SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
In the Will of James Edmond O’Connor (deceased); Ex parte Lennox [2024] QSC 224
PARTIES:
SAMANTHA TRACEY LENNOX
(applicant)
ST VINCENT DE PAUL SOCIETY VICTORIA INCORPORATED
(intervener)
FILE NO:
BS No 9026 of 2024
DIVISION:
Trial Division
PROCEEDING:
Application
ORIGINATING COURT:
Supreme Court of QueenslandDELIVERED ON:
19 September 2024
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
20 August 2024
JUDGE:
Martin SJA
ORDER:
1. The Application filed 11 July 2024 is dismissed.
2. Pursuant to Rules 603(1)(d) and 603(3) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules and subject to the formal requirements of the Registrar, a common form grant of Letters of Administration with the Will of James Edmond O’Connor, deceased, dated 23 May 2003, be granted to Mary Catherine Simpson, on behalf of St Vincent de Paul Society Victoria Incorporated.
3. The parties’ costs of and incidental to this application be paid from the estate on the indemnity basis.
CATCHWORDS:
SUCCESSION – MAKING OF A WILL – EXECUTION – INFORMAL DOCUMENT INTENDED TO BE WILL – GENERALLY – where Dr James Edward O’Connor died on 1 July 2020, having executed a will in 2003 leaving numerous gifts to friends, relatives, and charities – where various handwritten papers were found at the home of Dr O’Connor by relatives – where one set of papers, bearing signatures similar to that of the deceased’s and the heading “UPDATE AND CHANGES TO THE WILL OF JAMES EDMOND O’CONNOR”, lists in numbered paragraphs the names and addresses or identified purposes of persons or entities and a corresponding apportionment of the estate – where the applicant argues that those notes constitute an informal codicil – where the applicant relies on section 18 of the Succession Act 1981 (Qld) – whether the notes constitute a legally operative testamentary document
SUCCESSION – MAKING OF A WILL – TESTAMENTARY CAPACTIY – GENERALLY – where there is no presumption of testamentary capacity in respect of documents which are not formally executed – whether the applicant has demonstrated that Dr O’Connor had the requisite testamentary capacity
Succession Act 1981 (Qld), s 18
Lindsay v McGrath [2016] 2 Qd R 160, cited
Re Application of Brown; Estate of Springfield (1991) 23 NSWLR 535, cited
Re Estate of Brock [2007] VSC 415, cited
Re Estate of Carrigan (deceased) [2018] QSC 206, cited
Re Estate of Walter Ostro [2021] NSWSC 495, citedCOUNSEL: K Gaston for the applicant
K Kluss for St Vincent de Paul Society Victoria Incorporated intervening
SOLICITORS: Cornford-Scott Lawyers for the applicant
McCullough Robertson Lawyers for the intervener
James Edward O’Connor died on 1 July 2020. He had been a medical specialist who had never married and had no children. On 23 May 2003 he had executed a will in which he left numerous gifts to friends, relatives and charities (the Will). His appointed executors died before he did. Ms Lennox (who is the authorised representative of Cancer Council Queensland) seeks an order that she be granted letters of administration with the Will…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read In the Will of; Ex parte and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] QSC 224
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the principles established in Lindsay v McGrath and other relevant authorities, noting that for section 18 to apply, the court must be satisfied that the document in question was intended by the deceased to operate as their will, an alteration of their will, or a revocation of their will. The court found that the notes did not clearly express the deceased's settled testamentary intentions. The evidence did not establish that Dr O’Connor intended the documents to operate as his final will, as they contained preliminary, tentative, or incomplete expressions of his testamentary intentions. Furthermore, the court found that there was insufficient evidence to demonstrate that Dr O’Connor had the requisite testamentary capacity to execute the documents as a codicil. The court concluded that the applicant had not satisfied the necessary threshold for the court to recognise the documents as a valid codicil.
The court dismissed the application, noting that the applicant had not demonstrated that the handwritten notes met the requirements under section 18 of the Succession Act 1981 (Qld). Consequently, the court granted a common form grant of Letters of Administration with the Will to Mary Catherine Simpson, on behalf of St Vincent de Paul Society Victoria Incorporated. The court ordered that the parties’ costs of and incidental to this application be paid from the estate on the indemnity basis.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The Application filed 11 July 2024 is dismissed.
2. Pursuant to Rules 603(1)(d) and 603(3) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules and subject to the formal requirements of the Registrar, a common form grant of Letters of Administration with the Will of James Edmond O’Connor, deceased, dated 23 May 2003, be granted to Mary Catherine Simpson, on behalf of St Vincent de Paul Society Victoria Incorporated.
3. The parties’ costs of and incidental to this application be paid from the estate on the indemnity basis.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Succession Act sets out, in Part 2 Division 2 and 3, the requirements for making and altering wills. Those requirements may be dispensed with if the circumstances set out in s 18 are present. It provides:“18Court may dispense with execution requirements for will, alteration or revocation(1)This section applies to a document, or a part of a document, that—(a) purports to state the testamentary intentions of a deceased person; and(b) has not been executed under this part.(2)The document or the part forms a will, an alteration of a will, or a full or partial revocation of a will, of the deceased person if the court is satisfied that the person intended the document or part to form the person’s will, an alteration to the person’s will or a full or partial revocation of the person’s will.(3)In making a decision under subsection (2), the court may, in addition to the document or part, have regard to—(a) any evidence relating to the way in which the document or part was executed; and(b) any evidence of the person’s testamentary intentions, including evidence of statements made by the person.(4)Subsection (3) does not limit the matters a court may have regard to in making a decision under subsection (2).(5)This section applies to a document, or a part of a document, whether the document came into existence within or outside the State.”How should s 18 be applied? The applicable principles were comprehensively dealt with by Boddice J (with whom Gotterson JA agreed)in Lindsay v McGrath:[1][1][2016] 2 Qd R 160.“[57] In Hatsatouris v Hatsatouris Powell JA observed, in relation to the analogous provision in New South Wales:“It is, and has long been, my view that the questions arising on applications raising a question as to the applicability of s 18A are essentially questions of fact, the particular questions of fact to be answered being:(a)was there a document,(b)did that document purport to embody the testamentary intentions of the relevant Deceased?(c)did the evidence satisfy the Court that, either, at the time of the subject document being brought into being, or, at some later time, the relevant Deceased, by some act or words, demonstrated that it was her, or his, then intention that the subject document should, without more on her, or his, part operate as her, or his, Will?”This approach has been applied in Queensland. [58] The second element requires a consideration of the expression “testamentary intentions”. In Re Masters (deceased) Mahoney JA observed:“… [The] document must state the deceased’s ‘testamentary intentions’, that is, his wishes or intentions as to how, voluntarily, his property is to pass or be disposed of after his death. A will may, of course, do other things: it may, for example, appoint a legal personal representative, exercise a special power, appoint a guardian or the like: see Halsbury’s Laws of England, par 202. But it is the disposition of the deceased’s property voluntarily after his death which is, for present purposes, the relevant characteristic of a will.”[59] The third requirement requires the Court to be satisfied on the evidence that the deceased, either at the time of drafting the document or subsequently, formed the intention that the particular document operate as his or her Will. That requirement does not involve establishing that the deceased consciously set his or her mind to the legal formalities of making a Will. However, it is not enough that the document set out the deceased’s testamentary intentions. What must be established, by evidence, is that the deceased intended the document to operate to dispose of the deceased’s property upon death. [60] Great care is to be taken in the evaluation of the relevant evidence. To satisfy the onus, the evidence must show more than that the particular document sets out the deceased’s testamentary intentions or that it is consistent with other statements the deceased made about what he or she wanted to happen to the property upon death. The evidence must establish on the balance of probabilities that the deceased wanted the particular document to be his or her final Will, and did not want to make any changes to that document. [61] The expression “without more”, used by Powell JA in Hatsatouris emphasizes the distinction between a document which merely records testamentary intentions and a document which records such intentions in a complete and concluded way such that it is intended by the author to operate as his or her last Will. On this aspect, the observations of Habersberger J in Fast v Rockman are apposite:“Like Murray J in Dolan v Dolan, I consider that the words ‘without more’ have been mentioned by way of emphasising that the court must be satisfied that the deceased really did intend the terms of the document – ‘without any alteration or reservation’ – to be the manner in which his or her property was to be disposed of upon his or her death. Or as EM Heenan J put it in Mitchell v Mitchell, the words ‘without more’ were used in Oreski v Ikac:‘… to emphasise the need for the document being propounded for proof as an informal will to express the concluded testamentary intentions and decision of the deceased rather than being some provisional, preliminary or tentative proposal which had not by then received the deceased’s full assent.’”[62] Documents which contain only preliminary, tentative or incomplete expressions of a deceased’s testamentary intentions, or which on the evidence are demonstrated to have been prepared for consideration, further thought, deliberation or possible revision, will not suffice for the purposes of s 18 as the evidence will not establish the document in question embodied the settled testamentary intentions of the deceased.” (citations omitted, emphasis added)