Jackson Roberts-Young v Australian Weightlifting Federation

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

Case number: NST-E24-11998

Case Title: Jackson Roberts-Young v Australian Weightlifting Federation

Determination

National Sports Tribunal

General Division

sitting in the following composition:

Panel Member   Ms Bridie Nolan

in the arbitration between

Jackson Roberts-Young  (Appellant)

Represented by Mr Paul Horvath, legal representative

And

Australia Weightlifting Federation (AWF)                   (Respondent)

Represented by Mr Ian Moir, CEO

PARTIES

  1. The Appellant, Jackson Roberts-Young is an international representative athlete in weightlifting for the Respondent since 2016, who recently competed at the Birmingham Commonwealth Games in 2022.  

  2. The Respondent, Australian Weightlifting Federation (AWF), is the governing body for the sport of Weightlifting in Australia.

INTRODUCTION

  1. Pursuant to clause 8.1 of the 2024 Oceania Senior Championships Event Specific Selection Criteria (the Event Criteria), the Appellant appeals his non-selection to the 2024 AWF Oceania Senior Team.

  2. The date for the Event, the 2024 Oceania Championships in Auckland, New Zealand, was set and published on 28 October 2022 at the OWF Congress for 23 - 25 February 2024.

  3. In his application the Appellant described the dispute as follows:

    I was not afforded a fair and reasonable opportunity to meet selection criteria for 2024 Oceania Senior Championships.

    An event specific Selection Policy was only published 19 weeks into a 26 week qualification period.

    The minimum qualification total required for that level of event that had been in effect for five years was increased by 7.7% for my weight class – more than any other weight class

    I was advised of the change at Senior Worlds in Saudi Arabia, two days before competing.

    No reason has been published why the new Selection Policy was published so late. No external factors have been stated for why any change in qualification was necessary.

    The only reason given for the change in qualification occurred, verbally at High…[text cut off]

  4. For each year from 2019 through 2023 inclusive, the Minimum Qualifying Standard for the Appellant’s category of “Male - 109kg” was 325kg, which corresponds to the ‘B grade’ on the AWF Grading Scale. 

  5. The qualifying periods for Senior Oceania Championships 2019 through 2023 were consistently between 26 – 28 weeks, ending 15 weeks prior to the competition in the case of Olympic qualifiers (Tokyo 2020 and Paris 2024). In 2024, the Event is a Paris Olympic Qualifier.

  6. As at 30 April 2023, no event specific qualification policy was published for the Event. Accordingly, the Appellant says that he assumed that his B grade performance would be included in the qualification period to meet the Minimum Qualifying Standard. The Appellant competed at a State weightlifting competition, totalling 344 kg, which was enough, sufficient to place him in the higher grade. Thereafter, together with, and under the guidance of his coach, he planned his training for the remainder of the year to include achieving a B grade again at the AWF Senior Nationals Competition in August, the Appellant successfully made all six lifts at the senior nationals on 6 August and totalled 345 kg.

  7. On 21 August 2023, an “Information Bulletin” was published that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jackson Roberts-Young v Australian Weightlifting Federation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NST NST-E24-11998
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Jackson Roberts-Young filed an appeal against the Australian Weightlifting Federation (AWF) with the National Sports Tribunal (NST), seeking to overturn a selection decision that excluded him from the Oceania Senior Championships team. The appeal was made under the AWF Selection Appeals Policy, arguing that the Appellant was not given a fair opportunity to meet the selection criteria. The NST, sitting in the General Division, heard the appeal and concluded that the Appellant had indeed not been afforded a reasonable opportunity to satisfy the relevant selection policy. The Tribunal determined that the Appellant was not informed of the retrospective Minimum Qualifying Standards until the 19th week of a 26-week selection period, and was informed of new Minimum Qualifying Standards just two days before the competition at the World Championships. The Appellant also argued that the increase in Minimum Qualifying Standards based on rankings irrelevant to the Event was unreasonable, and that he should have been eligible to compete despite ranking second in his class. The NST found these arguments to be substantiated, leading to the Tribunal upholding the appeal and overturning the original selection decision.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the Appellant had a reasonable opportunity to satisfy the Minimum Qualifying Standards as outlined in the selection policy, and whether the AWF had adhered to its own policies and procedures in making the selection decision. The Appellant argued that the timing and nature of the information provided regarding the Minimum Qualifying Standards were unreasonable and did not give him a fair chance to compete. The Tribunal considered the submissions and evidence provided by both parties, focusing on the timeliness and clarity of the information provided to the Appellant, and the relevance of the Minimum Qualifying Standards to the Event. The NST found that the Appellant's arguments were valid and that the AWF had not provided a reasonable opportunity for the Appellant to meet the selection criteria. This conclusion led to the Tribunal overturning the original selection decision and referring the matter back to the AWF for reconsideration and redetermination.

In its determination, the NST emphasised that the Appellant had discharged the onus of proving that he was not given a reasonable opportunity to satisfy the selection criteria. The Tribunal found that the Appellant's contentions regarding the timing and relevance of the Minimum Qualifying Standards were substantiated, and that the AWF had not followed its own policies and procedures. The NST's decision to uphold the appeal and overturn the original selection decision was based on these findings. The Tribunal referred the matter back to the AWF for reconsideration and redetermination, subject to the conditions outlined in the AWF Selection Appeals Policy. This determination ensures that the Appellant has the opportunity to compete in the Oceania Senior Championships, subject to the AWF's compliance with the selection criteria and policies.

The final orders of the Tribunal were that the appeal was upheld, the original selection decision was overturned, and the matter was referred back to the AWF for reconsideration and redetermination. The NST's determination was to take effect immediately, on 19 January 2024. The Tribunal's decision ensures that the Appellant has a fair opportunity to compete in the Oceania Senior Championships, and that the AWF adheres to its own policies and procedures in making future selection decisions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 19 January 2024, the Tribunal made the following determination, which was notified to the parties that day:NOTICE OF DETERMINATION – NST-E24-11998 – Jackson Roberts-Young v Australian Weightlifting Federation (AWF)I refer to the captioned Selection Appeal made pursuant clause 5.2(a) of the AWF Selection Appeals Policy (the AWFSA Policy) on grounds stipulated in clause 5.2(b)(ii) the AWFSA Policy, referred to me, sitting in the General Division of the National Sports Tribunal (the NST) under section 23 of the National Sport Tribunal Act 2019 (NST Act).Further to the oral hearing held in accordance with clause 5.2(f) (i) of the AWFSA Policy at 10.00am today, which concluded at 11.00am, please be advised that in accordance with both clause 5.2(f) of the AWFSA Policy and section 27 the NST Act, the NST is satisfied that the Appellant has discharged the onus of making out the ground of appeal, in that the Appellant, viz., the Non-Selected Athlete, was not afforded a reasonable opportunity by the AWF to satisfy the relevant Selection Policy being the 2024 Oceania Senior Championships Event Specific Selection Criteria.In accordance with section 27(3) of the NST Act and clause 5.2(h) of the AWFSA Policy, this email provides written notice of the NST’s determination, as follows:1. The Appeal is upheld.2. The original selection decision is overturned.3. Subject to cl. 5.2(j) of the AWFSA Policy, the NST refers any subsequent decision regarding the Appellant’s non-selection or if required, any broader decision regarding selection of the Team for the Event back to the AWF for reconsideration and redetermination.The NST’s determination is to take effect today, 19 January 2024. While the Tribunal has considered all the facts, allegations, legal arguments, and evidence submitted by the parties, it has referred in this Determination only to the submissions and evidence it considers material to explain its reasoning in the Introduction and immediately below. The Appellant submits that he did not have a reasonable opportunity to satisfy the Minimum Qualifying Standard because the Respondent has not met the policy standards of:a.the Australian Sports Commission (ASC), in not publishing selection policy in a timely way;b.section 8.1 ‘Appeals’ of the ‘Event Specific Selection criteria’ for the Event;c.the processes of 5.1 of AWF Selection Appeals Policy – General; andd.its own education material on competition preparation. The Appellant maintains it is not reasonable:a.to be informed in the 19th week of a 26-week Selection of retrospective Minimum Qualifying Standards.b.to be informed 2 days before competition at World Championships of new Minimum Qualifying Standards;c.to bare an increase in Minimum Qualifying Standards based on ranking that is not relevant to the Event;d.to not be eligible to compete at the Event when he had ranked 2nd in the class; ande.that the Respondent expects athletes to compete interstate immediately after their yearly competition peak overseas.