In the Estate of PETER MCBRIDE (DECEASED)

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Testamentary Causes Jurisdiction: Application)

In the Estate of PETER MCBRIDE (DECEASED)

[2019] SASC 204

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Stanley

22 November 2019

SUCCESSION - ADMINISTRATION OF ESTATE

This is an application for judicial advice or direction pursuant to s 69 of the Administration and Probate Act 1919 (SA) (the Act).

The deceased died on 24 July 2018.  The gross value of his estate is $28,274,390.11.   The net value of his estate is $28,165,508.90.  The deceased executed his last will (the Will) on 27 September 2016.  The applicant, Franco Camatta, is the executor of the deceased’s estate pursuant to a grant of probate made on 15 March 2019.  Clause 15 of the Will states:

"I DIRECT my Trustee shall be entitled to a once only initial commission equal to  one percent (1%) of the gross value of my assets as disclosed in the list of assets to be filed with the application for a grant of Probate in my estate plus any Goods and Services Tax applicable thereupon out of which monies my Trustee shall bear the cost of insuring himself against all risks to him or carrying out the administration of my estate and in addition thereto my estate shall bear all costs and disbursements arising out of the proper administration of my estate in respect of which my Trustee shall be entitled to engage such legal accounting or other professional services as he shall in his absolute discretion deem necessary and my Trustee shall not be entitled to charge or be paid any other fees for his or her services in connection with this my Will or the trust."

The applicant is a solicitor and a director of the firm Camatta Lempens Pty Ltd (the law firm). 

On or around 11 October 2018, the applicant retained the law firm to provide professional (legal) and other services to him in his capacity as executor of the estate of the deceased.  The executor seeks advice or direction that, on the proper construction of clause 15 of the will, he would be justified in:

1.  continuing to retain the law firm to perform work for and on behalf of the deceased’s estate on a fee for service basis, provided that the law firm does not charge for any work (whether legal or executorial) done by him;

2.  having the estate pay the costs of executorial work performed by the law firm; and

3.  claiming and receiving his executor’s commission, clause 15 of the Will, despite having retained the law firm in accordance with the above.

The applicant also seeks an order that the costs of the application be paid out of the deceased’s estate, such costs to be adjudicated on the footing of an indemnity.

Held, per Stanley J:

1.  The applicant, in his capacity as executor of the estate of Peter McBride, is directed that he would be justified in retaining Camatta Lempens Pty Ltd to perform legal work for and on behalf of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read In the Estate of PETER MCBRIDE (DECEASED) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] SASC 204
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court was an application by the executor of the estate of Peter McBride, deceased, seeking directions regarding the administration of the estate, including the payment of executor’s fees and the retention of legal representatives. The executor was concerned about the propriety of charging the estate for certain legal services and sought the court's guidance under Section 69 of the Trustee Act 1936 (SA). The court was required to determine whether the executor could retain legal representatives and charge the estate for their services, and whether the executor was entitled to claim executor’s commission for work done.

The court began by noting the statutory provisions under Section 69 of the Trustee Act, which allows executors to seek the court's advice in matters of estate administration. The court considered precedents that indicated advice given under this section is prospective only and does not retroactively protect against breaches of trust. The court then examined the distinction between professional services, such as legal or accounting work, and non-professional executorial duties. It was established that an executor could retain professional services but could not charge the estate for their fees unless expressly permitted by the will. Furthermore, the court clarified that an executor is generally not entitled to charge the estate for non-professional work, such as administrative tasks, unless the will expressly allows it.

The court concluded that the executor was justified in retaining legal representatives to perform professional legal work on a fee-for-service basis and could claim executor’s commission for their services, provided these services were distinct from non-professional executorial duties. However, the executor was not entitled to charge the estate for non-professional work performed by the legal representatives. The court ordered the executor to reimburse the estate for any fees already charged for non-professional work and directed that the costs of the application be paid from the estate on an indemnity basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The application also seeks an order that the costs of the application be paid out of the deceased’s estate, such costs to be adjudicated on the footing of an indemnity.The evidence The applicant relies upon his affidavits filed 1 August 2019, 15 August 2019 and 26 August 2019. I am prepared to rely upon the statements of fact set out in those affidavits. In or around December 2011, the deceased instructed Jamison & Associates of 31 Dequetteville Terrace, Kent Town in the State of South Australia to draft a will. That will was executed on 19 December 2011 (the prior will). On 25 August 2016, the deceased instructed the applicant to draft the Will. The Will mirrors the prior will, save as to limited changes in the beneficiaries who were to receive gifts. The differences between the Will and the prior will are consistent with the handwritten notes of the deceased made on the face of the prior will. The applicant drafted the Will in accordance with the deceased’s instructions. To date four invoices have been raised by the law firm and three paid. The applicant has not billed or charged fees, and does not propose to bill or charge fees, for any work in administering the estate (including professional, legal or other work), whether through the estate or otherwise. The applicant seeks a direction as to the continuing retainer of the law firm. If the Court declines to give that direction and it finds that the past conduct in retaining the law firm constitutes a breach of trust, the applicant undertakes to take immediate steps to remedy the breach including, but not limited to, an application under s 56 of the Trustee Act 1936 (SA) (the Trustee Act).Section 69 Section 69 of the Act permits an executor, when in difficulty or doubt, to seek the advice or direction of the Court in matters connected with the administration of any estate, or the construction of any will, deed or document. Unlike analogous provisions in other jurisdictions[2] there is no express provision as to the effect of the advice or direction. In South Australia, it has been held that:The direction given to [the trustee] protects and indemnifies the trustee against any claim for breach of trust, provided always that the facts have been fully and fairly disclosed, but leaves the question open as between beneficiaries who have not been cited to see the proceedings.[3][2] Cf Trustee Act 1925 (NSW) s 63(2).[3] In Re Hunter [1957] SASR 194 at 196; Re IOOF Australia Trustees & The Trustee Act 1936 [1999] SASC 461 at [3]; Re Magarey Farlam Lawyers Trust Accounts (No 2) (2006) 96 SASR 323 at 330‑331; Public Trustee v O’Donnell [2008] SASC 181, (2008) 101 SASR 228 at [29]. In Re Atkinson,[4] the Court said:[5]If the executor or the trustee then followed the direction of the court, it would be protected from any claim by a beneficiary or creditor arising from its action or inaction in accordance with the court’s direction. [4] [1971] VR 612.[5] [1971] VR 612 at 615. To similar effect, in re GB Nathan & Co Pty Ltd (In Liq),[6] the Court said:[7]These various statutory provisions for directions were a development from the practice of the Court of Chancery under the general law in giving directions to those entrusted with the administration of property under the control of the court. Two main classes of such persons were (1) trustees of trust property, or executors or administrators of a deceased estate, under administration by the court pursuant to a decree for general administration, and (2) receivers (and managers) appointed by the court in respect of property the subject of litigation. In such cases the exercise by those persons (to whom I will collectively refer as official administrators) of administrative or managerial functions were subject to close control by the court and in many instances they could safely exercise their powers only with the approval, and in accordance with the directions, of the court …Generally speaking, if the court gave a direction to an official administrator who had made a full and fair disclosure to the court of the material facts, the official administrator might act in accordance with the direction without thereby incurring personal liability to any of the persons in whose interests the administration was being conducted, for example, creditors or beneficiaries of a deceased estate …[6] (1981) 24 NSWLR 674.[7] (1981) 24 NSWLR 674 at 677.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In the circumstances the applicant must take steps to reimburse the estate for the previous charges the estate has met for the performance by the law firm for non‑professional work.Conclusion I direct pursuant to s 69 of the Act that the applicant, in his capacity as executor of the estate of Peter McBride, late of 421 The Parade, Kensington Gardens in the State of South Australia, who died on 24 July 2018 (the deceased), on the proper construction of clause 15 of the Will of the deceased, would be justified in:1retaining Camatta Lempens Pty Ltd to perform legal work for and on behalf of the deceased’s estate on a fee for service basis, provided that Camatta Lempens Pty Ltd does not charge the estate for any work (whether legal or executorial) done by him; and2claiming and receiving his executor’s commission in clause 15 of the Will of the deceased, despite having retained Camatta Lempens Pty Ltd in accordance with paragraph 1 above. I further direct pursuant to s 69 of the Act that the applicant, in his capacity as executor of the estate of Peter McBride, late of 421 The Parade, Kensington Gardens in the State of South Australia, who died on 24 July 2018 (the deceased), on the proper construction of clause 15 of the Will of the deceased, would not be justified in charging the estate for the performance by his agents of any executorial work for and on behalf of the deceased’s estate. I direct he is to reimburse the estate for the charges the estate has met for the performance by the law firm of the non-legal work. I further direct that the costs of the application be paid out of the deceased’s estate, such costs to be adjudicated on the footing of an indemnity.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Advice given under s 69 is prospective or executory only. It does not authorise or protect against action for any conduct already undertaken that may constitute a breach of trust.[12] This would be a matter for s 56 of the Trustee Act. [12] Martin v Hayward [1908] SALR 187.Executor’s remuneration Subject to the terms of the will, an executor is not entitled to charge the estate for his or her work done in relation to the administration of the estate.[13] [13] Robinson v Pett (1734) 24 ER 1049; In the Will of McClung [2006] VSC 209 at [28]; Chick v Grosfeld (No 3) [2012] NSWSC 1536 at [7]. An executor may retain and charge the estate for the services of a professional person, such as a solicitor, accountant or estate agent, to provide such professional services as may be required to assist in the administration of the estate.[14][14] Chick v Grosfeld (No 3) [2012] NSWSC 1536 at [8]. In this context, a distinction is drawn between professional work (that is to say, work of a legal or accounting nature) and non-professional work (the work otherwise undertaken by the executor).[15] [15] In the Will of Sheppard [1972] 2 NSWLR 714 at 718. In general, and subject to the terms of the will, an executor is not entitled to be indemnified out of the estate for the costs of retaining a solicitor to undertake executorial duties of a non-professional nature. In In the Will of Douglas[16] Roper J held that in general an executor will not be allowed out of the estate charges of his solicitor for doing things which he ought strictly to have done himself.[17][16] (1951) 51 SR (NSW) 282.[17] (1951) 51 SR (NSW) 282 at 283. Finally, unless the will otherwise expressly provides, an executor who is such a professional person is not entitled to charge for his or her professional services if he or she does that work.[18] In the absence of a relevant clause in the will, an executor is only able to be remunerated by way of an application for the payment of commission from the estate under either s 70 of the Act or the inherent jurisdiction of the Court.[19] Commission is awarded for “pains” and “trouble”. “Trouble” is used to assess the work which is actually attended to by the executor.[20] In the event that the executor is a professional person, but not otherwise permitted to charge professional fees, the Court may take any such work into account in determining the amount of commission.[21][18] Chick v Grosfeld (No 3) [2012] NSWSC 1536 at [8].[19] ReGambling [1966] SASR 134 at 135-136; In the Will of Shannon [1977] 1 NSWLR 210 at 214-215.[20] Re Mclean (1911) 31 NZLR 139 at 144.[21] Re Craig (1952) 52 SR (NSW) 265 at 267-268. In Starke v James[22] and Starke v James (No 2)[23] this Court has recently allowed a solicitor to be paid a commission by way of an assessment of the work done and charged on the Supreme Court scale. In Starke v James the will appointed a solicitor as executor but did not have a charging clause. The Court permitted him to claim commission under s 70 of the Act to be assessed as the costs payable for the work he had properly done under the relevant Supreme Court Costs Schedule. This included both professional (legal) work and non‑professional executorial work.[24] [22] [2009] SASC 40.[23] [2009] SASC 221.[24] [2009] SASC 221 at [8].