be a ‘very respectable position within our society’; and the content of the email, which is ‘out-of-context’, could ‘elicit negative retaliation’ and this creates ‘a state of perpetual vulnerability’ which is said to severely impact the mental health of JCA. JCA submits that that this has the potential to negatively impact other members of the public;(m)finally, JCA submits that the parties to the proceeding will suffer no prejudice if the identifiable information in relation to JCA is not published.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.