J v P; J v The The Queen; J v Protected Persons

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

Supreme Court of South Australia

(Magistrates Appeal: Criminal)

J v P; J v R; J v PROTECTED PERSONS

[2022] SASC 45

Judgment of the Honourable Justice Stein 

16 May 2022

MAGISTRATES - APPEAL AND REVIEW - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - APPEAL TO SUPREME COURT

MAGISTRATES - ORDERS AND CONVICTIONS - ORDERS TO RESTRAIN DOMESTIC, FAMILY OR APPREHENDED VIOLENCE OR FOR PERSONAL SAFETY - INTERIM ORDER

The respondents sought and were granted interim intervention orders against the appellant. The appellant sought but was refused an interim intervention order against the respondents.

The appellant appeals against the grant of the two interim intervention orders against her and the dismissal of her application for interim intervention orders against the respondents.

Held, refusing permission to appeal:

1.The grant of interim intervention orders against the appellant was an interlocutory decision requiring permission to appeal.

2.The dismissal of the application for interim intervention orders against the respondents was an interlocutory decision requiring permission to appeal.

3.Permission to appeal is refused in respect of the grant of the interim intervention orders in circumstances in which the interim intervention orders have not yet proceeded to a hearing to determine whether final intervention orders ought to be made.

4.Permission to appeal is refused in respect of the dismissal of the application for interim intervention orders. An arguable case sufficient to constitute special reasons has not been established by the appellant.

Intervention Orders (Prevention of Abuse) Act 2009 (SA) ss 3, 6, 20(1), 23; Magistrates Court Act 1991 (SA) sub-s 42(1), (1a), (4); Supreme Court Criminal Rules 2014 (SA) r 104V(1)(a), (c), referred to.

Groom v Police (No 3) (2013) 231 A Crim R 1; Kiparoglou v Fantinel [2021] SASC 90; Shahin v El-Shafei; El-Shafei v Shahin (2018) 132 SASR 126; Thakur v Police (2016) 125 SASR 180, applied.

J v P; J v R; J v PROTECTED PERSONS
[2022] SASC 45

Magistrates Appeal: Criminal

STEIN J:

Overview

  1. This group of appeals concerns a strained relationship between neighbours which resulted in those neighbours making applications for interim intervention orders against each other. Interim intervention orders were granted for the protection of one set of neighbours, the respondents and their children, but a Magistrate declined to grant an interim intervention order for the protection of the other neighbour, the appellant. 

  2. Although there are three separate appeals, all arise out of the same factual background and I have therefore addressed all three together in these reasons.

    Background

  3. The appellant and respondents have been neighbours for about 18 years. The neighbours’ relationship initially was positive, however, it deteriorated.

  4. The appellant claimed the respondents were behaving in an unacceptable fashion. The appellant asserts that the respondents have, among other things, thrown faeces into the appellant’s driveway, gossiped about her in their back garden, screamed at her and sworn at her, thrown objects over the fence and poisoned her plants.

  5. The respondents assert that in 2012 the appellant installed cameras pointing directly at their back door and backyard in order to spy on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read J v P; J v The The Queen; J v Protected Persons and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] SASC 45
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant, J, has appealed against two decisions of the Magistrates Court of South Australia relating to applications for intervention orders against the respondents, P and R, and their two teenage sons. The appellant sought an intervention order against the respondents, which was refused on 29 September 2021. The respondents, on the other hand, applied for and were granted interim intervention orders against the appellant on 3 November 2021. Both decisions are being appealed by the appellant on the basis that she is the victim and was forced to accept the order to protect the respondents for six months. The appellant argues that she does not feel safe at home when the respondents are present and that they abuse her and teach their children to abuse her as well. The appeals require consideration of the legal framework governing intervention orders under the Intervention Orders (Prevention of Abuse) Act 2009 (SA) and the relevant appeal provisions in the Magistrates Court Act 1991 (SA) and the Supreme Court Criminal Rules 2014 (SA).

The primary legal issue before the court is whether the appellant has established special reasons to permit an appeal against the interlocutory decisions made by the Magistrates Court. The appellant’s appeal against the refusal to grant her an intervention order and the grant of interim intervention orders against her must first satisfy the criteria for permission to appeal under s 42(1a) of the Magistrates Court Act. The court must determine if any of the specified conditions—that the judgment stays the proceedings, destroys or substantially weakens the prosecution case, or if special reasons exist—are met. The appellant did not seek permission to appeal in her notice of appeal, and the court must now assess if she has established special reasons justifying an appeal against these interlocutory decisions.

The court found that the grant of interim intervention orders against the appellant and the refusal to grant an intervention order against the respondents were interlocutory decisions requiring permission to appeal. The court examined the submissions and the evidence presented, concluding that the appellant had not established special reasons for an appeal. Specifically, the court noted that the interim intervention orders had not yet been subject to a hearing to determine if final orders should be made, and the appellant had not demonstrated an arguable case that special reasons exist to appeal the dismissal of her application for an intervention order. The court concluded that permission to appeal was not warranted under the circumstances presented.

In light of the above, the court refused permission to appeal both the grant of interim intervention orders against the appellant and the dismissal of her application for intervention orders against the respondents. The court held that the interim intervention orders were an interlocutory decision requiring permission to appeal, and the appellant had not established special reasons to permit such an appeal. Similarly, the dismissal of the appellant’s application for an intervention order was also an interlocutory decision requiring permission to appeal, which the appellant had not demonstrated was warranted.

Orders

Orders of the court

Held, refusing permission to appeal:

1. The grant of interim intervention orders against the appellant was an interlocutory decision requiring permission to appeal.

2. The dismissal of the application for interim intervention orders against the respondents was an interlocutory decision requiring permission to appeal.

3. Permission to appeal is refused in respect of the grant of the interim intervention orders in circumstances in which the interim intervention orders have not yet proceeded to a hearing to determine whether final intervention orders ought to be made.

4. Permission to appeal is refused in respect of the dismissal of the application for interim intervention orders. An arguable case sufficient to constitute special reasons has not been established by the appellant.

Background

Background to the litigation

Although there are three separate appeals, all arise out of the same factual background and I have therefore addressed all three together in these reasons. Background The appellant and respondents have been neighbours for about 18 years. The neighbours’ relationship initially was positive, however, it deteriorated. The appellant claimed the respondents were behaving in an unacceptable fashion. The appellant asserts that the respondents have, among other things, thrown faeces into the appellant’s driveway, gossiped about her in their back garden, screamed at her and sworn at her, thrown objects over the fence and poisoned her plants. The respondents assert that in 2012 the appellant installed cameras pointing directly at their back door and backyard in order to spy on the respondents. They allege unacceptable conduct by the appellant such as playing loud music at 6.00am on weekends, squirting a hose at the fence, spraying water onto the respondents’ cars and behaving in a way to annoy them. The respondents allege that the appellant takes photographs and video footage of the respondents and their teenage children and has attended the workplace of one of the teenage sons complaining about him to his manager. The parties attended a mediation in about 2011 which was unsuccessful. On 17 September 2021, the appellant applied for an intervention order as against the respondents. On 29 September 2021, a Magistrate refused the appellant’s application. On 30 September 2021, one of the respondents, R, applied on behalf of herself, her husband and her two teenage sons for interim intervention orders against the appellant. Interim interventions orders were made on 3 November 2021. On 5 November 2021, the interim intervention orders were served on the appellant. A mediation took place on 1 December 2021 between the parties. The mediation was unsuccessful. On 12 January 2022, a Magistrate made an order adjourning the matter to 13 July 2022 to assess if the parties are able to abide the terms of the interim orders and come to an agreement, failing which the matter will proceed. As at the date the appeal was heard, a final intervention order had not been issued.Magistrate’s decision in relation to the appellant The Magistrate gave ex tempore reasons for refusing the appellant’s application for an interim intervention order. I will refer to this decision as the “Appellant Judgment”. The grounds of the appellant’s application before the Magistrate were that proposed defendants (the respondents) may commit an act of non-domestic abuse and the applicant had, and would, suffer emotional harm. The Magistrate listed the acts of alleged abuse. She acknowledged the appellant’s distress. However, the Magistrate was not satisfied on the evidence that it was reasonable to suspect that the respondents will, without intervention, commit an act of abuse against the appellant nor that it was appropriate to issue the order. The Magistrate referred to each of the alleged acts of abuse. The Magistrate said she was not satisfied that the alleged act of gossiping amounts to abuse. She was not satisfied an act of poisoning plants occurred based on only the appearance of the plants. There was an allegation that R video recorded the appellant. The Magistrate was not satisfied that the isolated incident amounted to an act of abuse. The Magistrate was not satisfied that the conduct of the male respondent, P, (in particular, swearing at the appellant) was sufficient to persuade her that the abuse was likely to continue without intervention. There was little information before the Court to suggest that the behaviour of the teenage son (also primarily swearing) was likely to continue.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Magistrate hearing the applications by the respondents made the interim intervention orders after hearing evidence from the respondents and viewing stills of video footage. I will refer to this decision as the “Respondents’ Judgment”. The Magistrate heard evidence, considered the stills of video footage and questioned the witnesses in relation to the relevant matters required to found the basis for an interim intervention order. It is apparent that the Magistrate was satisfied it was appropriate to grant interim intervention orders.The notices of appeal None of the parties were represented. Without in any way criticising the parties, this resulted in a lack of clarity in the submissions. Understandably, the appellant expressed her complaints in general terms. In respect of the Appellant Judgment, the appellant complains that the intervention order was refused on 29 September 2021. The appellant states she would like to be protected and have an intervention order in respect of her neighbours. In respect of the Respondents’ Judgment, in the notice of appeal the appellant seeks the removal of the order “because I’m the victim. I was forced to accept the order to protect my neighbours for 6 months by Magistrate … on 12.1.22”. The grounds of appeal state that the appellant does not feel safe at home when the respondents are home. She states that the respondents abuse her and teach their children to abuse her as well. The appeal book essentially comprised the material from the lower court file. The respondents’ material largely mirrors the lower court file.General principles on appeal The Intervention Orders (Prevention of Abuse) Act 2009 (SA) (“the Act”) provides for applications for an intervention order to be made to the Magistrates Court.[1] [1] Section 20(1) of the Act; “Court” is defined in section 3 of the Act. This appeal is governed by s 42 of the Magistrates Court Act 1991 (SA) (“Magistrates Court Act”)[2] and Chapter 12A of the Supreme Court Criminal Rules 2014 (SA) (“Rules”). [2] Groom v Police (No 3) (2013) 231 A Crim R 1, [22]-[28] (Sulan J). Pursuant to r 104V(1)(a) of the Rules, the hearing is to occur by way of re‑hearing. The Court may in its discretion hear further evidence pursuant to r 104V(1)(c), and, if the interests of justice so require, section 42(4) of the Magistrates Court Act. In addressing the appeals, I have considered the transcript of the hearings before the Magistrates, the material from the lower court files and the oral submissions made to me. Interlocutory order - requirement for permission to appeal The appellant (understandably) did not in her notice of appeal seek permission to appeal. Subsections 42(1) and (1a) of the Magistrates Court Act provides as follows:42—Appeals (1)A party to a criminal action may, subject to this section and in accordance with the rules of the appellate court, appeal against any judgment given in the action (including a judgment dismissing a charge of a summary or minor indictable offence but not any judgment arising from committal proceedings).(1a) An appeal does not, however, lie against an interlocutory judgment unless—(a) the judgment stays the proceedings; or(b) the judgment destroys or substantially weakens the basis of the prosecution case and, if correct, is likely to lead to abandonment of the prosecution; or(c) the Court or the appellate court is satisfied that there are special reasons why it would be in the interests of the administration of justice to have the appeal determined before commencement or completion of the trial and grants its permission for an appeal.Interlocutory order

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.