In the matter of an Application by Thomas John Saunders

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

In the matter of an application by Thomas John Saunders

[2011] NTSC 63

PARTIES:   THE LEGAL PROFESSION ACT 2006

AND

IN THE MATTER OF AN APPLICATION BY

SAUNDERS, Thomas John

TITLE OF COURT:   SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY

JURISDICTION:   SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY EXERCISING TERRITORY JURISDICTION

FILE NO:   LP 10 of 2010 (21019407)

DELIVERED:   25 AUGUST 2011

HEARING DATES:   18 & 19 AUGUST 2011

JUDGMENT OF:   RILEY CJ

CATCHWORDS:

LEGAL PRACTITIONERS (NORTHERN TERRITORY) – application for admission to practise – application opposed by the Law Society – whether the applicant is of good fame and character – whether the applicant is a fit and proper person – prior conviction – partial disclosure – attempt to minimise culpability – application dismissed.

Criminal Code(Cth), s 135(2)(1); Legal Profession Act, s 11, s 25(2)(b) and s 32(1),(3); Legal Profession Admission Rules, r 10and r 18

Re Hampton [2002] QCA 129; Re OG (A Lawyer) (2007) 18 VR 164; Thomas v Legal Practitioners Admission Board (2005) 1 Qd R 331, applied.

Incorporated Law Institute of New South Wales v Meagher (1909) 9 CLR 655; Re Deo (2005) 16 NTLR 102; Wentworth v The New South Wales Bar Association (1992) 176 CLR 239 followed.

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Applicant:   M Crawley (appearing amicus curiae)

Respondent:   D McConnel

Solicitors:

Applicant:   Self Represented

Respondent:   Law Society of the Northern Territory

Judgment category classification:    B

Judgment ID Number:   Ril1109

Number of pages:   19

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
OF AUSTRALIA
AT DARWIN

In the matter of an application by Thomas John Saunders

[2011] NTSC 63

No. LP 10 of 2010 (21019407)

IN THE MATTER OF:

THE LEGAL PROFESSION ACT 2006

AND:

IN THE MATTER OF AN APPLICATION BY

THOMAS JOHN SAUNDERS

CORAM:     RILEY CJ

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(Delivered 25 August 2011)

  1. The applicant seeks admission to the Supreme Court as a local lawyer pursuant to the provisions of the Legal Profession Act.  The Admissions Board considered the application and, pursuant to s 32 of the Act, resolved to refer to the Court the question of whether the applicant was a fit and proper person to be admitted. 

  2. The Law Society of the Northern Territory opposed the application for admission on three grounds:

    (1)     the applicant has been convicted of offences of dishonesty and the circumstances of the offences, the period over which the offending occurred and their relatively recent occurrence mean that he is not at this time a fit and proper person for admission;

    (2)     the applicant gave a misleading account of facts and circumstances surrounding the commission of the offences to the Court of Summary Jurisdiction for the purposes of obtaining a reduced penalty and as such, demonstrated a lack of candour which, though not tendered for the purposes of this application, nevertheless indicates that he is not at this time a fit and proper person for admission;

    (3)     the applicant: (i) swore an affidavit that he had given full disclosure of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read In the matter of an Application by Thomas John Saunders and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NTSC 63
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Thomas John Saunders applied for admission to practise as a legal practitioner in the Northern Territory. The application was opposed by the Law Society, which raised concerns about Saunders' fitness to practise due to prior criminal convictions. The court had to decide whether Saunders was of good fame and character and fit and proper to practise law. The main legal issues were whether Saunders had demonstrated his current fitness to practise and whether his past criminal conduct had been adequately disclosed and addressed.

The court found that Saunders had not provided a candid account of his past criminal conduct and had attempted to minimise his culpability. Saunders had pleaded guilty to charges of dishonestly obtaining benefits, indicating that he was aware of the criminal nature of his actions. Despite this, Saunders claimed he did not consider his actions to be a criminal offence because he intended to repay the money. The court rejected this defence, holding that Saunders was fully aware of the criminality of his actions at the time of the offending. Furthermore, Saunders had not provided any evidence of rehabilitation or improvement in his conduct since the convictions. The court concluded that Saunders had not demonstrated that he was now a fit and proper person to practise law.

In light of the findings, the court dismissed the application. The court held that Saunders had failed to show that he was of good fame and character and fit and proper to be admitted as a legal practitioner. The court emphasised the importance of honesty and integrity in the legal profession, and found that Saunders' past conduct and lack of candour undermined his application. The final orders of the court were that Saunders' application for admission to practise as a legal practitioner in the Northern Territory was dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Thomas John Saunders, a law student in his mid-20s, applied for admission to practice law in the Northern Territory. His application was opposed by the Law Society, which questioned whether Saunders was of good fame and character and a fit and proper person to be admitted. The opposition stemmed from Saunders' prior criminal convictions for failing to declare income received while also receiving government benefits, an offence under the Social Security Act 1991 (Cth). Saunders pleaded guilty to these charges and was convicted.

In the years leading up to his offending, Saunders had received benefits while also having occasional employment. He was aware of the necessity to complete disclosure of earnings forms to ensure the correct entitlement was calculated and received. Over a period of six years, he had previously complied with this obligation. However, during the period of his offending, he deliberately failed to declare his income, despite receiving multiple reminders from Centrelink. Saunders claimed he was unaware that such a failure constituted a criminal offence, believing that as long as he repaid the money, the matter would end there. However, the court found his evidence to be unconvincing, noting his past experience with the Social Security system and his acknowledgement that his conduct was "wrong".

The Board considered the material provided by Saunders but was not satisfied that he was a fit and proper person. They referred the matter to the Court under s 32(1) of the Legal Profession Act. During the proceedings, Saunders provided limited evidence of his conduct and behaviour during the intervening period, only detailing his employment history. He worked as a clerk in a firm of solicitors in Sydney and volunteered at the Aboriginal Legal Service for three months. However, there was no evidence to show how this employment contributed to his rehabilitation or demonstrated his recognition and efforts to address his past misconduct. The court concluded that Saunders had not provided a candid account of the commission of the offences and had not demonstrated that he was now a fit and proper person for admission. Consequently, the application was dismissed.

Thomas John Saunders filed an application for admission to practise law, which was opposed by the Law Society on the grounds that he was not of good fame and character and was not a fit and proper person to be admitted. This opposition was based on Saunders' prior conviction for offences of dishonesty. The application was initially considered by the Board, which was not satisfied that Saunders was a fit and proper person to be admitted and subsequently referred the matter to the Court under section 32(1) of the Legal Profession Act. The Court heard evidence from Saunders, who claimed that he was unaware his conduct constituted a criminal offence, despite having prior experience with the Social Security system and being a law student at the time of the offending. The Court found Saunders' evidence unconvincing, noting his awareness of the wrongfulness of his actions and his acknowledgment that failure to disclose income could result in criminal charges. Saunders' application for admission was ultimately dismissed as he failed to provide sufficient evidence of rehabilitation and did not demonstrate that he was now a fit and proper person to be admitted to practice law.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Board considered the whole of the material provided by the applicant and was not satisfied that he was a fit and proper person. The Board was not prepared to grant a compliance certificate and referred the matter to the Court pursuant to s 32(1) of the Legal Profession Act. The evidence of the applicant The applicant was called to give evidence in the proceedings. He adopted and relied upon the information provided in the affidavits filed on his behalf including the disclosure statement. In his evidence the applicant confirmed that in the years prior to the offending he had been in receipt of benefits at the same time as having occasional employment. He was aware that it was necessary to complete disclosure of earnings forms to ensure the correct entitlement was calculated and received. He had previously done so over a period of some six years. The applicant claimed he had no idea that a deliberate failure to declare income was a criminal matter. He said he believed that as long as he repaid the money that would be the end of the matter. When pressed in cross-examination regarding his claim that he was not aware that a deliberate failure to declare income would constitute a criminal offence he responded that he was aware that it would do so "in an abstract sense”, but that he "believed that as long as the money was repaid then it wasn't a criminal act as such". He said he "didn't even think about it as a criminal act". He then said that he knew that what he was doing "was wrong, but I didn't think of it in terms of the criminal act." When the issue was revisited later in his evidence, the applicant agreed that it was likely that there was a warning on the forms he completed indicating that failure to disclose such information would amount to an offence. However he maintained that, although he knew what he was doing was wrong, he did not, at that time, think about whether it constituted a criminal offence. He was obviously aware of the criminal nature of his conduct at the time of his application for admission. I do not accept the evidence of the applicant that he was not, at the time of the offending, aware that his conduct would amount to a criminal offence. The applicant was a law student in his mid-20s. He was an intelligent person who had been involved with the Social Security system for a period in excess of six years. He had, in the past, been placed in the situation where he received benefits during a period when he also had some work. As he acknowledged, he was fully aware of the obligation to declare income received and he had complied with this obligation on the earlier occasion over a substantial period of time. During the period of his offending he had been sent several letters reminding him of his obligation to advise Centrelink if he commenced paid work.[13] In cross-examination he acknowledged that he knew his conduct was "wrong" but said that he "never followed beyond that in my head". He knew that Centrelink was not a body from which he could seek a loan. He acknowledged that he was aware that a deliberate failure to declare income was a criminal offence "in an abstract sense", but asserted that his belief was that "as long as the money was repaid it wasn't a criminal act as such". Notwithstanding his belief, he pleaded guilty to the offence. It was submitted that he treated the overpayment as a loan. The highest he put it in his instructions as recorded by his solicitor, which were placed before the Court, was that: His past experience was that if he worked for a period and subsequently disclosed this, this would be raised as a debt that he would need to repay, it would not result in a prosecution.[14]

Decision

Reasons for decision

It is not disputed that the nature of the offending meant that the applicant was not a fit and proper person to be admitted at the time of the offending. The issue is whether he is a fit and proper person at this time. The applicant has not provided either the Board or the Court with any substantive information regarding his conduct and behaviour during the intervening period. Nothing of substance has been placed before the Court to demonstrate his rehabilitation. In his evidence before the Court he simply described his employment history during the period. This included work in Sydney, both as a clerk with a firm of solicitors, and work on a voluntary basis with the Aboriginal Legal Service for three months. Other than providing a record of employment, there was no evidence as to how that employment was relevant to his rehabilitation. There was no evidence as to how, or to what extent, the applicant had recognised and sought to address his rehabilitation. Following the recording of the convictions, in the circumstances of this case it is not sufficient for the applicant to rely solely upon the lapse of time. It is necessary for the applicant to demonstrate that whilst he was not a fit and proper person at the time of the offending, he is now a fit and proper person to be admitted as a local lawyer. He has not done so.Conclusions In my opinion the applicant has failed to provide the Board and this Court with a candid account of the commission of the offences and, as such, is not at this time a fit and proper person for admission. In addition he has been convicted of offences of dishonesty which, at the time of commission, demonstrated that he was not a fit and proper person for admission. There has been no evidence placed before the Court to enable a conclusion to be drawn that he is now a fit and proper person for admission. I am not satisfied that the applicant is of good fame and character and a fit and proper person to be admitted to practice. The application is dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the matter of an application by Thomas John Saunders, the court was tasked with determining whether the applicant was of good fame and character and a fit and proper person to be admitted as a local lawyer. The application was opposed by the Law Society, which argued that the applicant did not meet the necessary standards for admission. The court considered several key issues in its reasoning.

First, the court examined whether the applicant was of good fame and character. The applicant had a history of convictions for dishonesty, which are pertinent to the evaluation of his character. The court noted that the nature of the offending meant that the applicant was not a fit and proper person to be admitted at the time of the offending. The court scrutinized the applicant's past convictions and his conduct during the period leading up to the application. It found that the applicant had not provided a candid account of the commission of the offences. The court found his explanations unconvincing, particularly regarding his awareness of the criminal nature of his actions. The applicant claimed he was unaware that a deliberate failure to declare income was a criminal matter, but the court found this assertion to be implausible given his previous experience and intelligence.

Second, the court assessed whether the applicant was a fit and proper person to be admitted as a local lawyer. The applicant's past convictions of dishonesty were significant in this regard. The court applied the principle that past conduct is a critical factor in determining fitness to practise law. The court also considered the authority of previous cases which established that dishonesty is a serious concern in assessing fitness to practise. Given the applicant's history of dishonesty, the court concluded that he was not a fit and proper person for admission at the time of the offending.

Third, the court examined whether the applicant had demonstrated rehabilitation and was now a fit and proper person for admission. The applicant had to provide evidence of positive changes and behaviour over the intervening period. However, the court found that the applicant had not provided any substantive information regarding his conduct and behaviour during this period. The court noted that merely relying on the passage of time was insufficient. The applicant's evidence of his employment history did not demonstrate any significant steps towards rehabilitation. Without such evidence, the court could not conclude that the applicant had transformed into a fit and proper person.

Fourth, the court evaluated whether the applicant had provided a candid account of the commission of the offences. The applicant's evidence was inconsistent and evasive, particularly regarding his understanding of the criminal nature of his actions. The court found that the applicant had not demonstrated the level of honesty and transparency required to be deemed a fit and proper person for admission. The applicant's attempts to minimise his culpability were unconvincing.

Fifth, the court considered whether the applicant's past convictions of dishonesty demonstrated that he was not a fit and proper person for admission at the time of the offending. The court relied on legal principles and authorities that established the seriousness of dishonesty in assessing fitness to practise. Given the applicant's history of dishonest conduct, the court concluded that these convictions demonstrated that he was not a fit and proper person for admission at the time.

Finally, the court assessed whether the applicant had provided sufficient evidence to demonstrate his rehabilitation and suitability for admission. The court noted the lack of substantive evidence regarding the applicant's conduct and behaviour during the intervening period. The court found that the applicant had not provided sufficient evidence to demonstrate that he was now a fit and proper person for admission. Without such evidence, the court could not grant the application.

In conclusion, the court found that the applicant had failed to provide a candid account of the commission of the offences and had not demonstrated sufficient rehabilitation. The court was not satisfied that the applicant was of good fame and character and a fit and proper person to be admitted to practice. Therefore, the application was dismissed. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that an applicant with a history of dishonesty must provide clear and convincing evidence of rehabilitation and suitability for admission to practise law.