CITATION:In the Estate of Thompson [2021] NTSC 72
PARTIES:IN THE ESTATE OF THOMPSON
IN THE MATTER of an application to prove and admit to probate a copy of the Will of KEVIN JOHN THOMPSON
TITLE OF COURT: SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
JURISDICTION: SUPREME COURT exercising Territory jurisdiction
FILE NO:2021-02905-SC
DELIVERED ON: 24 September 2021
DELIVERED AT: Alice Springs
JUDGMENT OF: Grant CJ
CATCHWORDS:
SUCCESSION – Wills, Probate and Administration – Probate and Letters of Administration
Application by the son of the deceased to prove a copy of the Will of the deceased – Whether the presumption of revocation rebutted – Copy of the Will proved and admitted to probate.
Cahill v Rhodes [2002] NSWSC 561, Curley v Duff (1985) 2 NSWLR 716, Estate of Manning [2015] NTSC 21, Estate of Ponikvar [2016] SASC 95, Proud v Proud [2012] WASC 134, Warren (deceased) [2014] QSC 101, referred to.
Judgment category classification: B
Judgment ID Number: GRA2115
Number of pages: 6
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
OF AUSTRALIA
AT ALICE SPRINGSIn the Estate of Thompson [2021] NTSC 72
File No: 2021-02905-SC
IN THE ESTATE OF THOMPSON
IN THE MATTER OF AN APPLICATION FOR LEAVE TO PROVE A COPY OF THE WILL OF KEVIN JOHN THOMPSON
CORAM: GRANT CJ
REASONS FOR ORDER
(Delivered ex tempore on 24 September 2021)
The deceased died on 9 August 2020 at the age of 87 years. The deceased executed a Will on 7 May 2002 in compliance with the formal requirements. Following the death of the deceased, the original of that Will cannot be located and only a copy of that Will has been located. The copy Will names the deceased’s children, Karen Janetta Thompson and John Patrick Thompson, as executors and sole beneficiaries of his estate in equal shares. Karen Janetta Thompson has made an affidavit renouncing probate. John Patrick Thompson has made an application for probate and has filed all necessary affidavits for that purpose. John Patrick Thompson has now made separate application to prove the copy of the Will and have it admitted to probate.
That application is necessitated by the fact that an application for probate will ordinarily require the production of the original Will by the person seeking the grant of probate. This Court has power to recognise that the original of the Will has been lost, and to admit a copy of it to probate. However, in circumstances where the original of the Will cannot be produced after the death of the testator, a presumption of revocation arises. That is, there is a rebuttable presumption that the deceased destroyed the original of the Will with the intention of revoking it. The strength of that presumption will depend upon the circumstances, and if it is not rebutted an intestacy will result and the deceased estate is to be distributed according to the statutory rules on intestacy. It should be noted at the outset that the distribution of the estate…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read In the Estate of Thompson and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] NTSC 72
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court found that the deceased had executed the Will in 2002, and his circumstances had not materially changed by the time of his death. The Will had been witnessed by Christopher Warwick Turner, who was the deceased's neighbour and a legal practitioner at the time. Following the Will's execution, the deceased had not moved from his residence. The deceased's son had found the copy of the Will in the deceased's personal effects following his death but had been unable to locate the original Will. The Court accepted that it was likely that Mr Turner had provided the copy of the Will to the deceased, and had kept the original Will for safekeeping. The Court was satisfied that the deceased had not destroyed the original Will with the intention of revoking it, and that the presumption of revocation had been rebutted. The Court ordered that the copy of the Will be proved and admitted to probate.
Background
Background to the litigation
The deceased's circumstances did not materially change between the execution of the Will and his death. He was a widower at the time of the execution of the Will, had no further issue following the execution of the Will, and did not remarry following the execution of the Will. John Patrick Thompson found the copy of the Will in the deceased's personal effects following the death of the deceased. He has been unable to find the original of the Will in the deceased's house or personal effects despite conducting thorough searches, or in any other location. Following the execution of the Will, the deceased did not reside in any address other than the address in which he was residing at that time.
Christopher Warwick Turner, who prepared the Will, is now in palliative care and unable to give evidence in the matter or to provide any information in relation to the location of the original of the Will. Dianne McManus has identified that the copy of the Will sought to be proved is an accurate and complete copy of the original Will, and the Court finds that to be so. The solicitor for the applicant has written to all other firms in Alice Springs which may have made a subsequent will for the deceased, or which may have held the original of the Will executed on 7 May 2002, and those enquiries have not disclosed that the deceased made another will or that the original of the Will is held by any of those firms. The solicitor for the applicant has made enquiry of the Public Trustee for the Northern Territory, and that enquiry has not disclosed that the deceased made another will or that the original of the Will is held by the Public Trustee.
It is likely that following the execution of the Will, Christopher Warwick Turner provided the copy of the Will subsequently found by the deceased's son following the death of the deceased and now deposited in the Court Registry, and kept the original of the Will as part of his practice for safekeeping. It is improbable that the deceased had possession of both the original and the copy of the Will and subsequently destroyed the original with the intention of revoking it, but kept the copy of the Will. At some time following the execution of the Will, Christopher Warwick Turner ceased private practice and became an employed legal practitioner with the Alice Springs Town Council. It cannot now be ascertained what was done with the files and other documents in his possession which related to his previous practice. The inquiries and investigations made by the solicitor for the applicant have identified very few records relating to Christopher Warwick Turner’s private practice, none of which are related to the deceased in this matter. There is no person who might be prejudiced by the admission of the copy of the Will to probate.
The matter before the Supreme Court of the Northern Territory was an application by John Patrick Thompson, the son of the deceased, Kevin John Thompson, seeking to prove and admit to probate a copy of his father’s Will. The original Will could not be located following the death of Kevin John Thompson on 9 August 2020. The copy of the Will names Karen Janetta Thompson and John Patrick Thompson as executors and beneficiaries of the estate. Karen Janetta Thompson renounced probate, leaving John Patrick Thompson as the sole applicant for probate. However, the application for probate necessitated the original Will, which could not be produced, prompting the presumption of revocation. The presumption of revocation posits that the original Will was destroyed with the intention of revoking it, leading to a rebuttable presumption that the Will was revoked unless proven otherwise. The onus of rebutting this presumption lies with the applicant, requiring evidence that it is more likely than not that the Will was not revoked.
The procedural journey of this matter commenced with John Patrick Thompson filing an application for probate, followed by an application to prove the copy of the Will and admit it to probate. This application required the Court to consider whether the presumption of revocation had been rebutted. The Court examined the circumstances surrounding the Will, including the circumstances of its execution, the dispositions made, and the subsequent searches for the original Will. The Court made several findings, including that the copy of the Will was an accurate and complete copy, that the Will made a careful and complete disposition of the property, and that the original was likely in the possession of the deceased’s former solicitor, Christopher Warwick Turner, who was unable to provide any information regarding its whereabouts. The Court concluded that the presumption of revocation had been rebutted and ordered that the copy of the Will be proved and admitted to probate.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the presumption of revocation of the original Will has been rebutted.
2. Whether the copy of the Will is an accurate and complete representation of the original Will.
3. Whether the onus of proving the lost original Will lies with the applicant.
4. Whether the circumstances surrounding the loss of the original Will indicate that the presumption of revocation is stronger or weaker.
5. Whether the testator had the intention to revoke the Will by destroying the original.
6. Whether the distribution of the estate would be the same regardless of whether the copy of the Will is admitted to probate or the estate is distributed under intestacy.
Held
1. Whether the presumption of revocation of the original Will has been rebutted.
The court concluded that the presumption of revocation of the original Will has been rebutted and ordered the copy of the Will to be proved and admitted to probate.
2. Whether the copy of the Will is an accurate and complete representation of the original Will.
The court found that the copy of the Will is an accurate and complete representation of the original Will.
3. Whether the onus of proving the lost original Will lies with the applicant.
The court held that the onus of rebutting the presumption of revocation lies with the applicant.
4. Whether the circumstances surrounding the loss of the original Will indicate that the presumption of revocation is stronger or weaker.
The court found that the circumstances surrounding the loss of the original Will weakened the presumption of revocation.
5. Whether the testator had the intention to revoke the Will by destroying the original.
The court concluded that it was improbable that the deceased had the intention to revoke the Will by destroying the original.
6. Whether the distribution of the estate would be the same regardless of whether the copy of the Will is admitted to probate or the estate is distributed under intestacy.
The court noted that the distribution of the estate would be the same in both circumstances, with the son and daughter of the deceased as the sole beneficiaries in equal shares.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court in the Estate of Thompson began by outlining the issue of whether the presumption of revocation of the original Will has been rebutted. The Court noted that a rebuttable presumption of revocation arises when the original Will is not produced after the death of the testator, meaning it is presumed that the deceased destroyed the Will with the intention of revoking it. This presumption can be rebutted if the applicant establishes that it is more likely than not that the deceased did not destroy the Will with the intention of revoking it, and that the original has simply been lost or misplaced.
In determining whether the presumption of revocation has been rebutted, the Court considered several factors, including the circumstances surrounding the loss of the original Will, whether the copy of the Will is an accurate and complete representation of the original, and whether the testator had the intention to revoke the Will by destroying the original. The Court found that the presumption of revocation was rebutted based on the evidence presented.
The Court then turned to the issue of whether the copy of the Will is an accurate and complete representation of the original Will. The Court found that the copy of the Will was an accurate and complete representation of the original, as attested by one of the witnesses to the Will.
The Court also considered the issue of whether the onus of proving the lost original Will lies with the applicant. The Court noted that the onus of rebutting the presumption of revocation is on the person applying to the court for proof of a copy of the original Will.
The Court then examined the circumstances surrounding the loss of the original Will, and whether they indicated that the presumption of revocation was stronger or weaker. The Court found that the circumstances surrounding the loss of the original Will did not indicate that the presumption of revocation was stronger or weaker.
Finally, the Court considered whether the testator had the intention to revoke the Will by destroying the original. The Court found that it was improbable that the deceased had possession of both the original and the copy of the Will and subsequently destroyed the original with the intention of revoking it, but kept the copy of the Will.
The Court also considered whether the distribution of the estate would be the same regardless of whether the copy of the Will was admitted to probate or the estate was distributed under intestacy. The Court found that the distribution of the estate would be the same in either case, with the son and daughter of the deceased being the sole beneficiaries in equal shares.
Based on these considerations, the Court found that the presumption of revocation had been rebutted and ordered that the copy of the Will be proved and admitted to probate. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a rebuttable presumption of revocation arises when the original Will is not produced after the death of the testator, but this presumption can be rebutted if the applicant establishes that it is more likely than not that the deceased did not destroy the Will with the intention of revoking it, and that the original has simply been lost or misplaced. The Court in this case found that the presumption of revocation had been rebutted based on the evidence presented, and therefore admitted the copy of the Will to probate.