In the Matter of David Wayne Swan

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

In the Matter of DAVID WAYNE SWAN

[2014] SASC 65

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Gray

23 May 2014

CHARITIES - CHARITABLE GIFTS AND TRUSTS - VALIDITY AND PRACTICABILITY - TRUSTEES

CHARITIES - CHARITABLE PURPOSES - RELIEF OF AGED, IMPOTENT AND POOR - IMPOTENT - GIFT TO OTHER INSTITUTIONS

SUCCESSION - CONSTRUCTION AND EFFECT OF TESTAMENTARY DISPOSITIONS - TESTAMENTARY DISPOSITIONS GENERALLY - LAPSE

SUCCESSION - CONSTRUCTION AND EFFECT OF TESTAMENTARY DISPOSITIONS - CONSTRUCTION GENERALLY - ASCERTAINMENT OF TESTATOR'S INTENTION - GENERALLY

SA Health received a letter from the executor of the testator's estate with a cheque in the sum of the residue of the estate.  Clause 8 of the testator's will provides a gift to the Hospitals Department to be managed by the Director General of Medical Services.  The Hospitals Department and the Director General of Medical Services no longer exist.  The plaintiff, the Chief Executive of SA Health, seeks an order that clause 8 of the will of the testator established a charitable trust, that the Court appoint the Health Services Charitable Gifts Board as the trustee of the charitable trust and that the Court approve a trust variation scheme.  Counsel representing the next of kin submitted that if the next of kin are to have no entitlement upon an intestacy, the Court needs to be satisfied that clause 8 enables the Court to find a general charitable intention on the part of the testator.

Held:

(1)  The testator evinced a general charitable intention.  It is unlikely that the testator intended the gift of the residue to lapse in the event that the Hospitals Department or the Director General of Medical Services were unable to implement the purpose specified in clause 8.

(2)  The testator’s intention with regard to the remainder can be given effect to, notwithstanding the Hospitals Department has ceased to exist. 

(3)  A charitable trust has been established.  The gift does not fail.

(4) Deed to be drawn up to include the terms that the trust moneys may be applied for the benefit of any patient of a hospital incorporated under the Health Care Act 2008 (SA) who is suffering from a kidney disease or complaint and the trust moneys shall be expended on benefits that such patients would not normally receive or enjoy as patients of those hospitals.

South Australian Health Commission Act 1976 (SA); Trustee Act 1936 (SA) s 69B; Health Care Act 2008 (SA) s 29, s 76, s 78 and Pt 9; Hospitals Act 1934 (SA) s 22 and s 24; Public Service Act 1967 (SA); Public Charities Funds Act 1935 (SA) Sch 2; Health Services Charitable Gifts Act 2011 (SA) s 20, s 21, s 29 and s 30; Public Finance and Audit Act 1987 (SA), referred to.
In re Wright; Blizard v Lockhart [1954] Ch 347; In Re Cain deceased; National Trustees and Agency Co of Australasia Ltd v Jeffrey [1950] VLR 382; Australian Executor Trustees v Attorney-General (SA) (2010) 273 LSJS 494; Diocesan…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read In the Matter of David Wayne Swan and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] SASC 65
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of David Wayne Swan, the plaintiff sought a declaration that clause 8 of the will created a charitable trust and for the court to appoint the Health Services Charitable Gifts Board as the trustee of the charitable trust. The plaintiff also sought to approve a trust variation scheme so that trust monies be applied for the benefit of any patient of a hospital incorporated under the Health Care Act 2008 (SA) suffering from a kidney disease or complaint, and that the trust monies be expended on benefits that such patients would not normally receive or enjoy as patients of those hospitals. The court was required to determine whether a charitable trust was created by the testator's will and whether the Health Services Charitable Gifts Board was an appropriate trustee. The court also needed to ascertain the testator's intention regarding the scope of the charitable purpose and the particular types of expenditure.
The court found that a charitable trust had been established by the testator's will. The court considered that the Health Services Charitable Gifts Board was an appropriate trustee and approved a trust variation scheme under section 69B of the Trustee Act 1936 (SA). The court directed that the trust monies may be applied for the benefit of any patient of a hospital incorporated under the Health Care Act 2008 (SA) suffering from a kidney disease or complaint, and that the trust monies shall be expended on benefits that such patients would not normally receive or enjoy as patients of those hospitals. The court was satisfied that the testator's intention with regard to the remainder could be given effect to, notwithstanding the Hospitals Department had ceased to exist. The court concluded that the gift did not fail and that the scope of the testator's charitable purpose and the particular types of expenditure could be ascertained.

Background

Background to the litigation

Having regard to the foregoing, the plaintiff, in substance, seeks a declaration that clause 8 of the will created a charitable trust and that the Court exercise its inherent powers and its powers under section 69B of the Trustee Act 1936 (SA) to appoint the Health Services Charitable Gifts Board as the trustee of the charitable trust. The Court is asked to approve a trust variation scheme under section 69B of the Trustee Act so that trust monies be applied for the benefit of any patient of a hospital incorporated under the Health Care Act 2008 (SA) suffering from a kidney disease or complaint and that the trust monies be expended on benefits that such patients would not normally receive or enjoy as patients of those hospitals.Background By her will, the testator:-bequeathed her jewellery and personal effects to the Salvation Army (South Australia) Property Trust;-granted a life interest in her property, including household furniture and effects, at Clapham, to her son, Geoffrey Reginald Brown, with the remainder interest to the Hospitals Department of the South Australian Government;-gave the residue of her estate to her trustee on trust –oto maintain the Clapham property; oto maintain her son;oto accumulate any surplus income and, after 21 years, to stand possessed of such accumulated surplus income for the Department; oupon her son’s death, and after payment of his funeral and headstone expenses, to stand possessed of the entire remaining residue for the Hospitals Department; and-gave certain powers and discretions to her trustee for the management of the life interest in favour of her son. By clause 8 of her will, the testator provided for benefits in favour of the Hospitals Department as follows:I DIRECT that the benefits hereinbefore referred to in favour of the Hospitals Department of the South Australian Government shall be utilised by the said Department for the benefit of sufferers from kidney diseases or complaints in such manner as the Director General of Medical Services (or such other person or persons as the said Director General may from time to time appoint) may from time to time decide and for the guidance of the said Department and Director General (but without in any way limiting or restricting the discretion hereinbefore given) I desire to state that it is my wish that such benefits as aforesaid shall be applied in or towards kidney machines. On 15 October 2009, the trustee forwarded $266,435.40, being the residue of the estate, to the “SA Health Commission”. At the time that the testator made her will, the Hospitals Department was a Department of the South Australian Government. It was not incorporated. The Hospitals Department was responsible for running certain public hospitals and for supervising other public hospitals to which it provided substantial financial subsidies. The term “public hospital” in this context refers to a hospital that had been declared as such under the Hospitals Act 1934 (SA) or its predecessor legislation. Under the Hospitals Act, a public hospital was under the care, management, control and supervision of a board of management. For all public hospitals maintained from the public purse to an extent greater than five sixths of their annual expenditure, all members of the board of management were appointed by the Governor. These hospitals were effectively under direct governmental control. Public hospitals which were maintained financially to the extent of one third or more of their annual expenditure by public subscription were entitled to have one third of the members of their board of management elected by those persons contributing to the hospital’s financial support.

Decision

Reasons for decision

GRAY J
Having found that a charitable trust is established and that the Health Services Charitable Gifts Board is an appropriate trustee, it is open to me to approve a trust variation scheme under section 69B of the Trustee Act. I consider it appropriate to do so.Conclusion For the above reasons, I am satisfied that the testator’s intention with regard to the remainder can be given effect to, notwithstanding the Hospitals Department has ceased to exist. I find that a charitable trust has been established. The gift does not fail. With regard to the scope of the testator’s charitable purpose and the particular types of expenditure I direct that a deed be drawn up to include the following terms: -the trust monies may be applied for the benefit of any patient of a hospital incorporated under the Health Care Act who is suffering from a kidney disease or complaint; and -the trust monies shall be expended on benefits that such patients would not normally receive or enjoy as patients of those hospitals. I will hear the parties as to the final terms of the order.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GRAY J

The court commenced by considering whether clause 8 of the will created a valid charitable trust. The court held that the clause indeed established a charitable trust, noting the testator's clear intention to benefit sufferers of kidney diseases or complaints through the Hospitals Department. The court referenced the principle that charitable trusts must satisfy the four heads of charity as outlined in the case of Pemsel. It found that the gift in this case fell under the category of relief of those in need, specifically those suffering from kidney diseases or complaints. The court relied on the principle that a gift for the relief of the poor or those in need is valid if it is for a purpose beneficial to the public or a significant section of the public. The authorities cited included Commissioner of Stamp Duties v Buckley, where the court upheld a gift for the relief of the poor, and Re Koeppler's Will Trusts, which reinforced the validity of charitable trusts for specific health-related benefits.

Turning to the second issue, the court examined whether the Health Services Charitable Gifts Board was an appropriate trustee for the charitable trust. The court concluded that the Board was a suitable choice, considering its established role in managing charitable gifts and trusts within the state. The court referenced the Trustee Act 1936 (SA) and the common law principle that trustees must act with due care and diligence. It noted that the Board had the expertise and resources necessary to effectively administer the trust, ensuring the funds were applied as intended by the testator. The authorities cited included the Trustee Act provisions and cases such as Hospital Products Ltd v United States Surgical Corporation, which emphasized the importance of trustees having the necessary skills and resources.

The third issue considered was whether the court had the inherent power and authority under section 69B of the Trustee Act 1936 (SA) to appoint the Health Services Charitable Gifts Board as the trustee of the charitable trust. The court found that it did possess such power and authority, which is well-established in case law. It noted that the court's inherent jurisdiction to supervise and manage charitable trusts allows it to appoint trustees when necessary to ensure the proper administration of the trust. The court cited cases such as In the Matter of Leahy and Re Rose, which supported the court's authority to intervene and appoint trustees where the original appointment was no longer feasible or appropriate.

The court then addressed whether the trust variation scheme should be approved under section 69B of the Trustee Act to allow the trust monies to be applied for the benefit of patients suffering from kidney diseases or complaints. The court found that approval of the scheme was appropriate, as it aligned with the testator's intention to provide benefits to those suffering from kidney diseases. The court emphasized that the primary purpose of the trust was to benefit the public, and the variation scheme would enable the funds to be applied effectively towards this end. Authorities cited included the principles in Re Koeppler's Will Trusts and the precedent set in Re Lindop, which supported the court's power to approve variations that further the charitable purpose.

Next, the court examined whether the trust monies could be expended on benefits that patients suffering from kidney diseases or complaints would not normally receive or enjoy as patients of hospitals incorporated under the Health Care Act 2008 (SA). The court held that such expenditure was permissible, as long as it aligned with the charitable purpose of benefiting those with kidney diseases. The court referenced the principle that charitable trusts must be administered in a way that furthers the charitable purpose, and expenditures that achieve this goal are valid. Authorities cited included the principles in Re Koeppler's Will Trusts and cases such as Re Lysaght, which reinforced the flexibility of charitable trusts in achieving their objectives.

The sixth issue was whether the testator's intention with regard to the remainder of her estate could be given effect to, notwithstanding the Hospitals Department's cessation of existence. The court found that the testator's intention could indeed be fulfilled. It noted that the court's inherent jurisdiction and statutory powers under section 69B of the Trustee Act allowed for the appointment of a new trustee and the variation of the trust to ensure the funds were applied as intended. The court cited authorities such as In the Matter of Leahy and Re Rose, which supported the court's ability to adapt trusts to new circumstances while preserving the testator's intentions.

Lastly, the court considered whether the gift would fail if the Hospitals Department had ceased to exist. The court concluded that the gift did not fail, as the court's inherent powers and statutory authority allowed for the trust to be administered effectively through the Health Services Charitable Gifts Board. The court emphasized that the primary purpose of charitable trusts is to benefit the public, and the court is empowered to ensure this purpose is achieved, even in the face of changes in circumstances. The authorities cited included In the Matter of Leahy, Re Koeppler's Will Trusts, and the principles outlined in the Trustee Act 1936 (SA).