Integrated Securities No 3 Pty Ltd v Oceans 5 Ultimate Getaways Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Integrated Securities No 3 Pty Ltd v Oceans 5 Ultimate Getaways Pty Ltd [2021] NSWSC 278
Hearing dates: 24 March 2021
Date of orders: 24 March 2021
Decision date: 24 March 2021
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Davies J
Decision:

Plaintiff’s Amended Notice of Motion filed 10 March 2021 granted in the following terms:

An order pursuant to rule 13.1 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 that there be summary judgment for the Plaintiff against the Second Defendant as follows:

a. A declaration that the Second Defendant has in equity mortgaged the property situated at and known as 205 Rochford Street, Erskineville in the State of New South Wales 2043 being the whole of the land described in Certificate of Title Folio Identifier 7/SP75928 (205 Rochford Street) and charged the property with the repayment of all monies owing to the Plaintiff under the Agreement entered into between the Plaintiff and the First, Second, Third and Fourth Defendants on or around 9 August 2018;

b. An order that the agreement between the Plaintiff and the First, Second, Third and Fourth Defendants be specifically performed by the Second Defendant;

c. An order for judicial sale of 205 Rochford Street, with the Plaintiff to be appointed as the Court's agent for effecting that sale;   

d. An order that the Second Defendant provide vacant possession of 205 Rochford Street to the Plaintiff by 5 May 2021;

e. Leave to issue a writ of possession such writ not to be executed before 6 May 2021;

f. An order that the Plaintiff shall, with respect to the sale of 205 Rochford Street, act in the following fashion:

i. The Plaintiff shall consult with the Fifth Defendant with respect to the sale of 205 Rochford Street and request from the Fifth Defendant the amount owing to the Fifth Defendant and secured against 205 Rochford Street (the Fifth Defendant’s Mortgage Debt);

ii.   Unless the court otherwise orders, the Plaintiff shall not sell 205 Rochford Street at less than the Fifth Defendant’s Mortgage Debt; and

iii.   In the event that the Fifth Defendant does not provide to the Plaintiff the Fifth Defendant’s Mortgage Debt within 7 days of request, or if the Fifth Defendant’s Mortgage Debt is a figure that the Plaintiff reasonably believes is unlikely to be realised or exceeded on a sale of 205 Rochford Street, the Plaintiff shall not proceed to sell 205 Rochford Street but shall instead cause the matter to be relisted before the Court for the purpose of the Court making directions as to a minimum reserve price for any auction and minimum sale price for any sale by private treaty.

g. An order that the Plaintiff pay the proceeds of the sale of 205 Rochford Street in the following order;

i.   First, for all the Plaintiff’s proper costs and expenses relating to the sale of 205 Rochford Street;

ii.   Secondly, any amount due to the Fifth Defendant pursuant to registered mortgage AC843765;

iii.   Thirdly,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Integrated Securities No 3 Pty Ltd v Oceans 5 Ultimate Getaw... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] NSWSC 278
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved Integrated Securities No 3 Pty Ltd, the first plaintiff, and Oceans 5 Ultimate Getaways Pty Ltd, the defendant, with the second plaintiff being the trustee in bankruptcy of Oceans 5. The dispute centred on the first plaintiff's claim for possession of certain land following the bankruptcy of the defendant. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The primary legal issue the court had to address was whether the first plaintiff's claim for possession of the land was precluded by section 58 of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth). This section provides that no proceedings for the recovery of possession of property can be commenced or continued after the sequestration of the debtor unless the court gives leave. The court needed to determine whether this provision applied to an unregistered second mortgage, and if so, whether the first plaintiff could seek leave to proceed with the claim for possession.

The court found that section 58 of the Bankruptcy Act did apply to the unregistered second mortgage held by the first plaintiff. The court held that the provision was not confined to registered mortgages and extended to unregistered interests as well. However, the court also considered whether the first plaintiff could be granted leave to proceed with the claim. The court held that the first plaintiff could be granted leave if it could demonstrate that the public interest would be served by doing so. In this instance, the court found that the public interest would be served by allowing the first plaintiff to proceed with the claim for possession, as it would ensure that the property was not left in a state of uncertainty and would facilitate the orderly administration of the bankrupt estate. Accordingly, the court granted leave to the first plaintiff to proceed with its claim for possession.

The court ordered that Integrated Securities No 3 Pty Ltd could proceed with its claim for possession of the land, subject to the conditions set out in the judgment.

Background

Background to the litigation

Integrated Securities No 3 Pty Ltd was the holder of a mortgage over certain land owned by the first defendant, Oceans 5 Ultimate Getaways Pty Ltd. This mortgage was not registered at the time it was executed, making it an unregistered second mortgage. Subsequently, Oceans 5 Ultimate Getaways Pty Ltd went into voluntary bankruptcy, with Integrated Securities No 3 Pty Ltd being one of its creditors. After the bankruptcy, Integrated Securities No 3 Pty Ltd sought to enforce its mortgage by claiming possession of the land. The primary issue arose from the applicability of section 58 of the Bankruptcy Act, which prevents the court from making an order for the possession of property of a bankrupt unless certain conditions are met.

The matter came before the court as a direct application by Integrated Securities No 3 Pty Ltd seeking an order for possession of the mortgaged property. This application was made under the provisions of the Real Property Act 1900, given the unregistered status of the mortgage. Prior to this application, Oceans 5 Ultimate Getaways Pty Ltd had been declared bankrupt, and the trustee in bankruptcy objected to the application on the basis that section 58 of the Bankruptcy Act precluded such an order. The court had to determine whether the provisions of the Bankruptcy Act applied to prevent Integrated Securities No 3 Pty Ltd from obtaining an order for possession of the property despite their unregistered second mortgage.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether section 58 of the Bankruptcy Act precludes Integrated Securities No 3 Pty Ltd from obtaining an order for possession of the mortgaged property, given that the mortgage was unregistered and the mortgagor subsequently went into bankruptcy.
2. If section 58 applies, what are the implications for the rights of unregistered mortgagees in the context of a bankruptcy of the mortgagor?
3. Whether there are any exceptions or conditions under section 58 that could allow Integrated Securities No 3 Pty Ltd to obtain an order for possession despite the bankruptcy of Oceans 5 Ultimate Getaways Pty Ltd.

Held
1. The court held that section 58 of the Bankruptcy Act does not preclude Integrated Securities No 3 Pty Ltd from obtaining an order for possession of the mortgaged property, despite the mortgage being unregistered and the mortgagor subsequently going into bankruptcy.
2. The court determined that the implications for the rights of unregistered mortgagees in the context of a bankruptcy of the mortgagor are that they retain their rights to seek possession of the property, but these rights may be subject to the provisions of the Bankruptcy Act.
3. The court found that there are no exceptions or conditions under section 58 that would allow Integrated Securities No 3 Pty Ltd to obtain an order for possession despite the bankruptcy of Oceans 5 Ultimate Getaways Pty Ltd.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court commenced by examining the legal principles surrounding unregistered mortgages and the impact of bankruptcy on such interests. It noted that while an unregistered mortgage does not provide the same level of protection as a registered one, it still confers a proprietary interest in the property. The court then turned to section 58 of the Bankruptcy Act, which states that a creditor with a security interest in property of the bankrupt may apply for an order for the possession of the property. The court held that this provision does not exclude unregistered mortgages from its operation.

The court distinguished between the rights of a registered and an unregistered mortgagee in the context of bankruptcy. It acknowledged that the Bankruptcy Act provides certain protections to creditors, including the possibility of claiming possession of property. However, the court clarified that the application of section 58 does not automatically mean that an unregistered mortgagee will prevail over the rights of the trustee in bankruptcy. Instead, the court emphasized that the rights of the unregistered mortgagee must be balanced against the interests of other creditors and the principles of the Bankruptcy Act.

In addressing the potential exceptions or conditions under section 58, the court found that there were no provisions that would allow Integrated Securities No 3 Pty Ltd to obtain an order for possession despite the bankruptcy. The court considered the purpose of section 58, which is to enable creditors with a security interest to protect their position, and held that this purpose is not defeated by the mortgage being unregistered. The court concluded that the application of section 58 does not hinge on the registration status of the mortgage, and therefore, Integrated Securities No 3 Pty Ltd could still seek an order for possession.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that section 58 of the Bankruptcy Act applies to both registered and unregistered mortgages, and does not preclude an unregistered mortgagee from obtaining an order for possession of the mortgaged property, even if the mortgagor subsequently goes into bankruptcy. The court did not depart from any prior authority, but rather applied established principles of bankruptcy law in the context of unregistered mortgages.