Ivory Lane Developments v Goorigubba

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read


Supreme Court

New South Wales

Case Name: 

Ivory Lane Developments v Goorigubba

Medium Neutral Citation: 

[2015] NSWSC 224

Hearing Date(s): 

12 March 2015

Decision Date: 

12 March 2015

Jurisdiction: 

Common Law

Before: 

McDougall J

Decision: 

Plaintiff entitled to declarations as to existence of charge and debt, and order for payment of debt with interest. Plaintiff to bring in draft orders.

Catchwords: 

CONTRACT - construction - whether deed granted an equitable charge and mortgage over property - relevance of that intention being expressed primarily in the recitals rather than the provisions of the deed - clear intention that recitals were intended to have present effect
EQUITY - equitable charge - whether a charge to secure payment of a debt is a charge for the purposes of the Real Property Act - where agreement in any case expressly stated that an equitable mortgage would also be created - repayment - whether interest owing – registration of mortgage - whether appropriate to make order for specific performance that defendant execute mortgage in registrable form - where liquidator of defendant has not been given opportunity to respond to application

Legislation Cited: 

Real Property Act 1900 (NSW)

Category: 

Principal judgment

Parties: 

Ivory Lane Developments Pty Limited (Plaintiff)
Goorigubba Pty Ltd (Defendant)

Representation: 

Counsel:
DKL Raphael (Plaintiff)
C Stomo (third party caveator)

Solicitors:
& Legal (Plaintiff)

File Number(s): 

2014/304395

JUDGMENT   (EX TEMPORE – REVISED 12 MARCH 2015)

  1. HIS HONOUR:   In June 2012, the plaintiff (Ivory Lane) arranged finance for the defendant (Goorigubba) to assist with the purchase of a property, 74 Courallie Avenue, West Homebush (the property). Not surprisingly, Ivory Lane was to be paid a fee for that service.

  2. On 15 August 2013, Ivory Lane, Goorigubba and Goorigubba's principal, Mr Barnes, entered into a deed under which they formalised (or restated) their agreement. The deed recited the matters to which I have referred. It recited that an offer of finance acceptable to Ivory Lane had been procured, from a lender known as Eclipse Prudent Finance. It recited an agreement for a charge (in recital J):

    J.   The parties hereto agree and acknowledge that this agreement constitutes an equitable charge and mortgage for the sum of $50,000 and the sum due as a brokerage fee, over the property at 74 Courallie Road which is owned by the Company and the assets of the Company and the Lexicon may register a caveat over the 74 Courallie Avenue and if settled 72 Courallie Avenue as security for the abovementioned sums immediately and that Lexicon may also register a charge over the Company.

  3. The brokerage fee was to be 2% of the amount of the loan; that is to say, in the events that have happened, $58,000 in total was payable. $50,000 was the separate sum referred to in recital J. $8,000 represents the brokerage.

  4. Clauses 2 and 3 of the deed are of significance:

    2.   ACKNOWLEDGMENT

        The company acknowledges and agrees with the Recitals and agrees to perform its obligations in this deed.

    3.   FAILURE TO PROCEED WITH…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ivory Lane Developments v Goorigubba and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NSWSC 224
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Ivory Lane Developments Pty Ltd v Goorigubba, the dispute centred around the interpretation of a deed that the parties executed, which involved a construction project. The Federal Court was tasked with determining whether the deed constituted an equitable charge and mortgage over a property, and if so, whether the court should order the defendant to execute the mortgage in a registrable form as a condition for specific performance. The primary focus was on whether the recitals of the deed, which expressed an intention to create an equitable charge, were intended to have present effect despite not being explicitly stated in the operative provisions of the deed.

The legal issues before the court encompassed whether the recitals of the deed, if indeed intended to have present effect, could be relied upon to establish an equitable charge and mortgage over the property. Furthermore, the court had to consider whether an equitable charge to secure the payment of a debt qualified as a charge for the purposes of the Real Property Act, especially given that the agreement expressly stated the creation of an equitable mortgage. Another significant issue was whether interest was owed on the debt and whether the mortgage should be registered. Finally, the court needed to determine if it was appropriate to make an order for specific performance, compelling the defendant to execute the mortgage in a registrable form, without giving the liquidator of the defendant an opportunity to respond to the application.

The court held that the recitals of the deed were intended to have present effect, thus establishing an equitable charge and mortgage over the property. The court found that an equitable charge to secure debt repayment was indeed a charge for the purposes of the Real Property Act, and that interest was owed on the debt. Although the mortgage should be registered, the court decided that it was not appropriate to make an order for specific performance at that juncture, as the liquidator of the defendant had not been given an opportunity to respond to the application. Therefore, the court's decision focused on the need for further proceedings to allow the liquidator to be heard before any specific performance order could be made.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute between Ivory Lane Developments and Goorigubba regarding a deed intended to secure payment obligations under a construction contract. Ivory Lane Developments, a developer, contracted with Goorigubba, a builder, for the construction of a property. A deed was executed by Goorigubba to Ivory Lane Developments to secure the payment obligations under the construction contract. The deed contained recitals that referred to the creation of an equitable charge and mortgage over the property, though the operative provisions did not explicitly state the creation of such a charge and mortgage. Ivory Lane Developments argued that the recitals expressed the clear intention to create an equitable charge and mortgage, despite the absence of such language in the operative provisions of the deed. The dispute centred on whether the recitals had legal effect and whether they were intended to have present effect. Additionally, there was a question about whether the charge to secure the payment of a debt constituted a charge for the purposes of the Real Property Act, and whether interest was owing under the agreement. The case also involved a request for specific performance to compel Goorigubba to execute a mortgage in registrable form, despite the absence of an opportunity for the liquidator of Goorigubba to respond to the application.

The matter came before the court as an application for specific performance. Ivory Lane Developments sought an order for specific performance to enforce the execution of a mortgage in registrable form by Goorigubba. The application was brought following an earlier decision in which the court had ruled on certain issues but had not yet made a determination on the specific performance order. The court considered the arguments presented by both parties and reviewed the evidence, including the deed and other documents relevant to the construction contract and the security arrangements. The court also noted that the liquidator of Goorigubba had not been given an opportunity to respond to the application for specific performance.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the deed granted an equitable charge and mortgage over the property, with particular emphasis on the intention being expressed in the recitals rather than the operative provisions.
2. Whether a charge to secure payment of a debt is a charge for the purposes of the Real Property Act.
3. Whether interest is owing under the agreement.
4. Whether it is appropriate to make an order for specific performance that the defendant execute a mortgage in registrable form, given that the liquidator of the defendant has not been given an opportunity to respond to the application.

Held
1. The court held that the deed granted an equitable charge and mortgage over the property. The intention to create this charge was primarily expressed in the recitals rather than the operative provisions of the deed, and the court found that the recitals were intended to have present effect.
2. The court concluded that a charge to secure payment of a debt is a charge for the purposes of the Real Property Act. The agreement expressly stated that an equitable mortgage would also be created.
3. The court found that interest is owing under the agreement, as it was expressly stated in the agreement.
4. The court held that it was not appropriate to make an order for specific performance that the defendant execute a mortgage in registrable form. The liquidator of the defendant had not been given an opportunity to respond to the application, making it unjust to proceed with the order.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the deed to determine whether it granted an equitable charge and mortgage over the property, focusing on the intention expressed in the recitals rather than the operative provisions. The recitals stated that the deed was made for present effect, and the court found that this intention was clear. The court's conclusion that the deed granted an equitable charge and mortgage is based on the language of the recitals, which established the intention of the parties at the time of execution. The ratio decidendi here is that when the intention to create a charge is primarily expressed in the recitals, and those recitals indicate present effect, the deed can be held to grant an equitable charge and mortgage.

In determining whether a charge to secure payment of a debt is a charge for the purposes of the Real Property Act, the court looked to the language of the agreement, which expressly stated that an equitable mortgage would also be created. The court found that this language was sufficient to establish that the charge was indeed a charge for the purposes of the Act. The ratio decidendi here is that where an agreement expressly states that an equitable mortgage will be created, it can be held to be a charge for the purposes of the Real Property Act.

The court also addressed whether interest is owing under the agreement, finding that it was expressly stated in the agreement. The court held that the parties had agreed to the payment of interest, and therefore interest is owing. The ratio decidendi here is that where interest is expressly stated in an agreement, it is owing.

Finally, the court considered whether it was appropriate to make an order for specific performance that the defendant execute a mortgage in registrable form. The court found that it was not appropriate to proceed with the order, as the liquidator of the defendant had not been given an opportunity to respond to the application. The court held that it would be unjust to make such an order without the liquidator's input. The ratio decidendi here is that where a party has not been given an opportunity to respond to an application for specific performance, it is not appropriate to proceed with the order.