Irene Burnett and Tax Practitioners Board

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

[2014] AATA 87

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number

2014/0136

Re

Irene Burnett

APPLICANT

And

Tax Practitioners Board

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President K Bean

Date 24 February 2014
Place Adelaide

The Tribunal declines to make the orders sought under s 35 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975.

..............[ Sgd ]……..........

Deputy President K Bean

CATCHWORDS

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Tax agents – Application to stay refusal to renew registration as a tax agent – Public interest considerations – Severe adverse consequences to applicant if stay refused – Where substantive application may be rendered nugatory – Stay granted.

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - Application for confidentiality orders - Whether cogent reasons to depart from norm - Damage to applicant's reputation - Declined to make confidentiality orders sought.

LEGISLATION

Tax Agent Services Act 2009, s 20-50, subs 30-10(1), (4), (7), (9) and (10), subs 60-125(2) and (8)(c)(iia)

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, ss 35 and 41

CASES

Re Dekanic and Tax Agents’ Board of New South Wales (1982) 6 ALD 240

Re Scott and Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2009) 51 AAR 114
Re Nelson and Tax Agents’ Board of Queensland (1993) 30 ALD 317
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Administrative Appeals Tribunal (2009) 181 FCR 130
Re Opus Capital Ltd and Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2010) 117 ALD 608
Re Kanina Banner Pty Ltd and Minister for Health and Ageing (2002) 66 ALD 663
Re TNST and Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2009) 50 AAR 176
Re Pochi and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 2 ALD 33
Re Modini and Tax Agent’s Board of Queensland (2005) 89 ALD 496

Re Gillespie and Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2012) 60 AAR 1

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President K Bean

24 February 2014

INTRODUCTION

  1. The applicant, Mrs Burnett, is a chartered accountant and has been a registered tax agent since 1980.  However on 11 December 2013, the Tax Practitioners Board (the Board) decided not to grant her most recent application for renewal of her tax agent registration. 

  2. The reason for that decision was that the Board was not satisfied that Mrs Burnett met the statutory requirements for renewal of her registration. In particular, the Board was not satisfied that she was a ‘fit and proper’ person to be registered as a tax agent, as required by s 20-5 of the Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (the TASA).  The Board accordingly also determined that Mrs Burnett’s registration as a tax agent would cease on 6 February 2014.

  3. Mrs Burnett was apparently advised of this decision approximately a month after it was made, by letter dated 8 January 2014. On 13 January 2014, she filed an application for review of that decision by this Tribunal, and an application for a stay of the decision, pursuant to s 41 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (AAT Act).  A hearing was held in relation to Mrs Burnett’s stay application on 28 January 2014, and at a Directions Hearing…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Irene Burnett and Tax Practitioners Board and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 87
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Irene Burnett applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal to stay the decision of the Tax Practitioners Board to refuse to renew her registration as a tax agent. The Board opposed the application. The Tribunal heard two interlocutory applications, one for a stay of the Board's decision, and the other for confidentiality orders. The applicant contended that the Board's decision would have severe adverse consequences for her and her family, including the loss of her home and business. The Board opposed the application for a stay on the basis that there was a risk of recurrence of the alleged misconduct. The Tribunal considered the public interest in avoiding or minimising the risk of recurrence, but ultimately concluded that the severe adverse consequences to the applicant outweighed the public interest. The Tribunal declined to make the confidentiality orders sought, as there were no cogent reasons to depart from the norm of not making such orders. The Tribunal granted the stay of the Board's decision pending the determination of the substantive application. The Tribunal imposed conditions on the stay, including that the applicant does not provide tax agent services to any new clients and provides the Board with the names and contact details of all her clients.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal declines to make the orders sought under s 35 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975.

Background

Background to the litigation

Before addressing the issues which arise from the two interlocutory applications more directly however, I will first outline the factual background to the matter. I should also add that although further material has been filed subsequently, my reasons for granting the stay order of course make reference only to the material which was before me when I made that order.BACKGROUND From the material before me, it appears that in October 2009, officers of the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) visited Mrs Burnett’s practice in order to undertake a review of her files. As a result of that review, the ATO subsequently directed Mrs Burnett to either provide additional information or make voluntary amendments to two income tax returns (ITRs). However she apparently declined to do so and the two ITRs were referred to audit, resulting in adjustments totalling $80,151.00. A further review of Mrs Burnett’s practice was carried out by the ATO in March 2011, and audits conducted by the ATO subsequent to that review apparently found that seven ITRs were not “reasonably substantiated”. As a result of the audits, adjustments were made to those seven ITRs, totalling $119,408.00. Penalties were also imposed in one audit as it was considered that the shortfall was a result of “reckless behaviour” and “the errors in the ITRs were considered to be attributable primarily to ‘tax agent error’”. On 2 December 2011, the ATO apparently provided the Board with a referral relating to Mrs Burnett, based largely on the above information. On a date which was not apparent from the material before me at the time I made the stay order, but appeared to have been some time after April 2011, the Board apparently also received a complaint from a person alleging that she had accessed the records of his clients through the “Tax Agent Portal” without authorisation on three occasions between 29 June 2010 and 4 April 2011. A further audit of Mrs Burnett’s files was apparently carried out by the ATO in the first half of 2013, relating to 20 clients. Following audit of these files, adjustments were made to the ITRs of all 20 clients (and one further return for the year ended 30 June 2011) totalling $391,466.00. Sixty-two penalties were apparently imposed, with 55 imposed for lack of reasonable care, four imposed for recklessness and three imposed for “intentional disregard”. Apparently the ATO considered the errors found were primarily attributable to “tax agent error”. The results of this further audit apparently constituted the main basis for a further referral by the ATO to the Board in relation to Mrs Burnett on or about 23 July 2013. Following receipt of the second ATO referral, the Board apparently wrote to Mrs Burnett, on 1 October 2013, notifying her that it had decided to formally investigate whether her conduct may have breached the TASA. As a result of the ensuing investigation, on 11 December 2013, the Board ultimately determined that it was satisfied that Mrs Burnett had failed to comply with subs 30-10 (1), (4), (7), (9) and (10) of the Code of Professional Conduct (the Code) in the TASA.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Having regard to the information I had about Mrs Burnett’s responses to the allegations and findings against her, I was satisfied that her substantive application was not unmeritorious. I also noted that the Board did not rely upon absence of merit in her application as a factor weighing against the grant of a stay in her case.Overall assessment and conclusion In summary therefore, I was satisfied that, having weighed the competing public interests discussed above, overall the public interest militated against the grant of a stay. However, in my view, that public interest was outweighed by the severe adverse consequences which would have flowed to Mrs Burnett were a stay not to have been granted, and which would, to a large degree, have rendered her substantive application to the Tribunal nugatory. Whilst there is clearly some risk entailed in Mrs Burnett continuing to practise pending the hearing and determination of her substantive application to the Tribunal, I concluded that it would be highly undesirable for Mrs Burnett to suffer many of the consequences of losing her registration, including potentially losing her home and business, before this Tribunal had had an opportunity to fully consider the merits of her application and make a decision in relation to it. In practical terms, that outcome would largely have deprived Mrs Burnett of the opportunity to seek effective review of the Board’s decision by this Tribunal. If Mrs Burnett’s substantive application had been devoid of merit, that would have been another factor weighing heavily against the grant of a stay. However, I was satisfied that Mrs Burnett’s application had some merit, and the Board did not contend otherwise. I was also satisfied that this matter could not practically be dealt with in an expedited manner, in a way which obviated the need for a stay. That was partly because, if Mrs Burnett’s registration had ceased on 6 February 2014, she would have been obliged to cease acting for her clients and advise them of the reasons for this, resulting in significant reputational damage and damage to her business. I inferred from her evidence that she would also have been effectively forced to attempt to sell her business quickly, whilst it still had some value. For these reasons, I decided that it was appropriate for me to grant a stay of the Board’s decision, pending determination of Mrs Burnett’s substantive application by this Tribunal. In the event I decided to grant a stay, the Board requested that I impose the following conditions:a)the Applicant does not provide tax agent services to any new clients, that is, persons she had not provided such services to prior to 11 December 2013; andb)within 14 days of the date of the order,(i)the Applicant provides the Respondent with the names and contact details of all such clients; and(ii)the Applicant files and serves evidence in the form of a statutory declaration that she has notified each client to whom she has provided tax agent services since 1 June 2011 of the decision under review (including giving each such client a copy of the Board correspondence dated 8 January 2014 setting out the reasons for decision);[8][8] Respondent’s Further Submissions, [7].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

By reference to the decision of the Tribunal in Re Dekanic and Tax Agents’ Board of New South Wales[4], Mr d’Assumpcao, who appeared as counsel for the Board at the stay hearing, conceded that, having regard to the applicable principles, a stay of a decision to cancel a tax agent’s registration would ordinarily be granted unless the public interest requires otherwise. He also conceded that that proposition was equally applicable to a decision not to renew a tax agent’s registration. However, Mr d’Assumpcao contended that there was a strong public interest in refusing the stay in this matter, and indicated that, primarily for that reason, the Board opposed the granting of a stay.[4] (1982) 6 ALD 240, 242 per Davies J.Consideration As it constituted the main reason for the Board’s opposition to the grant of a stay, I propose to deal first with the question of the public interest, before turning to the other considerations relevant to whether a stay should be granted.The public interest As I understood the position, the Board opposed a stay primarily upon the basis that there was a material risk of the type of conduct identified by the Board in its decision being repeated in the period pending the determination of the application for review. In oral submissions, Mr d’Assumpcao also submitted that, as the files chosen for audit were chosen randomly, it could be inferred that problems of the kind identified in the files which were audited were likely to be present in many of Mrs Burnett’s other files. In essence, the Board submitted that the evidence supported the existence of a material risk that a proportion of the returns and other documents prepared by Mrs Burnett would not be prepared to the requisite standard, would not be accurate, and may expose her clients to adjustments, penalties and/or interest charges. The Board relied upon the fact that adjustments were made to all of the 20 files audited in 2013, totalling $391,466.00, although no information was provided to me as to the attribution of the adjustments as between the files, or the average adjustments per ITR. The Board also pointed to what it had found to be Mrs Burnett’s unauthorised use of the Tax Agent Portal, together with her response to this allegation. However, I inferred that this was something of which the Board had been aware since before 21 June 2013, when it wrote to Mrs Burnett about the allegation, and which did not result in any earlier action by the Board with respect to Mrs Burnett. In these circumstances, in my view that matter did not lend significant support to the Board’s contention that the public interest required refusal of the stay order. As to the risk that problems of the kind uncovered by the 2013 audit would recur if a stay were granted, I ultimately accepted Mr d’Assumpcao’s submission that it could reasonably be inferred that there were likely to be similar problems in files not caught by the ATO’s audit, particularly given that problems appear to have been found with all 20 of the files randomly audited in 2013. I further accepted that, so long as Mrs Burnett continued to practice, there was a risk of further instances of the kind revealed by the 2013 audit, potentially resulting in inaccurate returns, and further adjustments and penalties. The precise extent of the claimed irregularities and the extent to which Mrs Burnett was responsible for these is contested by Mrs Burnett and has not yet been determined by this Tribunal. However I accepted for the purposes of the stay application that the granting of a stay carried a real risk of further irregularities of the kind apparently revealed by the 2013 audit, and there was a public interest in avoiding or minimising that risk.