JBS Australia Pty Limited v the Workers' Compensation Regulator

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:        

JBS Australia Pty Limited v the Workers' Compensation Regulator [2019] QIRC 120

PARTIES:

JBS Australia Pty Limited
(Appellant)

v

the Workers' Compensation Regulator
(Respondent)

CASE NO:

WC/2017/234

PROCEEDING:

Appeal against a decision of the Workers' Compensation Regulator

DELIVERED ON:

21 August 2019

HEARING DATES: 

27 February 2019

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

MEMBER:

Bloomfield DP

ORDERS:

1.      The appeal is upheld in part.

2.      The decision of the Regulator dated 15 November 2017 is set aside.

3. The Worker is entitled to workers' compensation payments for the period of her total incapacity for work, calculated in accordance with the provisions of s 150 of the Act.

4. The Worker is entitled to workers' compensation payments for the periods of her partial incapacity for work, calculated in accordance with the provisions of s 162 and s 163 of the Act.

5.      The matter is returned to the Regulator, with the direction that the workers' compensation entitlements of the Worker are to be calculated in accordance with Orders (3) and (4) above.

6.      The matter of costs is reserved, to be dealt with on application, if either party is minded to apply.

CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS' COMPENSATION - APPEAL AGAINST DECISION - WHETHER EMPLOYER ENTITLED TO DECREASE PAYMENT OF WEEKLY COMPENSATION ENTITLEMENT DURING A SEASONAL CLOSURE - WHETHER REGULATOR ENTITLED TO DIRECT A HIGHER LEVEL OF WEEKLY ENTITLEMENT IF SELF‑INSURER DOES NOT PROVIDE REHABILITATION SERVICES - where principles of statutory interpretation - where no ambiguity - where natural and grammatical meaning of provisions applied - where neither seasonal shutdown nor termination of a worker's employment affects obligations of an employer as a-self insurer - appeal upheld in part - matter returned to the Regulator with directions.

LEGISLATION:

CASES:

Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003, s 4, s 5, s 107B, s 108, s 144A, s 145, s 147, s 150, s 162, s 163, s 168, s 173, s 220
WorkCover Queensland Act 1996, s 1171
Acts Interpretation Act 1954 (Qld), s 14A

Kelly v WorkCover Queensland [2002] 1 Qd R 496
State of Queensland (Queensland Ambulance Service) v Q‑Comp [2006] QIC 25
Anderton v Q-Comp 183 QGIG 671.
The Metropolitan Gas Co v The Federated Gas Employees' Industrial Union [1924] 35 CLR 449
Attorney-General v Prince Augustus of Hanover [1957] AC 436
Project Blue Sky  v Australian Broadcasting Authority (1998) 194 CLR 355

Grey v Pearson (1857) 6 HLC 61

Q-COMP v Baulch [2004] QIC 11, 175 QGIG 978
Cloncurry Shire Council v Workers' Compensation Regulatory Authority & Anor [2006] QSC 326
Brett Holt Plumbing Pty Ltd v Q-COMP (2005) 178 QGIG 255
Toll North Pty Ltd v Simon Blackwood (Workers' Compensation Regulator) & Lamb [2014] QIRC 065
Mandep Sarkaria v Workers' Compensation Regulator [2019] ICQ 001

APPEARANCES:

Dr G.J. Cross, Counsel instructed by Mr C. Murphy of HBA Legal, for the Appellant.

Mr P.B. O'Neill, Counsel directly instructed by Ms J. Edwards of the Workers' Compensation Regulator, for the Respondent.

Decision

  1. This matter concerns an Appeal by JBS…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read JBS Australia Pty Limited v the Workers' Compensation Regula... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QIRC 120
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of JBS Australia Pty Limited v the Workers' Compensation Regulator, the primary issue before the court was whether an employer was entitled to decrease the payment of weekly compensation entitlements during a seasonal closure, and whether the Regulator was entitled to direct a higher level of weekly entitlement if the self-insurer did not provide rehabilitation services. The dispute arose from the interpretation of provisions within the Queensland Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003. The Workers' Compensation Regulator argued that the employer's obligations as a self-insurer were not affected by a seasonal shutdown or termination of employment, whereas the employer contended that the compensation payments should reflect the seasonal nature of the employment.

The court meticulously examined the statutory language and principles of statutory interpretation, determining that there was no ambiguity in the provisions. It applied the natural and grammatical meaning of the statutory language to conclude that neither a seasonal shutdown nor the termination of employment affected the employer's obligations as a self-insurer. The court further held that the Regulator's interpretation aligned with the beneficial intent of the legislation and was consistent with other provisions of the Act, such as the ongoing obligation to provide rehabilitation services. The court found that the employer's argument, which sought to interpret the provisions in a manner that would reduce compensation payments during a seasonal shutdown, did not align with the clear language of the Act.

As a result, the court upheld the appeal in part, setting aside the Regulator's decision dated 15 November 2017. It directed that the worker's compensation entitlements should be calculated in accordance with the provisions of s 150, s 162, and s 163 of the Act, for total and partial incapacity for work, respectively. The matter was returned to the Regulator with directions to recalculate the worker's compensation entitlements in line with the court's orders. The court reserved the matter of costs, to be dealt with on application if either party chose to apply.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is upheld in part.

2. The decision of the Regulator dated 15 November 2017 is set aside.

3. The Worker is entitled to workers' compensation payments for the period of her total incapacity for work, calculated in accordance with the provisions of s 150 of the Act.

4. The Worker is entitled to workers' compensation payments for the periods of her partial incapacity for work, calculated in accordance with the provisions of s 162 and s 163 of the Act.

5. The matter is returned to the Regulator, with the direction that the workers' compensation entitlements of the Worker are to be calculated in accordance with Orders (3) and (4) above.

6. The matter of costs is reserved, to be dealt with on application, if either party is minded to apply.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In his oral submissions, Mr O'Neill, who represented the Regulator, stressed it was necessary for the Commission to keep in mind that there is a distinction between the employer, as such, and the employer as a self-insurer. In a situation where there was not self-insurance, and the employee was terminated - even on a seasonal termination of employment basis - the Insurer would still have the obligation to pay workers' compensation benefits.The Regulator's conclusion The Regulator said that if a beneficial interpretation to the Act was adopted by the Commission, then, to the extent that there is any ambiguity in s 147, it should be construed so as to give the fullest relief which the fair meaning of its language will allow (in the words of Martin P at paragraph [27] in Sarkaria[12]). The approach to the interpretation of s 147 propounded by the Regulator does this, whereas the approach propounded by the Appellant does not. In fact, the Appellant's approach subverts the beneficial intent of the legislation.[12] Mandep Sarkaria v Workers' Compensation Regulator [2019] ICQ 001, [27]. Finally, the Regulator submitted that its approach to the interpretation of s 147 was also consistent with the other provisions of the Act, like s 220 which confirms that the Insurer has an ongoing obligation to provide rehabilitation to an injured worker and to ensure an injured worker makes an early return to suitable duties. The Appellant made passing reference in its submissions to the provision in s 107B(3) of the Act in support of its argument that the provisions of s 147 should be interpreted in the manner it proposed, namely: that the Worker's entitlements should reflect those which she would have received during the relevant "season" - i.e. the seasonal shutdown - being $0. However, the flaw in this argument is that, on the submissions made, the Agreement does not include any reference to "seasons" per se, or different provisions that might apply in different seasons. Although the Agreement does include reference to a daily hire allowance and a seasonal allowance (both apparently paid while employees are at work), the nature of those provisions are not sufficiently apparent to attract the operation of s 107B(3). Further, a shutdown could hardly be described as a "season", given that there is no work performed during it. In the present situation, there is no apparent distinction in the Agreement between amounts payable to workers in one "season" compared to amounts which might be payable in another "season" such that the provisions of s 107B(3) would be enlivened. By way of contrast: an industrial instrument (such as an Agreement) covering the workforce of a sugar mill might include a provision to the effect that for six months of the year (the non-harvesting period) the hours of work will be 4 x 8.5 hour days = 34 hours per week, while in the other six months (the harvesting season) they will be 42 hours, worked on 5 days of 8.4 hours each. The provisions of that industrial instrument would activate the operation of s 107B(3) and require an injured worker's compensation payments to be calculated to reflect the relevant season (or part thereof).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It appears to be a logical and natural extension of the meaning and effect of s 147 that an employee who has lost the capacity to earn income, whilst engaged by the Appellant in a meat processing plant, will lose an entitlement to weekly compensation at the same time that other workers at that plant lose their entitlement to weekly income by reason of a seasonal closure.Previous consideration of s 147 The Appellant said s 147 was considered by Hall P in State of Queensland (Queensland Ambulance Service) v Q-Comp (QAS)[4] in circumstances which were not similar to the present situation. In that matter, the Appellant argued that an ambulance officer who was arrested by the police and charged with a number of drug and dishonesty offences, and later suspended without pay, was disentitled to workers' compensation in respect of an application for compensation for a major depressive order made after his suspension.[4] State of Queensland (Queensland Ambulance Service) v Q-Comp [2006] QIC 25. In the appeal proceedings, the Appellant contended that: if the worker, who is still employed and in that sense was still 'at work' had actually presented for work, the worker would have been turned away and would not have been paid. (Appellant's emphasis) In his decision, Hall P noted the decision of Atkinson J in Kelly and went on to express the view that s 147 was in the "nature of a limitation on beneficence", saying:It seems to me that it should be treated as part of a legislative attempt to achieve a careful and practical balance between competing interests and not moulded by a Court to better achieve a remedial goal. Hall P also drew attention to the fact that the Act expressly suspended the payment of compensation where a worker was serving a term of imprisonment and noted there was no comparable provision about suspension. Nonetheless, he went on to indicate that the task of the Magistrate was to construe the legislation, not to remedy (presumed) legislative defects. The Appellant submitted that, in the case, there was no contention that work for its general able-bodied employees was reduced to nil by reason of seasonal or other factors, as is the case here. There was no prospect that other employees would not have been "at work" as they had not been terminated. There is a distinction between an employee suspended for disciplinary reasons (as in QAS) and a situation where an employee has been seasonally terminated. Seasonal workers are addressed specifically under the Act by s 107B(3), which provides:If a worker is employed in an industry that is seasonal in nature, the amount payable to the worker must reflect the relevant season under the industrial instrument. There is a further distinction to be drawn between QAS and the present circumstances. The former relates to an employee who was still substantially employed, although suspended, whereas the present circumstances relate to an employee who had been (seasonally) terminated. In the former case there is an ongoing entitlement to employment whereas in the latter there is only a possibility of re-engagement in the new season.