ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
IN THE MATTER OF FG (Appeal) [2018] ACAT 134
AA 42/2018 (MH 108/2012)
Catchwords: APPEAL – Mental health – Appeal against a psychiatric treatment order (PTO) - whether statutory conditions for PTO were met – whether the person was refusing treatment – meaning of “refuses” – whether he was a risk to himself – whether he was at risk of mental deterioration – role of appeal Tribunal – whether evidence of the person’s behaviour in previous years was relevant to making of PTO – whether evidence of person’s behaviour subsequent to PTO was relevant to appeal – original decision confirmed
Legislation cited: ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 s 39, 40, 79
Mental Health Act 2015 ss 2, 5, 6, 7, 8, 15, 16, 24, 36, 51, 56, 57, 58, 62, 64, 77, 79, 194, 197, Dictionary
Legislation Act 2001 ss 138, 139, 140
Cases cited:House v R [1936] HCA 40
In the Matter of BC [2018] ACAT 67
In the matter of ED [2017] ACAT 84
LB v Mental Health ACT [2006] ACTSC 15
Rejman v Dunsmore (1983) 32 SASR 151
Tribunal:President G Neate AM
Presidential Member G McCarthy
Senior Member Dr P Norrie
Date of Orders: 19 November 2018
Date of Reasons for Decision: 24 December 2018
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY )
CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL ) AA 42/2018
BETWEEN:
FG
Appellant
AND:
CHIEF PSYCHIATRIST
Respondent
TRIBUNAL:President G Neate AM
Presidential Member G McCarthy
Senior Member Dr P Norrie
DATE:19 November 2018
ORDER
The Tribunal orders that:
The decision of the Tribunal on 2 August 2018 to make a psychiatric treatment order is confirmed.
Reasons for decision to be published.
……………Signed…………
President G Neate AM
For and on behalf of the Tribunal
REASONS FOR DECISION
On 2 August 2018, the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal (the original Tribunal) made a psychiatric treatment order (PTO) in relation to FG[1] to have effect for 6 months, unless sooner revoked. Under the PTO, FG is ordered to comply with any determination made by the Chief Psychiatrist or her delegate under section 62 of the Mental Health Act 2015 (MH Act).
[1] The letters FG have been used to preserve the anonymity of the person the subject of the PTO consistent with section 40 of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 and section 194 of the Mental Health Act 2015. The letters bear no resemblance to the initials of the subject person’s name
FG appealed against the PTO. He contended that the original Tribunal was in error in making it. He asked for the PTO to be set aside and for the initial application for that order to be dismissed.
His appeal was heard by the Tribunal as presently constituted (the appeal Tribunal) on 19 November 2018. FG appeared on his own behalf, with a representative of the Public Advocate as his support person.
At the conclusion of the hearing,…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read In the matter of FG and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] ACAT 134
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the ordinary meaning of the term "refuses" and concluded that it should be interpreted in its ordinary English sense, meaning to decline to accept or express a determination not to receive something offered. However, the court also noted that in the context of section 58(2)(b)(i), refusal should be assessed objectively based on the person's actions or words, rather than their subjective mental state or capacity to make an informed decision. The court considered that the refusal must be assessed at the time when the decision about the psychiatric treatment order is made. The refusal could include any aspect of treatment, care, or support offered to the person. The court held that the refusal must be evident through the person's words or actions and that it should not be influenced by the person's capacity to make an informed decision, as section 58(2)(b)(i) applies where the person lacks the decision-making capacity to consent to the treatment.
In confirming the decision of the original Tribunal, the court held that the applicant's refusal to receive treatment, care, or support was evident and objective, and that the history of whether the person received or refused to receive such treatment was relevant to determining whether section 58(2)(b)(i) was satisfied. The court also noted that the context and purpose of the relevant provisions of the Mental Health Act should be considered when interpreting the term "refuses". The Tribunal's decision to make a psychiatric treatment order was confirmed, and the reasons for the decision were ordered to be published.
Orders
Orders of the court
The Tribunal orders that:
1.
The decision of the Tribunal on 2 August 2018 to make a psychiatric treatment order is confirmed.
2.
Reasons for decision to be published.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
She also submitted that FG was legally represented, and the evidence was reliable and properly tested. Accordingly, the decision of the original Tribunal should not be disturbed.Consideration and conclusion In the circumstances of this appeal, and applications for PTOs generally, the requirement in section 58(2)(b)(i) prompts the following questions:(a)What does ‘refuses’ mean in this section of the MH Act?(b)By reference to what date must the issue whether or not someone ‘refuses’ be decided?(c)What might be refused?(d)How might refusal be evident?(e)Why might someone refuse?Our answers to those questions are set out below. When those questions are answered it becomes more clear that the history of whether a person received or refused to receive the treatment, care or support might be used to inform a decision whether that component of section 58(2)(b)(i) is satisfied. Having considered that issue in terms of section 58(2), it will be appropriate to consider also the context and purpose of the relevant provisions of the MH Act. Meaning of ‘refuses’ The word ‘refuses’ is not defined in the MH Act or the Legislation Act 2001. In our view, it should be given its ordinary English meaning. The Macquarie Dictionary[12] defines ‘refuse’ as meaning “to decline to accept (something offered)”, “to express a determination not (to do something)”, “to decline to submit to”, and “to decline acceptance, consent or compliance.” The Australian Concise Oxford Dictionary[13] defines ‘refuse’ as “say or convey by action that one will not accept or submit to or give or grant or gratify or consent”.[12] Macquarie Dictionary (Pan McMillan, 7th edn, 2017)[13] The Australian Concise Oxford Dictionary of Current English (Oxford University Press, 1987) For the purpose of section 58(2)(b)(i), a person refuses to receive the treatment, care or support if they decline to receive it, or express a determination not to receive it, or an unwillingness to receive it, whether by action or words. That meaning seems to include a notion of voluntariness which might ordinarily be premised on a person making an informed choice. In other words, a person would make an informed decision to refuse treatment. However, in our view, that approach is not appropriate because section 58(2)(b)(i) applies where the subject person does not have decision-making capacity to consent to the treatment, care or support. Refusal should be objectively assessed by reference to what the person says or does. Section 7 of the MH Act sets out the circumstances in which a person has capacity (with assistance) to make decisions in relation to their treatment, care or support for a mental illness. A person has decision-making capacity if they can:(a) understand when a decision about treatment, care or support for the person needs to be made; and(b) understand the facts that relate to the decision; and(c) understand the main choices available to the person in relation to the decision; and(d) weigh up the consequences of the main choices; and(e) understand how the consequences affect the person; and(f) on the basis of paragraphs (a) to (e), make the decision; and(g) communicate the decision in whatever way the person can.