Issa v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Issa v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2000] FCA 128

IMMIGRATION – application to review decision of Migration Review Tribunal to refuse “special need relative” visa – whether Tribunal erred by asking whether assistance could reasonably be provided to the applicant rather than asking whether “assistance cannot reasonably be obtained” by her – costs of application.

WORDS AND PHRASES – “reasonably be obtained”

Montes-Granados v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] FCA 60, applied

FATIMA ISSA v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

N 1296 of 1999

MADGWICK J

SYDNEY

4 FEBRUARY 2000

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 1296 OF 1999

BETWEEN:

FATIMA ISSA
APPLICANT

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

MADGWICK J

DATE OF ORDER:

4 FEBRUARY 2000

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application is dismissed.

2.        No order is made as to costs.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 1296 OF 1999

BETWEEN:

FATIMA ISSA
APPLICANT

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

MADGWICK J

DATE:

4 FEBRUARY 2000

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
(revised from transcript)

HIS HONOUR:

  1. This is yet another hard immigration case.  It concerns an application by Mrs Maha Issa, whom I will call Maha, to be granted a Preferential Family Visa under subclass 104 of the Regulation to the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”) (since repealed) as a "special need relative" of her mother, Mrs Fatima Issa, who was the review applicant before the Migration Review Tribunal (“the Tribunal”), and who is the applicant in these proceedings. I will call the review applicant Mrs Issa.

    Factual Background

  2. The uncontested medical evidence was that Mrs Issa's health is poor and deteriorating fast.  She has a number of conditions:  she is an insulin-dependent diabetic; she is an asthmatic in need of frequent resort to medication; she has serious depression and anxiety.  It is quite clear that Mrs Issa requires the regular and frequent assistance of a carer.  Maha is the eldest of Mrs Issa's five children.  Maha was at the time of the Tribunal's decision aged 33.  Mrs Issa's other daughter, Nour, is the youngest of her children, and was aged 19 at the time of the Tribunal's decision.

  3. The family is of southern Lebanese origin, and there is an inference that they were displaced to Syria because of the murderous conflicts of the Middle East.  Mrs Issa, her husband and the four children, other than Maha, migrated to Australia from Syria in about 1987.  Permission was given by the Australian Government for Maha also to come to Australia but she was at the time recently married and chose to remain in Syria with her husband and to enjoy the anticipated support of her in-laws.

  4. Mrs Issa's illnesses seem to have developed in recent years.  The attachment she has to her eldest child and elder daughter, Maha, has a special quality.  She is closely…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Issa v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 128
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Issa v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs involved Mrs Maha Issa, who applied for a Preferential Family Visa under subclass 104 of the Regulation to the Migration Act 1958 (Cth), seeking to be recognised as a "special need relative" of her mother, Mrs Fatima Issa. Mrs Issa, who resides in Australia, suffers from poor health conditions including diabetes, asthma, depression, and anxiety, necessitating the regular and frequent assistance of a carer. Maha, Mrs Issa's eldest daughter, was living in Syria and desired to move to Australia to provide care for her ailing mother. The primary legal issue before the court was whether Maha could demonstrate that substantial and continuing assistance for Mrs Issa could not reasonably be obtained from other relatives or welfare services in Australia, as required by the definition of "special needs relative" in Regulation 1.04.

The court carefully examined the evidence presented by both Maha and other family members, including Mrs Issa's younger daughter, Nour, who had previously cared for Mrs Issa but was no longer able or willing to do so due to personal reasons. Other family members, such as Mrs Issa's daughters-in-law, were either unable or unwilling to provide care due to various personal circumstances and family tensions. Despite the compelling case made by Maha regarding her mother's need for her specific care, the court found that Mrs Issa's needs could be met by other relatives or through available welfare services in Australia. The court emphasised that the mere assertions by Maha about her sons' unavailability or unwillingness to assist did not suffice to meet the stringent criteria for a "special needs relative" visa.

Based on the evidence and the legal criteria, the court upheld the Tribunal's decision to deny the visa application. The court concluded that there were other relatives and services available that could reasonably provide the necessary care for Mrs Issa, thus satisfying the requirements of Regulation 1.04. Consequently, the court dismissed the application and made no order regarding costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application is dismissed.

2. No order is made as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is yet another hard immigration case. It concerns an application by Mrs Maha Issa, whom I will call Maha, to be granted a Preferential Family Visa under subclass 104 of the Regulation to the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”) (since repealed) as a "special need relative" of her mother, Mrs Fatima Issa, who was the review applicant before the Migration Review Tribunal (“the Tribunal”), and who is the applicant in these proceedings. I will call the review applicant Mrs Issa.Factual Background The uncontested medical evidence was that Mrs Issa's health is poor and deteriorating fast. She has a number of conditions: she is an insulin-dependent diabetic; she is an asthmatic in need of frequent resort to medication; she has serious depression and anxiety. It is quite clear that Mrs Issa requires the regular and frequent assistance of a carer. Maha is the eldest of Mrs Issa's five children. Maha was at the time of the Tribunal's decision aged 33. Mrs Issa's other daughter, Nour, is the youngest of her children, and was aged 19 at the time of the Tribunal's decision. The family is of southern Lebanese origin, and there is an inference that they were displaced to Syria because of the murderous conflicts of the Middle East. Mrs Issa, her husband and the four children, other than Maha, migrated to Australia from Syria in about 1987. Permission was given by the Australian Government for Maha also to come to Australia but she was at the time recently married and chose to remain in Syria with her husband and to enjoy the anticipated support of her in-laws. Mrs Issa's illnesses seem to have developed in recent years. The attachment she has to her eldest child and elder daughter, Maha, has a special quality. She is closely in touch with that daughter by telephone at considerable expense. A continuing source of her depression is the fact that Maha is in Syria and faces certain difficulties there while, as Mrs Issa says, she is isolated from her brothers and sister. Mrs Issa, it appears, compulsively worries about Maha and misses her deeply. If Maha were here she would depend on her for much emotional support, and I have little doubt that the Tribunal accepted, that it is likely that she would be considerably relieved in her depression. The Tribunal’s decision The Tribunal member stated the nub of the problem simply. She said:“For the visa applicant [that is Maha] to be successful she must demonstrate that substantial and continuing assistance [for Mrs Issa] cannot reasonably be obtained from another relative or welfare services in Australia.”That is a fair and proper paraphrase of the requirements of the definition of "special needs relative" in Regulation 1.04. The uncontested material before the Tribunal showed that her daughter, Nour, had worked from the age of 15 for about three years and had then given up work to look after her mother, Mrs Issa. Nour had also married and had separated. Nour explained to the Tribunal member that she was young, she wished to remake her life following the failure of her marriage, she did not like not being unemployed and she was looking for work. She said, in effect, that her personality clashed with that of her mother and that she could not carry out the role of carer for her mother. One of Mrs Issa's daughters-in-law is the sister of Nour's estranged husband. Family tensions are such that that daughter-in-law has little contact with Mrs Issa. The other daughters-in-law have children of their own whose care makes substantial demands on their time.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mrs Issa's illnesses seem to have developed in recent years. The attachment she has to her eldest child and elder daughter, Maha, has a special quality. She is closely in touch with that daughter by telephone at considerable expense. A continuing source of her depression is the fact that Maha is in Syria and faces certain difficulties there while, as Mrs Issa says, she is isolated from her brothers and sister. Mrs Issa, it appears, compulsively worries about Maha and misses her deeply. If Maha were here she would depend on her for much emotional support, and I have little doubt that the Tribunal accepted, that it is likely that she would be considerably relieved in her depression. The Tribunal’s decision The Tribunal member stated the nub of the problem simply. She said:“For the visa applicant [that is Maha] to be successful she must demonstrate that substantial and continuing assistance [for Mrs Issa] cannot reasonably be obtained from another relative or welfare services in Australia.”That is a fair and proper paraphrase of the requirements of the definition of "special needs relative" in Regulation 1.04. The uncontested material before the Tribunal showed that her daughter, Nour, had worked from the age of 15 for about three years and had then given up work to look after her mother, Mrs Issa. Nour had also married and had separated. Nour explained to the Tribunal member that she was young, she wished to remake her life following the failure of her marriage, she did not like not being unemployed and she was looking for work. She said, in effect, that her personality clashed with that of her mother and that she could not carry out the role of carer for her mother. One of Mrs Issa's daughters-in-law is the sister of Nour's estranged husband. Family tensions are such that that daughter-in-law has little contact with Mrs Issa. The other daughters-in-law have children of their own whose care makes substantial demands on their time. A body called Health Services Australia, which is apparently accredited, as a matter of policy, by the respondent, furnished the Tribunal with a medical report that concluded that Mrs Issa required a carer for the purposes of a "carer visa" (in the context this seems not to refer to the requirements of the correctly so-called “carer visa”, but to that for a “special needs relative”). It seems that by this method the Department of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs instituted a means whereby an Australian relative allegedly in need of care could establish such need by obtaining a positive assessment from a body such as Health Services Australia. The Tribunal member in her findings said among other things, that:“It is clear from the evidence that the sponsor mother suffers from a number of medical problems and is distressed by her family circumstances regarding her parents, her sons and her daughter in Australia. I accept that she suffers anxiety and depression due to her separation from the visa applicant. I accept that her family circumstances, including her father's illness and her daughter's separation also cause her distress. I accept that she requires a carer due to asthma, anxiety and depression. Whilst the review applicant states she is unable to cook for herself or take her medications in relation to her diabetes, it is clear from the evidence that she is presently living on her own with her husband and is caring for herself. She has been referred to a specialist organisation to assist her to learn skills necessary to care for herself.The applicant's daughter attended at the hearing ... with her mother. Despite her protestations and having had the opportunity of seeing her give evidence to me I am not satisfied that she cannot do anything to help her mother. Whilst she was stated it is due to her problems being separated, I am not satisfied that she cannot assist her mother. Furthermore, I am not satisfied that her sons and their families are not able to assist the applicant... The mere fact that the visa applicant claims that her sons are too busy or that they have a bad attitude or that they get irritated quickly, does not convince me that they cannot do anything to help their mother. Furthermore, the evidence is that the review applicant does not often see her sons, but nevertheless she does see her sons. She admitted to the Tribunal that she sees her daughter on an average once a week. I am not satisfied that her daughter and her sons are unable to assist her. I am not satisfied that the sponsor has a permanent or long-term need for assistance because of [the factors set out in Regulation 1.04]… Furthermore, the applicant has other relatives in Australia who are able to assist her and there is available to her welfare, hospital, nursing and community services in Australia should the need arise.For the above reasons the Tribunal affirms the original decision not to grant the visa applicant the visa sought.” (Emphasis added)The applicant’s case

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.