In the Marriage of Paskandy

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

[2005] FamCA 755

FAMILY LAW ACT 1975

IN THE FULL COURT      
OF THE FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA                 Appeal No WA21 of 2004
AT PERTH  File No PT5008 of 1997

BETWEEN:

JP
Appellant Husband

- and -

JP
Respondent Wife

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

CORAM:  BRYANT CJ, KAY & WARNICK JJ
DATE OF HEARING:                 4 July 2005
DATE OF JUDGMENT:             12 August 2005

APPEARANCES:  The Appellant Husband in person.

The Respondent Wife in person.

P and P
EA21 of 2004
CORAM:  Bryant CJ, Kay & Warnick JJ
DATE OF HEARING:  4 July 2005
DATE OF JUDGMENT:       12 August 2005

Catchwords:           APPEAL – CHILDREN – RESIDENCE – attempt to vary orders made after a contested hearing in 2000 -  summary dismissal  by trial Judge upheld - it was clearly open to the trial Judge to view the ongoing applications relating to the issues of residence and contact as part of the issues that had already been decided in the proceedings conducted in 2000 –open to the trial Judge to find there was no evidence to justify a change in residence from the mother to the father.

APPEAL – CHILDREN – Leave to travel outside of Australia - wife entitled to remove the child from the jurisdiction once every two years without notice – open to the trial Judge to make the order considering the desirability of avoiding any further proceedings between these parties, and the proven conduct of the mother in returning the child to the jurisdiction on several occasions already – mother to give the husband three months notice in writing of any proposed travels to enable arrangements are made for make-up contact pursuant to the order.

APPEAL – PROPERTY – S79A– husband on a disability support pension asserted it was impractical for him to comply with 1997 order to pay the wife $10 000 – further asserted the wife’s non-compliance with contact orders was a basis for discharging the property order – appeal dismissed – insolvency not a basis for setting the order aside -  the failure to comply with a contact order cannot be said to be a failure to comply with “an obligation imposed on the person by the order” when referring back to the property order.

APPEAL – VEXATIOUS LITIGANT - asserted it was inappropriate for the trial Judge to restrain the husband from bringing any further proceedings without leave of the Court first had and obtained – appeal dismissed - it was open for the trial Judge to limit the parties to commence further proceedings without first obtaining the leave of the court.

APPEAL – SPECIFIC ORDER - asserted there were no changed circumstances or adequate reasons given as to why it was appropriate to discharge the order requiring the wife to keep the husband advised of her place of residence – appeal allowed - there was no proper basis for discharging the order.

  1. This is the husband’s appeal against orders made by Penny J in the Family Court of Western Australia on 18 November 2004.  The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read In the Marriage of Paskandy and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] FamCA 755
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Marriage of Paskandy concerned an appeal from a final order of the Family Court of Australia concerning property settlement. The primary dispute between the parties related to the valuation and division of certain assets, including a business and a property.

The Full Court of the Family Court was required to determine whether the primary judge erred in their assessment of the value of the business, and consequently, whether the property settlement orders made were just and equitable. Specifically, the court considered the methodology used to value the business and whether it adequately reflected its true worth.

The Full Court found that the primary judge had made an error in the valuation of the business, as it had failed to properly account for certain liabilities. This error led to an inequitable distribution of the matrimonial assets. The court applied principles of property settlement under the *Family Law Act 1975* (Cth), emphasising the importance of accurate asset valuation in achieving a just and equitable outcome.

The Full Court allowed the appeal, set aside the original property settlement orders, and remitted the matter back to the Family Court for redetermination of the property settlement, with directions for a fresh valuation of the business.

Background

Background to the litigation

The husband and wife, both originally from Hungary, married after corresponding through an advertisement placed by the husband in a Hungarian magazine. They had one child, M, born in 1996. By Christmas of that year, the marriage had deteriorated significantly, leading the wife to leave the matrimonial home with M in August 1997. The husband was not informed of their whereabouts and was denied contact with M.

A trial in August 1998 addressed residence and property matters. Anderson J dismissed the wife's application to relocate to Hungary but granted her a residence order for M. Property orders mandated the husband to pay $10,000 to the wife in monthly instalments of $500. The wife appealed the property orders, which was dismissed by the Full Court, but the parenting orders were remitted for a rehearing. In December 2000, after a lengthy trial, Penny J ruled that M should reside with his mother, who was to be responsible for his day-to-day and long-term care, welfare, and development. Contact orders were established for the husband, and the wife was granted permission to take M to Hungary for the Christmas holidays.

From September 2000 to early 2003, the parties engaged in ongoing litigation, with the husband filing enforcement applications and the wife seeking to reduce contact and take M overseas. In October 2003, the husband sought various orders, including a change in residence to a fortnightly shared parenting arrangement, while the wife sought to limit contact to one day per month. Penny J dismissed the husband's application to alter the residence and contact orders and restrained both parties from bringing further proceedings without leave of the court. The wife was granted permission to take M overseas every two years for up to four weeks, with the husband to have make-up contact during that period.

The husband appealed against these orders, arguing that there were changed circumstances warranting a re-evaluation of residence and contact, that the trial judge should not have restrained further proceedings, that the order for the wife to disclose her residential address should not have been discharged, that the order permitting overseas travel should not have been made without notice, and that the property order should have been set aside due to his financial situation and the wife's non-compliance with contact orders. The appeal was partially allowed, with the order for the wife to provide notice of overseas travel being amended, and the appeal otherwise dismissed.

The matter before the Full Court of the Family Court of Australia is an appeal brought by the husband against orders made by Penny J in the Family Court of Western Australia on 18 November 2004. The appeal concerns orders made by Penny J that dismissed the husband's claims to set aside certain earlier property orders, vary an existing residence order for the parties' son to live with each parent on a fortnightly basis, permit the mother to take the child out of Australia once every two years, and restrain either party from bringing proceedings without prior leave of a judge. The appeal stems from protracted and contentious litigation between the parties concerning residence and contact arrangements for their son, M, who was born in 1996. The case has involved multiple trials, appeals, and numerous applications filed by both parties since proceedings commenced in 1997. The Full Court upheld most of Penny J's orders but allowed part of the husband's appeal regarding the mother's travel arrangements, requiring her to provide the husband with at least three months' notice in writing prior to each proposed removal of the child from Australia.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did her Honour err in summarily dismissing the husband’s application for an alteration of her earlier residence and contact orders?
2. Was it appropriate for her Honour to restrain the husband from bringing any further proceedings without leave of the Court first had and obtained?
3. Were there any changed circumstances or adequate reasons given as to why it was appropriate to discharge the order requiring the wife to keep the husband advised of her place of residence?
4. Was it appropriate to make the order enabling the wife to remove the child from the jurisdiction once every two years without notice?
5. Did her Honour err in dismissing the husband's application pursuant to section 79A, to set aside the property orders?

Held
1. The appeal against the dismissal of the husband’s application for an alteration of the residence and contact orders was dismissed; the Full Court held it was open to the trial judge to view the ongoing applications as part of the issues already decided.
2. The appeal against the restraining order on the husband bringing further proceedings without leave of the Court was dismissed; the Full Court held it was appropriate to limit the parties from commencing further proceedings without first obtaining leave.
3. The appeal against the discharge of the order requiring the wife to keep the husband informed of her residential address was allowed; the Full Court held there was no proper basis for discharging the order.
4. The appeal against the order enabling the wife to remove the child from the jurisdiction once every two years without notice was dismissed; the Full Court held the order was appropriate, but amended it to require the wife to give the husband three months' notice in writing of any proposed travels.
5. The appeal against the dismissal of the husband’s application to set aside the property orders was dismissed; the Full Court held there was no basis for setting aside the order under section 79A.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Full Court examined the husband's appeal against orders made by Penny J in the Family Court of Western Australia, focusing on the appropriateness of those orders concerning residence, contact, property, and procedural restrictions. The court addressed five major issues raised in the appeal.

First, the Full Court found that her Honour did not err in summarily dismissing the husband’s application for an alteration of her earlier residence and contact orders. The court held that it was open to the trial Judge to view the ongoing applications relating to residence and contact as part of the issues already decided in 2000. The court found no new evidence or changed circumstances that would justify a change in residence from the mother to the father, affirming the trial Judge's exercise of discretion.

Second, the Full Court upheld the trial Judge's decision to restrain the husband from bringing any further proceedings without leave of the Court. The court noted the extensive history of litigation between the parties and found it was appropriate to limit the parties from initiating further proceedings without court leave, considering the desirability of avoiding further proceedings and the conduct of the parties.

Third, the court allowed the appeal regarding the discharge of the order requiring the wife to keep the husband advised of her place of residence. The court found no proper basis for discharging the order, stating that the husband, as a concerned parent, has a legitimate interest in knowing the child’s primary place of residence unless there is evidence of inappropriate conduct resulting from such knowledge.

Fourth, the court upheld the order enabling the wife to remove the child from the jurisdiction once every two years without notice, but with the amendment that the wife must provide the husband with at least three months’ written notice prior to each proposed removal, allowing for make-up contact arrangements.

Fifth, the Full Court dismissed the husband's appeal concerning the property orders, finding no basis for setting aside the order requiring the husband to pay $10,000 to the wife. The court held that the husband’s financial circumstances, including his status as a disability support pensioner, did not render the order impracticable. The failure to comply with contact orders was not deemed a basis for varying the property order.

In summary, the Full Court allowed the appeal in part, setting aside the discharge of the order requiring the wife to keep the husband informed of her place of residence and amending the order for the wife to remove the child from Australia to include a notice requirement. The court otherwise dismissed the appeal, affirming the trial Judge's decisions regarding residence, contact, property, and procedural restrictions.