In the Estate of ROBIN MICHAEL (DECEASED)

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Testamentary Causes Jurisdiction: Application)

In the Estate of ROBIN MICHAEL (DECEASED)

[2016] SASC 164

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Stanley

2 November 2016

SUCCESSION - MAKING OF A WILL - EXECUTION - INFORMAL DOCUMENT INTENDED TO BE WILL - MEANING OF “DOCUMENT”

SUCCESSION - MAKING OF A WILL - EXECUTION - INFORMAL DOCUMENT INTENDED TO BE WILL - DOCUMENT NOT EXECUTED BY MAKER

Application pursuant to s 12(2) of the Wills Act 1936 (SA) (the Act) for admission to probate of a copy of a document bearing date 11 February 2015 as the will of the deceased.

The deceased, Robin Michael, died on 28 June 2015 at Risdon Vale in Tasmania.  The application is made by the deceased’s son, Brett Michael (Brett). 

There are two unusual features to the application.  First, the original “document” is on the hard drive of the deceased’s laptop computer.  Second, both the “document” on the laptop computer and the printed copy bear a digital or facsimile copy of the deceased’s signature. 

The deceased made an earlier informal will in 2006.  By that will the deceased provided that his sons, Brett and Benjamin Michael (Ben), were the sole beneficiaries of his estate.   Both of them survived the deceased.  They are the only persons whose interests will be adversely affected if the “document” is admitted to probate.  Ben consents to the order sought by Brett Michael.

The application raises the following issues:

1.  Is the will on the deceased’s hard drive of his laptop computer a “document” within the meaning of s 12 of the Act?

2.  Did the deceased intend the “document” apparently prepared by him on his laptop to be his will?

3.  Is the digital or facsimile signature recorded on the “document” able to be accepted as the deceased’s signature?

4.  Which “document” did the deceased intend as his will?

5.  If an order is to be made, what is the proper form of the order in these circumstances? 

Held (per Stanley J):

1. The computer file containing the document entitled “LAST WILL AND TESTaMENT” is a “document” within the terms of s 12(2) of the Act (at [26]).

2.  The “document” expresses testamentary intentions of the deceased and the deceased intended the document to constitute his will (at [27]).

3.  The facsimile signature found on the computer file document and its printout closely resembles the signature of the deceased.  It was affixed to the computer document by the deceased as his signature and that he did so with the intention of giving effect to the document as his will (at [34]).

4.  The document which the deceased intended to be his will is the digital document in the computer file found on his laptop computer (at [35]).

5.  Admit to probate as the last will and testament of the deceased, Robin Michael, the copy of the document prepared by him and described as “LAST WILL AND TESTaMENT” found on the hard drive of the deceased’s laptop computer being…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read In the Estate of ROBIN MICHAEL (DECEASED) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] SASC 164
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Estate of Robin Michael, the deceased's estate was the subject of a succession dispute, which ultimately reached the Supreme Court of South Australia. The central issue revolved around the validity of a digital document found on the deceased's laptop, which was intended to serve as his last will and testament. The application sought to determine whether this digital document constituted a "document" under the relevant succession legislation and whether it was properly executed as a will.

The court was required to decide several legal issues, including whether the digital document on the deceased's laptop could be considered a "document" within the meaning of the Succession Act, whether the deceased intended this document to be his will, and whether the digital signature inserted into the document could be accepted as the deceased's signature. Additionally, the court needed to ascertain which document the deceased intended to be his will and determine the appropriate form of the order if the document were to be admitted to probate.

The court concluded that the digital document found on the deceased's laptop constituted a "document" under the Succession Act. It found that the deceased had intended this document to be his will, as evidenced by the content and the process he followed in creating it. The court accepted the digital signature as valid, as the deceased had previously scanned a physical signature and saved it as an image file, which he then used to sign the document. The court ruled that the document in its digital form on the laptop was the one the deceased intended to be his will. It also determined that the proper form of the order was to admit a printed copy of the digital document to probate as the deceased's last will and testament.

In light of the findings, the court ordered that the document prepared by the deceased and found on his laptop's hard drive, specifically exhibit "A" referred to in the affidavit of Brett Michael, be admitted to probate as the last will and testament of Robin Michael. This decision followed the precedent set in In the Estate of Wilden, where a similar approach was taken in admitting a transcript of a DVD recording to probate.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The application raises the following issues:1.Is the will on the deceased’s hard drive of his laptop computer a “document” within the meaning of s 12 of the Act?2.Did the deceased intend the “document” apparently prepared by him on his laptop to be his will?3.Is the digital or facsimile signature recorded on the “document” able to be accepted as the deceased’s signature?4.Which “document” did the deceased intend as his will?5.If an order is to be made, what is the proper form of the order in these circumstances? Evidence The applicant relies upon three affidavits he swore on 16 March 2016, 4 May 2016 and 14 July 2016 respectively. I am prepared to rely upon the evidence set out in those affidavits. They provide the necessary evidentiary foundation for the application. They disclose that the “document” came into being in the circumstances set out below. The deceased was married to Kerry Lyn Michael (Kerry). The deceased and Kerry were on holiday in Tasmania in February 2015. On 11 February 2015 the deceased killed Kerry. Following the incident which resulted in Kerry’s death, the deceased returned to a caravan at the Devonport caravan park where he and Kerry were staying. He typed the “document” on his laptop computer. After typing the “document” the deceased accessed a digital copy of his signature which he inserted into the “document”. Some years earlier the deceased signed a piece of paper which he then scanned and saved as an image file on his computer. This allowed him to place his digital signature into any document he produced on his laptop by opening the image file and copying and pasting the signature into the document. The document prepared by the deceased in the caravan on 11 February 2015 provides:LAST WILL AND TESTaMENT Robin Michael59 Sheoak RoadBelair SA 5052This is the last will and testament of Robin Michael of 59 Sheoak Road, Belair, SA 5052 dated 11th February 2015. I assign Peter McCullough (my accountant), Brett Michael (my son), Ben Michael (my son) and Nathan Scott Cahill (my stepson) as Executors of my estate.In the event that I die and my wife succeeds me, then my wish is that she receives 40% of the value of 59 Sheoak Road, Belair consistent with the Title, and that remaining assets except Goolwa and split 40:30:30 between my wife, and my sons Brett and Ben.In the event that my wife does not succeed me, I wish for Goolwa to be taken by Brett and Ben as is consistent with the legal structure administrated by Peter McCullough, and that the remaining assets (combined between my wife and myself), be distributed between my natural sons, Brett and Ben, and my stepson, Nathan Scott Cahill. If Kerry’s will is contrary to this, I ask that the executors seek to arrange a distribution as close to the this as is possible from the assets remaining after an appropriate distribution as sought in my wife’s will.This is my final wish. Signed.[Signature appearing].Robin MichaelWitnessPeter McCullough11th February 2015.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The document which the deceased intended to be his will is the digital document in the computer file found on his laptop computer. It is this document he typed and into which he inserted his digital signature. While he emailed copies of this document to his accountant, his sons and stepson, he did not insert his digital signature into those copies. The document exists on the hard drive of the deceased’s laptop computer. It is not practical, however, for the court to receive the document in that form. I propose to order that the document to be admitted to probate as the last will and testament of the deceased is the exhibit marked “A” referred to in the affidavit of Brett Michael sworn 16 March 2016 being a copy of the document on the hard drive of the deceased’s laptop computer. This is consistent with the approach taken by Gray J in In the Estate of Wilden where his Honour, having found that a DVD recording was a “document” within the meaning of s 12(2), admitted to probate a transcript of the DVD recording. Conclusion Pursuant to s 12(2) of the Act, I would admit to probate as the last will and testament of the deceased, Robin Michael, the copy of the document prepared by him and described as “LAST WILL AND TESTaMENT” found on the hard drive of the deceased’s laptop computer being exhibit “A” to the affidavit of Brett Michael sworn 16 March 2016.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established