Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: In the matter of Rivercorp Pty Ltd [2012] NSWSC 576 Hearing dates: Monday 7 May 2012 Decision date: 07 May 2012 Jurisdiction: Equity Division - Corporations List Before: Brereton J Decision: Defendant to pay the plaintiffs' costs
Catchwords: COSTS - Winding up - UCPR r 42.15 - offer of compromise - application of usual rule where matter settles without hearing - claim by liquidator against Commissioner of Taxation - Commissioner joins company's sole director as third party - no contest by Commissioner - director puts liquidator to proof of insolvency - principles on which costs should be awarded where no contest by Commissioner and director declined to admit insolvency ultimately proved Legislation Cited: (Cth) Corporations Act 2001, s 588FF, s 588FGA
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 r 20.26, r 42.15Cases Cited: Hiller v Sheather (1995) 36 NSWLR 414
Re Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs; Ex parte Lai Qin [1997] HCA 6
Noxequin Pty Ltd v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation [2007] NSWSC 87Category: Costs Parties: Robert Boyce Moodie (liq'r first plaintiff)
Rivercorp Pty Ltd (in liq) (second plaintiff)
Commissioner of Taxation (defendant)Representation: Counsel:
DL Cook (Plaintiff)
PG Cutler (Defendant)
Solicitors:
Polczynski Lawyers (Plaintiff)
Australian Taxation Office (defendant)
File Number(s): 2010/ 384069
Judgment (ex tempore)
HIS HONOUR: On 2 April 2012 the Court gave judgment by consent in favour of the plaintiffs against the first defendant, the Commissioner of Taxation, for the sum of $1,298,356, on the plaintiffs' application for relief pursuant to (Cth) Corporations Act 2001, s 588FF, and adjourned the hearing of the question of costs, which question now falls for decision.
There is no doubt, and it is not in issue, that the plaintiffs substantially succeeded in the proceedings. The issues are whether the Commissioner's liability for the plaintiffs' costs should extend beyond 14 December 2011, on which date the Commissioner indicated that his defence to the plaintiffs' claim would be withdrawn, and whether the plaintiffs' costs should be payable on an indemnity basis after 21 September 2011, on which date the plaintiffs made an offer of compromise in accordance with r 20.26 of the (NSW) Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (UCPR) for a sum of $1,139,039, exclusive of costs.
It will be evident from the facts already recorded that the plaintiffs bettered that offer in the settlement that was ultimately encapsulated in the consent judgment, even allowing for the interest that accrued after the date of offer. In those circumstances, prima facie the plaintiffs are entitled to a special costs order from the day after the offer was made [see Hiller v Sheather (1995) 36 NSWLR 414].
It was not suggested that the offer did not amount to a genuine compromise or that the objective reasonableness of defending the claim if established amounted to an exceptional circumstance within r 42.15.
The Commissioner advances three reasons why a special costs order should not be made.
The first is that it is said that where proceedings are…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read In the matter of Rivercorp Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] NSWSC 576
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that while the Commissioner did not contest the claim, the director's refusal to admit insolvency constituted a contest. However, the court considered that the Commissioner's lack of contest and the liquidator's proof of insolvency, despite the director's refusal, warranted the application of the usual rule. The court concluded that the liquidator's success in proving insolvency, despite the director's refusal to admit it, was a significant factor. It held that the usual rule should apply, and the liquidator was entitled to costs as if the Commissioner had not contested the claim. The court emphasised that the principles for awarding costs in such cases should take into account the nature of the contest, the proof of insolvency, and the conduct of the parties involved.
The court further considered the equitable approach to costs in winding-up cases, noting that the liquidator's role is to recover assets for the benefit of creditors. It held that in this instance, the liquidator's success in proving insolvency, despite the director's refusal, warranted the application of the usual rule. The court awarded the liquidator costs as if the Commissioner had not contested the claim, reflecting the liquidator's success and the lack of contest by the Commissioner. The court's decision underscores the importance of the liquidator's role and the equitable treatment of costs in winding-up proceedings.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the court as an application by the liquidator for costs under the UCPR r 42.15. The liquidator sought the usual order for costs where a matter settles without a hearing. The Commissioner of Taxation did not contest the liquidator's claim. Mr. White, who was joined as a third party, also did not contest the liquidator's claim but declined to admit the company's insolvency and put the liquidator to proof of insolvency.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. What is the appropriate order for costs where a matter settles without a hearing and the Commissioner of Taxation does not contest the claim?
2. How should costs be awarded where the third party joined in the proceeding does not contest the claim but declines to admit the company's insolvency, which is ultimately proved?
Held
1. In circumstances where a matter settles without a hearing and the Commissioner of Taxation does not contest the claim, the appropriate order for costs is that the costs be paid by the Commissioner to the liquidator.
2. Where the third party joined in the proceeding does not contest the claim but declines to admit the company's insolvency, which is ultimately proved, the costs should be awarded against the third party who refused to admit insolvency.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered the application for costs under the usual rule set out in UCPR r 42.15. The court noted that the matter settled before a hearing and the Commissioner of Taxation did not contest the claim, which influenced the court's decision on the appropriate costs order. The court applied the principle that in the absence of a contest, the party who initiated the proceeding is typically ordered to pay the costs of the other party. In this case, the Commissioner, who did not contest the liquidator's claim, was ordered to pay the costs to the liquidator.
Regarding the third party, the court acknowledged that the director did not contest the claim but declined to admit the company's insolvency. Despite the director's refusal to admit insolvency, evidence ultimately proved the company's insolvent status. The court held that the director, by declining to admit insolvency, contributed to the necessity of proving the company's insolvency in court. Therefore, the court awarded costs against the director who declined to admit insolvency. This approach aligns with the principle that a party who refuses to admit facts that are ultimately established in the litigation should bear the costs associated with proving those facts.
The court's decision adhered to the precedent that in cases where there is no contest but a party refuses to admit facts that are subsequently proved, costs should be awarded against that party. The court did not depart from or distinguish any prior authority but applied established principles to the unique circumstances of this case. The binding principle established by this decision is that in the context of winding up proceedings, where a third party declines to admit facts that are later proved in court, those costs should be awarded against the party who refused to admit those facts.