In the marriage of LENEHAN, G.H.R. and LENEHAN, J.I.
(1987) FLC ¶91-814
Other publishers' citations: (1987) 11 FamLR 615
In the Full Court of the Family Court at Brisbane.
Judgment delivered 30 April, 1987.
Before: Fogarty, Maxwell and Gun JJ.
Fogarty, Maxwell and Gun JJ.: By notice of appeal dated 18 July 1986 Janet Irving Lenehan has appealed against orders which were made by Mr Justice Lambert on 20 June 1986 after a trial before him on 3 to 6 February 1986. For the sake of convenience we will refer to the parties as ``husband'' and ``wife'' respectively although they have in fact been divorced for several years.
The proceeding before his Honour was an application by the wife under sec. 79 of the Family Law Act. The effect of his Honour's orders is to require the husband to pay to the wife the sum of $72,000 within two months. The orders went on to provide that in default of that payment the former matrimonial home registered in the name of the husband was to be sold and the proceeds divided as to $72,000 to the wife and the balance to the husband.
The appeal as conducted before us raised several individual issues which we will deal with separately. In those circumstances it is sufficient for present purposes to outline relatively briefly the facts as found by his Honour and then turn to the individual issues which were raised on behalf of the appellant.
The parties were married on 10 February 1963. They separated on 25 September 1982, although there had been a previous separation of about six months in the first half of 1980. The parties were divorced by this Court on 4 January 1984. There are four children born of the marriage namely S, born in 1962 and now aged 24, R, born in 1964 and now aged 22, G, born in October 1970 and now aged 16 years and D, born in July 1972 and now aged 14 years. After separation S remained living in the former matrimonial home with the husband until 1985 and R has remained living in that home throughout the period to the trial. Neither of those children is dependent on the parties. G and D divide their time between their parents. Both are attending private schools, G in grade 12 and D in grade 9 in 1986. At the time of the trial the husband was aged 54 and the wife 45.
At the time of marriage the husband was a pharmacist employed by his father. The wife was then employed in a secretarial position but ceased that employment approximately six months after the marriage due to the impending birth of their first child. She resumed permanent employment when she commenced nursing training in 1974. However during the intervening period to 1974 she engaged in periods of casual employment cleaning, sewing, typing and ironing.
At the time of marriage the husband owned a block of land at Taringa then valued at…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read In the Marriage of Lenehan and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1987] FamCA 8
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Full Court was required to determine whether the trial judge erred in their assessment of the parties' contributions, both financial and non-financial, to the marriage and the acquisition, conservation, and improvement of their property. A key issue was the appropriate weight to be given to Mrs Lenehan's significant non-financial contributions as a homemaker and parent, particularly in light of the parties' differing financial contributions during the marriage. The court also had to consider whether the final property division was just and equitable.
The Full Court found that the trial judge had placed undue emphasis on the financial contributions of the parties and had not adequately recognised the substantial non-financial contributions of Mrs Lenehan. The judges applied the principles established in relevant High Court and Full Court authorities, which mandate a holistic approach to property division, requiring the court to consider all relevant contributions of each party. They reasoned that a failure to properly weigh these non-financial contributions could lead to an unjust and inequitable outcome.
Consequently, the Full Court upheld the appeal, setting aside the original property settlement orders. The matter was remitted back to a single judge for redetermination of the property settlement, with directions to give due weight to Mrs Lenehan's non-financial contributions.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi