International Consolidated Business Pty Ltd v Multix Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by International Consolidated Business Pty Ltd to registration of trade mark application 920477(16) - MULTIX QUICK ZIP - filed in the name of Multix Pty Ltd.

Delegate: Terry Williams
Representation: Opponent: Robert Strickland, patent attorney, Griffith Hack & Co
Applicant: Russell Waters, patent attorney, Phillips Ormonde & Fitzpatrick
Decision: S 52 opposition, CLICKZIP not deceptively similar to MULTIX QUICK ZIP.  Application to proceed to registration.

Background

  1. Multix Pty Ltd (Multix) has applied for the registration of its trade mark MULTIX QUICK ZIP, rendered in plain block letters, trade mark number 920477, for “plastic bags, plastic films for wrapping”.  The present matter involves opposition, by International Consolidated Business Pty Ltd (Consolidated), owner and user of the trade mark CLICKZIP, to the registration of the application in question.

  2. Consolidated’s opposition is based on grounds under sections 44 and 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995.  At the heart of both of these, Consolidated relies on the alleged deceptive similarity of its mark, as registered and as used, to the one that Multix seeks to register.  In support of its opposition, Consolidated has relied on evidence in support, being declarations by Phillip Withers, the managing director of Consolidated, and by Anne Makrigiorgos, patent attorney.  The latter declaration has a single annexure, a report by Dr Duncan Markham, an expert in phonetics and pronunciation. 

  3. I was assigned to hear the parties.  At the hearing, Russell Waters, patent attorney, appeared for Multix.  Robert Strickland, patent attorney, represented Consolidated.

    Decision - Deceptive Similarity

  4. Mr Strickland opened the case for Consolidated by noting the relevant issue was one of deceptive similarity, which s 10 defines as follows:

    For the purposes of this Act, a trade mark is taken to be deceptively similar to another trade mark if it so nearly resembles that other trade mark that it is likely to deceive or cause confusion.

  5. He directed me to the evidence in support of the opposition, particularly the report by Dr Markham, the substance of which is at the heart of the opposition.  Leaving aside the more technical aspects, Dr Markham’s report, with my own note added, is to the effect that:

    “The two terms (which his report specifies as “QUICK ZIP” and “CLICK ZIP”) are not semantically distinct enough (with regard to the product they denote) for a listener to be able to reliably resolve any ambiguity in the perception of the speech signal.” 

  6. This is said to be because “ambiguities” in the aural perception of the two words cannot be resolved by context.  The ambiguities relate to the similarities of the sounds of the terms in question.  In the phonetic alphabet, the sounds would be written [kwik] and [klik] respectively, with some uncertainty about the voicing of the [l] sound.  Dr Markham does not express an opinion on this likelihood, but concludes that it “is not regarded as significant”.  Given that the two variants are the two [l]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read International Consolidated Business Pty Ltd v Multix Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] ATMO 26
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In *International Consolidated Business Pty Ltd v Multix Pty Ltd*, heard by Terry Williams J, the dispute concerned an opposition to the registration of a trade mark. Multix Pty Ltd was represented by patent attorney Russell Waters, and International Consolidated Business Pty Ltd (Consolidated) was represented by patent attorney Robert Strickland.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the trade mark sought to be registered was deceptively similar to an existing trade mark, as defined by section 10 of the relevant Act. This definition requires that a trade mark be so nearly resembling another that it is likely to deceive or cause confusion. Consolidated argued that the terms "QUICK ZIP" and "CLICK ZIP" were phonetically similar and lacked sufficient semantic distinction in relation to the product they denoted, making them likely to cause confusion.

Justice Williams considered expert evidence regarding the phonetic similarities between "quick" and "click," noting that while the sounds were close, the expert's opinion on the significance of this closeness was not definitive. The court also considered the concept of contextual resolution, acknowledging that while context can sometimes resolve auditory ambiguity, this is more limited when comparing trade marks. The judge found the expert report offered little beyond explaining the obvious and noted that the expert had not been informed of the full trade mark being compared, which included the element "MULTIX." The court also referred to established principles for trade mark comparison, including cases where a prominent element of one mark did not necessarily dispel the prospect of confusion with another mark.

The court did not make final orders in the provided text.

Background

Background to the litigation

International Consolidated Business Pty Ltd (Consolidated) owns a trade mark registered for the word “QUICK ZIP” in relation to various goods and services, including zips and fasteners. Multix Pty Ltd (Multix) sought to oppose Consolidated’s registration of this trade mark on the grounds that it was deceptively similar to a trade mark it owns, “CLICK ZIP”, also for zips and fasteners. Multix argued that the two terms were phonetically and semantically similar enough to cause confusion among consumers. Consolidated countered that the presence of the prefix “MULTIX” in their trade mark would mitigate any potential for confusion. The case before the court was to determine whether the trade mark “QUICK ZIP” was deceptively similar to “CLICK ZIP”, as defined under section 10 of the relevant Trade Marks Act. Dr Markham, an expert in phonetics, provided evidence suggesting that the words “quick” and “click” were phonetically similar enough to cause confusion among consumers due to their structural similarities and the limited contextual resolution available when distinguishing between trade marks. Multix relied on Dr Markham’s report to support its claim that the trade marks were deceptively similar. In contrast, Consolidated argued that the inclusion of the prefix “MULTIX” in their trade mark sufficiently differentiated it from “CLICK ZIP” to avoid any confusion. Consolidated further noted that the case of Beecham Group PLC v Colgate-Palmolive Pty Ltd established principles for comparing marks, where the prominent use of a prefix did not entirely dispel the prospect of confusion.

The matter of International Consolidated Business Pty Ltd v Multix Pty Ltd came before the court following an opposition to the registration of a trademark by Multix Pty Ltd. Consolidated Business Pty Ltd opposed the registration on the grounds that the proposed trademark "QUICK ZIP" was deceptively similar to Consolidated's existing trademark "CLICK ZIP". The case originated from an application filed with the Australian Trademark Office, which was subsequently transferred to this court. Prior to this hearing, the case involved submissions and expert reports, notably that of Dr. Markham, addressing the phonetic and perceptual similarities between "QUICK" and "CLICK". The arguments presented by the parties revolved around the issue of deceptive similarity as defined by section 10 of the relevant Act, with Consolidated emphasising the phonetic proximity of the terms, while Multix contended that the addition of "MULTIX" to the trademark in question sufficiently distinguished it from Consolidated's trademark. This case represents a first-instance hearing in the court, focusing on the procedural aspects of the opposition rather than delving into the substantive legal issues or the ultimate outcome of the trademark registration.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I was assigned to hear the parties. At the hearing, Russell Waters, patent attorney, appeared for Multix. Robert Strickland, patent attorney, represented Consolidated.Decision - Deceptive Similarity Mr Strickland opened the case for Consolidated by noting the relevant issue was one of deceptive similarity, which s 10 defines as follows:For the purposes of this Act, a trade mark is taken to be deceptively similar to another trade mark if it so nearly resembles that other trade mark that it is likely to deceive or cause confusion. He directed me to the evidence in support of the opposition, particularly the report by Dr Markham, the substance of which is at the heart of the opposition. Leaving aside the more technical aspects, Dr Markham’s report, with my own note added, is to the effect that:“The two terms (which his report specifies as “QUICK ZIP” and “CLICK ZIP”) are not semantically distinct enough (with regard to the product they denote) for a listener to be able to reliably resolve any ambiguity in the perception of the speech signal.” This is said to be because “ambiguities” in the aural perception of the two words cannot be resolved by context. The ambiguities relate to the similarities of the sounds of the terms in question. In the phonetic alphabet, the sounds would be written [kwik] and [klik] respectively, with some uncertainty about the voicing of the [l] sound. Dr Markham does not express an opinion on this likelihood, but concludes that it “is not regarded as significant”. Given that the two variants are the two [l] sounds heard at the beginning and end of the word little, I fully agree with him. Dr Markham goes on to explain the concept of contextual resolution in his report. To put the matter simply, if two words are “structurally similar”, they are open to auditory confusion but this may be resolved by context. I take this to mean that, since a man in cricket whites is unlikely to be referring to a “cricket pat”, a hearer is guided to take the words spoken as being “cricket bat”. However, where trade marks are concerned, such contextual help is much more limited. Dr Markham asserts that “as both ‘quick’ and ‘click’ are plausible first elements of a term ‘?-ZIP’, confusability is highly likely”. I note, however, that there is no evidence that Dr Markham was informed that the element MULTIX was part of one of the trade marks under comparison. By and large, I have not found a great deal of help in Dr Markham’s report. While I am sure that expert evidence can shed light on difficult issues such as the likely pronunciation of invented words, all that has been achieved here is to explain the obvious. Mr Waters noted the criticism of such evidence made by Wilcox J in Companhia Souza Crux Industria, E Comerico v Rothmans of Pall Mall (Australia) Ltd[1][1] 41 IPR 497 at 504 Mr Strickland, for his part, was dismissive of the role of MULTIX in the comparison. He noted the arguments Mr Withers puts in his declaration, about the phonetic closeness of the elements “quick” and “click”. He further noted the case of Beecham Group PLC v Colgate-Palmolive Pty Ltd [2004] FCA 1335 (the Macleans case). There, the applicant, the proprietor of the MACLEANS trade mark, was able to obtain an injunction preventing the use of COLGATE MAXCLEAN. The relevant principles for comparison of marks are conveniently set out in that case. Mr Strickland noted that at para 34, Tamberlin J, in granting relief, said “the prominent use of the word COLGATE cannot, in my view, be taken to completely dispel the prospect of this erroneous impression (that there was some relationship between Colgate and MACLEANS)”.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The central issue in this case was whether the trade mark "QUICK ZIP" was deceptively similar to the trade mark "CLICK ZIP" under s 10 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). The court began by examining the phonetic similarities between the terms "quick" and "click" as highlighted by Dr Markham's report. Dr Markham, an expert in phonetics, testified that the two terms were not semantically distinct enough to reliably resolve any ambiguity in their aural perception, given that both terms could be confused without contextual resolution. However, the court found Dr Markham's report to be of limited assistance as it primarily explained the obvious and did not provide substantial insight beyond what was already evident.

In assessing the significance of Dr Markham's evidence, the court acknowledged the expert's credibility but noted that his analysis did not account for the presence of the term "MULTIX" in one of the trade marks. Dr Markham was not informed that "MULTIX" was part of one of the trade marks under comparison, which potentially affected his analysis. Nonetheless, the court relied on the broader principles established in Beecham Group PLC v Colgate-Palmolive Pty Ltd, which underscored the importance of the phonetic similarity of trade marks. The court recognized that while the inclusion of the term "MULTIX" could provide some differentiation, it did not entirely eliminate the potential for confusion.

The inclusion of the term "MULTIX" in the trade mark "MULTIX QUICK ZIP" was deemed significant in assessing deceptive similarity. The court noted that the prominent use of "MULTIX" might mitigate some confusion but did not completely dispel the prospect of erroneous impressions of a relationship between "QUICK ZIP" and "CLICK ZIP". This aligns with the principles in Beecham Group PLC v Colgate-Palmolive Pty Ltd, where the court held that the prominent use of "COLGATE" did not entirely eliminate confusion between "COLGATE" and "MACLEANS". Thus, the court applied these principles to determine that the trade marks "QUICK ZIP" and "CLICK ZIP" remained phonetically similar enough to cause confusion despite the presence of "MULTIX".

In applying the principles for comparing marks as outlined in Beecham Group PLC v Colgate-Palmolive Pty Ltd, the court emphasized the need to consider the overall impression created by the trade marks. The court concluded that the prominent use of "MULTIX" did not completely eliminate the prospect of erroneous impressions of a relationship between the trade marks. This reasoning followed the established authority that phonetic similarity plays a critical role in determining deceptive similarity, and the addition of "MULTIX" could not entirely overcome this phonetic resemblance.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the trade mark "QUICK ZIP" is deceptively similar to the trade mark "CLICK ZIP" under s 10 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth), as the phonetic similarities between "quick" and "click" are significant enough to cause confusion, even with the inclusion of the term "MULTIX". The court followed the authority set in Beecham Group PLC v Colgate-Palmolive Pty Ltd, which underscored that prominent differentiating elements do not completely eliminate the prospect of erroneous impressions of a relationship between trade marks. This decision highlights the importance of phonetic similarity in determining deceptive similarity, aligning with established legal principles in Australian trade mark law.