In the Estate of CHRISTOPHER JAMES PEARSON

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Testamentary Causes Jurisdiction: Application)

In the Estate of CHRISTOPHER JAMES PEARSON

[2014] SASC 77

Reasons for Decision of The Honourable Justice Gray

19 June 2014

SUCCESSION - MAKING OF A WILL - EXECUTION - INFORMAL DOCUMENT INTENDED TO BE WILL - GENERALLY

SUCCESSION - MAKING OF A WILL - EXECUTION - INFORMAL DOCUMENT INTENDED TO BE WILL - OTHER CASES

Application under section 12(2) of the Wills Act 1936 (SA) for an order admitting an informal will to probate. In May 2008, the deceased instructed a solicitor in relation to the preparation of a new will. After taking instructions, the solicitor asked the deceased whether he wished to sign a handwritten will pending the preparation of a more formal document. The deceased agreed and signed the handwritten document. A typewritten draft will was subsequently posted to the deceased. However, the deceased did not reply to this correspondence and there is no indication as to what he did with the typewritten draft will. The deceased died in June 2013. The persons named as executors and trustees in the handwritten document applied to have that document admitted to probate as the will of the deceased.

Whether the handwritten document should be admitted to probate under section 12(2) of the Wills Act. Whether the deceased intended for the handwritten document to be a stopgap will, to have effect only until the deceased had the opportunity to make a formal will.

Held (granting the application):

1.  The deceased intended for the handwritten document to operate as his last will and not merely to act as a stopgap will to have effect only until the deceased had the opportunity to make a formal will.

2.  The handwritten document is to be admitted to probate as the last will of the deceased.

Wills Act 1936 (SA) s 8 and s 12(2); Probate Rules 2004 (SA) r 77, referred to.
Permanent Trustee Co Ltd v Milton (1995) 39 NSWLR 330; Leslie v McDowell [2000] NSWSC 727, considered.

In the Estate of CHRISTOPHER JAMES PEARSON
[2014] SASC 77

Testamentary Causes Jurisdiction

GRAY J.

Introduction

  1. This is an application under section 12(2) of the Wills Act 1936 (SA) for an order admitting an informal will to probate.

  2. The application has been referred to me by the Registrar of Probates pursuant to rule 77 of the Probate Rules 2004 (SA).  On 26 March 2014, I granted the application and made orders admitting the document to probate as the will of the deceased.  My reasons for doing so follow.

  3. Christopher James Pearson, the deceased, died on 7 June 2013.  The deceased made a formally executed will dated 1 May 1996.  The informal document the subject of the present application is dated 13 May 2008.  The applicants, John James Snelling and Aaron Mark Russell, are the persons appointed as executors of the deceased’s estate in that informal document.  The Court was informed that the net worth of the deceased’s estate at the time of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read In the Estate of CHRISTOPHER JAMES PEARSON and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] SASC 77
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves the estate of Christopher James Pearson, with the primary issue being the admissibility of a handwritten document as the deceased's last will. The applicants sought to have the handwritten document admitted to probate, arguing it represented Pearson's testamentary intentions. The court had to determine if the document, which was informal and not formally executed, could be considered a valid will.

The central legal issues revolved around the execution and validity of the informal document as a will. The court considered whether the document, despite its informal nature, could be deemed a will under the Succession Act, given the deceased's clear expression of intent to replace his prior, formally executed will. Key factors included the deceased's testamentary capacity, the circumstances surrounding the creation of the document, and the intentions of the deceased as conveyed to the solicitor.

In its reasoning, the court found that the deceased had expressed a clear intention to replace his formal will with the informal handwritten document, which he believed to be valid. The court relied on the affidavits and evidence presented, including the testimony of the solicitor and the deceased's discussions with others, to conclude that the document reflected the deceased's testamentary wishes. The court determined that the informal document was intended to serve as a will and should be admitted to probate as such.

The court ordered that the handwritten document, marked as exhibit "A" in the affidavit of John James Snelling, be admitted to probate as the last will of the deceased, and that probate be granted to the applicants. This decision recognises the deceased's clear intention to use the informal document as his will, despite its lack of formal execution.

Background

Background to the litigation

Several affidavits were filed in support of the application, including: affidavits of each of the applicants; affidavits of Mark Peter Jappe, the solicitor responsible for the preparation of the purported will; an affidavit of Gaetano Anthony Aiello, who appeared as counsel on behalf of the applicants on the hearing of the application; an affidavit of Emma Alexandra Wilkinson, a solicitor who had retrieved the purported will from storage following the deceased’s death; an affidavit of Father Michael McCaffrey, a minister of religion; and an affidavit of Philip Geoffrey Jones, the person named as the sole executor and trustee in the earlier referred to formal will of 1 May 1996. On the hearing of the application, Mr Jappe gave evidence. In recording the facts that appear later in these reasons, I have drawn from the contents of those affidavits and that oral evidence.Background The will of the deceased dated 1 May 1996 was typewritten and appears to have been formally executed. In that document, the deceased appoints Mr Jones as sole executor and trustee. The deceased makes a specific disposition of his shares in The Adelaide Review Pty Ltd and his units in The Adelaide Review Unit Trust to his friend, Anthony John Abbott. The residue of the estate is to be divided in equal parts between the deceased’s mother and Mr Jones and, if either of those persons predecease the deceased, their share is to pass to the survivor. If both predecease the deceased, the residue is to pass to Mr Abbott. Mr Snelling deposed that prior to the deceased’s death, he disposed of his shares in The Adelaide Review and units in The Adelaide Review Unit Trust, with the result that the bequest to Anthony John Abbott in the 1996 will was adeemed. Mr Snelling further deposed that the deceased’s mother predeceased him. If the 1996 will were admitted to probate as the will of the deceased, Mr Jones would therefore be appointed as executor and trustee of the deceased’s estate and would be entitled to the whole of the estate. The Court was informed that a compromise had been reached between the applicants and Mr Jones, whereby Mr Jones was to be paid $50,000.00 in consideration for agreeing to provide an affidavit of consent to the present application to admit the informal document to probate. On 13 May 2008, Mr Jappe, then an employee of the law firm Johnston Withers, attended at the home of the deceased to take instructions for a new will. This was the first occasion on which Mr Jappe had taken any instructions from the deceased. Mr Jappe recorded his instructions by hand. Mr Jappe gave evidence that the deceased appeared lucid, and Mr Jappe was satisfied of his testamentary capacity. The deceased told Mr Jappe that the terms of his then current will did not represent his testamentary intentions. In particular, the deceased’s mother had died. Mr Jappe deposed that the deceased said words to him to the effect that Aaron Russell’s younger brother, Joseph, was the deceased’s godson and suffered from Down’s Syndrome. The deceased wished to make some provision for Joseph. Mr Jappe asked whether he wished to do so by means of a trust. The deceased indicated that he was content to simply express the wish and to have Mr Russell use his discretion as to how to apply the assets, without formalising his intentions in a trust.

Decision

Reasons for decision

GRAY J
The evidence of Father McCaffrey and of the applicants as to their discussions with the deceased concerning his testamentary intentions strengthens this conclusion. On that evidence, the deceased clearly expressed a belief that he had a valid and effective will, the terms of which were consistent with those of the handwritten document.Conclusion For the above reasons, I made an order that the handwritten document being the exhibit marked “A” referred to in the affidavit of John James Snelling sworn on 18 September 2013 be admitted to probate as the last will of the deceased and that probate be granted to the applicants.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GRAY J

The court's primary task was to determine whether the informal handwritten document constituted a valid and effective will of the deceased. The court carefully examined the circumstances surrounding the execution of the document, considering the testimony of Mr Jappe, who took the instructions, and Father McCaffrey, who had discussions with the deceased regarding his testamentary intentions. The court found that the deceased expressed a clear belief that he had a valid will, which was consistent with the content of the handwritten document. This finding was pivotal in establishing that the deceased intended the document to serve as his last will.

In deciding whether the informal document could be admitted to probate, the court considered the requirements of s 33 of the Succession Act 2006 (SA). The court acknowledged that a will may be in any form but must be in writing and signed by the testator. Given the handwritten nature of the document and the evidence supporting its execution in the presence of Mr Jappe, who testified to the deceased’s lucidity and testamentary capacity, the court concluded that the document satisfied the statutory requirements for a will. The informal nature of the document did not preclude it from being admitted to probate, provided it met the essential criteria of being signed by the deceased and reflecting his intentions.

The court further explored the legal status of the handwritten document in relation to the deceased's testamentary intentions. It considered the testimony of Father McCaffrey and the applicants, who corroborated the deceased's expressed wishes. The court found that the deceased's communications with Mr Jappe and Father McCaffrey were indicative of a deliberate intent to update his will. The court held that the document was not merely a draft but a final expression of the deceased’s wishes, thus constituting a valid will.

Assessing the deceased's testamentary capacity, the court relied on the evidence provided by Mr Jappe, who testified that the deceased appeared lucid and capable during their interaction. The court also considered Father McCaffrey's affidavit, which detailed the deceased’s coherent discussions about his testamentary intentions. The court concluded that the deceased was of sound mind and possessed testamentary capacity at the time he expressed his intentions for the handwritten document.

The discussions and evidence provided by Father McCaffrey, the applicants, and Mr Jappe were integral to supporting the validity of the handwritten document as the deceased's will. The court emphasized that the deceased's interactions with these individuals revealed a clear and consistent testamentary intent. The court found that the deceased's expressed wish to provide for his godson Joseph, despite the informal manner of the document, was a deliberate and informed decision, which was duly captured in the handwritten document.

The existence of the formal will dated 1 May 1996 did not affect the court's consideration of the handwritten document as the deceased's last will. The court noted that the deceased had explicitly stated that the terms of his then current will did not represent his testamentary intentions and that the handwritten document reflected his updated wishes. The court held that the subsequent informal document superseded the earlier formal will, given the deceased's clear expression of a new testamentary intent.

Finally, the implications of the compromise reached between the applicants and Mr Jones were considered by the court. The court acknowledged that Mr Jones, who was named as the executor and trustee in the 1996 will, had been paid $50,000 to consent to the application for the handwritten document to be admitted to probate. The court concluded that this compromise did not undermine the validity of the handwritten document, as it was based on the applicants' recognition of Mr Jones' entitlement under the earlier will and did not affect the substantive validity of the deceased’s later testamentary intentions.