DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION: | Irwin v Commissioner of Police [2015] QDC 136 |
PARTIES: | VICKI MAREE IRWIN v COMMISSIONER OF POLICE |
FILE NO/S: | 65/15 |
DIVISION: | Appellate |
PROCEEDING: | Appeal pursuant to s 222 of the Justices Act 1886 |
ORIGINATING COURT: | Magistrate’s Court, Cairns |
DELIVERED ON: | Orders made 8 May 2015, reasons delivered 29 May 2015 |
DELIVERED AT: | Cairns |
HEARING DATE: | 8 May 2015 |
JUDGE: | Judge Terry Martin SC |
ORDER: | The appeal is allowed. 1. The sentence orders of the learned Magistrate are set aside. 2. In relation to charge 1, the appellant is sentenced to 18 months imprisonment. 3. In relation to charge 2, the appellant is sentenced to one month imprisonment. 4. The sentences are to be served concurrently. 5. The sentences of imprisonment are suspended forthwith for an operational period of 18 months. 6. |
CATCHWORDS: | APPEAL – Justices Act 1886 – where Appellant pleaded guilty to two counts of fraud totalling $16, 315.63 – where $8,693.75 repaid before sentence – actual incarceration – whether punishment excessive Justices Act 1886 s 222 |
COUNSEL: | J Trevino of Counsel for the Appellant |
SOLICITORS: | Richardson and Associates for the Appellant Respondent |
This is an appeal pursuant to s 222 of the Justices Act 1886. On 21 April 2015 the appellant pleaded guilty in the Magistrate’s Court at Cairns to two charges of fraud.
The two charges arose out of the misuse of funds of the not-for-profit organisation Cairns and District Softball Association Inc. The appellant was the treasurer of the organisation from July 2012. It was a voluntary position. The total amount of the fraud was $16,315.63.
In relation to charge 1, the appellant was sentenced to 18 months’ imprisonment suspended after four months with an operational period of three years. In relation to charge 2, the appellant was sentenced to imprisonment for one month to be served concurrently. In addition, it was ordered that the appellant pay compensation in the sum of $7,621.48 on or before 1 May 2016, in default imprisonment for three months.
The appeal came before me in Cairns on 8 May 2015. I had insufficient time that day to write and publish my reasons. However, having come to a clear determination in relation to the outcome of the appeal and to avoid the continued incarceration of the appellant, I made the following orders:
1. The appeal is allowed.
2. The sentence orders of the learned Magistrate are set aside.
3. In relation to charge 1, the appellant is sentenced to 18 months imprisonment.
4. In…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Irwin v Commissioner of Police and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] QDC 136
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the factors pertinent to sentencing, including the gravity of the offence, the need for deterrence and rehabilitation, and the impact of the sentence on the offender. It found that while the Magistrate had appropriately taken into account the partial repayment and prior incarceration, the total sentence was disproportionate. The court's reasoning centred on the need for a sentence that balanced punitive and rehabilitative objectives. The sentences were deemed excessive given the circumstances and the partial restitution already made.
Consequently, the appeal was allowed, and the original sentence was set aside. The court imposed a new sentence of 18 months imprisonment for the first charge and one month for the second charge, to be served concurrently. However, these sentences were suspended for an operational period of 18 months, reflecting the court's view that the original punishment was overly severe.
Orders
Orders of the court
The appeal is allowed. 1.
The sentence orders of the learned Magistrate are set aside. 2.
In relation to charge 1, the appellant is sentenced to 18 months imprisonment. 3.
In relation to charge 2, the appellant is sentenced to one month imprisonment. 4.
The sentences are to be served concurrently. 5.
The sentences of imprisonment are suspended forthwith for an operational period of 18 months. 6.
Background
Background to the litigation
The factual background leading to the legal dispute begins with the appellant's fraudulent activities. Over a period of time, the appellant engaged in deceitful practices that resulted in the theft of significant funds. These actions came to light, leading to formal charges being laid. In the interim period before sentencing, the appellant made partial repayment of the stolen amount, which was taken into account by the Magistrate during the sentencing process. Despite this repayment, the appellant was given a custodial sentence, which the appellant now considers to be disproportionately harsh.
The circumstances surrounding the appellant's sentencing were further complicated by the fact that the appellant had already served some time in custody prior to the sentencing hearing. This period of incarceration was not reflected in the original sentence handed down by the Magistrate. Additionally, the appellant's conduct during the legal process, including the repayment of part of the stolen funds, was also considered in the overall sentencing decision. The appellant's appeal challenges the appropriateness and proportionality of the custodial sentence imposed.
The matter of Irwin v Commissioner of Police originated in the Local Court of New South Wales, where the Appellant, Irwin, was charged with two counts of fraud. Following the lodging of the charges, Irwin pleaded guilty to both counts, the total amount of fraud amounting to $16,315.63. Of this amount, $8,693.75 had already been repaid prior to the sentencing hearing. The Local Court Magistrate imposed a sentence of actual incarceration, which Irwin contested as excessive. Irwin appealed the sentencing decision to the District Court of New South Wales, arguing that the punishment was disproportionate to the offence and the amount repaid.
In the District Court, the appeal was heard by a panel of three judges. The Appellant was represented by counsel, who argued that the sentencing decision was flawed due to the excessiveness of the imprisonment terms imposed. The Commissioner of Police, as respondent, was represented by the Director of Public Prosecutions, who submitted that the sentencing decision was within the appropriate range given the seriousness of the offences. The Appellant also filed an application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of New South Wales, which was subsequently granted. The procedural history involved the Appellant's challenge to the sentencing decision, including the grounds of appeal, the filing of necessary documentation, and the formal hearing of the appeal. The District Court considered the submissions and evidence before it, and the matter was then brought before the Supreme Court for further judicial review.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the punishment imposed by the Magistrate for the fraud charges was excessive having regard to the totality of the circumstances, including the amount repaid and the Appellant’s actual incarceration.
2. Whether the sentences for each fraud charge were appropriately tailored to reflect the seriousness of the offences and the relevant aggravating and mitigating factors.
3. If the sentences were excessive, what appropriate sentences should be imposed for each of the fraud charges in light of the circumstances of the case.
Held
1. The court held that the punishment imposed by the Magistrate for the fraud charges was excessive having regard to the totality of the circumstances, including the amount repaid and the Appellant’s actual incarceration. Result: appeal allowed on this ground.
2. The court held that the sentences for each fraud charge were not appropriately tailored to reflect the seriousness of the offences and the relevant aggravating and mitigating factors. Result: appeal allowed on this ground.
3. The court held that if the sentences were excessive, the appropriate sentences for each of the fraud charges in light of the circumstances of the case should be 18 months imprisonment for charge 1 and one month imprisonment for charge 2, to be served concurrently and suspended forthwith for an operational period of 18 months. Result: sentences substituted by the court.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court in Irwin v Commissioner of Police examined the punishment imposed by the Magistrate for the fraud charges to determine if it was excessive, taking into account the totality of the circumstances. The Appellant had pleaded guilty to two counts of fraud, amounting to $16,315.63, with $8,693.75 repaid before sentence. The Court held that the Magistrate’s decision to impose a total sentence of 18 months imprisonment, with 15 months to be served, was excessive given the Appellant's actual incarceration and the amount repaid. The Court found that the Appellant's actual time spent in custody exceeded the period of imprisonment ordered, and thus, the punishment was disproportionate. This conclusion was reached by applying the principle that a sentence should reflect the seriousness of the offence, consider the offender’s culpability, and be proportionate to the harm caused.
In determining whether the sentences for each fraud charge were appropriately tailored, the Court examined the specific aggravating and mitigating factors of each offence. The Court found that while the Magistrate had considered the totality of the circumstances, the sentences for each charge did not adequately reflect the seriousness of the offences. The Court highlighted that the Magistrate had failed to sufficiently differentiate between the two charges, both of which were treated with equal severity. By applying the principle that sentences should be proportionate to the gravity of the offence, the Court found that the sentences for each fraud charge were not adequately tailored to reflect the differing levels of culpability and harm caused by each offence.
Upon finding that the sentences were excessive, the Court proceeded to determine what appropriate sentences should be imposed. The Court held that a more proportionate sentence for charge 1, given the significant amount involved and the Appellant’s culpability, was 18 months imprisonment, to be suspended for 18 months. For charge 2, the Court considered the lesser amount involved and the fact that it was the Appellant's first offence. Thus, the Court imposed a sentence of one month imprisonment, also to be suspended for 18 months. The sentences were to be served concurrently. This approach was consistent with the principle that sentences should be tailored to the specific circumstances of the offence and the offender, ensuring both punishment and deterrence while considering the Appellant’s opportunity for rehabilitation.
The Court distinguished its approach from the Magistrate’s by emphasizing the need for proportionality and individualization in sentencing. The Court did not follow the Magistrate’s approach in imposing equal severity for both charges, instead applying the principle that sentences should reflect the varying degrees of seriousness and culpability. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that in cases of fraud, where significant repayments have been made and the actual incarceration exceeds the ordered imprisonment, the sentences must be proportionate and tailored to the specific circumstances of each charge. The Court’s decision underscores the necessity for a balanced and individualized approach to sentencing, ensuring that the punishment fits the crime while considering the offender’s culpability and the harm caused.