Court of Appeal
Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Jabbcorp (NSW) Pty Ltd v Strathfield Golf Club [2021] NSWCA 154 Hearing dates: 28 June 2021 Decision date: 27 July 2021 Before: Basten JA at [1];
Leeming JA at [3];
Emmett AJA at [70].Decision: Appeal dismissed with costs.
Catchwords: CONTRACT – construction – design and construct contract – contractor claimed additional payment for works required pursuant to development consent – whether works were “Excluded Works” – significance of definition commencing “Notwithstanding any other clause” – significance of grammatical meaning of clause – clause required to be read as a whole, harmoniously with other provisions in contract
Cases Cited: Angas Securities Ltd v Small Business Consortium Lloyds Consortium No. 9056 [2016] NSWCA 182
Chartbrook Ltd v Persimmon Homes Ltd [2009] 1 AC 1101; [2009] UKHL 38
Director of Public Prosecutions v Leys (2012) 44 VR 1; [2012] VSCA 304
Eddy Lau Constructions Pty Ltd v Transdevelopment Enterprise Pty Ltd [2004] NSWSC 754
Fitness First Australia Pty Ltd v Fenshaw Pty Ltd (2016) 92 NSWLR 128; [2016] NSWCA 207
Gourmania Holdings Pty Ltd v Schlegel [2021] WASCA 28
Jabbcorp (NSW) Pty Ltd v Strathfield Golf Club [2020] NSWSC 1317
Mount Bruce Mining Pty Ltd v Wright Prospecting Pty Ltd (2015) 256 CLR 104; [2015] HCA 37
Piper v Corrective Services Commission of New South Wales (1986) 6 NSWLR 352
Price v JF Thompson (Qld) Pty Ltd [1990] 1 Qd R 278
Re Bland Bros and the Council of the Borough of Inglewood (No 2) [1920] VLR 522
Toll (FGCT) Pty Ltd v Alphapharm Pty Ltd (2004) 219 CLR 165; [2004] HCA 52
XL Insurance Co SE v BNY Trust Company of Australia Ltd [2019] NSWCA 215
Zhang v ROC Services (NSW) Pty Ltd (2016) 93 NSWLR 561; [2016] NSWCA 370
Texts Cited: R Dickerson, The Fundamentals of Legal Drafting (2nd ed, Little, Brown & Co, 1986)
Category: Principal judgment Parties: Jabbcorp (NSW) Pty Ltd (Appellant)
Strathfield Golf Club (Respondent)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
M Christie SC, D Weinberger (Appellant)
D Rayment, A Smorchevsky (Respondent)
Mason Parkes Lawyers (Appellant)
Swaab (Respondent)
File Number(s): 2020/287957 Publication restriction: Nil Decision under appeal
- Court or tribunal:
- Supreme Court of New South Wales
- Jurisdiction:
- Equity – Technology and Construction List
- Citation:
- Date of Decision:
- 1 October 2020
- Before:
- Ball J
- File Number(s):
- 2018/379786
Judgment
-
BASTEN JA: I agree with Leeming JA that the appeal should be dismissed with costs; I also agree with his reasons.
-
The trial judge, Ball J, dealt expeditiously with a contractual dispute heard over four days, delivering judgment in under two weeks: Jabbcorp (NSW) Pty Ltd v Strathfield Golf Club [2020] NSWSC 1317. In addressing the amounts claimed by the builder in addition to the contract sum, in reliance on par (u) in the definition of “Excluded Works”, the judge focused on the meaning of “[a]ny works required on the golf course and outside the construction boundary of the Site”: at…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Jabbcorp (NSW) Pty Ltd v Strathfield Golf Club and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] NSWCA 154
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court of Appeal was required to determine whether certain works, specifically those reflected in variations 14A and 59, constituted "Excluded Works" as defined in the contract. This involved interpreting the contractual provisions, particularly a clause that commenced with the phrase "Notwithstanding any other clause," and considering its grammatical meaning in conjunction with the contract as a whole and its other provisions. The court also considered whether any claims relating to back-charges, which were dependent on the determination of the "Excluded Works" issue, should be upheld.
The Court of Appeal, in dismissing the appeal, reasoned that the primary judge had correctly concluded that the works in question were not "Excluded Works." The court emphasised the importance of reading the contract as a whole and harmoniously, applying the grammatical meaning of the relevant clause within that broader context. The court found that the specific wording of the definition of "Excluded Works" did not encompass the works claimed by Jabbcorp.
Accordingly, the appeal was dismissed with costs, affirming the primary judge's decision to dismiss Jabbcorp's claim.
Orders
Orders of the court
68.
For those reasons, the primary judge was correct to conclude that the works reflected in variations 14A and 59 were not “Excluded works”, and correct to dismiss Jabbcorp’s claim. The grounds of appeal separately identified grounds based on certain back-charges, but those claims stood and fell with the submissions based on variations 14A and 59 and were not the subject of separate oral or written submissions. Accordingly, the appeal should be dismissed. There is no reason so far as I am aware for costs not to follow the event.
69.
I propose that the appeal be dismissed with costs.
70.
EMMETT AJA: This appeal is concerned with the meaning of a provision in a building contract made between the respondent, Strathfield Golf Club as Principal (the Club), and the appellant, Jabbcorp (NSW) Pty Ltd as contractor (Jabbcorp). The building contract was constituted by various instruments as follows:
Background
Background to the litigation
The contract was composed of multiple instruments, and the parties disagreed on the grammatical and contextual interpretation of the clause defining "Excluded Works". The clause in question commenced with "Notwithstanding any other clause" and needed to be read in conjunction with other provisions in the contract to understand its full scope. Jabbcorp asserted that the clause should be interpreted narrowly, excluding only specific works explicitly listed. The Golf Club, on the other hand, argued for a broader interpretation, encompassing any works not specifically outlined elsewhere in the contract. The primary judge concluded that the works reflected in variations 14A and 59 were not "Excluded Works" and dismissed Jabbcorp's claim, a decision that Jabbcorp appealed.
The appeal hinged on the interpretation of the contract's language, particularly the clause defining "Excluded Works" and its interaction with other clauses. The appeal did not focus on separate back-charges, as those claims were contingent on the outcome of the primary dispute over variations 14A and 59. The case thus turns on the nuanced interpretation of contractual language and the principles of harmonising clauses within a comprehensive contract.
The matter before the court is an appeal brought by Jabbcorp (NSW) Pty Ltd against the decision of the primary judge. Jabbcorp had originally sought additional payment for works performed under a design and construct contract with the respondent, Strathfield Golf Club, which it claimed were not covered by the term "Excluded Works" in the contract. The primary judge dismissed Jabbcorp’s claim, and this decision is now under appeal. The appeal focuses on the interpretation of a specific clause within the contract and whether the additional works fell within the definition of "Excluded Works." Prior to the appeal, the matter was heard in the lower court, where the primary judge ruled against Jabbcorp on the interpretation of the contract clause. The appeal does not address the substantive legal issues or the outcome but rather focuses on the procedural aspects and the correctness of the primary judge’s interpretation of the contract terms. The appeal was heard on the basis of written submissions and did not include separate claims regarding certain back-charges, as these were contingent on the primary issues concerning variations 14A and 59.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. What is the meaning of the term "Excluded Works" as defined in the building contract between Strathfield Golf Club and Jabbcorp (NSW) Pty Ltd?
2. How should the phrase "Notwithstanding any other clause" in the definition of "Excluded Works" be interpreted?
3. Does the grammatical structure of the clause require it to be read as a whole and in harmony with other provisions in the contract?
4. Were the works reflected in variations 14A and 59 "Excluded Works" under the contract?
5. If not, does this affect the validity of Jabbcorp's claim for additional payment for these works?
6. Should the appeal be dismissed with costs following the primary judge's conclusion?
Held
1. The court concluded that the term "Excluded Works" in the building contract between Strathfield Golf Club and Jabbcorp (NSW) Pty Ltd is defined in a specific way, which excludes certain works from the scope of the contract. The appeal was dismissed with costs.
2. The court interpreted the phrase "Notwithstanding any other clause" in the definition of "Excluded Works" to mean that this definition overrides other clauses in the contract that might otherwise apply. The appeal was dismissed with costs.
3. The court held that the grammatical structure of the clause requires it to be read as a whole and in harmony with other provisions in the contract, ensuring consistency and coherence. The appeal was dismissed with costs.
4. The court found that the works reflected in variations 14A and 59 were not "Excluded Works" under the contract. The appeal was dismissed with costs.
5. The court determined that since the works in variations 14A and 59 were not "Excluded Works", this does not affect the validity of Jabbcorp's claim for additional payment for these works. The appeal was dismissed with costs.
6. The court agreed that the appeal should be dismissed with costs following the primary judge's conclusion. The appeal was dismissed with costs.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Jabbcorp (NSW) Pty Ltd v Strathfield Golf Club, the appeal hinged on the interpretation of certain terms within the building contract between the parties. The primary issue was the meaning of the term "Excluded Works" as defined in the contract, and whether specific works constituted "Excluded Works." The court needed to determine if these works were excluded from Jabbcorp's scope of liability and thereby warranted additional payment. The court first examined the definition of "Excluded Works" and the phrase "Notwithstanding any other clause," which was pivotal in interpreting the scope of the exclusions.
The court considered the phrase "Notwithstanding any other clause" and its implications for the interpretation of the definition of "Excluded Works." The phrase suggested that the exclusions were to be applied irrespective of other provisions within the contract, but this did not necessarily mean that the exclusions were absolute or could be interpreted in isolation. The court recognised that the phrase did not necessarily override other contractual provisions but required the clause to be read in the context of the entire contract.
Further, the court addressed the grammatical structure of the clause and whether it should be read as a whole and harmoniously with other provisions in the contract. The court emphasised that contractual clauses should be interpreted as a whole, ensuring that each part of the contract is given meaning and effect. This holistic approach is in line with established principles of contract interpretation in Australian law, where the focus is on the overall intention of the parties as expressed in the contract.
In applying these principles, the court scrutinised whether the works reflected in variations 14A and 59 were "Excluded Works" under the contract. The court found that these works did not fall within the definition of "Excluded Works," as they did not align with the specific exclusions outlined in the contract. The court's decision was influenced by the need to give effect to each part of the contract and the importance of ensuring that the interpretation was consistent with the overall purpose of the agreement.
The court then considered whether the determination that the works were not "Excluded Works" affected the validity of Jabbcorp's claim for additional payment. The court concluded that since the works were not excluded, Jabbcorp was liable for these works under the contract, and thus, its claim for additional payment was invalid. This decision was based on the principle that if works are not excluded, the contractor remains responsible for them under the contract.
Finally, the court addressed the question of whether the appeal should be dismissed with costs. Given that the primary judge had correctly interpreted the contract and dismissed Jabbcorp's claim, the court found no basis to overturn this decision. The court proposed that the appeal should be dismissed with costs, adhering to the principle that costs should follow the event unless there are exceptional circumstances. The court's decision was in line with the primary judge's conclusion and the established legal principles of contract interpretation.