[2014] AATA 415
Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION File Number(s)
2011/2711
Re
Janet Roberts-Billett
APPLICANT
And
Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation
RESPONDENT
DECISION
Tribunal Regina Perton, Member
Date 25 June 2014 Place Melbourne The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.
[sgd]........................................................................
Regina Perton, Member
SUPERANNUATION – spouse pension – widow – applicant remarried husband shortly before his death – applicant not living with husband – whether apart due to special circumstances – remittal by Federal Court to explain reason for a particular finding more fully – decision affirmed
Legislation
Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 sections 6A, 6B, 39
Cases
Roberts-Billett and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation [2013] AATA 440Roberts-Billettt v Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation [2013] FCA 1328
REASONS FOR DECISION
Regina Perton, Member
25 June 2014
Janet Roberts-Billett is the widow of the late Royston Stanley Billett who died on 19 March 2010. Mr Billett retired from the Defence Force on 8 April 1985 after more than 15 years of service. Mrs Roberts-Billett and Mr Billett remarried eight days before his death after having separated and divorced years earlier.
On 3 June 2010 Mrs Roberts-Billett applied for a spouse benefit under the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 (the Act). On 24 August 2010 a delegate of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority (the Authority) refused the benefit on the basis that Mrs Roberts-Billett did not meet the definition of surviving spouse in the Act. On review, the Authority affirmed the delegate's decision on 6 June 2011. On 27 June 2013, this Tribunal affirmed the reviewable decision (Roberts-Billett and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation [2013] AATA 440).
Mrs Roberts-Billett lodged an appeal in the Federal Court. On 6 December 2013, the Court remitted the matter by consent to the Tribunal (Roberts-Billett v Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation [2013] FCA 1328) with the following orders:
1. The decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal in Janet Roberts-Billett v Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation [2013] AATA 440 is set aside.
2. The Tribunal’s reasons for decision are inadequate because they do not explain the Tribunal’s finding that s 6A(5) of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 (“the Act”) does not apply in this case.
3. The decision is remitted to the Tribunal with the direction that:
(a) the Tribunal consider the Applicant’s argument that although she may not actually have been living with the deceased at the time of his death nevertheless in the circumstances the Corporation (and the Tribunal on appeal) ought to have been satisfied that the Applicant and the deceased would have been living together during that period but for a period of absence because of special circumstances, namely the deceased’s psychiatric illness followed by his final physical illness, as contemplated by s 6A(5) of the Act; and
(b) the Tribunal give reasons in relation to its finding in relation to s 6A(5) of the Act.
4. There is no order as to costs.
The Tribunal’s earlier reasons for decision published in June 2013 set out the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Janet Roberts-Billett and Commonwealth Superannuation Corpor... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] AATA 415
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The key legal issue before the Tribunal was whether Mrs Roberts-Billett's absence from living with Mr Billett qualified as an exception under s 6A(5) of the Act due to special circumstances. The Tribunal had to determine whether the couple's long-term separation, the divorce, and subsequent lack of contact could be seen as a continuation of their marital relationship or if these events constituted a termination of that relationship. The Tribunal also needed to assess whether Mr Billett’s decision to divorce Mrs Roberts-Billett was influenced by his psychiatric condition.
The Tribunal deliberated on the arguments presented by Mrs Roberts-Billett's counsel, who suggested that the marriage continued despite its challenges and that the divorce was merely an interruption. However, the Tribunal found that the legal dissolution of the marriage and the two years of deliberate lack of contact between the former spouses indicated the termination of their marital relationship. The Tribunal rejected the notion that the divorce could be ignored and highlighted that there was no evidence that Mr Billett’s decision to initiate divorce proceedings was due to his psychiatric condition. The Tribunal concluded that the separation and divorce, along with their lack of contact for two years, were indicative of the end of their marital relationship.
Based on the above, the Tribunal affirmed the decision under review, finding that Mrs Roberts-Billett did not meet the criteria for benefits under s 6A(5) of the Act. The Tribunal did not accept the argument that the marriage continued throughout the separation and divorce.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Section 6A(5) of the Act states:…(5)For the purposes of this section, a person is taken to be living with another person if the Authority is satisfied that the person would have been living with that other person except for a period of:(a)temporary absence; or(b)absence because of special circumstances (for example, absence because of the person’s illness or infirmity or a posting of the person).Tribunal Deliberations Mr Billett and Mrs Roberts-Billett remarried eight days before his death. They had not been living together in the years preceding Mr Billett’s final hospitalisation. Mr Billett appears to have been aware, as was Mrs Roberts-Billett, that at the time of their remarriage, it was unlikely that they would be living together in the future given his fragile state of health and the nature of his illness. The Court has directed that the Tribunal consider Mrs Roberts-Billet’s argument that although she may not have been living with Mr Billett at the time of his death that it ought to have been satisfied that she would have been living with him but for special circumstances, namely Mr Billett’s psychiatric illness followed by his final physical illness. Mrs Roberts-Billett and Mr Billett had not lived together for nine years at the time of his death. Mrs Roberts-Billett left the marital home in early 2001. The marital home was sold in late 2001 and both parties purchased separate properties which were at least one hour drive from each other. They finalised their joint financial affairs in 2005 and were divorced in 2007. While there was some social interaction at family gatherings and other events, their communication with each other prior to meeting up again in late 2009 was sporadic. Mrs Roberts-Billett gave evidence that they did not talk to each other for two years following the divorce until her daughter engineered a meeting between her and Mr Billett in late 2009. There is no evidence before the Tribunal that either of them encouraged the other to move in together after they met up again in 2009, two years after their divorce. Even when Mrs Roberts-Billett was caring for Mr Billett in his home after the diagnosis of his illness in 2009, she did not stay at his home overnight. Counsel for Mrs Roberts-Billett, in a written submission dated 4 February 2013, submitted that in all the circumstances of this case, it was the one marital relationship which subsisted throughout, despite its hiccups hurdles, trials and tribulations. He also suggested that the divorce… was an interruption , to, but not an end to, their marital relationship. The Tribunal does not accept that it was the one marital relationship or that the divorce ought to be ignored. The Tribunal is not satisfied that the legal dissolution of the marriage, followed by two years of deliberate lack of contact between the former spouses, can be viewed as one marital relationship. Furthermore, there is no evidence that Mr Billett’s decision to initiate divorce proceedings was the result of his psychiatric condition. He and Mrs Roberts-Billett had already separated their financial affairs long before the divorce and had not lived together for at least six years by that time. Indeed, his deliberate action in seeking a divorce is an indicator of the termination of the marital relationship.