JBS Australia Pty Limited v Mr Gai Reng

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

[2013] FWCFB 5761

FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION


Fair Work Act 2009

s.604—Appeal of decision

JBS Australia Pty Limited
v
Mr Gai Reng
(C2013/44)

VICE PRESIDENT LAWLER
DEPUTY PRESIDENT SMITH
COMMISSIONER BLAIR

SYDNEY, 14 AUGUST 2013

Appeal against decision [[2012] FWA 10879] of Commissioner Ryan at Melbourne on 3 and 11 January 2013 in U2012/12197 – unfair dismissal – error of fact.

[1] This is an application by JBS Australia Pty Limited (JBS) for permission to appeal and, if permission is granted, an appeal against the decision and order of Commissioner Ryan allowing an application for an unfair dismissal remedy by the Respondent, Mr Gai Reng, and ordering his reinstatement with backpay.

Background

[2] The Respondent (Mr Reng or Tito) had been employed by JBS at its cold store facility in Brooklyn since February 2006 and has been employed as a forklift driver at the cold store since early 2012. Mr Reng has also been the National Union of Workers (NUW) site delegate since 2007 and an elected Health and Safety Representative since 2008.

[3] Mr Reng was dismissed for misconduct. The letter of termination records that the employer relied upon the following reasons for dismissing Mr Reng:

    (i) Deliberately failed to follow your Supervisor and Manager’s instructions.

    (ii) Acting violently in the workplace and, in particular, “placing at risk the workplace health and safety of your Manager by continually pushing the office door into her and standing over her in a threatening and abusive manner” in breach of the employer’s Workplace Health and Safety Policy.

[4] The dismissal arose out of an incident that occurred on 20 July 2012. The origins of the incident were not in dispute. Mr Reng was walking past a group of employees on a break. One of the employees uttered the vulgarity “fuck!”. Mr Reng considered that the remark had been directed at him and took offence. He proceeded to the office of Ms Chanel Matthews, the cold store manager. Ms Matthews said she was busy and asked Mr Reng to come back later.

[5] Mr Reng returned to the employees and remonstrated with them. One of the employees, Mr Riki Muru, took offence at Mr Reng’s approach and both he and Mr Reng went to Ms Matthews’ office.

[6] The misconduct relied upon by the employer is alleged to have occurred when Mr Reng returned to Ms Matthew’s office.

What Happened in Matthews’ Office

[7] Ms Chanel Matthews gave the following account in her statement (Ex R3):

    “11. Literally 3 minutes [after she had told Mr Reng she was busy and to come back later], Riki came up the stairs in to my office with Tito right behind him and said “Chanel, what’s going on? This cunt is coming down to us telling us we are going to HR.”

    12. Then Tito said “Did you hear what he called me, his threatening me!”

    13. Riki said “I’m not talking to you, I want to know what’s going on!”

    14.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read JBS Australia Pty Limited v Mr Gai Reng and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FWCFB 5761
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

JBS Australia Pty Limited appealed a decision by Commissioner Ryan of the Fair Work Commission, delivered on 3 and 11 January 2013 in case number U2012/12197. The case pertains to an unfair dismissal claim brought by Mr Gai Reng against JBS Australia. The central dispute was whether Mr Reng was unfairly dismissed and whether the Commissioner erred in his findings of fact.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Commissioner made an error of fact in his assessment of the evidence presented. The court needed to determine if the Commissioner's findings were open to him on the evidence and whether any error in fact led to a manifestly unjust outcome. This included assessing the procedural fairness of the dismissal process and the employer's adherence to relevant laws and policies.

The court examined the evidence and the Commissioner's reasoning, ultimately finding that the Commissioner had erred in his assessment of certain facts. The court concluded that these errors led to a manifestly unjust outcome and thus overturned the Commissioner's decision. The court held that Mr Reng was indeed unfairly dismissed, but this was not the result of the errors identified. As a result, the appeal was dismissed, and the original decision of unfair dismissal was reinstated.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established