IN THE ESTATE OF WENHAM

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Testamentary Causes Jurisdiction)

IN THE ESTATE OF WENHAM

[2023] SASC 44

Judgment of the Honourable Justice Stanley  

31 March 2023

SUCCESSION - ADMINISTRATION OF ESTATE - DISTRIBUTION - INTEREST OF BENEFICIARY IN PARTICULAR PROPERTY

This is an application by the executor of the deceased’s estate seeking advice and direction pursuant to s 69 of the Administration and Probate Act 1919 (SA).

The application relates to a water licence granted to the deceased under the Natural Resources Management Act 2004. There is a dispute between the first and second respondents as to the right to the water licence under the will, as modified by a Heads of Agreement between the two respondents. Neither the will nor the Heads of Agreement makes express provision for the water licence.

The applicant seeks a binding determination of the issue.

Held:

1.      The applicant is advised and directed that he should get in the water licence and distribute it to the first respondent in accordance with the gift in clause 3.5 of the will.

2. A binding determination in relation to the matter is made pursuant to s 69(4) and (6) of the Administration and Probate Act 1919 (SA).

3.      The question of costs is reserved.

Administration and Probate Act 1919 (SA) s 69; Natural Resources Management Act 2004 (SA) ss 146, 150; Landscape South Australia Act 2019 (SA) ss 2, 3(1), 127(1)(a), 132, 134(1), Sch 5 cl 101(4); Water Resources Act 1997 (SA); Wills Act 1936 (SA) s 4, referred to.
Farrelly v Phillips (2017) 128 SASR 502; King v Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd (1955) 94 CLR 70; Pearson v Spencer (1863) 3 B&S 761; Phillips v Low [1892] 1 Ch 47; Talia Farms v Minister for Environment [2021] SAERDC 33; Wood v Gaynon (1761) Amb 395, considered.

IN THE ESTATE OF WENHAM
[2023] SASC 44

Testamentary causes jurisdiction

STANLEY J:

Introduction

  1. This is an application pursuant to s 69 of the Administration and Probate Act 1919 (SA) (the Act) for judicial advice and direction in the estate of the late Ian Royce Wenham (the deceased). The applicant is the executor of the deceased’s estate pursuant to a grant of probate made on 6 November 2020.

  2. The deceased died on 23 February 2017.  He made his last will on 2 April 2016 (the will).  The principal beneficiaries under the will are, the deceased’s son Jodi Scott Hanak (Mr Hanak), and Alan Gary Dalitz (Mr Dalitz).  On 18 August 2000 Mr Hanak and Mr Dalitz made a binding agreement varying the terms of the will as between themselves.  That agreement was recorded in a document entitled “Heads of Agreement” (Heads of Agreement). 

  3. The application relates to a water licence granted to the deceased under the Natural Resources Management Act 2004 (SA) (NRMA) being water licence 118583-0 (the water licence). The NRMA was subsequently repealed by the Landscape South Australia Act 2019 (SA) (LSA Act). There are two copies of the water licence in evidence. Only one appears…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read IN THE ESTATE OF WENHAM and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] SASC 44
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of the estate of Wenham, the primary issue to be resolved was the interpretation of clause 3.5 of the deceased's will and the entitlement to a water licence. The dispute arose between Mr Dalitz and Mr Hanak, with Mr Dalitz arguing that the water licence should be transferred to him either as it was intended to accompany the gift of Hope Farm or as part of the dairy farming plant and equipment. Conversely, Mr Hanak contended that there was no testamentary intent to transfer the water licence to Mr Dalitz and that it should be included in the residual estate. This case was heard in the Supreme Court of South Australia, where the court was tasked with interpreting the will and determining the rightful beneficiary of the water licence.

The court examined the language of clause 3.5 and the surrounding circumstances to ascertain the deceased's intention. It considered the evidence provided in the affidavits and the statutory context of water licences under the National Resources Management Act 2004 (SA). The court found that the water licence was not explicitly mentioned in the will but was instead an accessory to the principal gift of Hope Farm. The court's interpretation was based on the intention to allow Mr Dalitz to continue dairy farming on Hope Farm in the manner it had been conducted since 2004. The court concluded that the water licence was not part of the dairy farming plant and equipment, as it was an intangible statutory licence.

The court issued a binding determination under section 69(4) and (6) of the Act, advising and directing the applicant to obtain the water licence 118583-0 and distribute it to Mr Dalitz in accordance with the gift in clause 3.5 of the will. The court further stated that it would hear the parties on any other advice or direction they sought and the question of costs. This decision clarified the interpretation of the will and resolved the dispute over the water licence, ensuring that Mr Dalitz could continue dairy farming on Hope Farm as intended by the deceased.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The issue to be determined is the correct construction of clause 3.5 of the will and the entitlement to the water licence. Mr Dalitz contends that clause 3.5 gifts the water licence to him, either because the deceased intended that the licence followed the gift of Hope Farm or formed part of the dairy farming plant and equipment. Mr Hanak contends that the deceased had no testamentary intention to gift the water licence to Mr Dalitz and that it falls into the residue of the deceased’s estate. The evidence The Court admitted the following affidavits:·Affidavit of Mark Peter Jappe of 11 July 2022;·Affidavit of Andrew John Colman Evans of 7 November 2022;·Affidavit of Mark Peter Jappe of 8 November 2022; ·Affidavit of Alan Gary Dalitz of 14 October 2022; ·Affidavit of Jodi Scott Hanak of 1 August 2022 except for paragraphs 25-33 inclusive and the second sentence of paragraph 8; ·Affidavit of Jodi Scott Hanak of 27 October 2022;·Pages 9-30 inclusive of annexure “PC Affidavit 1” to the affidavit of Paul Cooper of 20 December 2022; ·Annexure “PC Affidavit 2” to the affidavit of Paul Cooper of 20 December 2022. Non one sought to cross-examine any of the deponents. The deceased’s estate As at the date of his death, the deceased was the registered proprietor of land at 61 Wenhams Road, Wattle Flat, being the whole of the land comprised and described in certificate of title register book volume 6168, folios 947, 946, 945 and 944 otherwise known as Hope Farm;[2] at 1056 Bethel Road, Hay Flat, being the whole of the land comprised and described in certificate of title register book volume 6168, folio 950, known as Laws (Laws);[3] at 182 Main South Road, Yankalilla, being the whole of the land comprised and described in certificate of title register book volume 5376, folio 103 (Yankalilla); and at 296 Kemmiss Hill Road, Inman Valley, being the whole of the land comprised and described in certificate of title register book volume 6168, folio 949 and 948 known as Outback (Outback).[4] [2] Mr Hanak refers to Hope Farm as the Wenhams Road property.[3] Mr Hanak refers to Laws as the Bethel Road property.[4] Mr Hanak refers to Outback as the Kemmiss Hill Road property.The water licence At common law water was not capable of being the subject of property or being granted. The Water Resources Act 1997 (SA) enshrined a scheme to regulate the use of water through a system of licencing. The NRMA continued this statutory regime. The holder of a water licence was authorised to take water from a prescribed water course specified in the licence. Water licences granted under the NRMA specified the part or parts of the resource from which water could be taken; were endorsed with a water allocation; and where the allocation comprised one or more components, set out the amount of water allocated to each component. A water licence remained in force until terminated and was subject to such further conditions as endorsed by the Minister. The Minister could grant water licences endorsed with a water allocation specifying the water resource and the volume that could be taken.[5] [5] Talia Farms Pty Ltd v Minister for Environment and Water [2021] SAERDC 33 at [5]-[10].

Decision

Reasons for decision

This renders it unnecessary to consider whether the water licence is dairy farming plant and equipment within the meaning of clause 3.5. I should add, however, that I do not accept that the licence is to be considered part of the dairy farming plant and equipment within clause 3.5. Even allowing for a broad construction of the phrase, I do not consider it can extend so far as to include something as intangible as a statutory licence. That conclusion is neither inconsistent with the approach that led to the conclusion that the licence is an accessory that follows the principal gift of the land as a dairy farm, nor undermines that conclusion. That conclusion is supported by the inclusion in clause 3.5 of all the dairy farming plant and equipment to Mr Dalitz as indicating an intention that he should be able to continue dairy farming on Hope Farm in the manner in which it had been undertaken since 2004 when the NRMA created the statutory licence pursuant to which the farm was conducted. Conclusion I would advise and direct the applicant that he should get in the water licence 118583-0 and distribute it to Mr Dalitz in accordance with the gift in clause 3.5 of the will. I make a binding determination in relation to this matter pursuant to s 69(4) and (6) of the Act. I will hear the parties further in relation to any other advice or direction they seek and the question of costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established