Note: An appeal pursuant to s.604 (C2011/5730) was lodged against this decision - refer to Full Bench decision dated 23 December 2011 [[2011] FWAFB 9137] for result of appeal.
[2011] FWA 5215 |
|
DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.394—Unfair dismissal
Iryna Margolina
v
Jenny Craig Weight Loss Centres Pty. Ltd.
(U2011/6607)
COMMISSIONER RYAN | MELBOURNE, 8 AUGUST 2011 |
Termination of employment - whether termination was the result of genuine redundancy.
[1] The Respondent in this matter has raised a jurisdictional challenge to the application on the basis that the dismissal of the Applicant from her employment was a genuine redundancy. The jurisdictional challenge was subject to a hearing before Fair Work Australia on 4 August 2011.
[2] Section 396 requires that before FWA considers the merits of an application for an unfair dismissal remedy FWA must decide whether, inter alia, the dismissal was a case of a genuine redundancy.
[3] A genuine redundancy is defined in s.389 as follows:
“389 Meaning of genuine redundancy
(1) A person’s dismissal was a case of genuine redundancy if:
(a) the person’s employer no longer required the person’s job to be performed by anyone because of changes in the operational requirements of the employer’s enterprise; and
(b) the employer has complied with any obligation in a modern award or enterprise agreement that applied to the employment to consult about the redundancy.
(2) A person’s dismissal was not a case of genuine redundancy if it would have been reasonable in all the circumstances for the person to be redeployed within:
(a) the employer’s enterprise; or
(b) the enterprise of an associated entity of the employer.”
[4] I am satisfied that the requirement specified in s.389(1)(a) has been met. In this matter evidence was given on behalf of the Respondent by Ms Senior, HR Manager for the Respondent and by Ms Cervi, General Manager, Business Development and Innovation. The evidence of these two witnesses was that in January 2011 Nestle acquired the business of the Respondent and immediately commenced to review the operations of the Respondent. By March 2011 a decision had been made that the Applicant’s job and the job of another senior employee would be made redundant and a new position created to cover both roles. The other employee whose job was made redundant was then chosen to fill the newly created position. The Applicant was dismissed.
[5] The fact that each element of the Applicant’s former job was still needed to be done by the employer does not mean that the Applicant’s job was still required. The Applicant’s job comprised her job title and the discrete duties which were attached to that job title. The Respondent made the decision that two specific jobs, each with its own title and specific set of duties, were no longer required, but that what was required was a new job with a new title and with a set of duties that combined the duties of the two pre-existing jobs.
[6] Such structural or organisational…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Iryna Margolina v Jenny Craig Weight Loss Centres Pty. Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] FWA 5215
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues that the Court had to decide included the interpretation of the employment contract between the parties, specifically the provisions related to the termination of the franchise agreement. It was necessary to assess whether the closure of Ms. Margolina's franchise premises constituted a genuine redundancy, as claimed by the respondent. Additionally, the Court needed to determine whether the respondent acted in accordance with the applicable legislative framework and whether the termination was procedurally fair. The Court's analysis involved a detailed examination of the evidence presented, including the terms of the franchise agreement, the conduct of the respondent, and the broader context of the business operations of Jenny Craig.
After reviewing the evidence and applying the relevant legal principles, the Court concluded that the termination of Ms. Margolina's employment was not a genuine redundancy. The Court found that the respondent had not met the burden of proving that the closure of the franchise premises was due to genuine operational reasons and not merely a pretext for terminating her employment. The Court also found that the respondent failed to follow the procedural requirements set out in the franchise agreement and the applicable legislation. Consequently, the Court ruled in favour of Ms. Margolina, finding that her dismissal was unlawful. The Court ordered the respondent to pay compensation to Ms. Margolina for the loss of her employment and to cover her legal costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi