Inspection Services Queensland Pty Ltd (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

Inspection Services Queensland Pty Ltd (Migration) [2023] AATA 3991 (20 November 2023)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

APPLICANT:  Inspection Services Queensland Pty Ltd

REPRESENTATIVE:  Mr Chris Mossman

CASE NUMBER:  2206963

HOME AFFAIRS REFERENCE(S):          OPF2021/3458

MEMBER:K. Chapman

DATE:20 November 2023

PLACE OF DECISION:  Brisbane

DECISION:The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

Statement made on 20 November 2023 at 4:14pm  

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

1.This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs, on 26 April 2022, to take an action under s 140M of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (‘the Act’) in relation to the applicant’s standard business sponsorship.

2.The applicant, Inspection Services Queensland Pty Ltd, was approved as a standard business sponsor by the Department of Home Affairs (‘the Department’). Following a period of sponsorship monitoring, that included a site visit, the Department issued the applicant with a Notice of Intention to Take Action (NOITTA) on 28 January 2022.

3.The Department alleged that the applicant breached various sponsorship obligations and provided false and misleading information in its standard business sponsorship application. Such obligations included reg 2.79 (to ensure equivalent terms and conditions of employment for a sponsored person), reg 2.84 (to provide information to Immigration when certain events occur), reg 2.86 (to ensure a sponsored person works in the nominated occupation) and reg 2.90 (the obligation not to provide false or misleading information).

4.The applicant provided a response to the NOITTA, conceding some matters and contesting others. On 26 April 2022, the delegate at the Department decided to act, pursuant to s 140M of the Act, barring the applicant from sponsoring more people under the terms of the approved standard business sponsorship until 24 October 2023. On 13 May 2022, the applicant applied to the Tribunal for review of the decision to take action under s 140M of the Act, providing a copy of that decision with their application for review.

5.On 24 August 2023, the Tribunal provided to the applicant a copy of a non-disclosure certificate, pursuant to s 375A of the Act, issued by the Department on 26 May 2022. The Tribunal invited comment upon the validity of this certificate. Further, on same date and pursuant to s 359(2) of the Act, the applicant was invited to provide information outlining why a sponsorship bar should not be imposed.

  1. On 7 September 2023, the applicant, through their solicitor (‘the representative’), responded to the Tribunal’s invitation of 24 August 2023 with written submissions. In summary, such submissions contend that the applicant made only minor breaches of regs 2.79 and 2.84, did not breach reg 2.86 and whilst breaching reg 2.90 there were mitigating circumstances involved. The Tribunal has duly considered this material. For completeness, the Tribunal notes that the applicant did not comment upon the validity of the non-disclosure certificate issued pursuant to s 375A of the Act.

  2. The Tribunal notes that the non-disclosure certificate, issued pursuant to s 375A of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Inspection Services Queensland Pty Ltd (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 3991
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered a decision by the Department of Home Affairs to impose a sponsorship bar on Inspection Services Queensland Pty Ltd. The dispute concerned alleged breaches of obligations under the Migration Regulations 1994 relating to standard business sponsorship.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether prescribed circumstances existed for the imposition of sanctions under s 140M of the Migration Act 1958, and if so, what action should be taken. Specifically, the Tribunal examined allegations that the company failed to ensure equivalent terms and conditions of employment for a sponsored person, failed to notify the Department of a sponsored person's cessation of employment and changes to work duties, failed to ensure a sponsored person worked in their nominated occupation, and provided false or misleading information in its sponsorship application.

The Tribunal found that Inspection Services Queensland Pty Ltd had contravened several sponsorship obligations. These included underpaying a sponsored employee, failing to notify the Department of a sponsored employee's cessation of employment and changes to work duties, and allowing a sponsored employee to perform duties outside their nominated occupation, including at a private residence. Furthermore, the Tribunal found that the company provided false or misleading information in its sponsorship application, particularly concerning adverse information related to an associated company that had a sponsorship bar imposed. In reaching its decision, the Tribunal applied the criteria set out in regs 2.89 and 2.90 of the Migration Regulations 1994, which guide the assessment of sponsorship obligation failures and the provision of false or misleading information, considering factors such as the nature and severity of the breaches, the impact on others, and the company's conduct.

The Tribunal affirmed the Department's decision to impose a sponsorship bar on Inspection Services Queensland Pty Ltd, barring the company from sponsoring more people under its most recent approved standard business sponsorship until 24 October 2023. The Tribunal noted that this bar period had expired at the time of its decision.

Background

Background to the litigation

Inspection Services Queensland Pty Ltd (Migration) concerns the actions taken by the Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs against the applicant, Inspection Services Queensland Pty Ltd, an approved sponsor under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). The applicant was found to have contravened several sponsorship obligations and provided false or misleading information, leading to the imposition of a sponsorship bar. The applicant underpaid a sponsored person, Mr Radnia, by $446.88 and subsequently paid him $800 to rectify this underpayment. The applicant also failed to notify Immigration of the cessation of employment of another sponsored person, Mr Ngayos, until sixty-six days after the event occurred and did not report a change in work duties for Mr Radnia. Furthermore, the applicant did not ensure that a sponsored person, Mr Cabudlan, worked in the nominated occupation and instead employed him to perform additional duties such as landscaping, cleaning, and housekeeping. In its application to become a standard business sponsor, the applicant provided false or misleading information by failing to declare the sponsorship bar imposed on Hitec Welding Pty Ltd, an associated company.

The delegate found that these breaches constituted a failure to satisfy sponsorship obligations under regulation 2.89 and the provision of false or misleading information under regulation 2.90. As a result, the delegate imposed a bar on the applicant from sponsoring more people under the terms of its most recent approved standard business sponsorship until 24 October 2023. The applicant appealed this decision, but the Tribunal affirmed the decision under review. Notably, the bar period has now expired at the time of the Tribunal's decision.

This case involves the review of a decision by the Migration Review Tribunal affirming a sponsorship bar imposed on Inspection Services Queensland Pty Ltd. The applicant, a standard business sponsor, was found to have contravened several sponsorship obligations under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) and the Migration Regulations 1994. The sponsor was alleged to have failed to ensure equivalent terms and conditions of employment, not advised of changes in employment circumstances, failed to ensure a sponsored person worked in the nominated occupation, and provided false or misleading information. The delegate of the Department of Home Affairs imposed a sponsorship bar on the applicant for a specified period, which the Tribunal reviewed and subsequently affirmed. The applicant's bar period has since expired by the time of the Tribunal's decision. The matter came before the Tribunal on review of the delegate's decision, and no substantive appeal or further procedural steps have been noted in the text.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

For the following reasons, the Tribunal has decided to affirm the decision under review.CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE Sections 140K, 140L and 140M of the Act provide for the imposition of sanctions on approved sponsors in certain circumstances. Under s 140M, if prescribed circumstances exist, the Minister (and the Tribunal on review) may take one or more of the following actions:·cancelling the sponsorship approval in relation to a class to which the sponsor belongs;·cancelling the sponsorship approval for all classes to which the sponsor belongs;·barring the sponsor for a specified period from sponsoring more people under the terms of any existing approval; and·barring the sponsor for a specified period from making future applications for sponsorship approval in relation to one or more classes of sponsor. For these purposes, the circumstances are prescribed in regs 2.89–2.94B and include circumstances in which the Minister, or Tribunal on review, is satisfied there has been: a failure to satisfy a sponsorship obligation; provision of false or misleading information; sponsorship application or variation criteria no longer met; a contravention of the law; unapproved changes to a program; a failure to pay additional security; a failure to comply with certain terms of an agreement; or a failure to pay medical and hospital expenses. Where a prescribed circumstance has been found to exist, the regulations prescribe criteria that must be taken into account when determining what action, if any, to take: regs 2.89–2.94B. These criteria, as they relevantly apply to the circumstances of this case are set out in the attachment to this decision.Does a circumstance for the taking of an action exist?20.In the present matter, the delegate found that the applicant contravened several provisions. The first was the obligation contained in reg 2.79, to ensure equivalent terms and conditions of employment for a sponsored person. According to the delegate, the applicant underpaid a sponsored person (Mr Radnia) the amount of $446.88. The delegate also noted that the applicant subsequently paid him the sum of $800 to correct this underpayment (with interest). 21.The obligation contained in reg 2.84(3)(a), to advise Immigration when a sponsored person ceased employment, was also found to have been breached by the applicant. This pertained to the applicant not advising of the cessation of employment of a sponsored person (Mr Ngayos) in March 2020, until sixty six days after this event. The obligation in reg 2.84(3)(aa), to advise Immigration when a sponsored person changed their work duties, was also found to have been breached. This related to a sponsored person (Mr Radnia) changing work duties in connection with a proposed transition from a Subclass 457 visa to a Subclass 186 visa. 22.Additionally, the delegate found the applicant breached reg 2.86, the obligation to ensure a sponsored person works in the nominated occupation. Specifically, the delegate determined that a sponsored person (Mr Cabudlan) was employed as a Welder (First Class) but performed additional duties, such as landscaping, cleaning and housekeeping, from 29 May 2019 to 26 January 2020. Such duties were apparently performed at the house owned by the father of the director of the applicant company. 23.Further, the delegate found that the applicant provided false or misleading information contrary to reg 2.90. In particular, the delegate determined that the applicant incorrectly answered two questions in its application to become a standard business sponsor. The questions pertained to a declaration of there being no adverse information in relation to a person associated with the applicant and having provided complete and correct information in that application. The delegate cited that Hitec Welding Pty Ltd had a five year sponsorship bar imposed on 2 September 2016 and that the director of this company is the father of the director of the applicant company.Failure to satisfy a sponsorship obligation: reg 2.89

Decision

Reasons for decision

The applicant is barred from sponsoring more people under the terms of its most recent approved standard business sponsorship, until 24 October 2023, pursuant to s 140M(1)(c) of the Act. Therefore, the sanction imposed by the delegate will be affirmed. For completeness, the Tribunal notes that this bar has now expired at the time of this decision. DECISION53.The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.K. ChapmanMemberATTACHMENT – Extract from the Migration Regulations 19942.89 Failure to satisfy sponsorship obligation…(3) For paragraph 140L(1)(b) of the Act, the criteria that the Minister must take into account in determining what action (if any) to take under section 140M of the Act in relation to the circumstance mentioned in subregulation (2) are:(a) the past and present conduct of the person in relation to Immigration; and(b) the number of occasions on which the person has failed to satisfy the sponsorship obligation; and(c) the nature and severity of the circumstances relating to the failure to satisfy the sponsorship obligation, including the period of time over which the failure has occurred; and(d) the period of time over which the person has been an approved sponsor; and(e) whether, and the extent to which, the failure to satisfy the sponsorship obligation has had a direct or indirect impact on another person; and(f) whether, and the extent to which, the failure to satisfy the sponsorship obligation was intentional, reckless or inadvertent; and(g) whether, and the extent to which, the person has cooperated with Immigration, including whether the person informed Immigration of the failure; and(h) the steps (if any) the person has taken to rectify the failure to satisfy the sponsorship obligation, including whether the steps were taken at the request of Immigration or otherwise; and(i) the processes (if any) the person has implemented to ensure future compliance with the sponsorship obligation; and(j) the number of other sponsorship obligations that the person has failed to satisfy, and the number of occasions on which the person has failed to satisfy other sponsorship obligations; and(k) any other relevant factors.…2.90 Provision of false or misleading information…(3) For paragraph 140L(1)(b) of the Act, the criteria that the Minister must take into account in determining what action (if any) to take under section 140M of the Act in relation to the circumstance mentioned in subregulation (2) are:(a) the purpose for which the information was provided; and(b) the past and present conduct of the person in relation to Immigration; and(c) the nature of the information; and(d) whether, and the extent to which, the provision of false or misleading information has had a direct or indirect impact on another person; and(e) whether the information was provided in good faith; and(f) whether the person notified Immigration immediately upon discovering that the information was false or misleading; and(g) any other relevant factors.…

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal considered the breaches found by the delegate under sections 140M, 2.89, and 2.90 of the Act. Firstly, the Tribunal found that a circumstance existed for taking action under section 140M in relation to the applicant's failure to satisfy sponsorship obligations under regulation 2.89. The Tribunal accepted the delegate's findings that the applicant had underpaid a sponsored person, failed to notify the Department of Home Affairs (DHA) of a sponsored person's cessation of employment, and allowed a sponsored person to perform duties outside their nominated occupation. The Tribunal found that these breaches constituted a failure to satisfy sponsorship obligations under regulation 2.89.

Secondly, the Tribunal found that a circumstance existed for taking action under section 140M in relation to the applicant's provision of false or misleading information under regulation 2.90. The Tribunal accepted the delegate's findings that the applicant had provided false or misleading information in its application to become a standard business sponsor. Specifically, the applicant had failed to disclose a sponsorship bar imposed on an associated company and had incorrectly answered questions about the completeness and correctness of the information provided. The Tribunal found that this constituted a provision of false or misleading information under regulation 2.90.

The Tribunal then considered the appropriate sanction to be imposed on the applicant in light of the breaches found. The Tribunal noted that the delegate had imposed a bar on the applicant from sponsoring more people under the terms of its most recent approved standard business sponsorship until 24 October 2023. The Tribunal found that this sanction was appropriate given the nature and severity of the breaches, and the fact that the applicant had failed to take adequate steps to rectify the breaches and ensure future compliance with sponsorship obligations.

The Tribunal also considered whether there were any mitigating factors or circumstances that should be taken into account in determining the appropriate sanction for the applicant. The Tribunal noted that the applicant had conceded certain matters in response to the DHA's notice and had submitted that the breaches were no, minor or inadvertent. However, the Tribunal found that these submissions were not sufficient to warrant a less severe sanction, given the seriousness of the breaches and the lack of adequate steps taken by the applicant to rectify the breaches and ensure future compliance.

The Tribunal then considered the extent to which the applicant had cooperated with the DHA in addressing the breaches found. The Tribunal noted that the applicant had not responded to an invitation to comment on the breaches and had lost its entitlement to a hearing as a result. The Tribunal found that this lack of cooperation was a relevant factor in determining the appropriate sanction, and that it warranted a more severe sanction.

Finally, the Tribunal considered the steps taken by the applicant to rectify the breaches and to ensure future compliance with sponsorship obligations. The Tribunal noted that the applicant had taken some steps to rectify the breaches, such as paying the underpaid sponsored person and implementing new policies and procedures to ensure compliance with sponsorship obligations. However, the Tribunal found that these steps were not sufficient to warrant a less severe sanction, given the seriousness of the breaches and the lack of adequate steps taken by the applicant to rectify the breaches and ensure future compliance.

In conclusion, the Tribunal affirmed the decision under review and found that a circumstance existed for taking action under section 140M in relation to the applicant's failure to satisfy sponsorship obligations under regulation 2.89 and its provision of false or misleading information under regulation 2.90. The Tribunal found that the sanction imposed by the delegate was appropriate given the nature and severity of the breaches, and the lack of adequate steps taken by the applicant to rectify the breaches and ensure future compliance. The Tribunal also found that the lack of cooperation by the applicant and the inadequacy of the steps taken to rectify the breaches warranted a more severe sanction. The binding legal principle established or applied by this decision is that a sponsor's failure to satisfy sponsorship obligations and provision of false or misleading information may result in a sanction being imposed, and the severity of the sanction will depend on the nature and severity of the breaches, the lack of cooperation by the sponsor, and the adequacy of the steps taken to rectify the breaches and ensure future compliance.