[2011] QCA 24
COURT OF APPEAL
MUIR JA
Appeal No 159 of 2011
SC No 5325 of 2008
JAMES CONOMOS Applicant/Second Respondent
and
TOGITO PTY LTD Respondent/Appellant
ACN 003 089 192
and
PIONEER INVESTMENTS (AUST) PTY LTD Applicant/First Respondent
ACN 070 004 045
BRISBANE
DATE 21/02/2011
JUDGMENT
MR FREEBURN: Your Honour, Freeburn, initials P A, Senior Counsel, instructed by Coyne & Associates and I appear for Mr Conomos who's second respondent in the appeal and the applicant.
MUIR JA: Okay.
MR ROBINSON: Good morning, your Honour. My name is Robinson, initials G J. I appear instructed by Lillas & Loel for Pioneer Investments (Aust) Pty Ltd, the first respondent in the substantive appeal and the first applicant.
MR HACKETT: My name is Hackett, initials P W. I'm instructed by Morgan Conley and I appear for the appellant in the proceedings who's the respondent to both the applications.
MUIR JA: The first and second respondents apply for security for the costs of the appeal. The relevant principles are well established and there was no debate about them. It's not contested that the appellant will not be able to meet the respondents' costs should the respondents be successful on the appeal.
There is debate, however, about the likely quantum of the costs. The appellant's solicitor has assessed the costs of each party, that is, of each respondent party at $12,700 approximately. The first respondent's solicitor assessed his client's costs at $45,000 approximately and a costs assessor has assessed the second respondent's costs at $43,430 - $32,636 after deducting $10,794, being the estimate for the costs of this application.
The issues raised in the appellant's outline of argument appear to be within fairly short compass. They were ventilated, I would think, extensively at first instance. Considering the likely extent of preparation for the appeal, I'm inclined to the view that there is some substance in Mr Pitman's (the solicitor for the appellant) criticisms of the respondents’ respective estimates.
It is relevant, also, that an order for security for costs, at least as a general proposition, is not intended to provide a full indemnity to the applicants for the order.
A director of the appellant, Mr Smits, has offered an undertaking, in effect, to pay each of the respondents up to $25,000 on account of their assessed or agreed costs of the appeal if the appellant fails to meet a costs order. In an attempt to substantiate the worth of his undertakings, he has sworn to the value of some specified assets.
The respondents complain that it's impossible to gain a true appreciation of Mr Smits' net asset position from the material supplied. The criticisms are justified. Mr Smits seeks to show a substantial asset position by reference to a second mortgage over land owned by a company of which he is the sole director and shareholder. Nothing is said of the company's liabilities or, for that matter, of Mr Smits’ own general financial position. It is clear from the material that he is…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read James Conomos v Pioneer Investments (Aust) Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] QCA 24
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the appellant should be required to provide security for the costs of the appeal, and if so, the appropriate quantum of such security. The court had to consider the appellant's ability to meet the costs, the fairness of the estimates provided by the respondents, and the nature of the undertakings offered by the appellant's director, Leonardus Gerardus Smits. The court also had to assess the implications of the respondents' application for costs against Smits personally.
The court acknowledged that the principles governing security for costs are well-established, but there was significant debate over the likely quantum of the costs. The appellant's solicitor assessed the costs at approximately $12,700, whereas the first and second respondents' solicitors assessed their costs at approximately $45,000 and $43,430 respectively. The court found that the respondents' estimates appeared to be exaggerated, given the likely extent of preparation for the appeal. The court also noted that an order for security for costs is not intended to provide a full indemnity to the applicants.
Furthermore, the court considered the undertaking by Smits to pay up to $25,000 on account of the respondents' costs if the appellant fails to meet a costs order. However, the court found that the material provided by Smits did not allow for a true appreciation of his net asset position, as it did not account for his liabilities or personal financial position. The court also took into account the respondents' application for costs against Smits personally, which suggested that the appeal might be stifled by security for costs orders.
Ultimately, the court concluded that an order should be made for security for costs, at least in favour of the second respondent. The court ordered that the appellant provide security in the sum of $25,000 within seven days of the date of the judgment. The court also noted that the gap between the amounts claimed by the respondents and the amount ordered was significant, and that such applications were part of the litigation process.
In conclusion, the Court of Appeal ordered that the appellant provide security for the costs of the appeal in the sum of $25,000, acknowledging the limitations of the undertakings offered by the appellant's director and the potential impact on the appeal if a higher amount was ordered. The court also noted the personal application for costs against Smits and the implications for the conduct of the appeal.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi