In the Estate of Wilson: Application for Executor’s Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

In the Estate of Wilson: Application for Executor’s Commission

Citation: 

[2023] ACTSC 186

Hearing Date: 

On the papers

Decision Date: 

19 July 2023

Before:

Curtin AJ

Decision: 

(1) The application in proceedings filed on 8 June 2023 is dismissed.

(2) The costs of the application shall be paid out of the estate of the deceased on the indemnity basis.

Catchwords: 

WILLS, PROBATE & ADMINISTRATION – Executors – claim for commission – s 70 of the Administration and Probate Act 1929 (ACT) – discretion of the Court – whether the evidence establishes that the responsibility, anxiety and worry of administering the estate is beyond what would ordinarily be required – whether the task of administering an estate is onerous – office of executor is prima facie a gratuitous one – application dismissed

Legislation Cited: 

Administration and Probate Act 1929 (ACT), s 70
Court Procedure Rules 2006 (ACT), r 2748

Cases Cited: 

In the Estate of Woodrow: Application for Executor’s Commission [2023] ACTSC 129

Parties: 

Brian Peter Munn ( Applicant)

Representation: 

Solicitor

Griffin Legal ( Applicant)

File Number:

PRO 263 of 2023

CURTIN AJ:  

Introduction

1․This is an application brought by the administrator (Mr Munn) of the estate of the late William Ernest Wilson pursuant to s 70 of the Administration and Probate Act 1929 (ACT) (the PAA Act) and r 2748 of the Court Procedure Rules 2006 (ACT) (the Rules) seeking an Order allowing him commission to be paid out of the assets of the estate.

2․For the reasons set out below the application is refused. That is essentially because, in layman’s terms, administrators usually work for free. They may sometimes be entitled to a commission, but that is exceptional and usually only occurs where the task of administering an estate is onerous, or where the responsibility, anxiety and worry of administering the estate is beyond what would ordinarily be required. The evidence does not establish any of those factors.

3․I appreciate Mr Munn is of limited means and undertook his task voluntarily and generously without any expectation of reward. However, the law does not allow me to reward that generosity in the circumstances proved on the evidence provided.

Principles

4․In the Estate of Woodrow: Application for Executor’s Commission [2023] ACTSC 129, I set out the applicable principles regarding the awarding of commissions to executors and administrators. To avoid the need for extensive cross-referencing I set out what I there said at [2]-[3] and [5]-[32]:

2. Section 70 of the PAA Act says:

70 Executors etc may be allowed commission

The Supreme Court may allow out of the assets of a deceased person to the person’s executor, administrator or trustee the commission or percentage for his or her services that is just.

3.     Rule 2748 of the Court Procedure Rules 2006 (ACT) relevantly says:

2748Estate of trust accounts—application for commission

(1)If an executor or administrator of an estate applies for an order for the allowance of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read In the Estate of Wilson: Application for Executor’s Commissi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] ACTSC 186
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involved an application by Brian Peter Munn, the administrator of the estate of the late William Ernest Wilson, seeking an order for the allowance of commission under section 70 of the Administration and Probate Act 1929 (ACT). The application was brought pursuant to rule 2748 of the Court Procedure Rules 2006 (ACT). The primary legal issue before the court was whether the administrator was entitled to a commission for his work in administering the estate. The court needed to determine if the evidence established that the task of administering the estate was onerous or if the responsibility, anxiety, and worry of administering the estate was beyond what would ordinarily be required.

The court began by outlining the principles applicable to the allowance of commissions to executors and administrators, drawing on previous cases and statutes. It noted that while the office of executor is generally gratuitous, a commission may be awarded in exceptional circumstances where the task is onerous or the responsibility, anxiety, and worry are beyond the ordinary. The court emphasised that the allowance of commission is a discretionary matter and is based on the specific circumstances of each case. The court also referred to various cases and publications to provide a guide on the typical rates of commission, although it stressed that these rates are only indicative and the actual amount should reflect the particular facts of the case.

The court then examined the evidence provided by Mr. Munn, which included an account of the administration of the estate and an affidavit detailing the tasks performed and hours worked. The account showed that the total value of receipts was just under $70,000, with disbursements slightly over $33,500, resulting in a balance of $36,474.77. Mr. Munn claimed a commission of $2,280, calculated based on 57 hours of work at a rate of $40 per hour. Despite acknowledging Mr. Munn's voluntary and generous efforts, the court found that the evidence did not establish that the administration of the estate was unduly onerous or that the responsibility, anxiety, and worry were beyond the ordinary. The court also noted that Mr. Munn had the assistance of his solicitors, which reduced some of the burden on him. Consequently, the court concluded that it was not just to allow a commission in these circumstances.

Accordingly, the court dismissed the application and ordered that the costs of the application be paid out of the estate of the deceased on the indemnity basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

Brian Peter Munn, the applicant, applied for an executor's commission under section 70 of the Administration and Probate Act 1929 (ACT) and rule 2748 of the Court Procedure Rules 2006 (ACT) for his work in administering the estate of the deceased, William Ernest Wilson. Mr Munn provided a detailed account of his work verified by affidavit, which included tasks such as attending to the deceased's home, arranging the funeral, closing bank accounts, and liaising with solicitors and funeral directors. He claimed a commission of $2,280, calculated based on 57 hours of work at a rate of $40 per hour. The estate's total receipts were slightly under $70,000, with disbursements slightly over $33,500, resulting in a balance of approximately $36,500.

Mr Munn undertook his duties voluntarily and without expectation of reward. He meticulously documented his activities, which ranged from searching for the will and testament at the deceased's residence to arranging the funeral and managing various administrative tasks over several months. He also provided evidence of the time and effort he invested, listing specific tasks and the hours worked on each date. Despite his extensive efforts, Mr Munn's application for a commission was dismissed by Curtin AJ. The decision was based on the principle that administrators typically work without remuneration, and a commission is only granted in exceptional circumstances where the administration of the estate is particularly onerous or involves significant additional responsibility, anxiety, and worry beyond the ordinary. In this case, the court found that the administration of the estate did not meet these criteria, and thus, it was not just to allow a commission.

This case involves an application by Brian Peter Munn, the administrator of the estate of the late William Ernest Wilson, seeking an order for commission to be paid out of the estate's assets pursuant to s 70 of the Administration and Probate Act 1929 (ACT) and r 2748 of the Court Procedure Rules 2006 (ACT). The application was filed on 8 June 2023, and the decision was rendered on 19 July 2023. Acting Justice Curtin dismissed the application, holding that the evidence did not establish that the administration of the estate was onerous or that the responsibility, anxiety, and worry of administering the estate were beyond what would ordinarily be required. Consequently, the Court refused to allow a commission to be paid to Mr. Munn.

The procedural history of this matter begins with the filing of the application by Mr. Munn on 8 June 2023. In accordance with r 2748 of the Court Procedure Rules 2006 (ACT), Mr. Munn submitted a full and correct account of the estate's administration, verified by affidavit. The account revealed that the total value of receipts was slightly under $70,000, with disbursements slightly over $33,500, leaving a balance of $36,474.77. Mr. Munn claimed a commission of $2,280, calculated based on 57 hours of work at a rate of $40 per hour.

Acting Justice Curtin considered the relevant legal principles and authorities, including the decision in In the Estate of Woodrow: Application for Executor’s Commission [2023] ACTSC 129, and concluded that the administration of the estate was not unduly onerous, and the responsibility, anxiety, and worry of administering the estate were not beyond what would ordinarily be required. The Court also noted that Mr. Munn had the assistance of his solicitors. As a result, the Court dismissed the application and ordered that the costs of the application be paid out of the deceased's estate on the indemnity basis.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the applicant, as the administrator of the estate, is entitled to an executor's commission under s 70 of the Administration and Probate Act 1929 (ACT)?
2. If so, what is the appropriate amount of commission to be awarded, considering the nature and extent of the responsibilities undertaken by the applicant?
3. Whether the task of administering the estate was onerous or if the responsibility, anxiety, and worry involved in the administration of the estate were beyond what would ordinarily be required?
4. Whether the use of professional services, such as solicitors, affected the applicant's entitlement to a commission?
5. Whether the principles and guidelines for determining the allowance of a commission, as outlined in the cited cases and statutes, have been properly applied in this case?

Held
1. Whether the applicant, as the administrator of the estate, is entitled to an executor's commission under s 70 of the Administration and Probate Act 1929 (ACT)?
The court concluded that the application for executor's commission was dismissed.

2. If so, what is the appropriate amount of commission to be awarded, considering the nature and extent of the responsibilities undertaken by the applicant?
The court did not award any commission as the evidence did not establish that the task was onerous or the responsibility, anxiety, and worry were beyond what would ordinarily be required.

3. Whether the task of administering the estate was onerous or if the responsibility, anxiety, and worry involved in the administration of the estate were beyond what would ordinarily be required?
The court concluded that the task of administering the estate was not onerous, and the responsibility, anxiety, and worry involved were not beyond what would ordinarily be required.

4. Whether the use of professional services, such as solicitors, affected the applicant's entitlement to a commission?
The court noted that the applicant had some assistance from solicitors, which was a factor considered in the decision.

5. Whether the principles and guidelines for determining the allowance of a commission, as outlined in the cited cases and statutes, have been properly applied in this case?
The court applied the relevant principles and guidelines in determining that the applicant was not entitled to a commission.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by establishing the applicable legal principles and authorities that govern the allowance of executor's commissions under s 70 of the Administration and Probate Act 1929 (ACT). The court noted that the office of executor is generally gratuitous, and an executor must convince the court to exercise its discretion to allow a commission. The court referred to relevant authorities, including In the Estate of Woodrow, Re Estate Gowing, and Nissen v Grunden, to outline the principles governing the allowance of commissions. The court emphasized that the commission must be "just" and that the assessment of what is "just" is evaluative and not amenable to precise calculation, considering factors such as responsibility, anxiety, worry, and the amount of work involved in administering the estate. The court also noted that the use of professional services, such as solicitors, can affect the entitlement to a commission.

Applying these principles to the facts of the case, the court found that Mr. Munn, as the administrator of the estate, had undertaken the tasks described in his affidavit. However, the court held that the evidence did not establish that the task of administering the estate was onerous or that the responsibility, anxiety, and worry involved were beyond what would ordinarily be required. The court acknowledged that Mr. Munn undertook his task voluntarily and generously without any expectation of reward, but noted that the legal principles do not take into account the personal motives of the administrator in awarding a commission.

The court also considered the amount of commission sought by Mr. Munn, which was calculated based on 57 hours of work at a rate of $40 per hour. The court noted that the total value of receipts was just under $70,000, and the balance after disbursements was $36,474.77. The court found that the amount of commission sought by Mr. Munn was not justified based on the evidence provided. The court held that the administration of this very small estate was not unduly onerous, and the responsibility, anxiety, and worry of administering the estate was not beyond what would ordinarily be required. In those circumstances, it was not "just" to allow a commission.

The court distinguished this case from prior authority by noting that the task of administering the estate was not onerous, and the responsibility, anxiety, and worry involved were not beyond what would ordinarily be required. The court also noted that Mr. Munn had the assistance of his solicitors, which relieved him of some of the responsibility, anxiety, and worry involved in administering the estate. The court followed prior authority in holding that the office of executor is generally gratuitous, and an executor must convince the court to exercise its discretion to allow a commission.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that an administrator of an estate is not entitled to an executor's commission under s 70 of the Administration and Probate Act 1929 (ACT) unless the task of administering the estate is onerous or the responsibility, anxiety, and worry involved are beyond what would ordinarily be required. The amount of commission to be awarded must be "just" and based on the particular circumstances of the case. The use of professional services, such as solicitors, can affect the entitlement to a commission. The principles and guidelines for determining the allowance of a commission, as outlined in the cited cases and statutes, have been properly applied in this case.