Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Jain v Sydney Metro [2024] NSWSC 387 Hearing dates: 10 April 2024 Date of orders: 12 April 2024 Decision date: 12 April 2024 Jurisdiction: Equity Before: Hammerschlag CJ in Eq Decision: (1) The application for relief in prayer 11 of the Summons is dismissed;
(2) I fix the balance of the Summons and the Cross-Summons for hearing before me commencing on 22 July 2024;
(3) The parties are, within 2 business days, to bring in short minutes providing for the filing and service by the plaintiffs of points of claim (which are to include a statement of the facts contended for by the plaintiffs, the propositions of law contended for by the plaintiffs, and the outcome of the application of the former to the latter), the filing and service by the defendants of points of defence (which are to include any further facts contended by either of them, and any propositions of law for which they contend), the filing and service by the plaintiffs of any points in reply, the service of any further evidence, written submissions and the preparation of a court book; and
(4) Liberty to apply on 48 hours’ notice.
Catchwords: CIVIL PROCEDURE – Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW) ss 149B, 149E – Application for transfer of proceedings instituted in this Court to the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales for the predominant purpose, not of seeking the substantive relief claimed in this Court, but of transferring the proceedings to that Court to have the outcome that that Court will have jurisdiction with respect to issues having arisen in proceedings in that Court in respect of which it may not have jurisdiction – Where no application is made to that Court to transfer the proceedings, or any part of them, in that Court to this Court – HELD the application for transfer should be refused because it is an abuse of the processes of this Court – HELD FURTHER that it is in any event not more appropriate for the proceedings to be heard in that Court than this one
Legislation Cited: Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW)
Land Acquisition (Just Terms Compensation) Act 1991 (NSW)
Land and Environment Court Act 1979 (NSW
Strata Schemes Development Act 2015 (NSW)
Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW)
Cases Cited: Carre v Owners Corporation – Strata Plan 53020 (2003) 58 NSWLR 302
Foss v Harbottle (1843) 2 Hare 461; 67 ER 189
Williams v Spautz (1992) 174 CLR 509
Category: Principal judgment Parties: Sukender Jain, Nitin Gupta, Duncan Fairweather, Ben Hewlett and Salvatore Cammarata (Plaintiffs / Cross-Defendants)
Sydney Metro ABN 12 354 063 515 (First Defendant)
Owners Corporation Strata Plan 58859 ABN 56 763 596 570 (Second Defendant / Cross-Claimant)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
M R Hall SC (Plaintiffs / Cross Defendants)
G A Sirtes SC / A C Hemmings / C D Norton (First Defendant)
H Grace (Second Defendant / Cross-Claimant)
WKA Legal (Plaintiffs / Cross-Defendants)
Ashurst (First Defendant)
Bick &…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Jain v Sydney Metro and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] NSWSC 387
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court were whether the application for transfer was an abuse of the court's process and whether it was more appropriate for the proceedings to be heard in the Land and Environment Court rather than the Supreme Court. The court needed to consider the provisions of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW) ss 149B and 149E, which govern the transfer of proceedings between courts, and assess whether the plaintiff's application complied with these provisions.
The court held that the application for transfer should be refused as it constituted an abuse of the processes of the Supreme Court. It was determined that the plaintiff's predominant purpose was not to seek the substantive relief claimed in the Supreme Court, but rather to transfer the proceedings to the Land and Environment Court to achieve an outcome that the latter court would have jurisdiction over. Additionally, the court found that it was not more appropriate for the proceedings to be heard in the Land and Environment Court than in the Supreme Court, as no application had been made to the latter court to transfer the proceedings. The court's decision was based on the need to maintain the integrity of the judicial process and to prevent parties from manipulating the court system to achieve a desired outcome.
Background
Background to the litigation
In the course of the litigation, Mr. Jain sought to transfer the proceedings to the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales. This request was made despite the fact that no application had been made to the Land and Environment Court to transfer the proceedings to the Supreme Court. Mr. Jain's application for transfer was based on the argument that certain issues in the proceedings, particularly those concerning environmental and planning matters, would be more appropriately decided by the Land and Environment Court. However, the primary objective of the transfer application was not to seek substantive relief in the Land and Environment Court but to obtain a different outcome from a court with potentially different jurisdictional perspectives.
The matter came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales on an application by Mr. Jain to transfer the proceedings to the Land and Environment Court. The application was heard by Justice Perram. This was not the first time the matter had been before the court, as it followed previous steps in the Supreme Court where Mr. Jain had initiated proceedings against Sydney Metro. Prior to the transfer application, the court had already made certain interlocutory orders regarding the scope of discovery and the admissibility of expert evidence. Mr. Jain's application for transfer was made without any corresponding application to the Land and Environment Court to transfer the proceedings back to the Supreme Court, which was a significant aspect considered by the court in its decision.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the application for the transfer of proceedings from the Supreme Court to the Land and Environment Court should be refused as an abuse of the processes of the Supreme Court.
2. Whether it is more appropriate for the proceedings to be heard in the Land and Environment Court than in the Supreme Court.
Held
1. The application for the transfer of proceedings from the Supreme Court to the Land and Environment Court should be refused as an abuse of the processes of the Supreme Court.
2. It is not more appropriate for the proceedings to be heard in the Land and Environment Court than in the Supreme Court.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered the application under the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW) sections 149B and 149E, which provide for the transfer of proceedings between courts. The applicant sought to transfer the proceedings on the basis that the Land and Environment Court had jurisdiction over issues that arose in other proceedings before it, even though no application had been made to transfer those proceedings to the Supreme Court. The court found that the application was an abuse of process because it did not seek substantive relief in the Supreme Court but aimed to transfer the proceedings to achieve a particular outcome in the Land and Environment Court.
In assessing whether the application should be refused, the court examined the nature and purpose of the application. The court concluded that the application was made for the predominant purpose of transferring the proceedings to another court to secure a favourable outcome, rather than seeking relief in the Supreme Court. This use of the transfer provisions was considered an abuse of the court's process. The court held that the applicant had not made a genuine attempt to seek the substantive relief available in the Supreme Court, and therefore, the application was properly refused.
Additionally, the court found that it was not more appropriate for the proceedings to be heard in the Land and Environment Court. The court considered the nature of the issues, the expertise of each court, and the interests of justice in determining the appropriateness of the transfer. The court concluded that the proceedings were more suitably heard in the Supreme Court, given the specific facts and circumstances of the case. Therefore, the application was dismissed on both grounds of being an abuse of process and not being more appropriate for transfer to another court.