Jarrad v Melbourne and Metropolitan Tramways Board

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

CATCIJWORDS

II

Industrial law - breach of award -

stand down'' of employees -

work available not given

to employees but kept for later

II

resumption of work

- not thereby unable to usefully employ" -

"usefully" not synonym for "gainfully"

- employer failing to

exercise sufficient diligence

In deciding to stand down

employees - penalty imposed - Conciliation and Arbitration

Act

1904 S . 119

Clifford Jarrad v. Melbourne and Metropolitan

Tramavs Boerd

Coram :

Keely J.

Place:

Melbourne

Date:

4 August 1978

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTR4LIA

) 1

INDUSTRIAL DIVISION

)

V. No. 16 of 1978

)

VICTORIA

DISTRICT

EGISTRY

1

IN THE MATTER o f the Conciliation and Arbltration Act 1904

CLIFFORD JARRAD

Claimant

- and -

MELBOURNE AND METROPOLITAN

TRAMWAYS BOA2D

espondent

JUDGE MAKING ORDER:

KEELY, J.

DATE OF ORDER:

4 August 1978

WHERE MADE:

Melbourne

ORDER OF THE COURT:

1.

The Court determines that the respondent on or

about

4 October 1977 committed

a breach of the Vehlcle Industry

(Roping In No. 1) Award 1974 in that it failed to pay to

the persons whose names appear in the summons herein (as

amended) other than James John krphy the amount of wage

appropriate under the said Award to which the said persons

were entitled in respect

of 4 October 1977.

2. The Court imposes upon the respondent a penalty of Five

hundred dollars ($500.00) in respect of the said breach

of the Award.

3. The Court orders thaL the whole of the penalty be paid to

the Vehicle Builders Employees' Federation

f Australia.

J

- 2 -

9

4 . The Court orders that the respondent shall pay to each of

the employees referred to

in paragraph 1 hereof in respect

of whom the said breach has been found,

the amount of the

underpayment resulting from the

said breach of the Award.

5.

Liberty to

apply.

r'KOM lKANSLRIr,I

Or

ORAL

J U U G M t N ' I

,

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

)

) V. No. 16 of 1978

INDUSTRIAL DIVISION

)

IN THE MATTER of the Conciliatlon

and Arbitration Act

1904

B E T W E E N :

CLIFFORD JARRAD

Claimant

AND

THE MELBOURNE ASD NETR@POLITAN

TRAMWAYS BOARD

Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGXENT

4 AUGUST 1978

KEELY, J.

This is an application under s.119

of the Conciliztion

and Arbitration Act 1904, (the Act) for the imposition of

a penalty in respect

of an alleged breach of the Vehicle

Industry (Roping-In No. 1) Award 1974.

The breach alleged.

as amended without obJection at the hraring, is that of failing

to pay to certain members

of the Vehicle Builders Employees'

Federation of Australia (the FederaLion) wages

in respect of

the whole or any part

of 4 October 1977.

At the commencement of the hearing the summons

was

amended by consent to delete the name Max Flynn from the llst

i

of employees set out in the summons. The summons as amended

1

contained the names

of 14 employees of whom…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jarrad v Melbourne and Metropolitan Tramways Board and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1978] FCA 71
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Clifford Jarrad v. Melbourne and Metropolitan Tramways Board involved a dispute over the employer's decision to stand down employees without pay due to electricity restrictions. The claimant, Clifford Jarrad, acting on behalf of the Vehicle Builders Employees' Federation of Australia, sought a penalty for the employer's alleged breach of the Vehicle Industry (Roping-In No. 1) Award 1974. The key legal issues were whether the employer had the right to stand down the employees without pay and if the employer exercised sufficient diligence in determining the availability of work. The court found that the employer was in breach of the award by failing to pay wages to employees on 4 October 1977. The court held that the term "usefully employed" did not equate to "gainfully employed" and that the employer was required to exercise diligence in ascertaining the availability of work. The court imposed a penalty of $500 and ordered the employer to pay the underpaid wages to the affected employees.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established