| [2024] FWC 3550 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
| DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.739—Dispute resolution
Isabella Lonigro
v
Krispy Kreme Australia Pty Limited
(C2024/5585)
| COMMISSIONER MIRABELLA | MELBOURNE, 20 DECEMBER 2024 |
Alleged dispute about matters arising under an enterprise agreement
This decision arises from an application by Isabella Lonigro (the applicant) for the Fair Work Commission (the Commission) to deal with the dispute under s 739 of the Fair Work Act 2009 ( the Act). The applicant is an employee of Krispy Kreme Pty Ltd (the respondent).
The dispute arises from provisions of the Krispy Kreme National Enterprise Agreement 2020 (the Agreement) regarding Rostering Principle 2 of the Agreement (Principle 2). This Principle relates to an employee’s request for a rostering change and the consideration of Management of that request.
A conference was held in this matter on 2 September 2024 but failed to resolve the dispute.
In consultation the parties agreed to the question for arbitration.
The Respondent did not object to the matter being decided on the papers. The applicant requested an explanation of ‘what would the process of determining the outcome be via the papers’. In response, chambers sent an explanatory email to the Applicant on 18 December 2024 and further requested she provide a view on the matter by 1:00pm on 19 December 2024. An attempt was also made to call the Applicant on 18 December 2024. The applicant did not contact chambers by the nominated deadline. A further unsuccessful attempt was made to telephone the Applicant on the afternoon of 19 December 2024 and another email was sent to the Applicant urging her to provide a response by 3:00pm on 20 December 2024. As of 3:00pm 20 December 2024, the Commission has not heard from the Applicant. I have proceeded to determine the matter on the papers.
The parties agreed that the question for arbitration is:
‘Does Rostering Principle 2 require Krispy Kreme to take into consideration availability of their employees?’
Background and submissions
The applicant works for Krispy Kreme on an apparent part time basis. She has made numerous requests over the course of 2024 for a change to her rostered hours ‘to change my availability to fit in with my professional job.’[1] As a result, the applicant submits that she has been rostered on days and times that she cannot work and has had to take up additional days in her ‘professional’ job in order to make up for the loss of earnings.
The applicant submits that in accordance with Principle 2, she followed the ‘appropriate measures to change my availability’[2]. She further submits that ‘In line with what is written in Krispy Kremes National enterprise, yes I believe Krispy Kreme is required to take into consideration the changing availability of their employees.’[3]
The respondent submits that the question for arbitration can be answered by considering the plain meaning of the words in Principle 2. It submits that when an employee who needs to change their rostering availability makes…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Isabella Lonigro v Krispy Kreme Australia Pty Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] FWC 3550
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue the court had to decide was whether Rostering Principle 2 of the Agreement required Krispy Kreme to take into consideration the availability of its employees when an employee made a request to change their rostered hours. The applicant argued that the principle mandated the employer to consider the employee's availability, while the respondent contended that while the request must be considered, approval of the change was subject to operational requirements. The court had to interpret the specific language of the principle to ascertain whether the consideration of an employee's request necessarily included a requirement for the employer to adjust the roster based on the employee's availability.
The FWC, in its reasoning, applied well-established principles of interpreting enterprise agreements, which include giving effect to the plain meaning of the language used in the agreement. The court noted that while the phrase "this request will be considered" implied that the request would be taken into account, it did not automatically mean that the request would be approved. The principle explicitly stated that any consideration was subject to operational requirements, indicating that operational needs took precedence in the decision-making process. Therefore, the FWC concluded that the respondent was required to consider the employee's request for roster changes, but the ultimate decision on whether to approve the change was contingent on operational requirements.
The decision of the FWC was that Rostering Principle 2 did indeed require Krispy Kreme to consider the availability of its employees when an employee made a request for a roster change. The Commission determined that the phrase "this request will be considered" meant that the request would be factored into any decision-making process, but the principle's stipulation that any approval was subject to operational requirements meant that the final decision lay with the employer, considering their operational needs. The court's interpretation aligned with the language of the agreement, giving due weight to the context and purpose of the principle.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi