In the matter of Bauskis

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read
CITATION: In the matter of BAUSKIS [2006] NSWSC 908
HEARING DATE(S): 28.7.06, 4.8.06, 23.8.06, 25.8.06
 
JUDGMENT DATE : 

25 August 2006
JURISDICTION: Common Law
JUDGMENT OF: Adams J at 1
EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT DATE: 08/25/2006
DECISION: Guilty of contempt of court.
PARTIES: John Peter BAUSKIS
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 2006/13638
COUNSEL: Mr R Cogswell SC, Crown Advocate
Contemnor unrepresented
SOLICITORS: I V Knight, Crown Solicitor
Contemnor unrepresented

Ex tempore - revised

THE SUPREME COURT


OF NEW SOUTH WALES


COMMON LAW DIVISION

ADAMS J

FRIDAY 25 AUGUST 2006

13638/06 – IN THE MATTER OF JOHN PETER BAUSKIS

JUDGMENT

1 HIS HONOUR: John Peter Bauskis is charged with contempt in the face of the Court. The particulars of that charge are that the Court having ordered that he should not remain in Court whilst wearing a T-shirt containing the words in large letters "Trial by jury is democracy" he refused to leave the Court and refused a lawful direction to leave made by the officers of the Sheriff. When asked to plead Mr Bauskis declined to do so and, accordingly, exercising the powers of the Court, I entered a plea of not guilty.

2 The circumstances arose out of litigation commenced by one John Wilson and one Eric Jury. The essence of the actions which were commenced by these persons was that they were entitled in the particular circumstances alleged to have a trial by jury. The defendants were instrumentalities of the State of New South Wales. The Crown Solicitor, acting on behalf of the defendants, filed notices of motion seeking summary judgment or to strike out the statements of claim. Those notices of motion, which were filed on or about the 18 July 2006, specified a return date of 24 July 2006.

3 In accordance with the usual practice these, together with other matters appropriate for the duty judge to determine, were called over by the Registrar of this Court. At the time the Registrar did so, a large number of persons, perhaps between twenty and thirty, attended in his Court. It is clear that they were supporters of the plaintiffs, namely, Mr Wilson and Mr Jury. Many wore T-shirts of a kind which has been exhibited in these proceedings and which was worn by Mr Bauskis, containing in large letters the slogan “Trial by jury is democracy”. It is inescapable that their coming to the Registrar's Court was by way of supporting Mr Wilson and Mr Jury in their attempts to resist the applications to which I have referred. When the Registrar referred the matter to me, as duty judge, Mr Wilson, Mr Jury and the group which I have mentioned came to Court 2 where it was intended I should sit.

4 When the Court convened the matters were called. Mr Weinstein announced his appearance for the applicants on the notices of motion. Mr Wilson at the bar table, wearing the T-shirt to which I have referred, demanded a jury. I said, "I'm afraid you cannot have one". He said,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read In the matter of Bauskis and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] NSWSC 908
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Bauskis, the contemnor, John Peter Bauskis, was found guilty of contempt of court. The proceedings were initiated when Bauskis, along with several others, attended the court wearing T-shirts bearing the slogan "Trial by jury is democracy". The court had previously ruled that such attire was inappropriate and ordered that the individuals remove the T-shirts or leave the courtroom. Bauskis refused to comply with this order, leading to his arrest and subsequent charge of contempt of court.

The court had to determine whether Bauskis' refusal to leave or remove his T-shirt constituted contempt. The legal issues involved interpreting the inherent jurisdiction of the court to maintain order in its proceedings and assessing whether Bauskis' conduct interfered with the administration of justice. The court found that Bauskis' actions, including his refusal to comply with a lawful court order and his participation in disruptive and abusive behaviour, constituted contempt in the face of the court.

Adams J found Bauskis guilty of contempt beyond reasonable doubt, noting that Bauskis had knowingly disobeyed a clear and lawful court order. The judge highlighted the importance of maintaining order in the courtroom and the authority of the court to enforce its rules. Bauskis' argument that the court's order was unlawful and his refusal to comply with it was justified by his support for the right to trial by jury were rejected. The court's decision underscores the necessity of respecting court orders to ensure the proper functioning of the judicial system.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves John Peter Bauskis who is charged with contempt in the face of the Court. The particulars of the charge state that the Court had ordered Bauskis not to remain in Court while wearing a T-shirt with the words "Trial by jury is democracy" in large letters. Despite being asked to leave the Court and being given a lawful direction to do so by the officers of the Sheriff, Bauskis refused to comply. When asked to plead, Bauskis declined to do so, leading the Court to enter a plea of not guilty on his behalf. The circumstances of the case arose out of litigation initiated by John Wilson and Eric Jury, who claimed a right to a trial by jury against the State of New South Wales. The defendants in those actions filed notices of motion seeking summary judgment or to strike out the statements of claim. When the matter was called before the Court, a large number of individuals, supporters of Wilson and Jury, attended wearing T-shirts with the same slogan as Bauskis. These individuals disrupted the proceedings by shouting abuse and making offensive statements about corruption. The Court was in uproar and the Judge directed the individuals to leave the Court while wearing their T-shirts. Bauskis, among others, refused to comply with the order and was subsequently arrested.

The matter came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales, Common Law Division, presided over by Adams J. The hearing took place over several dates in August 2006. The Crown Advocate represented the Crown, while Bauskis appeared unrepresented. Prior to this hearing, notices of motion seeking summary judgment or to strike out the statements of claim had been filed by the Crown Solicitor on behalf of the defendants in the underlying litigation. The Court had previously ordered the removal of individuals wearing T-shirts with the slogan "Trial by jury is democracy" from the courtroom to maintain order and decorum.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the contemnor, Bauskis, was aware of the Court's order and deliberately disobeyed it, constituting contempt of court.
2. Whether the contemnor's conduct, including his refusal to remove the T-shirt and his verbal defiance, amounted to contempt in the face of the Court.
3. If the contemnor's actions were justified as a form of lawful protest or if they undermined the administration of justice.

Held
1. The court held that the contemnor, Bauskis, was aware of the Court's order and deliberately disobeyed it, constituting contempt of court.
2. The court held that the contemnor's conduct, including his refusal to remove the T-shirt and his verbal defiance, amounted to contempt in the face of the Court.
3. The court held that the contemnor's actions did not qualify as a form of lawful protest and that they did undermine the administration of justice.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court was faced with the task of determining whether Bauskis' conduct amounted to contempt of court. The central issue was whether Bauskis was aware of the Court's order to remove his T-shirt and deliberately disobeyed it, constituting contempt. The court found that Bauskis was indeed aware of the order and chose to disobey it, which was a clear instance of contempt. This was evidenced by his refusal to remove the T-shirt and his verbal defiance when directed by the Sheriff's officers. The court further established that Bauskis' conduct, including his refusal to leave the courtroom and his verbal abuse, amounted to contempt in the face of the Court. The court emphasized that such conduct was not only disrespectful but also had the potential to undermine the administration of justice by instilling fear and attempting to intimidate the judge. The court rejected Bauskis' argument that his actions were justified as a form of lawful protest, noting that the right to trial by jury was a matter to be addressed through legislative means, not by disrupting court proceedings. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that deliberate disobedience of a court order, coupled with defiant and disruptive behaviour in the courtroom, constitutes contempt of court and undermines the administration of justice.