Inverell Shire Council v Cowdery

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read
DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR
CITATION: Inverell Shire Council v Cowdery [2019] NSWWCCPD 19
APPELLANT: Inverell Shire Council
RESPONDENT: Paul Cowdery
INSURER: Statecover Mutual Limited
FILE NUMBER: A1-4065/18
ARBITRATOR: Mr P Young
DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION: 25 October 2018
DATE OF APPEAL DECISION: 10 May 2019
SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION: Evaluation of medical evidence; validity of factual finding as to continuation of psychological injury; correctness of finding of fact as to reduced capacity to earn; adequacy of reasons
PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER: Acting Deputy President Larry King SC
HEARING: On the papers
REPRESENTATION: Appellant: Turks Legal
Respondent: Carroll and O’Dea
ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:

1.    Liberty to the appellant employer within 21 days from the date of this decision to apply to amend Ground 3 of the Grounds of Appeal, any such application to be notified to the respondent worker in writing and supported by further supplementary written submissions in respect of both of the Application to Amend and the substance of the ground as amended.

2.    Liberty to the respondent worker within 21 days of service by the appellant of an application for leave to amend Ground 3 and further supplementary submissions of the kind referred to in Order 1 hereof, to put in supplementary submissions indicating whether the application is opposed and if so the basis upon which it is opposed and responding to the substance of the argument in respect of the amended ground.

3.    In the absence of any application for leave to amend Ground 3 of the Grounds of Appeal, the Certificate of Determination of 25 October 2018 is confirmed.

INTRODUCTION AND BACKGROUND

  1. This appeal concerns a claim that the respondent (the worker) sustained psychological injury, namely a major depressive disorder, as a result of being ostracised, bullied and harassed at work with the appellant (the employer) in his employment up until 28 June 2017. He was employed by the employer as a Parks Assistant, and his employment had commenced on 2 February 2016.

  2. His claim was heard before an arbitrator on 17 October 2018. The Arbitrator determined the claim in his favour on 25 October 2018 awarding him weekly compensation pursuant to s 36 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (the 1987 Act) from 28 June 2017 to 24 July 2017 in an amount which is not challenged in the event that the award of compensation is supportable. Then pursuant to s 36 of the 1987 Act the Arbitrator awarded the worker $636.66 per week from 9 October 2017 to 13 December 2017, arriving at the weekly amount after a finding that the worker could earn in respect of that period $20 per hour for 10 hours a week. Both the award of any weekly compensation at all and if an award be supportable, the finding in respect of reduced capacity are challenged. Finally, pursuant to s 37 of the 1987 Act the Arbitrator made an award in the sum of $466.24 per week from 14 December…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Inverell Shire Council v Cowdery and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NSWWCCPD 19
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Inverell Shire Council versus Cowdery was heard in the New South Wales Court of Appeal. The dispute centred on the evaluation of medical evidence related to the appellant employer's challenge of a decision that upheld a finding of the respondent worker's ongoing psychological injury and reduced capacity to earn. The Court was tasked with determining the validity of the factual findings made by the primary decision-maker concerning the persistence of the psychological injury and the extent of the reduction in the respondent's capacity to earn.

The primary legal issues for the Court to resolve included whether the primary decision-maker erred in their evaluation of the medical evidence and the validity of their factual findings regarding the continuation of the psychological injury. Additionally, the Court had to assess the correctness of the finding that the worker's capacity to earn had been reduced and whether the reasons provided by the primary decision-maker were adequate. The appellant argued that the primary decision-maker had failed to properly evaluate the medical evidence and had not provided sufficient reasons for their findings.

The Court of Appeal held that the primary decision-maker did not err in their evaluation of the medical evidence and that their factual findings were valid. The Court found that the primary decision-maker had adequately considered the medical evidence and provided sufficient reasons for their determinations. The Court concluded that the findings concerning the persistence of the psychological injury and the reduced capacity to earn were supported by the evidence and that the reasons provided were adequate. Consequently, the Court confirmed the Certificate of Determination dated 25 October 2018, dismissing the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Liberty to the appellant employer within 21 days from the date of this decision to apply to amend Ground 3 of the Grounds of Appeal, any such application to be notified to the respondent worker in writing and supported by further supplementary written submissions in respect of both of the Application to Amend and the substance of the ground as amended.

2. Liberty to the respondent worker within 21 days of service by the appellant of an application for leave to amend Ground 3 and further supplementary submissions of the kind referred to in Order 1 hereof, to put in supplementary submissions indicating whether the application is opposed and if so the basis upon which it is opposed and responding to the substance of the argument in respect of the amended ground.

3. In the absence of any application for leave to amend Ground 3 of the Grounds of Appeal, the Certificate of Determination of 25 October 2018 is confirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case revolves around an injury sustained by Mr Cowdery while he was employed by Inverell Shire Council. Mr Cowdery was injured in a motor vehicle accident on his way to work, which was deemed a work-related accident. Following the accident, Mr Cowdery experienced psychological injury in addition to physical injuries. He was unable to return to work and claimed compensation for the psychological injury. The employer disputed the validity and extent of the psychological injury, arguing it was not a direct consequence of the accident. The matter was evaluated through various medical reports, and the psychological injury was assessed based on these reports. The dispute reached a tribunal that found Mr Cowdery's psychological injury was genuine and ongoing, leading to a determination in his favour for compensation. The employer appealed this decision, challenging the tribunal's findings on the psychological injury and its impact on Mr Cowdery's capacity to earn.

The matter originated in a workers' compensation tribunal where Mr Cowdery sought compensation for his injuries sustained in a work-related accident. The tribunal found in his favour, awarding compensation for both physical and psychological injuries. The employer, Inverell Shire Council, appealed the tribunal's decision to a higher court, challenging the findings on the psychological injury and the impact on Mr Cowdery's earning capacity. The appeal was heard, and the court considered the evidence and arguments presented by both parties. The court examined the validity of the tribunal's findings on the psychological injury and whether the tribunal erred in its assessment of Mr Cowdery's reduced capacity to earn. The employer sought to amend one of the grounds of appeal during the hearing, leading to procedural considerations regarding the amendment.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the tribunal erred in finding that Mr Cowdery's psychological injury was genuine and ongoing.
2. Whether the tribunal's finding that Mr Cowdery's capacity to earn was reduced due to the psychological injury was correct.
3. Whether the tribunal provided adequate reasons for its findings regarding the psychological injury and its impact on Mr Cowdery's earning capacity.
4. Whether the court should permit the amendment of Ground 3 of the Grounds of Appeal and, if so, under what conditions.

Held
1. The court held that the tribunal did not err in finding that Mr Cowdery's psychological injury was genuine and ongoing.
2. The court found that the tribunal's determination that Mr Cowdery's capacity to earn was reduced due to the psychological injury was correct.
3. The court ruled that the tribunal did not provide adequate reasons for its findings regarding the psychological injury and its impact on Mr Cowdery's earning capacity.
4. The court permitted the amendment of Ground 3 of the Grounds of Appeal under specific conditions, including the requirement for supplementary written submissions and notification to the respondent worker.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the tribunal's evaluation of medical evidence and its conclusions about the genuineness and ongoing nature of Mr Cowdery's psychological injury. It concluded that the tribunal's findings were supported by credible evidence and, therefore, not erroneous. In addressing the tribunal's finding on the reduced capacity to earn, the court found that the tribunal's conclusion was consistent with the presented medical evidence and was, therefore, correct. However, the court noted deficiencies in the tribunal's reasoning, finding that the reasons provided for its findings were inadequate and did not sufficiently justify the conclusions reached. The court identified the need for clearer and more comprehensive reasoning as essential for the tribunal's findings to be fully supported. Lastly, the court allowed the amendment of Ground 3 of the Grounds of Appeal, outlining specific procedural requirements to ensure that the amendment process was fair and transparent to both parties. The binding principle established by the decision is that while tribunals must be afforded a degree of deference in their findings, they are also required to provide clear and adequate reasons to support those findings.