IN THE ESTATE OF NEMER

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Testamentary Causes Jurisdiction)

IN THE ESTATE OF NEMER (DECEASED)

[2021] SASC 14

Decision of the Honourable Justice Bampton  

24 February 2021

EQUITY - TRUSTS AND TRUSTEES - APPLICATIONS TO COURT FOR ADVICE AND AUTHORITY

SUCCESSION - ADMINISTRATION OF ESTATE - OTHER MATTERS

The executors of a will bring an application for judicial advice or direction pursuant to s 69 of the Administration and Probate Act 1919 (SA) — whether the executors would be justified in continuing probate proceedings commenced by them seeking to propound an alleged codicil — the defence of proceedings where they are named as respondents — the institution and prosecution of proposed proceedings.

HELD: It is appropriate to provide the executors with the necessary advice or direction in favour of continuing to prosecute the probate proceedings, to institute and prosecute the proposed proceedings, and to defend the proceedings where they are named as respondents — a Beddoe order by way of indemnity is justified.

Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA) r 83(4); Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA) rr 1.4(4), 1.3, 24.6; Administration and Probate Act 1919 (SA) s 69, referred to.

Re Beddoe; Downes v Cottam [1893] 1 Ch 547; Re Application of Macedonian Orthodox Community Church St Petka Inc (No 3) [2006] NSWSC 1247, applied.

Aoukar & Anor v Nemer & Ors [2019] SASC 218; Tschirn v Australian Executor Trustees Ltd [2016] SASC 149; Re Atkinson [1971] VR 612; Macedonian Orthodox Community Church St Petka Inc v His Eminence Petar the Diocesan Bishop of the Macedonian Orthodox Community Church of Australia and New Zealand & Anor (2008) 237 CLR 66; Macedonian Orthodox Community Church St Petka Inc (No 2) (2005) 63 NSWLR 441; Macedonian Orthodox Community Church St Petka Inc v His Eminence Petar, the Diocesan Bishop of the Macedonian Orthodox Church of Australia and New Zealand (2006) 66 NSWLR 112 ; In the Estate of Martin [1958] SASR 365; Barnes v Addy (1874) 144 ER 643; Farah Constructions v Say-Dee Pty Ltd (2007) 230 CLR 89 and Consul Development Pty Ltd v DPC Estates Pty Ltd (1975) 132 CLR 373, discussed.

IN THE ESTATE OF NEMER (DECEASED)
[2021] SASC 14

Testamentary Causes Jurisdiction

  1. BAMPTON J: The executors of the will of Linda Carmel Nemer (“Linda”) seek advice or direction pursuant to s 69 of the Administration and Probate Act 1919 (SA) (“the Act”) in the nature of a Beddoe[1] application regarding the continuance of proceedings commenced by them, the defence of proceedings where they are named as respondents and the commencement of proposed proceedings.

    [1]     Re Beddoe; Downes v Cottam [1893] 1 Ch 547.

  2. Linda died on 10 October 2017, aged 91, leaving a will dated 23 July 2015 (“Linda’s will”) and a codicil dated 24 May 2017 (“the codicil”).  Linda was married to Antoine Nemer (“Antoine”), the founder of the Tip Top Dry Cleaning business in South Australia which is part of the Nemer Group of Companies (“the Nemer Group”).  Antoine…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read IN THE ESTATE OF NEMER and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] SASC 14
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of IN THE ESTATE OF NEMER involves parties Sonia and Brian, who are the executors of Linda's estate, seeking advice and direction from the court regarding the administration of Linda's estate and the pursuit of certain actions against George. The primary dispute revolves around the management and preservation of Linda's estate assets, particularly Lebanese assets, and the proposed action against George for breach of trust, tracing, and equitable compensation. The court was required to determine whether the executors were justified in continuing with the probate action, initiating proceedings against George, and appearing as respondents in the administration action. Additionally, the court had to assess whether these actions were appropriate expenses for the administration of Linda's estate.

The court's reasoning centered on the opinions of counsel, the evidence presented, and the nature of the proposed actions. Counsel's opinion indicated that George's conduct potentially fell within the first limb of Barnes v Addy, suggesting personal liability. The court concluded that the actions were not fruitless and were necessary for the proper administration of Linda's estate. It was determined that Sonia and Brian were entitled to be indemnified for their costs from the estate funds specified in Linda's will, provided they sought an adjustment or marshalling of these funds if necessary. The court granted the executors the necessary advice and direction to proceed with the actions, subject to certain conditions regarding costs and reimbursement.

The final orders included advising and directing the executors to continue with the probate action up to mediation, institute proceedings against George up to mediation, and appear as respondents in the administration action. The executors were to be indemnified for their costs from specific estate funds, with the possibility of seeking an adjustment or marshalling of these funds. Sonia and Brian's costs in these proceedings were also to be paid from the specified funds, with taxation on a solicitor-client basis. The court further granted liberty to apply for further advice or direction.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Sonia and Brain are concerned that the administrators of Antoine’s estate are not taking any steps to identify and call in the Lebanese assets. They are also concerned that land in Lebanon is owned by George, Paul, Leslie, and Joseph. They consider that steps should be taken to investigate what assets were owned by Antoine at the date of his death and what has become of those assets. In the event any of the assets have been taken out of Antoine’s name or otherwise dealt with inappropriately, Sonia and Brian would seek to recover those assets for the benefit of Linda’s estate.The collection and preservation of evidence No submissions were made under this heading. Accordingly, Sonia and Brian, having obtained counsel’s advice, submit that it is necessary for them as named respondents to appear, make submissions, and lead evidence on behalf of Linda’s estate in respect of the foregoing issues in the administration action.The merits of the proposed action against George Sonia and Brian propose commencing an action against George for breach of trust, tracing and equitable compensation. A draft statement of claim exhibited to Ms Hooper’s first affidavit sets out the claim against George. It alleges that George was the sole director and secretary of Hilltop, and in that capacity he caused Hilltop to take certain actions which had the effect of reducing the Hilltop Legacy. The draft pleading alleges that Hilltop’s actions were unconscionable and a breach of trust which denied the recipients of the Hilltop Legacy the benefit of their full entitlement and George knowingly received the benefit of Hilltop’s breach of trust.[33][33] Ms Hooper’s first affidavit at [39]-[40]. Counsel have provided opinion to the effect that George caused Hilltop to act in the way it did, in circumstances where he was aware of the Hilltop Legacy and that others stood to benefit from it, and that he acted in a manner contrary to the interests of those beneficiaries. Counsel have advised that it is at least arguable that George’s conduct falls into the first limb of Barnes v Addy,[34] which exposes him to personal liability. As such, Sonia and Brian have been advised that the prospects of successfully prosecuting the proposed action are reasonable. [34] (1874) 144 ER 643; Farah Constructions v Say-Dee Pty Ltd (2007) 230 CLR 89 and Consul Development Pty Ltd v DPC Estates Pty Ltd (1975) 132 CLR 373.Conclusion Sonia and Brian submit that, having regard to the circumstances of Linda’s estate, they are entitled to be indemnified out of Linda’s estate as pursuing the three actions is clearly an expense properly incurred in the performance of their duties in administering Linda’s estate. In determining whether it is appropriate that the probate action continue and that the proposed action against George be commenced, I have not undertaken a detailed assessment of the merits. I have had regard to the opinions of counsel as to the merits and have had regard to the evidence as to the value and composition of the estate as detailed in Mr Wood’s affidavit. I have also had regard to the nature of the three actions and the issues raised as deposed to in Ms Hooper’s first affidavit and am satisfied that the probate action and the proposed action are not fruitless.[35] Further, having regard to Mr Woods affidavit, Ms Hooper’s first affidavit and counsel’s oral submissions, I am satisfied it is appropriate and necessary for Sonia and Brian to appear, make submissions, and lead evidence on behalf of Linda’s estate as respondents in the administration action. [35] Tschirn v Australian Executor Trustees Ltd [2016] SASC 149 at [62].

Decision

Reasons for decision

Counsel have provided opinion to the effect that George caused Hilltop to act in the way it did, in circumstances where he was aware of the Hilltop Legacy and that others stood to benefit from it, and that he acted in a manner contrary to the interests of those beneficiaries. Counsel have advised that it is at least arguable that George’s conduct falls into the first limb of Barnes v Addy,[34] which exposes him to personal liability. As such, Sonia and Brian have been advised that the prospects of successfully prosecuting the proposed action are reasonable. [34] (1874) 144 ER 643; Farah Constructions v Say-Dee Pty Ltd (2007) 230 CLR 89 and Consul Development Pty Ltd v DPC Estates Pty Ltd (1975) 132 CLR 373.Conclusion Sonia and Brian submit that, having regard to the circumstances of Linda’s estate, they are entitled to be indemnified out of Linda’s estate as pursuing the three actions is clearly an expense properly incurred in the performance of their duties in administering Linda’s estate. In determining whether it is appropriate that the probate action continue and that the proposed action against George be commenced, I have not undertaken a detailed assessment of the merits. I have had regard to the opinions of counsel as to the merits and have had regard to the evidence as to the value and composition of the estate as detailed in Mr Wood’s affidavit. I have also had regard to the nature of the three actions and the issues raised as deposed to in Ms Hooper’s first affidavit and am satisfied that the probate action and the proposed action are not fruitless.[35] Further, having regard to Mr Woods affidavit, Ms Hooper’s first affidavit and counsel’s oral submissions, I am satisfied it is appropriate and necessary for Sonia and Brian to appear, make submissions, and lead evidence on behalf of Linda’s estate as respondents in the administration action. [35] Tschirn v Australian Executor Trustees Ltd [2016] SASC 149 at [62]. In respect of all three actions, I have considered the estimate of the costs likely to be incurred as deposed to in Ms Hooper’s second affidavit. I am satisfied that the estimate of costs to be incurred is proportionate to the issues raised in each of the three actions. Sonia and Brian have undertaken to pay the costs incurred out of the funds held in their solicitors’ trust account which are subject to the gift in clause 3.6 of Linda’s will and unaffected by the validity or otherwise of the codicil. Having made the undertaking as to costs, should Sonia and Brian seek an adjustment or marshalling as between the monies subject to the gift in clause 3.6 of Linda’s will (unaffected by the validity or otherwise of the codicil) and Linda’s residuary estate and/or that Linda’s residuary estate be used for their reimbursement and indemnity, they must make application in these proceedings and serve it on the George, Paul, and Leslie. In the circumstances of Linda’s estate, I am satisfied that it is appropriate to provide Sonia and Brian with the necessary advice or direction in favour of pursuing the three actions and that a Beddoe order by way of indemnity is justified.Orders1.Pursuant to s 69 of the Administration and Probate Act 1919 (SA), Sonia and Brian in their capacity as executors of the estate of Linda Nemer, late of 10 Cross Road, Malvern, South Australia, deceased, who died on 10 October 2017 (“Linda”), are advised and directed that they would be justified and should:1.1.continue to propound the alleged codicil dated 24 May 2017 by prosecuting action SCCIV‑18‑1323 but only up to and including the holding of a mediation, with such mediation to be held at the completion of all reasonable interlocutory steps but prior to trial; and1.2.institute and prosecute further proceedings against George Nemer in the Supreme Court of South Australia in terms of the draft pleading exhibited to Ms Hooper’s affidavit affirmed 7 August 2020, but only up to and including the holding of a mediation, with such mediation to be held at the completion of all reasonable interlocutory steps but prior to trial; and1.3.appear, make submissions and lead evidence on behalf of Linda’s estate as respondents in action SCCIV‑19‑724;but that:1.4.they are only entitled to be indemnified and reimbursed for their costs, charges and expenses incurred in conducting the proceedings referred to in 1.1, 1.2 and 1.3 above out of the funds held in the trust account of Wallmans Lawyers on behalf of Linda’s estate, being the funds formerly held in National Australia Bank Account 28 299 9624 and 19 723 1645 that are subject to the gift in clause 3.6 of the will of Linda dated 23 July 2015; and1.5.such indemnity and reimbursement may be the subject of an application that there be an adjustment or marshalling as between the monies referred to in order 1.4 and the residuary estate of Linda and/or that the indemnity and reimbursement should be from the residuary estate, with such application to be served on the residuary beneficiaries. 2.Sonia and Brian’s costs of these proceedings be paid out of the funds referred to in order 1.4 above, such costs to be taxed on a solicitor-client basis.3.Liberty to apply for further advice or direction (including any application referred to in order 1.5 above) in these proceedings.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Donna, Pauline, and Marie were served with the proceedings but have not filed a notice of address for service or a defence. They have each sworn an affidavit consenting to Linda’s will being admitted to probate “without there being a grant of probate of any potential codicil”.[2][2] FDN 15, FDN 16 and FDN 17 in the probate action.The administration action On 14 July 2019, Leslie and Mr Woods issued an application seeking advice or direction pursuant to s 69 of the Act in respect of the administration of Antoine’s estate in action number SCCIV-19-724 (“the administration action”). Mr Woods deposes in an affidavit sworn 14 June 2019 and filed in the administration action[3] that he was Antoine’s accountant and the accountant for “various family members and Companies and trusts associated with him”. Mr Woods details the disclosed assets and liabilities of Antoine’s estate and the complications that have arisen that require judicial advice or direction in administering Antoine’s estate. [3] MFI E2. Relevant to Sonia and Brian’s application for advice or direction is Mr Woods description of the following assets:[4]39.4an option to direct Allied Investment Group SARL (Allied), a company incorporated in Lebanon, to transfer to [Antoine] and/or his estate the issued capital of Hilltop (the Hilltop Option) with a value of $4,936,664;39.5.property held in trust for [Antoine] being an unregistered estate in fee simple in a property at 43 Delamere Avenue Springfield (the Springfield residence)[5] with a value of $1,700,000;39.6.a further option to direct Allied to assign the benefit of what was described as being “the Allied Debt” being debt due by Hilltop to Allied (the Allied Debt Option) with a value of $1,884, 377;(Emphasis in original, footnote added)[4] At [39].[5] The Springfield residence is hereafter referred to as “the Delamere property”. Allied and Hilltop, like Tip Top Dry Cleaning Pty Ltd (“Tip Top”) are entities forming part of the Nemer Group. The administration action names Sonia and Brian in their capacity as executors of Linda’s estate,[6] George, Paul, and Leslie as respondents to the administration action.[6] At the time the administration proceedings were commenced Sonia and Brian had not been granted probate in Linda’s estate.The decree proving Linda’s will in the probate action Upon Paul, George, and Leslie filing a defence in the probate action admitting the validity of Linda’s will and disputing the validity of the codicil, Sonia and Brian made application for judgment by admissions to admit the will to probate in circumstances where the validity of the codicil was disputed. Sonia and Brian’s application was heard by Stanley J, who commented in his judgment in Aoukar & Anor v Nemer & Ors[7] that there was evidence which might permit the drawing of an inference that Sonia and Brian (Sonia being a beneficiary under Linda’s will) were seeking a grant of probate of Linda’s will because they wished to use the standing the grant would give them to pursue other claims against the administrators of Antoine’s estate.[8] Justice Stanley noted that this was a factor which led to the administrators of Antoine’s estate seeking advice or direction in the administration action. [7] [2019] SASC 218 at [17].[8] Affidavit of Andrew Donald Lovelock Woods at [171]-[214] filed in the administration action.