Jamil v Medical Board of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Court of Appeal: Civil)

JAMIL v MEDICAL BOARD OF AUSTRALIA

[2025] SASCA 103

Judgment of the Honourable Justice Stanley  

19 September 2025

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - ADMISSION OF FURTHER EVIDENCE

PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - COURT SUPERVISION - AMENDMENT - ORIGINATING PROCESS, PLEADINGS ETC

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - PROCEDURE - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - WHEN APPEAL LIES - FROM SUPREME COURT - BY LEAVE OF COURT - INTERLOCUTORY ORDERS AND JUDGMENTS

This is an interlocutory application.

The applicant was found to have engaged in professional misconduct within the meaning of s 5 of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (South Australia) Act 2010 (SA) by the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (The Tribunal). These findings followed complaints made by two medical students against the conduct of the applicant, which led to an investigation and ultimately a formal amended Complaint from the Medical Board of Australia. The Complaint was referred to the Tribunal for determination.

Mr Jamil appealed the Tribunal's decision to a single Judge of the Supreme Court of South Australia. The appeal was essentially a challenge to the Tribunal’s findings on credit and reliability of the witnesses and how it weighed their evidence. The appeal was dismissed, finding no error in the Tribunal’s approach and reasons.  He has now sought to appeal that decision to the Court of Appeal with essentially the same challenge being put to the Court, and in doing so, brings an interlocutory application ahead of the appeal seeking leave to adduce further evidence on appeal, and leave to amend his notice and grounds of appeal.

The further evidence the applicant seeks to adduce is said to undermine the credibility of witnesses who gave evidence before the Tribunal. The amended grounds of appeal, with the exception of proposed ground 6, are contingent upon the admission of this further evidence.

The respondent opposes the application to adduce further evidence on appeal, submitting that the further evidence sought to be adduced does not meet the well-established legal principles for the admission of further evidence on appeal, particularly in the circumstances where the evidence involves collateral attacks on the credit of witnesses, and where its admission would pose a risk to the integrity and efficiency of the civil litigation system. The respondent also opposes the application to amend the notice and grounds of appeal. 

Held, dismissing interlocutory application FDN 16:

1.The public interest in the finality of litigation stands in the way of the application to adduce further evidence on appeal, even when allowing for the considerations that apply to disciplinary proceedings, and particularly where the further evidence sought to be admitted goes to collateral issues.

2.In circumstances where arguments could have been but were not put during the Tribunal proceedings and in front of the single Judge, and where evidence could have been obtained by the exercise of reasonable diligence, but was not, the omission earlier makes their late introduction unjustifiable.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jamil v Medical Board of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] SASCA 103
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, a medical practitioner, sought to appeal a decision of the Tribunal concerning a complaint made against him by two medical students, AB and CD. The complaint, investigated by the Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency (AHPRA) and referred to the Tribunal by the Medical Board of Australia (the Board), alleged professional misconduct including transgressing professional boundaries, breaching patient confidentiality, and creating false documents. The Board opposed the applicant's application. The matter came before Stanley J in the Supreme Court of South Australia.

The primary legal issues before the Court were whether to admit further evidence on appeal and, consequently, whether to grant an application to amend the notice of appeal. The applicant sought to introduce new evidence, and the Court considered the principles governing the admission of such evidence under Rule 218.17(1)(c) of the Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA). These principles include whether the evidence was available at the original hearing, whether it would have had an important influence on the decision, its practical impact, and the public interest in the finality of litigation.

Stanley J refused the application to adduce further evidence. His Honour reasoned that while the Court has a broad discretion to receive further evidence, similar considerations to those for "fresh evidence" on appeal apply. The Court considered whether the evidence was available at the hearing below and its potential influence on the original decision. The Court also noted the risk of prolonging litigation, increasing costs, and the public interest in finality. Specifically, the Court found that one proposed ground of appeal, relating to the expert evidence not being based on specialised knowledge, was not raised before the Tribunal or McIntyre J and permitting its amendment would likely necessitate recalling an expert witness, causing further delay and expense.

Consequently, as the application to adduce further evidence was refused, there was no justification to grant the application to amend the notice of appeal. The interlocutory application was dismissed, and the parties were to be heard as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The Board is the regulatory authority that supervises the registration and practice of medical practitioners in Australia. It prosecuted the Complaint against the applicant. It opposes this application. On the hearing of his application the applicant appeared as a litigant in person. Background The Complaint arose out of events in June and July 2020. At the time, the applicant was a recently registered medical practitioner working at an Adelaide hospital. AB and CD were two medical students undertaking three-week placements at the same hospital in 2020. They complained to the applicant’s employer, the Central Adelaide Local Health Network of SA Health (CALHN), concerning the applicant’s conduct. The Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency (AHPRA) conducted an investigation which resulted in the Complaint.[1] The Complaint proceedings were referred to the Tribunal by the Board. The Tribunal heard evidence from the applicant, AB, CD, and Mr Jean-Pierre du Plessis, an expert in computer technology. The allegations against the applicant were set out in an amended Complaint filed on 29 November 2022. The Tribunal, in its decision, described the allegations against the applicant as follows.[1] AHPRA was established to implement the national legislative scheme and to provide support to the Board. This includes comprehensive powers to investigate notifications concerning registered health practitioners. The first allegation is that the applicant transgressed professional boundaries by engaging in sexualised and/or inappropriate conduct with respect to AB and CD. AB alleges the applicant sent her text messages of an inappropriate and sexualised nature. She further alleged that the applicant sent her a disappearing message which contained a nude photograph of him. It was further alleged that he sent another disappearing message which contained the same photograph but with his genitals blurred or obscured and arrows added to demonstrate muscle groups. The allegations relating to CD are that he sent her messages that were inappropriate and/or sexualised; sent a message containing a photograph of his genitalia and other messages containing a nude photograph of him; that he touched CD’s thigh in the work environment; grabbed CD’s hand while in the work environment and rubbed it along his thigh; asked CD to accompany him to an empty meeting room to “debrief”; asked CD on a number of occasions to go for a drive with him; purchased a vibrator which he gave to CD at the clinic; and drove CD to his home where he propositioned her for sex and played pornography on his laptop. The second allegation is that the applicant breached patient confidentiality by disclosing the name of a patient of the clinic and making disparaging comments about the patient’s mental health to AB during a text message exchange on 10 July 2020. The third allegation is that the applicant created and provided two false documents to the authorities in the context of investigations into his conduct. The first was alleged to be a copy of a purported screenshot of an exchange in the secret messages function of Facebook Messenger between himself and AB. The second was alleged to be a purported screenshot of messages sent to the applicant by CD in which she apologised to him. The basis of the findings of fact

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal also found the third allegation proved, finding that the applicant created and provided two false documents to the authorities in the course of the investigation into his conduct. The first was a screenshot of a purported exchange in the secret messages function of Facebook Messenger between himself and AB, in which it appeared that AB initiated a conversation about personal matters with the applicant. The second was a screenshot of messages purportedly sent to the applicant by CD in which CD appears to offer an apology to the applicant that she “took your nude” and requesting that he tell the police to stop asking her about it. Principles relevant to the admission of further evidence on appeal The principles relevant to the application to admit further evidence on appeal were analysed in the judgment of Doyle JA, with which I agreed,[2] in Burke v Public Trustee for the State of South Australia[3] as follows:[4] [2] Burke v Public Trusteefor the State of South Australia [2022] SASCA 64 at [480].[3] [2022] SASCA 64.[4] Burke v Public Trusteefor the State of South Australia [2022] SASCA 64 at [455]-[456].… the Court has a broad discretion under r 218.17(1)(c) of the Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA) to receive further evidence on a question of fact that arises on an appeal. The discretion is not circumscribed by the common law principles governing the reception of “fresh evidence” on appeal, although similar considerations apply. In particular, it will generally be relevant to consider: ·whether the evidence was available, or could with reasonable diligence have been obtained, for use at the hearing below;·whether the evidence is such that it would have had an important influence on the decision below. While it need not necessarily be decisive, it must be more than merely relevant or useful;·the likely practical impact of receiving the evidence, including whether it is controversial or contested, and if so likely to require cross-examination, further responding evidence and/or that the matter be remitted for rehearing; and·the public interest in the finality of litigation.The relevance of the last two considerations, and in particular the public interest in finality, was emphasised by the Full Court in both Chakravarti v Advertiser Newspapers Ltd and Collex Waste Management Services Pty Ltd v The Corporation of the City of Enfield (No 2).[citations omitted]. In Slater v Ecosol Pty Ltd[5] Bleby JA explained the risk to the adversarial system of civil litigation if courts permitted adducing fresh evidence on appeal on collateral issues. He said:[6]Mr Slater thus seeks to adduce fresh evidence on appeal in order to raise a collateral issue that goes only to the credit of Mr Smith. Adducing evidence to that effect would not be permitted at trial. As Gleeson CJ said in Goldsmith v Sandilands, the adversarial system of civil litigation would collapse if the adversaries were permitted to lead evidence about every matter of contention that arises in the course of proceedings. The mischief is compounded here in that the effect of the evidence is contested. Moreover, it is said to go to the credit of Mr Smith only in the most obscure of ways, in that it seeks to draw on conduct subsequent to the trial to show that Mr Smith should have been found at trial to have been a dishonest witness. The word ‘collapse’ is insufficient to describe the damage that would be done to the adversarial system of civil litigation if litigants were to be permitted to adduce fresh evidence on appeal of subsequent conduct of a witness, the effect of which is contested and which, in any event, was only directed to the general credibility of that witness by casting a backward light over answers given at trial. The principle of finality stands firmly in the way of Mr Slater’s application. [citation omitted].[5] [2024] SASCA 95.[6] Slater v Ecosol Pty Ltd [2024] SASCA 95 at [25]-[27].

Decision

Reasons for decision

The application by the applicant to amend the notice of appeal is consequential on the admission of the further evidence with the exception of proposed ground 6. Proposed ground 6 relates to a submission that the expert evidence before the Tribunal was not based on specialised knowledge. That submission was not made before the Tribunal or McIntyre J. To permit that amendment now is likely to require the recall of Mr du Plessis, further delay, cost and the prolongation of the matter. Conclusion Even allowing for the considerations that apply to disciplinary proceedings, I would refuse the application to adduce the further evidence. As a result, there is no justification to grant the application to amend the notice of appeal. Accordingly, I would dismiss the interlocutory application FDN 16. I would hear the parties as to costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established