JURISDICTION : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
IN CHAMBERS
CITATION: INDEPENDENT TIMBER SUPPLIES PTY LTD -v- HOLLAND [2024] WASC 362
CORAM: WHITBY J
HEARD: 2 OCTOBER 2024
DELIVERED : 2 OCTOBER 2024
FILE NO/S: CIV 2142 of 2024
BETWEEN: INDEPENDENT TIMBER SUPPLIES PTY LTD
Plaintiff
AND
CHRISTOPHER JAMES HOLLAND
First Defendant
REGISTRAR OF TITLES
Second Defendant
Catchwords:
Caveats - Application to extend operation of caveat - Guarantee and indemnity clause - No appearance by defendant - Caveator's claim has substance - Balance of convenience favours extension - Extension of caveat granted
Legislation:
Transfer of Land Act 1893 (WA)
Result:
Caveat extended on an interim basis
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
| Plaintiff | : | Mr W B MacDonald |
| First Defendant | : | No Appearance |
| Second Defendant | : | No Appearance |
Solicitors:
| Plaintiff | : | Roe Legal Services |
| First Defendant | : | No Appearance |
| Second Defendant | : | No Appearance |
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
Bashford v Bashford [2008] WASC 138
Bride v The Registrar of Titles [2015] WASC 11
Brogue Tableau Pty Ltd v Binningup Nominees Pty Ltd [2007] WASCA 179
Palazzo Homes Pty Ltd v Goh [2010] WASC 407
Southern Wine Corporation Pty Ltd (in liq) v Frankland River Olive Co Ltd [2005] WASCA 236
WHITBY J:
(This judgment was delivered extemporaneously on 2 October 2024 and has been edited from the transcript)
This is the plaintiff's application, by originating summons filed on 26 September 2024, for an order pursuant to a s 138C of the Transfer of Land Act 1893 (WA) (TLA) extending the operation of Caveat Q105263 (Caveat) registered by the plaintiff against the first defendant's interest in land at 26 Leslie Road, Wandi, Western Australia (Property).
The application is supported by the affidavit of Kym Li Long sworn 26 September 2024 (Long Affidavit), the affidavit of William Bowie MacDonald sworn 1 October 2024 (MacDonald Affidavit), a certificate of urgency filed on 26 September 2024 and an undertaking as to damages filed on 26 September 2024.
Christopher James Holland, the first defendant, is the registered proprietor as to a 30/100 undivided share of the Property. On 19 August 2024, the plaintiff lodged the Caveat over the first defendant's share of the Property.
On 18 September 2024, the Registrar of Titles, the second defendant, upon the application of the first defendant issued a notice to the plaintiff under s 138B of the TLA advising that the Caveat would lapse on 9 October 2024, unless before that time the second defendant is served with a copy of an order of this court extending its operation.
The first defendant has not entered an appearance to the Originating Summons and has not appeared at the hearing today. The MacDonald Affidavit deposes to attempts to serve the first defendant with the Originating Summons and notice of hearing of the application. I am satisfied, on the basis of that evidence, that all reasonable attempts to bring the Originating Summons and the listing of the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Independent Timber Supplies Pty Ltd v Holland and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] WASC 362
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the plaintiff had a strong claim to an interest in the property, and the balance of convenience favoured the extension of the caveat. The court recognised that there was a practical impediment to the other co-owners dealing with their share of the property, but there was no legal impediment. The court was satisfied that the plaintiff had provided an undertaking as to damages, which protected the other defendants in the event that the plaintiff's claim turned out not to have substance. The court noted that the caveat was in absolute form, and while it was appropriate to extend the caveat, it should be amended to a subject to claim caveat to accord with the principle that a caveat should not go beyond the plaintiff's legitimate claim necessary to protect its interests. The court held that it had the power to amend a caveat as a condition of its extension, but it should not encourage the belief that an imprecisely worded caveat could easily be amended at a later date.
The court concluded that, having due regard to the overall merits of the plaintiff's application, it was appropriate to make the requested amendment and to conditional the continued operation of the caveat upon amendment. The court granted the plaintiff's application to extend the caveat, subject to the caveat being amended to a subject to claim caveat.
No further orders were made.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the court as an application for an extension of a caveat. The plaintiff had previously lodged a caveat against the Property, which was due to lapse. The first defendant did not appear or respond to the application. The court considered the plaintiff's application for an extension of the caveat, taking into account the balance of convenience, the nature of the plaintiff's claim, and the appropriateness of amending the form of the caveat.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the balance of convenience favours the extension of the caveat?
2. Whether the caveat should be amended from an absolute form to a subject to claim form as a condition of its extension?
3. Whether the court has the power to amend a caveat as a condition of its extension, and if so, what principles should guide such an amendment?
Held
1. The court concluded that the balance of convenience favours the extension of the caveat. As a result, the application to extend the caveat was allowed.
2. The court held that the caveat should be amended from an absolute form to a subject to claim form as a condition of its extension. The continued operation of the caveat was made conditional upon this amendment.
3. The court determined that it has the power to amend a caveat as a condition of its extension. The court should not encourage the belief that an imprecisely worded caveat can easily be amended at a later date. The court applied this principle in making its decision.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The claim made by plaintiff clearly relates to a proprietary interest in the Property. The plaintiff and the first defendant, as parties to the Credit Agreement, have expressly provided for any interest in land of the first defendant's to be appropriated for the discharge of an outstanding debt under the Credit Agreement. This gives rise to a proprietary interest in the Property capable of protection by caveat.[14][14] Southern Wine Corporation Pty Ltd (in liq) v Frankland River Olive Co Ltd [2005] WASCA 236 [40]. The first defendant has acknowledged, by his emails to Ms Long of the plaintiff, that there is an amount outstanding under the Credit Agreement. The plaintiff submits that the balance of convenience favours the extension of the Caveat. The Property is subject to a contract of sale and therefore, the plaintiff says that if the Caveat is not extended, there is a high likelihood that its proprietary interest in the Property will be defeated. Weighing against the balance of convenience in favour of extending the Caveat is that the fact that other persons own 70/100 undivided shares in the Property and those persons do not owe money to the plaintiff. Given the ownership of the Property is as tenants in common, there is no legal impediment to those persons dealing with their share of the Property. I recognise however, that there is a practical impediment to them doing so. The plaintiff has provided an undertaking as to damages which protects the first defendant and the other registered proprietors of the Property in the event that the plaintiff's claim turns out not to have substance. I am satisfied that, given the strong claim that the plaintiff has to an interest in the Property, the fact that it would be defeated if the Property is sold, and the undertaking as to damages provided by the plaintiff, the balance of convenience favours the extension of the Caveat. The Caveat is in absolute form. While I am satisfied that the Caveat should be extended, it is appropriate that it is amended. The plaintiff accepts that the form of the caveat should be amended to a subject to claim caveat to accord with the principle that a caveat should not go beyond the plaintiff's legitimate claim necessary to protect its interests. The court may make such order as it considers appropriate in dealing with an application to extend a caveat, including the power to order amendment of the caveat as a condition of its extension.[15] The court, however, may not order an amendment of a caveat which would result in the substitution of a different estate or interest than the estate or interest claimed in the caveat. Although the court has the power to amend a caveat, the court should not encourage the belief that an imprecisely worded caveat can easily be amended at a later date. Wrongfully formulated caveats should not be easily tolerated.[16][15] Palazzo Homes Pty Ltd v Goh [2010] WASC 407 (Palazzo Homes) [7].[16] Palazzo Homes [9] - [11]. Having due regard to the overall merits of the plaintiff's application, I am satisfied that the requested amendment ought be made and it is appropriate that the continued operation of the Caveat be conditional upon amendment.