James v State of Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

James v State of Queensland [2018] QSC 188

PARTIES:

PAUL ANTHONY JAMES
(Plaintiff)
and
STATE OF QUEENSLAND

(Defendant)

FILE NO/S:

S390 of 2008

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Claim

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland at Cairns

DELIVERED ON:

10 December 2018

DELIVERED AT:

Mackay

HEARING DATES:

30 April, 1 May, 2 May, 3 May, 6 August, 7 August 2018

JUDGE:

Henry J

ORDERS:

1.   Claim dismissed.

2.   I will hear the parties as to costs if costs are not earlier agreed at 9.15 am 30 January 2019.

CATCHWORDS:

TORTS – NEGLIGENCE– ESSENTIALS OF ACTION FOR NEGLIGENCE – STANDARD OF CARE – GENERALLY –– whether the Queensland Ambulance Services’ Priority One system for managing risk of psychiatric injury was adequate to safeguard the risk – whether there was a failure to comply with the priority One system by not activating a Critical Incident Stress Debriefing – whether misbehaviour at a training incident signalled the need for psychiatric support –  whether an employer’s duty of care extends to imposing counselling without request of the employee.

EMPLOYMENT LAW – CONTRACT OF SERVICE – TERMS OF CONTRACT – IMPLIED TERMS – whether the Queensland Ambulance Services’ Priority One system for managing risk of psychiatric injury was adequate to safeguard the risk – whether there was a failure to comply with the priority One system by not activating a Critical Incident Stress Debriefing – whether misbehaviour at a training incident signalled the need for psychiatric support –  whether an employer’s duty of care extends to imposing counselling without request of the employee.

Hegarty v QAS, [2007] QSC 90, followed.
Koehler v Cerebos (Aust) Ltd (2005) 222 CLR 44, cited.

COUNSEL:

G C O’Driscoll for the plaintiff

G W Diehm QC with A Luchich for the defendant

SOLICITORS:

Hall Payne Lawyers for the plaintiff

Crown Law for the defendant

  1. The plaintiff claims damages for a psychiatric injury caused by his exposure to traumatic events when working as a paramedic at Doomadgee in 2004.[1]  He claims the Queensland Ambulance Service (“QAS”)[2] failed to respond reasonably to the risk of such injury from exposure to such trauma. 

    [1]     The claim was not filed until 19 August 2008, nearly four years after the key events and the plaintiff did not press for the trial to be heard until recently, well over a decade after the events.

    [2]     In fact his claim is against the State of Queensland but the relevant operating entity of the State of Queensland was QAS.  References herein to the QAS should be taken to also be references to the defendant.

  2. His case is an exercise in hindsight identification of a means by which his injury might have been avoided by an all-knowing and intrusive employer.  It fails to acknowledge his employer did take reasonable care, conscientiously educating him about signs of adverse reaction to traumatic events and providing a system of support which respected his autonomy and was a reasonable response to the risk of injury from exposure…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read James v State of Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QSC 188
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of James v State of Queensland, the plaintiff, James, brought an action against the defendant, the State of Queensland, seeking damages for negligence in the context of employment. James, an employee of the Queensland Ambulance Services, alleged that the defendant breached its duty of care by failing to provide adequate psychological support and counselling, leading to psychiatric injuries sustained during his employment. The central issues before the court were whether the Queensland Ambulance Services' Priority One system for managing the risk of psychiatric injury was sufficient, whether there was a failure to implement the Critical Incident Stress Debriefing as required by the system, and if the employer's duty of care extended to imposing counselling on the employee without their request. The court had to determine if the employer had adequately safeguarded against the risk of psychiatric injury and whether the employer's actions or omissions contributed to the plaintiff's injuries.

The court examined the adequacy of the Priority One system and found that it was designed to manage risks of psychiatric injury and included provisions for Critical Incident Stress Debriefing. However, the court noted that the system's effectiveness depended on its proper implementation. In this case, there was evidence that the Critical Incident Stress Debriefing was not activated following a training incident where there was misbehaviour that could have signalled the need for psychiatric support. The court also considered whether the employer's duty of care extended to imposing counselling without the employee's request, concluding that such an imposition would not necessarily be a breach of duty if it was reasonably necessary under the circumstances. Ultimately, the court found that while the employer had a duty to provide a safe working environment, which included psychological support, there was no evidence that the failure to activate the Critical Incident Stress Debriefing or the imposition of counselling without request directly caused the plaintiff's injuries.

In light of the findings, the court dismissed the plaintiff's claim, ruling that the defendant was not liable for the psychiatric injuries sustained by the plaintiff. The court scheduled a hearing to discuss costs, setting the date and time for the parties to present their positions if costs were not agreed upon beforehand.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Claim dismissed.

2. I will hear the parties as to costs if costs are not earlier agreed at 9.15 am 30 January 2019.

Background

Background to the litigation

An analysis of the facts is necessary before returning to the alleged breaches and causation. PART B: FACTSPast mental health assistance In evidence-in-chief Mr James testified that prior to the incidents of concern in this case he had on one previous occasion been prescribed Effexor, an anti-depressant, when he had chest tightness at a time when his son was having problems at school.[18] However, he claimed not to have taken the Effexor.[19] He was not being candid with the court. [18] T2-10 L45 – T2-11 L7.[19] T2-11 L39. A medical attendance report provided to Mr James’ insurer on 30 August 2004 disclosed Mr James had been prescribed Effexor on 7 November 2012 for “anxiety depression”.[20] His medical records confirm that and also record that the same drug was prescribed on 7 May 2003.[21] According to his medical records he was also prescribed Effexor on 30 December 2003 and 16 July 2004.[22] He conceded in cross-examination that he probably would have taken the Effexor and could not explain why he had said differently in evidence-in-chief.[23] [20] Ex 25.[21] Ex 26.[22] Ex 26.[23] T3-15 L22. Mr James was equivocal in his responses as to whether he had informed the psychiatrist he dealt with after the incidents in question about his history of anxiety and depression.[24] The reports of his treating psychiatrist, Dr Likely, the expert on which his case relies, make no reference to it. To the contrary, according to Dr Likely’s report of 20 January 2005 Mr James positively asserted that prior to the incidents in question “he had never before had problems with his mental health”.[25] [24] T3-20 LL20-37.[25] Ex 29.1 p114 None of this boded well for Mr James’ credibility or the existence of an accurate factual foundation for the expert psychiatric opinion in the case.The first incident and its aftermathThe first incident In respect of the so-called “first incident” the parties jointly admitted:“11. On Thursday 30 September 2004 when the Plaintiff was relieving at Doomadgee, the plaintiff responded to a request that he attend and treat a “dog bite” case.12. Upon his arrival at the scene that morning, the Plaintiff encountered a young male person, then naked and unconscious, who had been mauled.”[26][26] Ex 31 Statement of Agreed Facts. The ambulance report form in which Mr James recorded the details of his attendance noted he arrived at the scene at 6.45 am.[27] Despite having been tasked to attend a case of dog bite, Mr James testified that in the yard of the premises in question a teenage boy was being mauled by a group of dogs. The mauling had evidently been in progress for a substantial time. There were pieces of clothing, human flesh and intestine lying about and the dogs were still biting and pulling at the boy.[28] [27] Ex 2.[28] T1-32 L40 – T1-33 L1, T1-36 LL17-40. When Mr James went to intervene, the dogs were not readily deterred and were also aggressive towards him. After he had thrown some ambulance equipment at the dogs and some bystanders joined in repelling the dogs, Mr James was able to tend to the patient. The boy’s genitalia had been gnawed at and were partly missing.[29] His stomach had been bitten into and entrails pulled out.[30] The boy bore many other bite injuries, had lost a lot of blood and was semi-conscious.[31][29] T1-33 L10, T1-36 L25.[30] T1-37 LL1-14.[31] T1-33 LL27-42.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.