In the Estate of Carluen

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

CITATION:In the Estate of Carluen [2022] NTSC 80

PARTIES:IN THE ESTATE OF CARLUEN

ON REFERENCE from the Registrar of the Supreme Court of the Northern Territory

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF THE

NORTHERN TERRITORY

JURISDICTION:  SUPREME COURT exercising Territory jurisdiction

FILE NO:2022-02106-SC

DELIVERED:  7 October 2022

JUDGMENT OF:  Brownhill J

Collins v Marinovich (2021) 8 QR 235, applied.

Doe d Cross v Cross (1846) 8 QB 714; Fletcher v Fletcher (1844) 4 Hare 67; In the Goods of Morgan (1866) LR 1 PD 214; In the Goods of Robinson (1867) LR 1 P&D 384; Re Anziani; Herbert v Christopherson [1930] 1 Ch 407; Re Bubnich; Marian v Bubnich [1965] WAR 138; Re Leung Wai Jing [2004] 1 HKC 453; Re White (1987) 38 DLR (4th) 631; Thorncroft v Lashmar (1862) 164 ER 1083; Wolfe v Wolfe [1902] 2 IR 246, referred to.

G E Dal Pont & K F Mackie, Law of Succession (LexisNexis Butterworths,

1st ed, 2013)

Administration and Probate Act 1969 (NT) ss 17, 22, 61

Evidence (National Uniform Legislation) Act 2011 (NT) s 140

Succession Act 2006 (NSW) s 113

Wills Act 2000 (NT) ss 3, 6, 8, 10, 11, 12, 34, 45, 46

REPRESENTATION:

Solicitors:

Applicant:Kelly & Partners

Judgment category classification:    C

Judgment ID Number:  Bro2211

Number of pages:  17

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
OF AUSTRALIA
AT DARWIN

In the Estate of Carluen [2022] NTSC 80

No. 2022-02106-SC

BETWEEN

IN THE ESTATE OF CARLUEN

ON REFERENCE FROM THE REGISTRAR OF THE SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY

CORAM:    BROWNHILL J

REASONS FOR ORDERS

(Delivered 7 October 2022)

  1. The issue in this matter is whether an agreement executed by the deceased and his wife in the Philippines which provided for both inter vivos and testamentary dispositions of his property constitutes his will. If not, he died intestate. If so, he failed to appoint an executor, so a subsidiary issue arises as to whom administration should be granted.

    Background

  2. The Registrar referred this matter (‘the reference’) under s 17(2)(c) of the Administration and Probate Act 1969 (NT) (‘APA’).

  3. The deceased, Antonio Marquez Carluen, died on 25 August 2020.

  4. At the time of his death, he was married to Paulina Calbay Mercado (‘Ms Mercado’) and they resided together in the Northern Territory. They were married on 30 September 2018. The deceased had two adult children from a previous marriage, Constantine Anthony David Carluen and Christine Bernadette David Carluen, who both live in New South Wales.

  5. The deceased left an estate with a net value of $431,348.13, which comprised assets in the Northern Territory and New South Wales.

  6. On 22 August 2022, Ms Mercado applied to this Court for administration of the estate on the basis that the deceased died without a valid will. It appears that, if he was intestate, she will be the sole beneficiary of the deceased’s estate.[1]

  7. On 27 February 2019, the deceased and Ms Mercado executed a written document, headed ‘Agreement’ (‘the Agreement’).…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read In the Estate of Carluen and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NTSC 80
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court involves the interpretation and application of the Wills Act 2000 (NT) to determine whether an agreement executed by Antonio Marquez Carluen and Paulina Calbay Mercado in the Philippines, which included provisions for the division of assets both upon divorce and the death of the deceased, constitutes a valid will. The outcome of this determination affects the distribution of the deceased’s estate, valued at $431,348.13, which includes assets in both the Northern Territory and New South Wales. Paulina Mercado has applied for administration of the estate on the basis that the deceased died without a valid will, suggesting that she would be the sole beneficiary if he was intestate. However, the court must ascertain whether the Agreement executed in the Philippines is sufficient to be considered a will or if the estate should be distributed according to the laws of intestacy.

The primary legal issue before the court is whether the Agreement, which was executed in the Philippines, satisfies the requirements of a valid will under the Wills Act 2000 (NT). Additionally, if the Agreement is deemed not to be a will, the court must determine who is entitled to administer the estate. The court must consider the specific clauses of the Agreement, the presence of witnesses and a Notary Public, and the implications of the Agreement being executed outside Australia. The subsidiary issue concerns the appointment of an executor, or the allocation of administration rights, if the Agreement is not a valid will.

The court examined the content and execution of the Agreement to determine its validity as a will. It considered the formal requirements set out in the Wills Act, including the necessity for the document to be in writing, signed by the testator, and witnessed. The court noted the presence of witnesses and a Notary Public in the execution of the Agreement, which aligns with the formalities required by the Wills Act. However, the court also assessed whether the provisions of the Agreement, particularly those pertaining to the division of assets upon death, align with the statutory definition of a will. The court concluded that while the Agreement includes testamentary dispositions, it does not meet the criteria to be considered a valid will under the Wills Act because it does not sufficiently express the deceased's testamentary intentions in the required form. Consequently, the deceased died intestate, and the court must now determine the appropriate person to administer the estate.

The court ordered that the estate of Antonio Marquez Carluen be administered as intestate. Given that the deceased did not appoint an executor and the wife is the sole beneficiary under the laws of intestacy, the court granted administration of the estate to Paulina Calbay Mercado. The court's decision ensures that the estate is distributed according to the statutory rules of intestacy, and Ms Mercado was appointed to oversee the administration process.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The issue in this matter is whether an agreement executed by the deceased and his wife in the Philippines which provided for both inter vivos and testamentary dispositions of his property constitutes his will. If not, he died intestate. If so, he failed to appoint an executor, so a subsidiary issue arises as to whom administration should be granted.Background The Registrar referred this matter (‘the reference’) under s 17(2)(c) of the Administration and Probate Act 1969 (NT) (‘APA’). The deceased, Antonio Marquez Carluen, died on 25 August 2020. At the time of his death, he was married to Paulina Calbay Mercado (‘Ms Mercado’) and they resided together in the Northern Territory. They were married on 30 September 2018. The deceased had two adult children from a previous marriage, Constantine Anthony David Carluen and Christine Bernadette David Carluen, who both live in New South Wales. The deceased left an estate with a net value of $431,348.13, which comprised assets in the Northern Territory and New South Wales. On 22 August 2022, Ms Mercado applied to this Court for administration of the estate on the basis that the deceased died without a valid will. It appears that, if he was intestate, she will be the sole beneficiary of the deceased’s estate.[1] On 27 February 2019, the deceased and Ms Mercado executed a written document, headed ‘Agreement’ (‘the Agreement’). The Agreement provides that the deceased and Ms Mercado agreed that:(a)if they get divorced within three years of their marriage, Ms Mercado would be entitled to $10,000 from the deceased as ‘alimony or share in their joint assets’ (clause 1);(b)if they get divorced after three years of their marriage, Ms Mercado would be entitled to 30% of the net assets of the deceased (clause 2);(c)if the deceased dies, Ms Mercado is entitled to 30% of the net assets of the deceased (clause 3);(d)in the event of the deceased’s death, his two children, Mr Carluen and Ms Carluen, are to have 40% and 30% respectively of the net assets of the deceased (clause 4). The Agreement was signed by the deceased and Ms Mercado in the presence of two witnesses and a Notary Public in Quezon City, Manila, Philippines. In her affidavit in support of her application for administration, Ms Mercado stated that she and the deceased entered into the Agreement which is ‘on the subject of the division of marital assets in the event that we divorce or the deceased passes away’. She said it had come to her attention that the Agreement is not a valid will. She does not know of any other document that expresses the deceased’s testamentary intentions so she believes that the deceased did not leave a will. The issue for determination on the reference is whether the Agreement is a will within the Wills Act 2000 (NT). If not, the estate would be administered pursuant to the laws of intestacy.[2]Agreement was executed in the Philippines An issue arises as to the operation of the Wills Act because the Agreement was executed in the Philippines.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established