James Menz and Border Express

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

[2014] AATA 124  

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2013/1890, 2013/2758, 2013/6003

Re

James Menz

APPLICANT

And

Border Express

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

RM Creyke, Senior Member

Date

Date of written reasons

6 March 2014  

7 March 2014  

Place

Canberra

The Tribunal does not have jurisdiction to hear Matter 2013/1890 and Matter 2013/6003.  In relation to Matter 2013/2758 the Tribunal does not have jurisdiction to consider matters involved in the application with the exception of the calculation of ‘Comcare make-up pay’ amount of $72.82 in accordance with section 19(3) of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth). In relation to that aspect only of the Matter 2013/2758 the Tribunal revokes its decision made on 10 December 2013 under section 42A(4) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (AAT Act) and reinstates that issue for consideration by the Tribunal under section 42A(10) of the AAT Act. Otherwise, the applications under the three matters are dismissed.

..............................[sgd]..........................................

RM Creyke, Senior Member

Catchwords

COMPENSATION – whether Tribunal had jurisdiction – oral decision – request for reasons  - several matters – whether all aspects of those matters already dealt with by the Tribunal – whether matter dismissed in error – Tribunal reinstated one issue under Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) s 42A(10).

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) s28, 42A

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (Act) s 8, 9, 9A, 19, 62

Secondary Materials

Transport Workers Long Distance Drivers Award 2000 clause 20.6.

REASONS FOR INTERLOCUTORY DECISION

RM Creyke, Senior Member

  1. An interlocutory hearing was held on 10 December 2013 to consider whether the Tribunal had jurisdiction in matters covered by file numbers AAT 2013/1890, 2013/2758, 2013/6003, all applications for review concerning entitlements of Mr James Menz under his accepted compensation claim.

  2. Mr Menz was represented by his wife, Ms Menz, and Border Express was represented by their legal counsel.

  3. The question of the Tribunal’s jurisdiction in these three matters was decided adversely to Mr Menz and the matters were accordingly dismissed.

  4. On 15 January 2014, the Tribunal received an email from Mrs Menz requesting that reasons be provided for that decision. In particular, as Mrs Menz noted in her email and confirmed in a telephone conference on 6 February 2014, that Mr Menz would like an explanation of the reasons for the decisions in the interlocutory hearing, specifically, whether increases in the consumer price index had been taken into account in the calculations of Normal Weekly Earnings (NWE), and whether any extra hours worked by Mr Menz over his Normal Weekly Hours (NWH) were also reflected in the calculations of make-up pay in the payments made after the injury was accepted.

  5. The application for written reasons was out of time in accordance with the time limits in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) section 28(1). The Tribunal hereby agrees to extend the time for Mr Menz to seek reasons for the interlocutory decision.

    Background

  6. Mr Menz has been  employed by Border Express as a line haul,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read James Menz and Border Express and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 124
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, James Menz, and Border Express were involved in a dispute concerning the calculation of incapacity payments owed to Mr Menz, who had suffered a work-related shoulder injury. The matter was before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, which was required to determine whether it had jurisdiction to consider Mr Menz’s applications for review of certain decisions made by Border Express regarding his normal weekly earnings (NWE) and the calculation of his incapacity payments. The three matters before the Tribunal related to decisions made by Border Express on 4 November 2013, 13 March 2013, and 1 July 2009, respectively. Mr Menz sought review of these decisions, arguing that they incorrectly calculated his NWE and, as a result, his incapacity payments.

The primary legal issue was whether the Tribunal had the jurisdiction to review the decisions of Border Express concerning Mr Menz's NWE and incapacity payments. Mr Menz argued that Border Express had misapplied the CPI indexation amount and that the increases in his NWE should be applied to the full amount of his NWE rather than a portion of it. Border Express maintained that it had correctly applied the relevant provisions of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) in making its decisions. The Tribunal needed to determine whether the objections raised by Mr Menz were valid and if the Tribunal had the authority to review the decisions in question.

The Tribunal found that it had jurisdiction to review the decisions made by Border Express. It concluded that Mr Menz's understanding of the application of the CPI indexation amount was incorrect, as the relevant provisions applied only to employees who had ceased to be employed by a licensee. Since Mr Menz remained employed by Border Express, the indexation amount was not applicable. The Tribunal also noted that the increases in Mr Menz's NWE were correctly applied in accordance with the award applicable to him. The Tribunal held that it could review the decisions of Border Express concerning the calculation of Mr Menz's NWE and incapacity payments. It rejected Mr Menz's objections and found that the decisions of Border Express were in accordance with the relevant legislation.

The Tribunal granted an extension of time for Mr Menz to seek reasons for the interlocutory decision, thereby allowing him to pursue his review of the decisions concerning his incapacity payments. The Tribunal's decision affirmed its jurisdiction to review the actions of Border Express and provided clarity on the application of the relevant provisions of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) in calculating Mr Menz's incapacity payments.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The application for written reasons was out of time in accordance with the time limits in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) section 28(1). The Tribunal hereby agrees to extend the time for Mr Menz to seek reasons for the interlocutory decision.Background Mr Menz has been employed by Border Express as a line haul, that is, long distance, driver since 1989. He remains an employee. He suffered a work-related shoulder injury on 3 May 2008 described as a ‘left shoulder injury (tear of supraspinatus and infraspinatus tendon)’ which incapacitated him from working as a driver. He returned to work on a graduated return program in the second half of 2008, but, except for a couple of days’ work in December 2010, effectively ceased working on 13 August 2010. Border Express accepted liability for the shoulder injury on 9 May 2008. On 2 December 2010, Mr Menz claimed compensation for a secondary psychological condition described as ‘depression’ arising as a consequence of the injury to his shoulder. Liability was accepted on 10 December 2010 for ‘adjustment disorder with depressed and anxious mood’, secondary to the initial claim. Subsequently Mr Menz has sought review of several decisions concerning the amount of his incapacity payments under section 19 of the Act. In a consent decision approved by the Tribunal on 25 February 2010, the normal working hours’ component of the figures taken into account in that calculation was determined to be 58.16 hours per week. The correctness of the normal weekly earnings component used in the calculation, and in particular whether it took account of rostered days off, and the relevant period for the purposes of the calculation was decided by the Tribunal on 17 May 2013. Those matters have been settled. The three matters before the Tribunal at its interlocutory hearing on 10 December 2013 were:·Matter 2013/6003 which related to a decision by Border Express dated 4 November 2013 to reconsider and recalculate Mr Menz’s normal weekly earnings (NWE) according to the terms of section 8 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (Act). The reconsideration decision took into account increases in the relevant award rate applicable to Mr Menz as required by section 8(9) and (9A) of the Act;·Matter 2013/1890 which concerned a decision of 13 March 2013 by Border Express, to revoke its decision as to the amount of Mr Menz’s NWE and to substitute a decision as to the amount of NWE so as to include amounts representing the dangerous goods allowance payable under the relevant award, namely, the Transport Workers Long Distance Drivers Award 2000 clause 20.6. The decision also affirmed that the ‘relevant period’ for the purposes of section 8 of the Act was the 12 week period prior to the injury; and·Matter 2013/2758 which related to a decision of Border Express to revoke its decision made on 1 July 2009 and take into account the figure for normal weekly hours applicable to Mr Menz as decided by the Tribunal, for the purposes of calculating his NWE under section 19 of the Act. Border Express recalculated Mr Menz’s incapacity payments for the period 12 July 2009 to 25 March 2010, in accordance with section 19(3) of the Act. LegislationThe relevant legislation is the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (Act). Section 19 contains the methodology for calculating the amount of incapacity payments; section 8 concerns the methodology for calculating the normal weekly earnings; and section 9 covers the relevant period for the calculation.Issues

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The sole issue was whether the Tribunal had jurisdiction to consider the applications in Matters 2013/6003; 2013/1890; and 2013/2758.Consideration Matter 2013/6003 On 4 November 2013 Border Express in its reconsideration decision affirmed its decisions relating to the NWE of Mr Menz dated 16 July 2009, 13 July 2010, 17 April 2012, 24 April 2012, 26 July 2012 and 15 July 2013. These decisions were to adjust NWE to take account of increases in the award base rate as follows:·16 July 2009: to $1,596.21 for the period from 29 September 2008.·13 July 2010: to $1,619.11 for the period from 5 July 2010.·17 April 2012: to $1,642.31for the period from 4 July 2011.·24 April 2012: to $1,619.11 for the period from 27 March 2011 to 3 July 2011. ·26 July 2012: to $1,662.81 for the period from 4 July 2012.·15 July 2013: to $1,681.71 for the period from 1 July 2013. In its explanation for the decisions, Border Express noted that the NWE increases had been made according to award rate increases to the base rate applicable to line haul drivers for weeks when Mr Menz was not in receipt of a trip rate paid under the cents per kilometre method (38 hours week). As Mr Menz remains employed by Border Express, the relevant provisions are sections 8(9) and 8(9A) of the Act. The terms of section 8(9), and (9A) of the Act require that NWE is to be increased or reduced by the ‘relevant percentage’ of any increase in the minimum rate per week payable to an employee in the same class of employees as Mr Menz. Mr Menz objected to the CPI indexation amount on the basis that ‘Border Express has applied the indexation to a portion of the NWE and not the full amount’. That appears to be a misunderstanding on his part since the application of a CPI indexation amount arises under section 8(9B) of the Act and only applies in the case of an employee who ‘has ceased, or ceases’ to be employed by a licensee.[1] Mr Menz has not ceased to be employed by Border Express. Therefore, the indexation amount is not relevant to any incapacity payments which are made to him under sections 8 and 19 of the Act. [1] Re Chun v Comcare [2012] AATA 471 at [18]. The Tribunal notes that section 8(9A) specifically states that the relevant percentage increase or decrease ‘means the same percentage as the percentage of increase or reduction in the minimum amount per week payable’ (emphasis added) to line haul drivers. Section 8(9A) refers to increases in remuneration payable to a class of continuing employees where those increases come about because of the operation of law or changes made in accordance with an industrial determination or agreement.[2] The relevant increases in this matter were made under the award applying to Mr Menz. The Tribunal has taken the reference to Mr Menz’s objection to an amount being ‘a portion of the NWE’ to refer to the base level amount in the award. The Tribunal understands that Mr Menz objection is because he considers that the increase should be applied to the whole amount of the NWE. [2] Id at [19].