IP AUSTRALIA
AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE
Innovia Security Pty Ltd v De La Rue International Limited [2016] APO 57
Patent Application: 2010311176
Title:Improvements in security devices
Patent Applicant: De La Rue International Limited
Opponent: Innovia Security Pty Ltd
Delegate: Xavier Gisz
Decision Date: 31 August 2016
Hearing Date: Written submissions filed on 21 July 2016
Catchwords: PATENTS - Final determination of an opposition under section 59 – the amendments do not overcome the findings in the earlier decision – application is refused.
Representation: Patent attorney for the opponent: Watermark
IP AUSTRALIA
AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE
Patent Application: 2010311176
Title:Improvements in security devices
Patent Applicant: De La Rue International Limited
Date of Decision: 31 August 2016
DECISION
The amendments to the specification do not overcome the deficiencies identified in the earlier decision. Subject to an appeal of this decision, I direct the application be refused.
Costs are awarded according to Schedule 8 against the Applicant, De La Rue International Limited.
REASONS FOR DECISION
Background
Grant of a patent for application 2010311176 in the name of De La Rue International Limited (the Applicant) was opposed by Innovia Security Pty Ltd (the Opponent). Following a hearing on 19 August 2015 I issued a decision upholding the opposition, which was reported as Innovia Security Pty Ltd v De La Rue International Limited [2015] APO 77 (the earlier decision) dated 24 November 2015. I found that all claims of the Application lacked inventive step in view of D1 (WO 2008/043981). In response to the Decision, on 11 January 2016 the Applicant lodged a Request to Amend under Section 104. The amendments were allowed and published on 28 April 2016.
On 4 May 2016 the parties were asked is they wished to be heard on the final determination of the matter. On 18 May 2016 the Opponent advised that it wished to be heard on the matter and on 9 June 2016 the Opponent further advised they wished for the hearing to be on the basis of written submissions. On 23 June 2016 the parties were advised that written submissions were due on 21 July 2016 and responding submissions were due on 28 July 2016. The Opponent filed submissions on 21 July 2016 while the Applicant did not provide any submissions.
The Law
At the final determination hearing, it was not in dispute that the decision of the High Court in R v Smith (Commissioner of Patents); Ex parte Mole Engineering Pty Ltd [1981] HCA 25; (1981) 147 CLR 340 (Ex parte Mole) supports the Commissioner deciding an opposition with more than one decision, providing that each decision is final and decides all the issues arising on the notice of opposition so far as they were capable of determination at the time. The issues to be considered in the final determination are whether the amendments to the specification overcome the deficiencies identified in the earlier decision and whether the amendments introduce any new deficiencies.
Earlier decision
In the earlier decision I found:
“Claims 1-28 lack…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Innovia Security Pty Ltd v De La Rue International Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] APO 57
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court included whether the amendments to the patent specification were sufficient to overcome the deficiencies identified in the earlier decision and whether the amendments introduced any new deficiencies. The court also considered the appropriate legal framework for determining a patent application with more than one decision, as established in the High Court's decision in R v Smith (Commissioner of Patents); Ex parte Mole Engineering Pty Ltd.
The delegate concluded that the proposed amendments did not address the deficiencies identified in the earlier decision. The first added phrase merely clarified how the first light absorbing layer was partial, but this was already implicit in the original claims and was found to be disclosed in the prior art document D1. The second added phrase described the optical result achieved by the device, which was also considered to be implicit in the original claims and was found to be obvious in light of the prior art. The delegate found that the amendments did not represent a genuine attempt to overcome the lack of inventive step and consequently refused the application. Costs were awarded to the opponent, Innovia Security Pty Ltd, in accordance with Schedule 8.
The delegate's decision was based on the principle that the amendments did not address the deficiencies identified in the earlier decision and did not introduce any new deficiencies. The delegate refused the application and awarded costs to the opponent, subject to any appeal by the applicant. The decision highlights the importance of making genuine attempts to overcome deficiencies in a patent application, and the potential consequences of failing to do so.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi