Jang v Australia Meat Holdings P/L

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

REGISTRY: TOWNSVILLE

NUMBER: S21 OF 1995

Plaintiff PETER KEITH JANG
AND
Defendant AUSTRALIA MEAT HOLDINGS PTY LTD
(ACN 01 062 338)

DECISION - DOUGLAS J.

DELIVERED THE SIXTEENTH DAY OF MARCH 2000.

1.         The Plaintiff is 53 years of age, having been born on 17 May 1946. He is

now unemployed and has not worked since leaving the employ of the

Defendant in 1993.

2.         He has lived in Townsville for almost all of his life. In his last year of school

he contracted rheumatic fever and subsequently left school at Grade 10.

He came from a family of eight children who are closely reliant, each upon

the other.

3.         He worked in various jobs over the years and eventually in 1992 obtained

employment at the Defendant's meatworks in Townsville. To begin with he

was employed there as a Trade's Assistant but preferred to do outside

work. He was offered outside work but from time to time he was called to

do work inside the meatworks. He did not like it because it was an

unpleasant sort of job and he preferred to be outside. In any event he was

from time to time called up to do work inside the meatworks and in

particular, on a number of days in what was known as the "condemned"
room, where foetuses extracted from pregnant cows were drained for their

blood for research work. He periodically went inside the meatworks to clean

up in and around the meat products. In all, he was at the meatworks for

about 12 months.

4.         It is admitted by the Defendant that the Plaintiff contracted a rickettsial

disease known as Q Fever in May/June 1993 and further that the Defendant

did not vaccinate the Plaintiff during his period of employment with the

Defendant. What is not admitted is that he contracted Q Fever at the

meatworks operated by the Defendant.

5.         The evidence reveals that Q Fever is a disease which is prevalent in

meatworks. It is prevalent wherever cows, sheep and goats are present

and in particular when they are being slaughtered. Indeed the evidence

revealed that the contraction of Q Fever in Switzerland, when associated

with a moving herd of cattle down a mountain, was known. In my view there

is no doubt that the Plaintiff contracted Q Fever whilst in the Defendant's

employ at the Townsville meatworks.

6.         In about 1990, the Plaintiff had a number of months off work whilst waiting

for a heart valve replacement. The necessity for this heart valve

replacement was caused by the rheumatic fever which he had contracted

whilst at school. Much was made by the Defendant of symptoms which the

Plaintiff complained of prior to his contraction of Q Fever in 1993. I find that

prior to that contraction of Q Fever he had intermittent symptoms similar to

those which relate to Q Fever but which did not have the attendant result of

keeping him away from work. He had…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jang v Australia Meat Holdings P/L and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] QSC 60
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Jang v Australia Meat Holdings P/L, the plaintiff, Peter Keith Jang, claimed against the defendant, Australia Meat Holdings P/L, for damages arising from his employment at the defendant's meatworks in Townsville. Jang alleged that he contracted Q Fever during his employment in 1993, which rendered him unable to work, and that the defendant was negligent in not vaccinating him against Q Fever and not warning him of the risks associated with the disease. The defendant admitted that Jang contracted Q Fever but denied that it was contracted at the meatworks or that it was negligent in its duty of care towards Jang. The court had to determine whether the defendant was negligent in failing to vaccinate Jang against Q Fever and in not warning him of the risks of contracting the disease.

The court found that the defendant was negligent in not warning Jang of the risks of contracting Q Fever and the means by which it could be avoided. The court accepted that by 1992, a vaccine to prevent the contraction of Q Fever was commercially available and that the defendant had set up a consultation process to determine whether the entire existing workforce of the defendant should be vaccinated against the disease. However, the defendant failed to warn prospective employees of the specific risk of Q Fever and the means by which it could be avoided. The court found that had Jang been appropriately warned, he would have consulted his general practitioner and been vaccinated before he took up employment with the defendant. The court also found that the defendant's failure to warn Jang of the risks of contracting Q Fever constituted a lack of reasonable care. The court rejected the defendant's defence of contributory negligence, noting that it was not a defence to an action of this nature.

The court assessed Jang's damages at $290,571.37, taking into account his past and future economic loss, general damages for his ongoing Post Q Fever Fatigue Syndrome, and special damages for medical and other expenses. The court awarded Jang judgment against the defendant in the sum of $259,937.63, together with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Peter Keith Jang, a 53-year-old man from Townsville, was employed by Australia Meat Holdings P/L (AMH) at their Townsville meatworks in 1992. He was initially employed as a Trade's Assistant but preferred outdoor work. He was occasionally required to work inside the meatworks, including in a "condemned" room where foetuses were drained for research. AMH did not vaccinate Jang against Q Fever, a rickettsial disease known to be prevalent in meatworks. Jang contracted Q Fever in May/June 1993, and while AMH admitted he contracted the disease during his employment, they disputed that he contracted it at their meatworks. The court found that Jang did contract Q Fever at the meatworks. Jang suffered from Q Fever Fatigue Syndrome post-infection, rendering him incapable of working. The court found that the symptoms he experienced prior to contracting Q Fever were not severe enough to prevent him from working. The case also involved determining whether Jang's 1999 heart valve replacement was due to Q Fever endocarditis, which the court concluded had not been proven.

This case was heard in the Supreme Court of Queensland at Townsville. The Plaintiff, Peter Keith Jang, sued the Defendant, Australia Meat Holdings P/L, for negligence and breach of contract. Jang claimed damages for the injuries he sustained due to contracting Q Fever while employed by AMH. The court assessed the Plaintiff's damages and determined liability. The Defendant attempted to raise defences of contributory negligence and counter-claimed for breach of contract damages, both of which were dismissed by the court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Defendant was negligent in failing to warn the Plaintiff of the risk of contracting Q Fever and the availability of a vaccine.
2. Whether the Plaintiff was contributorily negligent in not taking precautions to protect himself from Q Fever.
3. Whether the Defendant's failure to warn about Q Fever and the availability of a vaccine constitutes a breach of contract.

Held
1. The court found that the Defendant was negligent in failing to warn the Plaintiff of the risk of contracting Q Fever and the availability of a vaccine.
2. The court found that the Plaintiff was not contributorily negligent in not taking precautions to protect himself from Q Fever.
3. The court found that the Defendant's failure to warn about Q Fever and the availability of a vaccine did not constitute a breach of contract.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court assessed the Defendant's duty of care towards the Plaintiff, concluding that employers must take reasonable care to avoid exposing employees to unnecessary risks. The Defendant had a warning system in place for zoonotic diseases but failed to specifically warn about Q Fever, a well-known risk in abattoirs. The court held that this omission was a lack of reasonable care, as the Plaintiff, who was health-conscious and regularly consulted with doctors, would have sought vaccination had he been properly warned. The court also ruled that contributory negligence was not applicable as it was not a defence to the Plaintiff's claim brought both in negligence and in contract. Regarding the breach of contract, the court relied on prior authority to conclude that no action for damages for breach of contract lay against the Plaintiff.

The court's decision highlighted the importance of specific warnings about known risks in employment settings, especially when preventive measures such as vaccines are available. The binding principle established is that employers must provide explicit warnings about significant risks to which employees may be exposed in the workplace, and failure to do so can constitute a breach of the duty of care. The court distinguished this case from previous holdings by emphasizing that contributory negligence is not a defence in actions combining negligence and contract claims.