IN THE ESTATE OF MURCHISON (DECEASED)

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Testamentary Causes Jurisdiction)

IN THE ESTATE OF MURCHISON (DECEASED)

[2023] SASC 77

Reasons for the Orders of the Honourable Justice Bampton  

18 May 2023

SUCCESSION - PROBATE AND LETTERS OF ADMINISTRATION - GRANTS OF PROBATE AND LETTERS OF ADMINISTRATION - TO WHOM PROBATE GRANTED - PASSING OVER OF EXECUTOR AND OTHER MATTERS

SUCCESSION - PROBATE AND LETTERS OF ADMINISTRATION - GRANTS OF PROBATE AND LETTERS OF ADMINISTRATION - ADMINISTRATION WITH WILL ANNEXED - TO WHOM GRANTED

Application for passing over – where the first named executor in a will predeceased the testator and the first reserve executor died following the testator’s death leaving the respondent the sole person entitled to apply for probate – where the residue of the deceased estate is left to the three executors named in the will in equal shares – where probate in the first reserve executor’s estate was granted to the applicant – where the applicant (as legal personal representative of the first reserve executor, a residual devisee and legatee of the deceased estate) seeks an order passing over the respondent as executor – where no original of the will can be located – whether the respondent as sole remaining executor is competent to carry out executorial duties.

HELD:  The respondent be passed over as executor named in the will and as a person entitled to a grant of letters of administration in the deceased estate – the copy of the will of the deceased be admitted to proof.

Supreme Court Act 1935 (SA) s 18; Wills Act 1936 (SA) s 8; Administration and Probate Act 1919 (SA); Probate Rules 2015 (SA) rr 33(5), 69, referred to.
In the Estate of Crane (2005) 93 SASR 198; In the Estate of Spiros Vlahiotis (deceased) [2019] SASC 207, considered.

IN THE ESTATE OF MURCHISON (DECEASED)
[2023] SASC 77

Testamentary Causes Jurisdiction

BAMPTON J.

Background

  1. Sylvia Rosemary Murchison (“Sylvia”) died on 11 May 2019 survived by her son Gary John Murchison (“Gary”) and her daughter Wendy Marie Murchison (“Wendy”).  Sylvia was predeceased by her two other children: Bronte Scott Murchison (“Bronte”) who died in 2006, and Michelle Gail Murchison (“Michelle”) who died in 2017.  Both Bronte and Michelle died with no issue.

  2. Sylvia made a will on 27 February 2007 (“the 2007 will”) appointing Gary as executor, with Wendy (known then as Wendy Marie Wakeham) and Michelle named as reserve executors.  By the 2007 will, Sylvia made a gift of $1,000 to the Down Society of South Australia, made a gift of $1,000 to Vision Australia Ltd and gave the residue of her estate to Gary, Wendy, and Michelle in equal shares or their children if Gary, Wendy or Michelle predeceased her. 

  3. Gary died on 19 December 2019[1] and probate in his estate was granted to Grant Peter Jarrett (“Grant”) on 3 June 2020.[2]

    [1] PROB-23-000593, FDN 2 at [1].

    [2]     PROB-20-002706, FDN 8.

  4. As both Gary and Michelle have died, Wendy was the only person entitled to apply for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read IN THE ESTATE OF MURCHISON (DECEASED) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] SASC 77
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of the Estate of Murchison, the deceased, Wendy Marie Murchison sought to challenge the decision to pass her over as an executor of the estate of Sylvia Rosemary Murchison. The deceased had passed away, and her will named Wendy as an executor. However, the petitioner, Grant Peter Jarrett, contended that Wendy was unfit to act as an executor due to her alleged incompetence and lack of understanding of her duties. The Court of Probate was tasked with determining whether Wendy was competent to continue as an executor and whether her actions were detrimental to the proper administration of the estate.

The court had to decide whether Wendy was competent to act as an executor and whether her actions were in the best interest of the estate and the beneficiaries. The court had to consider Wendy's understanding of her role, her ability to carry out her duties, and the potential harm caused by her actions. Additionally, the court had to examine whether there were any unmeritorious investigations that could dissipate the estate's funds.

The court concluded that Wendy was not competent to act as an executor due to her lack of understanding of her role, her injuries and trauma, and her pursuit of unmeritorious investigations. The court found that Wendy's actions were detrimental to the proper administration of the estate and the interests of the beneficiaries. Consequently, the court exercised its jurisdiction to pass over Wendy as an executor and granted the orders sought by Grant. The court ordered that Wendy be passed over as an executor, and that Grant be granted letters of administration. The court also ordered that the costs of the application be paid out of Wendy's share of the estate.

In summary, the Court of Probate granted the petitioner's application to pass over Wendy as an executor of the estate of Sylvia Rosemary Murchison. The court found that Wendy was not competent to act as an executor and that her actions were detrimental to the proper administration of the estate and the interests of the beneficiaries. The court ordered that Wendy be passed over as an executor and that Grant be granted letters of administration. The court also ordered that the costs of the application be paid out of Wendy's share of the estate.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

BAMPTON J
Mr Villegas maintained his assertion that Grant’s solicitors were harassing Wendy. As I pointed out to him on 1 May 2023, the solicitors were merely doing what would be expected of them as solicitors and officers of the Court. Conclusion Having regard to the affidavits filed in this matter and the submissions, I am not satisfied that Wendy is competent to proceed with the administration of Sylvia’s estate for the reasons contended by Grant. I have no confidence that Sylvia’s estate will be efficiently and properly administered according to the terms of the 2013 will whilst Wendy remains an executor. She does not appear to properly understand her role as executor, has deposed to suffering significant injuries and trauma which prevent her from finalising Sylvia’s estate, and is pursuing unmeritorious investigations that may dissipate Sylvia’s modest estate through legal and accounting fees. Having regard to the due and proper administration of Sylvia’s estate and the interests of the those beneficially entitled to her estate, I was satisfied it is appropriate to exercise the Court’s jurisdiction and grant the orders sought to pass over Wendy as executor of Sylvia’s estate. Accordingly, I made the following orders:1.The respondent, Wendy Marie Murchison, be passed over as executor named in the will of Sylvia Rosemary Murchison dated 10 September 2013 (“the will”) and as a person entitled to a grant of letters of administration of the estate of Sylvia Rosemary Murchison deceased (“the deceased”).2.The copy will of the deceased dated 10 September 2013 annexed and marked “B” to the affidavit of Grant Peter Jarrett affirmed on 31 January 2023 be admitted to proof.3.Upon Grant Peter Jarrett (in his capacity as legal personal representative of Gary John Murchison, a residuary devisee and legatee of the deceased’s estate) making an application for a grant of letters of administration (copy will annexed) of the deceased’s estate in a form acceptable to the Registrar of Probates, the Registrar be directed to issue the grant.4.The costs of and incidental to the application to have the respondent passed over be paid for out of the respondent’s share of the estate of the deceased. I make the following further order:1.The costs of the application to have the copy of the 2013 will admitted to proof be paid out of the estate of the deceased.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BAMPTON J

Grant stated he does not know if the Payneham unit is currently insured and, based on a conversation his solicitor had with Wendy on 19 July 2022, Wendy was unaware of her obligation as executor to insure the unit and had not done so.Administration of Michelle’s estate In relation to Wendy’s assertion that Sylvia’s estate is owed monies by Michelle’s estate, Grant deposed that his solicitor spoke to Bennett and Philp Lawyers, the firm instructed on the distribution of Michelle’s estate. Bennett and Philp Lawyers confirmed that Michelle’s estate was distributed appropriately, and Sylvia was not entitled to a share of Michelle’s estate. A copy of Michelle’s will dated 25 January 2017 (“Michelle’s will”), the vesting deed for the Michelle Gail Murchison Testamentary Trust (“the vesting deed”) and the sealed grant of probate in relation to Michelle’s will are annexed to Grant’s affidavit.[22] Michelle’s will establishes the Michelle Gail Murchison Testamentary Trust (“Michelle’s trust”) is governed by the vesting deed. Clause 16(c) of Michelle’s will provides: Any income and capital of the trust fund not distributed prior to the vesting day shall be held by the trustee upon trust for such of the beneficiaries referred to in clause 16(a)(ii) as shall then be living and if more than one in equal shares as tenants in common in equal shares. (Emphasis added)[22] PROB-23-000593, FDN 2 at [25.3] and annexure “J”. Sylvia is a named beneficiary named in clause 16(a)(ii) of Michelle’s will. Pursuant to the vesting deed, the vesting day of Michelle’s trust was 4 October 2019. Sylvia died on 11 May 2019, prior to the vesting day. As such, Sylvia was not entitled to a share of Michelle’s estate. Regardless of Wendy’s concerns over the administration of Michelle’s estate and its impact on Sylvia’s estate, there is no reason why Wendy could not have applied for a grant of probate over the last three years since Gary’s death, noting that there may be further assets to be called in. When this was explained to Wendy at the directions hearing on 9 November 2022,[23] Wendy indicated she understood what was required of her and the steps she needed to take to ensure Sylvia’s estate was finalised.[24][23] T9.30-T10.8; T13.9-17; T14.5-12 (9 November 2022).[24] T15.16-20 (9 November 2022).Wendy instructs a solicitor On 1 March 2023, Grant’s solicitor informed my chambers by email that Wendy was now represented by Mr Ricardo Villegas, who had agreed to consent orders that Wendy file any affidavit in response to application to pass over by 16 March 2023. The consent orders were made administratively and the matter was adjourned to 23 March 2023. At the directions hearing on 23 March 2023, I extended the time for Wendy to file and serve any affidavit in response to the application to pass over by close of business 5 April 2023. I also ordered Grant file and serve any further affidavit by close of business 14 April 2023 and listed the application for hearing on 1 May 2023. Wendy’s affidavit