SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
Case Title: | In the Estate of Cervo |
Citation: | [2023] ACTSC 283 |
Hearing Dates: | 6 October, 10 October 2023 |
Decision Date: | 11 October 2023 |
Before: | Taylor J |
Decision: | See [48]-[49]. |
Catchwords: | SUCCESSION – EXECUTORS AND ADMINISTRATORS – Application for special administration ad colligenda bona defuncti or appointment of administrator pendente lite– suitability of applicant to be appointed administrator pendente lite |
Legislation Cited: | Administration and Probate Act 1929 (ACT), ss 9(1), 23 Probate and Administration Act 1898 (NSW), s 73 Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld), r 638 |
Cases Cited: | Angus McInnes MacDonald (as one of the executors of the will of Muriel Ann MacDonald deceased) v Hamish MacDonald (as one of the executors of the will of Muriel Ann MacDonald deceased) [2023] QSC 149 Estate Ritossa, Deceased [2022] NSWSC 1083 Gooley v Gooley [2020] NSWSC 798 |
Parties: | Angelo Didio ( Plaintiff) Ian Julien ( Defendant) |
Representation: | Counsel Danny Moujalli ( Plaintiff) Kerin Cotchett ( Defendant) |
| Solicitors Thomson Geer ( Plaintiff) Elringtons Lawyers ( Defendant) | |
File Numbers: | PRO 476, 1040 of 2023 |
TAYLOR J:
Introduction
1․This is an application in relation to the estate of Mrs Margaret Anne Cervo and Mr Renato Cervo. The applicant, Mr Angelo Didio, pursuant to ss 9(1) or 23 of the Administration and Probate Act 1929 (ACT) (the Act) seeks to be appointed as a special administrator ad colligenda bona defuncti or as an administrator pendente lite in relation to both estates.
Background
2․It is necessary to summarise some of the history relevant to the application. On 2 May 2019, Mr Cervo executed a valid will ("the Renato Cervo Will”),
3․The Renato Cervo Will appointed his wife, Mrs Margaret Cervo as executor and named her as the beneficiary of one half share of his estate. Additionally, the Renato Cervo Will made provision for, among other matters, his daughter, Ms Gina Cervo (who is the step-daughter of Mrs Cervo). The Renato Cervo Will directed the executor to employ the services of Mr Ian Julien as the solicitor for the estate.
4․Mr Cervo died on 24 December 2022, aged 89 years. A grant of probate was issued by the Court to Mrs Cervo on 31 May 2023.
5․Mrs Cervo executed a Will (“the First Will”) on 18 April 2023 in which she appointed Mr Julien as the executor of her estate. Mr Julien is also a residuary beneficiary under the terms of that will. So too is the applicant in these proceedings.
6․Shortly thereafter on 16 May 2023 Mrs Cervo executed another Will (“the Second Will”) in which she revoked all former wills and testamentary dispositions and appointed a new executor, namely the applicant. The applicant is also a residuary beneficiary under the terms of the Second Will to a greater extent than that provided by the First Will. The Second Will does not make any provision for Mr Julien. Both the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read In the Estate of Cervo and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] ACTSC 283
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the factors relevant to the appointment of an administrator pendente lite. While the court had a discretion to appoint an administrator, it needed to be satisfied that the appointment would advance the proper administration of the estate and the interests of beneficiaries. The court found that Mr Didio was not an appropriate candidate for the role because of his direct involvement in the contest over the validity of the will, his lack of relevant qualifications or experience to manage the complex estates, and his recent history of bankruptcy. The court appointed Ms Tamara Goodwin as the administrator pendente lite of both estates instead. The court outlined the extensive powers and duties of the administrator to manage the estates and preserve their value pending the resolution of the substantive litigation.
Background
Background to the litigation
Shortly thereafter, on 16 May 2023, Mrs. Cervo executed another will, the Second Will, revoking all prior wills and testamentary dispositions. In this will, she appointed Mr. Angelo Didio as the executor and named him as a residuary beneficiary to a greater extent than provided by the First Will. Notably, the Second Will made no provision for Mr. Julien. Both the First and Second Wills provided significant benefits to Mrs. Cervo’s sister, Ms. Brenda Mitchell, a resident of the United States. On 6 June 2023, Mrs. Cervo made an Enduring Power of Attorney appointing Mr. Didio as her attorney. However, on 15 June, Mr. Julien issued a letter signed by Mrs. Cervo purporting to revoke the Enduring Power of Attorney.
Mrs. Cervo died on 30 August 2023, aged 93. At the time of her death, the administration of Mr. Cervo's will had not been fully completed. On 25 September 2023, a caveat was filed on behalf of Mr. Julien to prevent the Court from granting probate in relation to the Second Will. The caveat raised objections to the validity of the Second Will, including claims that Mrs. Cervo lacked testamentary capacity, did not have knowledge and approval of the will's contents, and was unduly influenced by Mr. Didio. Currently, there is no executor or administrator appointed to manage Mrs. Cervo's and Mr. Cervo's estates, which have estimated net values of approximately $40,376,869.43 and $26,245,458.79, respectively.
This case in the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory is an application related to the estates of Mrs Margaret Anne Cervo and Mr Renato Cervo. Angelo Didio, the plaintiff, seeks to be appointed as a special administrator ad colligenda bona defuncti or as an administrator pendente lite in relation to both estates under sections 9(1) or 23 of the Administration and Probate Act 1929 (ACT). This application arises due to the contested validity of Mrs Cervo’s Second Will, which was executed on 16 May 2023 and appointed Mr Didio as the executor of her estate. Mr Ian Julien, the defendant, has filed a caveat objecting to the grant of probate in relation to the Second Will on several grounds, including lack of testamentary capacity and undue influence. Given the significant value of the estates and the need to protect and preserve the assets pending the resolution of the litigation, the court considers the appointment of an administrator pendente lite necessary. Despite Mr Didio's arguments in favour of his appointment based on his familiarity with the estates and his intention not to charge for his services, the court determines that he is not suitable due to his involvement in the litigation and lack of relevant qualifications. Instead, the court appoints Tamara Jayne Goodwin, a solicitor independent of the parties, as the administrator pendente lite for both estates.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Court should appoint an administrator pendente lite to manage the estates of Mr and Mrs Cervo pending resolution of the litigation concerning the validity of Mrs Cervo's Second Will?
2. If so, who should be appointed as the administrator pendente lite: the applicant, Angelo Didio, or an independent third party such as Ms Tamara Goodwin?
3. Should the appointment of the administrator pendente lite be made on an interim basis with a further hearing to be set for a later date?
Held
1. The Court held that an administrator pendente lite should be appointed to manage the estates of Mr and Mrs Cervo pending resolution of the litigation concerning the validity of Mrs Cervo's Second Will. Result: Appointment of administrator pendente lite ordered.
2. The Court held that Angelo Didio should not be appointed as the administrator pendente lite due to his involvement in the litigation and lack of necessary qualifications. Instead, Ms Tamara Goodwin, an independent third party, should be appointed. Result: Appointment of Ms Tamara Goodwin as administrator pendente lite ordered.
3. The Court held that the appointment of the administrator pendente lite should not be made on an interim basis with a further hearing to be set for a later date. Result: Interim appointment not made.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In this case, the Court was asked to decide whether an administrator pendente lite should be appointed to manage the estates of Mr and Mrs Cervo while the validity of Mrs Cervo's Second Will was being contested. The applicant, Angelo Didio, sought to be appointed as the administrator pendente lite. The court needed to consider whether appointing an administrator pendente lite was necessary, who should be appointed, and whether the appointment should be made on an interim basis.
The Court began by considering the statutory authority for appointing an administrator pendente lite, which is found in s 23 of the Administration and Probate Act 1929 (ACT). The court noted that while the Act grants a discretionary power to appoint an administrator pendente lite, such an appointment is not made as a matter of routine but rather when necessary to advance the proper administration of the estate and the interests of the beneficiaries. The court looked to precedents from other jurisdictions, such as Estate Ritossa, Deceased [2022] NSWSC 1083 and Gooley v Gooley [2020] NSWSC 798, which emphasised that the court must be satisfied that the appointment will help protect the estate and its assets.
The court then considered whether Angelo Didio should be appointed as the administrator pendente lite. The applicant presented several arguments in favour of his appointment, including his familiarity with the estates and the specific tasks that needed attention, his proximity to the ACT, and his intention not to charge for his services. However, the caveator, Mr Julien, opposed the applicant's appointment on the grounds that the applicant was not independent due to his involvement in the litigation concerning the validity of the Second Will and his potential bias.
In deciding who should be appointed, the court considered factors such as the nature and extent of the issues to be fought in the litigation, the tasks required of the administrator, the candidate's suitability and qualifications, and the views of the beneficiaries. The court held that appointing someone connected to the litigation could generate needless litigation and distrust among the parties. While the applicant had some qualifications and familiarity with the estates, the court found that the nature of the contest and the complexity of the estates weighed against the applicant's appointment.
Finally, the court considered whether the appointment should be made on an interim basis. The applicant suggested an interim appointment with a further hearing set for a later date. However, the court found that this approach would create unnecessary litigation and fragment the issues to be determined. Instead, the court opted to appoint an independent third party, Ms Tamara Goodwin, as the administrator pendente lite.
In conclusion, the Court found that an administrator pendente lite should be appointed to manage the estates of Mr and Mrs Cervo during the litigation concerning the validity of Mrs Cervo's Second Will. However, the Court decided against appointing Angelo Didio as the administrator pendente lite due to his involvement in the litigation and lack of independence. Instead, the Court appointed Ms Tamara Goodwin, an independent third party, as the administrator pendente lite. The Court also decided against making the appointment on an interim basis, opting instead for a final appointment to avoid generating further unnecessary litigation.